The Dr Who thread
Re: The Dr Who thread
This has to be the worst Dr Who season ever.
.
.
.
.
....I'm the BEST thing that has ever happened to ME............I think therefore I'm a Yam.
.
.
.
....I'm the BEST thing that has ever happened to ME............I think therefore I'm a Yam.
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: The Dr Who thread
He's a writer, he's supposed to make things up. I liked that: a good time-travel story. One thing Moffat is happy to do is not just write good Dr Who stories but really explore what it means for him to be a time traveller. Being sent back in time so you appear again as an old person is hardly an original idea but the twist was it happened here, then they broke out of it, then it happened again. In the end what better way to say goodbye to two companions than have them live happily ever after.Mir Nyet wrote:Well, any episode with River Song in it is a good one for me - however the Angels were completely not needed and Moffat seems to be making stuff up again.
All the principals were good, especially Alex Kingston, and both modern and 1930s New York gave it a lot of atmosphere. Moffat's clearly having a lot of fun with the angels, with their ability to take on different forms. I wonder if we'll ever get to see where they're from?
Anyway, this popped up on one their Youtube channels:
- Mir Nyet
- Baaaa!

- Posts: 684
- Joined: Tue Apr 23, 2002 12:48 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: Mir_Nyet
- Location: London
- Contact:
Re: The Dr Who thread
Yep...PVB wrote:Seeing Alex Kingston's ample cleavage made the episode good for me.
- Gorecki
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 5962
- Joined: Sat Aug 31, 2002 1:39 am 0
- Location: Essex, home of the Boy Racer
Re: The Dr Who thread
I loved that. It was scary, clever and emotional. The only problem I had was that it was never any of those at the same time so it kind of shunted from one thing to the other a bit.
Having to wait till christmas is bloody ridiculous though. And yes it was Richard E. Grant.
Having to wait till christmas is bloody ridiculous though. And yes it was Richard E. Grant.
Tang Sou!
Re: The Dr Who thread
Fine epp imho. Not seeing big plotholes either - the only exception being the gravestone at the end which is also read (simple fix too-they should have had Amys name covered)
I really approve of the whole "once I have seen a future I cant change it". Its a realistic rule to stick too, and allows for drama too. Bonus - its more or less what some real time travel theories say.

Seemed pretty plot-critical to me, even if the statue of liberty was underused.
Anyway...
Christmass..
bloody hell..
Anyone got a time machine?
I really approve of the whole "once I have seen a future I cant change it". Its a realistic rule to stick too, and allows for drama too. Bonus - its more or less what some real time travel theories say.
wahu? So you think a new monster that sends people back in time would have been betterhowever the Angels were completely not needed
Seemed pretty plot-critical to me, even if the statue of liberty was underused.
Anyway...
Christmass..
bloody hell..
Anyone got a time machine?
-
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
- Mir Nyet
- Baaaa!

- Posts: 684
- Joined: Tue Apr 23, 2002 12:48 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: Mir_Nyet
- Location: London
- Contact:
Re: The Dr Who thread
Darkflame wrote:Fine epp imho. Not seeing big plotholes either - the only exception being the gravestone at the end which is also read (simple fix too-they should have had Amys name covered)
I really approve of the whole "once I have seen a future I cant change it". Its a realistic rule to stick too, and allows for drama too. Bonus - its more or less what some real time travel theories say.
wahu? So you think a new monster that sends people back in time would have been betterhowever the Angels were completely not needed
Seemed pretty plot-critical to me, even if the statue of liberty was underused.
Anyway...
Christmass..
bloody hell..
Anyone got a time machine?
Ok - Two easy ones - Fracture time at that point in the space/time - and people being sent back powers the fracture - thus you have a self powering event. No need for the Angels or a total change in their behaviour. Tie in a problem caused by the Tardis forcing its way in and you have a better story with real threat and the possiblity of closure where the removal from the Doctor of Amy has meaning... Better still, make the cause of the problem the Tardis itself - perhaps some echo of something the Doctor already did... So the Doctors actions become the cause of Amy and Rory being removed... Far more powerful and would open up a host of other story lines and give River a stronger role in the show as she helps the Doctor come to terms with what happened.
Also - he states he cannot go back and get Rory as he cannot take the Tardis back into New York... So, go back and get another mode of transport and get him by that way? Jump back 1 year before the point in space/time where Rory was send and take a liner to New York, wait in the graveyard for him to pop up and take another liner back to wherever he hide the Tardis... They would know the year from the year and age of death on the gravestone, worse case is that they have to hang around the graveyard for a few weeks/months.
As I said before - felt like the Angels were not needed, it fact like a lot of this year - it felt lazy.
Re: The Dr Who thread
I loved it. The angels got them in the end :'( . It would have been crap if they'd invented a new monster just for this, IMO...
I made a deviantart page.
'....The baron is a gay old rogue with an eye for the ladies....'
'....The baron is a gay old rogue with an eye for the ladies....'
Re: The Dr Who thread
err...why? thats self-causing. The Angels caused the messed up time because they were feeding on large scales, your proposing it caused itself.Ok - Two easy ones - Fracture time at that point in the space/time - and people being sent back powers the fracture - thus you have a self powering event. No need for the Angels
Thats kinda acceptable in a time travel show, but I wouldn't say its better.
huh? how is the threat not "real" here?forcing its way in and you have a better story with real threat
yay! moopy doctor blaming himself! haven't had that before...So the Doctors actions become the cause of Amy and Rory being removed
whats the big change? The fact they wanted their food in one place...I dont think they have ever stated angels cant displace things in space - they still feed the same way as always, this was them just trying to be a bit more organized. It was the baby that did it anyway - which we haven't even seen before.No need for the Angels or a total change in their behaviour
Because he cant change things he has already read - stated explicitly thoughout the epp. Its a fixed point (again, stated explicitly). It was the (potential) paradox preventing him going back, and the dangers of causing it over already damaged space. If it was just the Tardis, River could have gone her own way.Also - he states he cannot go back and get Rory as he cannot take the Tardis back into New York... So, go back and get another mode of transport and get him by that way? Jump back 1 year before the point in space/time where Rory was send and take a liner to New York, wait in the graveyard for him to pop up and take another liner back to wherever he hide the Tardis... They would know the year from the year and age of death on the gravestone, worse case is that they have to hang around the graveyard for a few weeks/months
Now, it doesn't make total sense because the gravestone did change when Amy went back, but I think they covered quite clearly why Rory couldn't be saved from the past.
-
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
- Harlequin
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 6505
- Joined: Wed Jun 05, 2002 4:19 am 0
- Location: London, directly above the centre of the Earth.
Re: The Dr Who thread
It was stated that the Angels had replaced the statues.Governmentyard wrote:Remind me what the Statue of Liberty is made of, and what Angels turn into, again...
Indeed. That also adheres to the same principle (wave function collapse of entangled [indeterminate] states upon perception/measurement) behind the 'quantum locking' of the Angels themselves.Darkflame wrote:I really approve of the whole "once I have seen a future I cant change it". Its a realistic rule to stick too, and allows for drama too. Bonus - its more or less what some real time travel theories say.
Emoticon and contraction free since... quite a while ago.
-
anon76235
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 6712
- Joined: Fri Jul 23, 2004 4:52 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: tyrwmuwyru,tyweiu,
- PSN: r6wsmunwrtyurtmuwrty
- Yahoo Messenger: 567.,uim576eiw65nuw6u
- Location: rtumsrytu,sruyrtu,sytru
Re: The Dr Who thread
u wot
- Governmentyard
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 11757
- Joined: Sun Oct 31, 2004 9:41 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: GovernmentYard
- Yahoo Messenger: governmentyard
Re: The Dr Who thread
Where is the real one then? They couldn't send it back in time because if that worked on inanimate objects they'd be like the man in the skittles advert.Harlequin wrote:It was stated that the Angels had replaced the statues.Governmentyard wrote:Remind me what the Statue of Liberty is made of, and what Angels turn into, again...
It's irrelevant anyway because no scientific theories or explanations will solve the riddle of why it wasn't scary or sad. Even people's children are reporting the angles to he less scary now.
Last edited by Governmentyard on Mon Oct 01, 2012 4:58 pm 0, edited 1 time in total.
XBox Gamertag: GovernmentYard
Everything else: governmentyard
Everything else: governmentyard
Re: The Dr Who thread
There was nowt wrong with it chap.
- Governmentyard
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 11757
- Joined: Sun Oct 31, 2004 9:41 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: GovernmentYard
- Yahoo Messenger: governmentyard
Re: The Dr Who thread
It was contradictive of stuff the Doctor himself proved last series about preventing his own death and so on. Who is full of complete codswallop and time locking/fixed points is their get out clause for when something has to happen. It undermines the show, they overuse it and it jars the perception even when I'm trying to ignore the stupidity of the endlessly contradicted internal logic.
As mentioned elsewhere, plot holes are like removing kerplunk straws, the first twenty are not important but eventually one brings the whole thing down. It's different for everyone, but while manage to keep most people on side, many others are quite divisive, last Saturday's included.
As mentioned elsewhere, plot holes are like removing kerplunk straws, the first twenty are not important but eventually one brings the whole thing down. It's different for everyone, but while manage to keep most people on side, many others are quite divisive, last Saturday's included.
XBox Gamertag: GovernmentYard
Everything else: governmentyard
Everything else: governmentyard
Re: The Dr Who thread
The fixed time concept is infinitely less broken than the Bill & Ted Time idea which he's experimented with previously and (it seems) rejected.
I genuinely saw no obvious plot flaw about the episode since I accept the fixed time concept where you can't manipulate your own time stream - after all, that's how Doctor Who always worked until the unpleasant venturing into B&TT a couple of years ago. Obviously that makes the B&TT episodes contradictory, but since they were contradictory to the very concept of drama that's no bad thing, and hopefully that will all go away now and those episodes can be handwaved away. (As always seemed likely to me, if you go look at my previous rants on the topic in this very thread).
Except perhaps the idea that nobody is watching the Statue of Liberty, but since it provided a couple of genuine laugh out loud moments I'm happy to forgive that.
I genuinely saw no obvious plot flaw about the episode since I accept the fixed time concept where you can't manipulate your own time stream - after all, that's how Doctor Who always worked until the unpleasant venturing into B&TT a couple of years ago. Obviously that makes the B&TT episodes contradictory, but since they were contradictory to the very concept of drama that's no bad thing, and hopefully that will all go away now and those episodes can be handwaved away. (As always seemed likely to me, if you go look at my previous rants on the topic in this very thread).
Except perhaps the idea that nobody is watching the Statue of Liberty, but since it provided a couple of genuine laugh out loud moments I'm happy to forgive that.
- Baggypants
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 5328
- Joined: Sun Mar 19, 2006 12:54 pm 0
- Location: Salford(UK);
- Contact:
Re: The Dr Who thread
It wasn't scary because the cut's were too quick.
I'm pretty sure if you go back and watch Blink again then you'd find lots of long eyewatering shots of people staring and not blinking.
I'm pretty sure if you go back and watch Blink again then you'd find lots of long eyewatering shots of people staring and not blinking.
"The eggs, get them!"
