SPACE

Inane baanter or words of wisdom - you decide...
Post Reply
User avatar
pogo
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 14180
Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
Location: County Durham

Re: SPACE

Post by pogo »

Dio wrote:As opposed to the presumption that they won't be hostile, which is supremely naive. We lose nothing by keeping quiet, but there is potentially everything to lose by not doing so.
But what will we lose if we don't? Now there's so much about even the nearest planets that we don't know. But centuries or millennia from now we may have explored them all, be living on some of them, so there is nothing left to discover locally. We could have telescopes in space hundreds of times bigger than the ones we use today able to peer further into space. We might see compelling evidence of the existence of other civilisations. I think there will be an overwhelming desire to contact them.

Don't forget we've already sent messages with probes we've sent into space, including the only ones to leave the solar system. In a sense the decision's already been made: if there is anyone out there we want to know and want them to know us.
User avatar
Dio
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18887
Joined: Mon May 31, 2004 1:08 pm 0
Location: Newcastle UK

Re: SPACE

Post by Dio »

Well, I couldn't possibly disagree more. But there you go.
User avatar
F-ZeroOne
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 8214
Joined: Wed Sep 29, 2004 8:27 pm 0

Re: SPACE

Post by F-ZeroOne »

pogo wrote:Why? That seems to presume that other civilisations will be hostile. That makes good sci-fi but I suspect the reality is much more boring. And whoever is out there they're constrained by the same laws of physics as us. If we find interstellar travel impossible then they should too. Even if they are hostile they'll be able to do nothing about it.
I think its just worth pointing out that we've found interstellar travel impossible so far. There have been some speculations on how it can be done even with slower-than-light (or even a fraction of it) spacecraft, such as self-replicating robot probes.
"Stars don't twinkle in space." - Char Aznable.
User avatar
pogo
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 14180
Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
Location: County Durham

Re: SPACE

Post by pogo »

By the time we're able to beam signals into space we should be a lot more certain whether interstellar flight is possible. And even if we solve that problem, it will be much more interesting to travel somewhere where we know there's another civilisation. If we're going to invest a large proportion of the world's resources in such a project we'll want to send it somewhere interesting such as somewhere with life.

It's possible that views like Dio's will prevail, and we won't do anything out of fear of what we find. But I don't see it: people explored the world knowing not what they would find, even thinking there were terrible things out there. And often there were and people didn't come back. But curiosity got the better of us, and I think it will in the future, especially once we've run out of things in the solar system to explore.
User avatar
Dio
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18887
Joined: Mon May 31, 2004 1:08 pm 0
Location: Newcastle UK

Re: SPACE

Post by Dio »

Weak analogy. Nobody thought when they were exploring the world that there was any possibility of the consequence being the extinction of the species.

When such things are on the agenda, a risk would have to be provably extremely small to be worth taking, and that absolutely, utterly, cannot be shown to be the case.
User avatar
Darkflame
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18236
Joined: Mon Mar 31, 2003 11:06 am 0
Location: Not the UK

Re: SPACE

Post by Darkflame »

Any civilization able to cross vaste distances to reach us would need nothing in terms of raw resources from our planet, we would only be valuable for our knowledge and culture.
They could try slavery, but whipping us out would be pointless. Even as slaves robots would be easier and cheaper.

The only scenario were the aliens would come specifically to wipe us out, would be if they were evil for evils sake - and evolution doesn't seem to favor that. You can be critical of humans as you like, but we tend to operate for our own self-interests or our groups interest, we dont go miles out of our way to harm others for its own sake.
Weak analogy. Nobody thought when they were exploring the world that there was any possibility of the consequence being the extinction of the species.
Plenty of people thought the LHC was going to kill us all in a black hole. Doesn't make them right, but people thought it.
As opposed to the presumption that they won't be hostile, which is supremely naive. We lose nothing by keeping quiet,
If your allowed to state they are potentially hostile, then we can also state they potentially have the solutions to all our worlds problems and will happily share them.
Their "tech tree" might be so different to ours that we both gain hugely from collaboration - protecting us from the universes natural threats.
User avatar
Darkflame
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18236
Joined: Mon Mar 31, 2003 11:06 am 0
Location: Not the UK

Re: SPACE

Post by Darkflame »

I can think of all sorts of scenarios but none where you get out more energy than you put in: to move planets you need to supply planet-sized energy, including to liberate planets from their orbits so then can speed towards the sun clipping other planets as they go. You really need to back this up with maths or a link to someone who's done the maths.
I am not saying its enough energy, I wouldn't know where to start to work that out.
But I cant see how you wouldn't gain some energy.
Are you saying, basicly, its horizontal speed times its mass will always be more then [whatever the equation is to work out the energy gained from something dropping like a stone from a far orbit towards the sun with no orbital momentum at all].
I mean, surely your also talking about ridiculous potential energy given that mass and distances? Isnt it the old penny-from-the--empire--state-building scenario?
User avatar
pogo
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 14180
Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
Location: County Durham

Re: SPACE

Post by pogo »

Darkflame wrote:I am not saying its enough energy, I wouldn't know where to start to work that out.
But I cant see how you wouldn't gain some energy.
Are you saying, basicly, its horizontal speed times its mass will always be more then [whatever the equation is to work out the energy gained from something dropping like a stone from a far orbit towards the sun with no orbital momentum at all].
I mean, surely your also talking about ridiculous potential energy given that mass and distances? Isnt it the old penny-from-the--empire--state-building scenario?
Again you really need to provide some theory: a falling penny is so unlike how planets move in so many ways it's useless as an example. The planets aren't sitting on a ledge, say, constrained from falling 'down' towards the sun so only a small nudge will set them on their way and liberate all that potential energy.
User avatar
Dio
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18887
Joined: Mon May 31, 2004 1:08 pm 0
Location: Newcastle UK

Re: SPACE

Post by Dio »

Darkflame wrote:Any civilization able to cross vaste distances to reach us would need nothing in terms of raw resources from our planet, we would only be valuable for our knowledge and culture.
They could try slavery, but whipping us out would be pointless. Even as slaves robots would be easier and cheaper.

The only scenario were the aliens would come specifically to wipe us out, would be if they were evil for evils sake - and evolution doesn't seem to favor that. You can be critical of humans as you like, but we tend to operate for our own self-interests or our groups interest, we dont go miles out of our way to harm others for its own sake.
This is merely naive optimism, trying to fit facts to your own worldview. If there is other life out there, in the absence of some kind of large-scale panspermia (which, science fiction not withstanding, there doesn't appear to be evidence for) we have absolutely no conception of what form it might take or what prejudices it might have. There are no reliable predictions that can be made. Only guesses.
Weak analogy. Nobody thought when they were exploring the world that there was any possibility of the consequence being the extinction of the species.
Plenty of people thought the LHC was going to kill us all in a black hole. Doesn't make them right, but people thought it.
Note my point about 'provably' above. There was plenty of good scientific work to show that the LHC would not do so, not to mention that far higher energy collisions than the LHC take place miles above your head every second.
As opposed to the presumption that they won't be hostile, which is supremely naive. We lose nothing by keeping quiet,
If your allowed to state they are potentially hostile, then we can also state they potentially have the solutions to all our worlds problems and will happily share them.
Their "tech tree" might be so different to ours that we both gain hugely from collaboration - protecting us from the universes natural threats.
That's not what I said. I said we wouldn't lose anything. You're arguing that we wouldn't potentially gain something.

Your argument is simply gambling, with the lives of the entire species. Isn't any chance of utter annihilation - even if small - most sensibly not taken? Would you play roulette if the penalty for the 0 was the forfeiture of your life, rather than your bet? You've a 97.3% chance of survival. How many spins would you play for? How many alien races might be out there?
User avatar
(o)(o)
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6885
Joined: Tue Jan 19, 2010 2:21 am 0

Re: SPACE

Post by (o)(o) »

Darkflame wrote:The only scenario were the aliens would come specifically to wipe us out, would be if they were evil for evils sake.. If your allowed to state they are potentially hostile, then we can also state they potentially have the solutions to all our worlds problems and will happily share them.
Will they want to have sex with us, that is the important question.
User avatar
Governmentyard
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 11757
Joined: Sun Oct 31, 2004 9:41 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: GovernmentYard
Yahoo Messenger: governmentyard

Re: SPACE

Post by Governmentyard »

I hope so.

Image
XBox Gamertag: GovernmentYard
Everything else: governmentyard
User avatar
funkstar
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 2069
Joined: Sun Aug 08, 2004 2:56 pm 0
Location: Copenhagen, Denmark

Re: SPACE

Post by funkstar »

Dio wrote:As opposed to the presumption that they won't be hostile, which is supremely naive. We lose nothing by keeping quiet, but there is potentially everything to lose by not doing so.
A space version of Pascal's wager, then?
User avatar
Darkflame
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18236
Joined: Mon Mar 31, 2003 11:06 am 0
Location: Not the UK

Re: SPACE

Post by Darkflame »

This is merely naive optimism, trying to fit facts to your own worldview. If there is other life out there, in the absence of some kind of large-scale panspermia (which, science fiction not withstanding, there doesn't appear to be evidence for) we have absolutely no conception of what form it might take or what prejudices it might have. There are no reliable predictions that can be made. Only guesses.
Evolution would still apply, and so would energy/resource issues.
Those were the only two things my logic depended on.
It takes effort to be evil for evils sake - for no evolutionary advantage.

It is not "optimism" to ask "why" when someone assumes a lifeform would travel vaste distances to try to whipe us out.
Note my point about 'provably' above. There was plenty of good scientific work to show that the LHC would not do so, not to mention that far higher energy collisions than the LHC take place miles above your head every second.
So your talking only of people thinking rationally then, fair enough.
So what rational reasons are there to expect aggression?
That's not what I said. I said we wouldn't lose anything. You're arguing that we wouldn't potentially gain something.
Semantics.
If we get whipped out by our inaction or lack of knowledge its the exact same thing. In both cases we "lose everything"
Your argument is simply gambling, with the lives of the entire species. Isn't any chance of utter annihilation - even if small - most sensibly not taken? Would you play roulette if the penalty for the 0 was the forfeiture of your life, rather than your bet? You've a 97.3% chance of survival. How many spins would you play for? How many alien races might be out there?
Id say its gabbling as much as the LHC was - unless a bunch of evolutionary scientists and physicists start saying "actually, it does make sense energy wise for a species to do this" then I dont think your reasoning makes sense at all.
Its counter to all (apparent) logic. While I do fully understand there may be factors I haven't considered I am not going to assume hiding in our corner is "safer" unless new evidence, or at least, hypothesis come to light.
Last edited by Darkflame on Tue Oct 09, 2012 3:40 pm 0, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
Darkflame
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18236
Joined: Mon Mar 31, 2003 11:06 am 0
Location: Not the UK

Re: SPACE

Post by Darkflame »

pogo wrote:
Darkflame wrote:I am not saying its enough energy, I wouldn't know where to start to work that out.
But I cant see how you wouldn't gain some energy.
Are you saying, basicly, its horizontal speed times its mass will always be more then [whatever the equation is to work out the energy gained from something dropping like a stone from a far orbit towards the sun with no orbital momentum at all].
I mean, surely your also talking about ridiculous potential energy given that mass and distances? Isnt it the old penny-from-the--empire--state-building scenario?
Again you really need to provide some theory: a falling penny is so unlike how planets move in so many ways it's useless as an example. The planets aren't sitting on a ledge, say, constrained from falling 'down' towards the sun so only a small nudge will set them on their way and liberate all that potential energy.
No, they have sufficient horizontal momentum that their "fall" is countered by drop of from the body they are orbiting. I might not know the lingo, but I understand orbits.

What I was trying to state is that if something has no orbital momentum then it is analogous to a falling penny. (so its position/speed would be the same as if it was indeed just lifted to that height in a elevator)
Therefor, to work out if this would gain energy we need to know if the energy needed to stop pluto would be greater or less then its potential energy from "falling".

Lets perhaps rephrase this:

If a penny was orbiting the earth, would it take more energy to stop the penny*, then the penny would release by falling to the ground from that height.
(assuming the penny is indestructible, and theres no air friction etc?)

*or even slow it enough to a decaying orbit
User avatar
venusian
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6655
Joined: Wed Nov 06, 2002 2:22 pm 0
Location: South Gloucestershire

Re: SPACE

Post by venusian »

Shirley, those two amounts of energy are the same. If one was greater than the other the planet would either fly off or crash into the sun.

Or perhaps 1 second isn't long enough to think about this.
Post Reply