Dio wrote:There is not enough energy for significant numbers of people to escape this planet's gravity well. Although I suppose there's an argument that the only number that's significant is two.
The leap to a solar system based civilisation wont save us from a gamma ray burst, but it will force the evolution of technology, once we are comfortable pottering about the solar system, we can take the next leap out of this solar system. It may well be in generational ships, it certainly will be one way for the first people to travel, but we have an entire universe waiting. Its a crying shame to sit on one rock around one star because people dare not dream we can succeed.
You probably think I am a wild dreamer, but I firmly believe we can do it, all it takes is application. We can leave this gravity well, we can survive in space, we have to try and make the step or like the dinosaurs we will be dug out of the rocks and the people doing the digging will wonder why the civilisation collapsed.
I found this brilliant letter from 1970 this morning. A nun wrote to NASA and asked, "Why spend all this money on the space programme while people are starving?" A NASA bod gave her a very good answer.
"I am a very considerate person. If I want to go out all night on my miniature golf course and shoot lizards, well, no reason to keep the neighbours awake..."
Firefox wrote:I found this brilliant letter from 1970 this morning. A nun wrote to NASA and asked, "Why spend all this money on the space programme while people are starving?" A NASA bod gave her a very good answer.
I am aware of that argument and I am not proposing abandoning space research. I am merely considering it in terms of practicality. Asking us to move into space is like giving Isembard Kingdom Brunel the entire GDP of the British Empire and asking him for an iPhone. It is simply out of our reach.
We should absolutely continue - indeed, increase funding for - basic science research - particularly energy technology, and one day that may cause us not to be so restricted in our options. But right now, you can choose to throw any amount of money you like at human colonization of space, and it will not happen, and indeed it will not be any closer to happening.
Declining to consider the failure of the planet we have is a far bigger danger to humans. If you go with the apocalyptic predictions of The Limits Of Growth, soon - inside our own lifetimes perhaps - one or more key resources will be consumed on this planet and probably multiple billion people will die, and with no resources the human race may never recover - I find it a scenario certainly possible, much more possible than any other global catastrophe.
I'll take my chances with the asteroids and the GRBs if I can stop my children or grandchildren experiencing that; even should western society survive and they personally be spared - far from guaranteed, given this island's utter inability to support it's own population - I would not want them to have to endure the sadness, or myself their anger since I and my entire generation did nothing to stop it.
The key thing is energy. We need much, much more of it. With enough clean energy we can solve most problems. Then we can think about moving elsewhere.
(But it isn't going to come from fusion, not in time. Fusion was 20 years away when I was a kid, and it still is; there won't be a practical fusion plant in my lifetime, although I hope to be proven wrong).
Fusion is attainable, the reason it's sat at 20 years from now for so long is because no me has taken it seriously, no one has funded it. The us has managed to find 1 trillion dollars to fight its recent wars, if just half of that had been given to fusion research we would be making advances.
You have yourself stated we will run out of resources, that's so strange when there are thousands of tons of resources within a few million miles of the planet. Enter space fully and resources and scarcity become things of the past, fail to take the leap and we are doomed to running out and returning to sitting in dark caves wondering what may have been.
The thing about energy is it's not expensive/profitable enough to be worth exploiting. A whole 7% (Wikipedia says 6%, maybe the energy usage has risen since I heard that) of the UK's energy needs is sitting in the Bristol Channel, and not being exploited in any way.
He had by some means, I scarcely know what, fastened wings to his hands and feet so that, mistaking fable for truth, he might fly like Daedalus, and, collecting the breeze upon the summit of a tower, flew for more than a furlong [201 metres]. But agitated by the violence of the wind and the swirling of air, as well as by the awareness of his rash attempt, he fell, broke both his legs and was lame ever after.
I suspect he didn't walk away from that one.
"My way is the way of not fighting":- the book of Enter the Dragon.
I think the point is that in those days people had no real understanding of the mechanics of flight, and therefore it was easy to see how people thought it impossible. Nowadays we know exactly how fusion works, and what it will take to sustain a useful reactor.
It's funny if you think about it now... there's all that old film of people strapping bits of wood to themselves and leaping off cliffs, and today a one man glider is a fairly cheap and simple thing to make and fly. It isn't always the money that counts, it's just that R&D can take a long time. One day we'll probably see fusion in the same way as flight.