SPACE

Inane baanter or words of wisdom - you decide...
Post Reply
User avatar
pogo
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 14180
Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
Location: County Durham

Re: SPACE

Post by pogo »

Dyson spheres again. Someone is looking for them, on the theory that advanced enough civilisations will build them and they will give off a particular energy signature.

http://www.theatlantic.com/technology/a ... ts/263217/

Sounds dubious to me though. The energy calculations are boggling. Today the amount of energy that lands on the Earth is 10,000 what we use. Ever assuming we eventually use 10% of Earth's area for collection and this is 10% efficient we can collect enough energy for our needs 100 times over: long before we need that we will have found ways to vastly improve our energy efficiency, and probably found new sources to supplement solar ones: fusion using the near limitless supply of hydrogen for example. Or we'll have found a source of uranium somewhere else in the solar system.
User avatar
Dio
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18887
Joined: Mon May 31, 2004 1:08 pm 0
Location: Newcastle UK

Re: SPACE

Post by Dio »

Since Freeman Dyson came up with the idea, and you're the one denigrating it, can I say, I'm with Dyson, who is a lot smarter than I will ever be. No ivory tower physicist he.
User avatar
pogo
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 14180
Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
Location: County Durham

Re: SPACE

Post by pogo »

I'm not denying it's possible, or trying to denigrate his discovery of it. It just seems very unlikely anything like that would be built, by us or by anyone. Of course we have little idea what a hypothetical anyone would do, but given that it seems even more necessary to base exploration on what we might do ourselves. E.g. scanning the skies for radio waves makes sense as sending radio waves is something we could do ourselves, and have done at low levels for decades.

Even if someone builds a Dyson sphere it might be so different from what we would imagine that we can't detect it. The search seems to be based on the assumption that such a sphere would radiate heat, as anything we built would as all our machines turn energy into heat eventually. But a civilisation that needs so much energy may use it for some other purpose – interstellar flight for example, or storage for use elsewhere – and so may not use it in situ.
User avatar
Dio
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18887
Joined: Mon May 31, 2004 1:08 pm 0
Location: Newcastle UK

Re: SPACE

Post by Dio »

If Dyson spheres exist, I would have thought the laws of thermodynamics imply the spectral shift they're looking for.

I agree with you that they won't likely find anything, and for a roughly similar reason (that in my opinion the solution to the Fermi Paradox and similar advanced-technology theories is simply that there's no way to bridge the energy gap required to make them work). But I think that if they exist they will be detectable as described.
User avatar
pogo
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 14180
Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
Location: County Durham

Re: SPACE

Post by pogo »

It's worth thinking of what would be needed for them to detect it. It would need to be a complete sphere. Not a single object which would require implausible amounts of stiffening, but lots of things in orbit. Enough that the star was blotted out and they collected all the energy, which they then re-radiated as heat which could be detected.

Now suppose this was done with platforms 500 miles square. Big enough for a small state, in fact as big as a European country or a US state. Making one of these would be a massive undertaking. Simply getting all the mass into orbit from Earth or from elsewhere would take probably thousands of years: think how long it has taken us to get the ISS into space, which is only 100m long and is mostly empty space. It might be cheaper to bring mass from elsewhere because of gravity but then it would need to be built in space, not on Earth and bolted together in space.

And once we've built one of those how many do we need to encircle the sun? About 1.2 million. How many to enclose it completely? About 500 billion. Even if we could build and launch one a year the sun will have extinguished long before we're done.

And suppose we solve these problems. Suppose we can put massive amounts of mass in orbit, and supply energy to move it and machines to make it useful. What do you think we'll do? Create a shell around the Sun? Or make 100km long arks to explore the galaxy in?
User avatar
F-ZeroOne
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 8214
Joined: Wed Sep 29, 2004 8:27 pm 0

Re: SPACE

Post by F-ZeroOne »

pogo wrote: Now suppose this was done with platforms 500 miles square. Big enough for a small state, in fact as big as a European country or a US state. Making one of these would be a massive undertaking. Simply getting all the mass into orbit from Earth or from elsewhere would take probably thousands of years: think how long it has taken us to get the ISS into space, which is only 100m long and is mostly empty space. It might be cheaper to bring mass from elsewhere because of gravity but then it would need to be built in space, not on Earth and bolted together in space.

And once we've built one of those how many do we need to encircle the sun? About 1.2 million. How many to enclose it completely? About 500 billion. Even if we could build and launch one a year the sun will have extinguished long before we're done.
I have an answer to that one: make your own sun... :lol:
"Stars don't twinkle in space." - Char Aznable.
User avatar
Darkflame
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18236
Joined: Mon Mar 31, 2003 11:06 am 0
Location: Not the UK

Re: SPACE

Post by Darkflame »

More or less why I said it would need to be grown somehow, not built.
It needs to be a process that doesn't need a civilization to maintain or build it, merely to set it going. Some genetic engineered super organism, or a grey goo of some sort.
The question still exists though if enough mass can be shifted within the lifespan of the star.
Sounds dubious to me though. The energy calculations are boggling. Today the amount of energy that lands on the Earth is 10,000 what we use. Ever assuming we eventually use 10% of Earth's area for collection and this is 10% efficient we can collect enough energy for our needs 100 times over: long before we need that we will have found ways to vastly improve our energy efficiency, and probably found new sources to supplement solar ones: fusion using the near limitless supply of hydrogen for example. Or we'll have found a source of uranium somewhere else in the solar system.
Certainly - I cant think of any normal needs of a civilization that could ever need that much energy. But isnt it interesting to speculate what might?
Creating mater itself? Bending space? Making wormholes? Maybe galactic-scale "lazers" for solar sail ships to ride on?
There might be crazy sci-fi ideas we haven't even thought of that take insane amounts of power, our civilization certainly tends to find news ways of using it up :)
Um, where? The planets are not like excited electrons waiting to fall into lower orbits, they are in stable orbits. You'd need to supply energy to move one. Lots of it. And you'd still have a large gravity well, just in a different orbit. Unless you sent it crashing into something else, which would liberate a lot of energy and debris. 65,000,000 years ago all over again.
I was certainly thinking of crashing them together, starting with the smallest one that can be used to shift a bigger one. It would take a lot of energy, but still a lot less then trying to shift saturn or something directly.
And, yes, debree and choas everywhere - I was speculating though that any civ considering this would be able to track and predict it all accurately thousands of years in advance.
I don't think many at NASA will be supporting Obama in next election for President of the United States.
Its him or a guy that doesn't know why aircraft windows don't open ;)
User avatar
pogo
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 14180
Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
Location: County Durham

Re: SPACE

Post by pogo »

Darkflame wrote:Certainly - I cant think of any normal needs of a civilization that could ever need that much energy. But isnt it interesting to speculate what might?
Speculate, sure, but not spend money searching such spheres on the assumption some other civilisation had the need and the resources.
I was certainly thinking of crashing them together, starting with the smallest one that can be used to shift a bigger one. It would take a lot of energy, but still a lot less then trying to shift saturn or something directly.
The problem is you don't magically reduce the amount of energy like this: to move Saturn say you need to supply enough energy + momentum to displace it wherever that energy comes from. And you don't gain energy as you smash smaller things together you lose it. Think e.g. snooker: the more things you hit the less energy is imparted to each.

For the gas giants you'd need to fire something larger at them, or something moving very fast. In either case it would need momentum greater than the planet you are trying to move. The only place that momentum exists in the solar system is inside the gas giants. You'd need to use one to displace another. Clearly impossible as what do you displace it with first? Even the rocky planets, or the moons of the planets, have the same problem: the only way to displace one is to fire something as big at it, but then how do you get that moving?
User avatar
Darkflame
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18236
Joined: Mon Mar 31, 2003 11:06 am 0
Location: Not the UK

Re: SPACE

Post by Darkflame »

? I though shifting something (like pluto) to a lower/decaying orbit would automatically make it faster? Pretty sure when moving masses towards the sun energy is gained - even if it takes a lot to set it going your going downwards into the suns energy well.

I was certainly going for the "small and fast" idea rather then bigger.
Speculate, sure, but not spend money searching such spheres on the assumption some other civilisation had the need and the resources.
agreed - if they constructed it, they would find being the ones finding us, or not want to be found.

Unless its still under construction, or they are dead.
In either case it wont likely match predictions.
User avatar
ElfQrin
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 4384
Joined: Mon Jul 28, 2003 12:55 pm 0
Location: Italy
Contact:

Re: SPACE

Post by ElfQrin »

Darkflame wrote:
Sounds dubious to me though. The energy calculations are boggling. Today the amount of energy that lands on the Earth is 10,000 what we use. Ever assuming we eventually use 10% of Earth's area for collection and this is 10% efficient we can collect enough energy for our needs 100 times over: long before we need that we will have found ways to vastly improve our energy efficiency, and probably found new sources to supplement solar ones: fusion using the near limitless supply of hydrogen for example. Or we'll have found a source of uranium somewhere else in the solar system.
Certainly - I cant think of any normal needs of a civilization that could ever need that much energy. But isnt it interesting to speculate what might?
Sure it does. 200 years ago nobody could imagine we'd need 12 terawatts to run Planet Earth.

And yet -- paraphrasing Bill Gates -- "12 terawatts ought be enough for any planet", is still a faulty thought.
User avatar
pogo
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 14180
Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
Location: County Durham

Re: SPACE

Post by pogo »

Darkflame wrote:? I though shifting something (like pluto) to a lower/decaying orbit would automatically make it faster? Pretty sure when moving masses towards the sun energy is gained - even if it takes a lot to set it going your going downwards into the suns energy well.
I can think of all sorts of scenarios but none where you get out more energy than you put in: to move planets you need to supply planet-sized energy, including to liberate planets from their orbits so then can speed towards the sun clipping other planets as they go. You really need to back this up with maths or a link to someone who's done the maths.
agreed - if they constructed it, they would find being the ones finding us, or not want to be found.
The search seems to be on the assumption that to detect radio waves the civilisation would have to be wanting to be found, which makes some sort of sense, and we can detect a Dyson sphere whatever. But radio waves still seem much more likely to me than Dyson spheres which just seem very improbable.

I wouldn't be surprised if we do that ourselves, make ourselves highly visible, by building large radio transmitters perhaps in space. Rather than broadcasting everywhere these could be directional, pointing at stars with planets of the right size, as I'm sure we'll get much, much better at detecting these using e.g. more spacebound detectors and telescopes. The assumption is if there's any civilisation out there it's monitoring radio sources, like we do all the time (as it can be done from Earth so is relatively cheap).
User avatar
Dio
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18887
Joined: Mon May 31, 2004 1:08 pm 0
Location: Newcastle UK

Re: SPACE

Post by Dio »

Advertising your presence in the universe is (blatantly obviously) mind-bogglingly stupid.
User avatar
pogo
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 14180
Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
Location: County Durham

Re: SPACE

Post by pogo »

Why? That seems to presume that other civilisations will be hostile. That makes good sci-fi but I suspect the reality is much more boring. And whoever is out there they're constrained by the same laws of physics as us. If we find interstellar travel impossible then they should too. Even if they are hostile they'll be able to do nothing about it.

We will be much more certain of this in the future, once we've several centuries space travel behind us and know the limits of technology (we already have a good grasp of the theory). So by the time we're able to start sending messages to other stats we should be much more confident of the outcome. And being unable to visit them ourselves and having already explored our own solar system by then it might be the only way left to expand our horizons.
User avatar
Dio
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18887
Joined: Mon May 31, 2004 1:08 pm 0
Location: Newcastle UK

Re: SPACE

Post by Dio »

As opposed to the presumption that they won't be hostile, which is supremely naive. We lose nothing by keeping quiet, but there is potentially everything to lose by not doing so.
User avatar
venusian
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6655
Joined: Wed Nov 06, 2002 2:22 pm 0
Location: South Gloucestershire

Re: SPACE

Post by venusian »

We'd lose triple breasted whores. I think the risk is worth it.
Post Reply