This is merely naive optimism, trying to fit facts to your own worldview. If there is other life out there, in the absence of some kind of large-scale panspermia (which, science fiction not withstanding, there doesn't appear to be evidence for) we have absolutely no conception of what form it might take or what prejudices it might have. There are no reliable predictions that can be made. Only guesses.
Evolution would still apply, and so would energy/resource issues.
Those were the only two things my logic depended on.
It takes
effort to be evil for evils sake - for no evolutionary advantage.
It is not "optimism" to ask "why" when someone assumes a lifeform would travel vaste distances to try to whipe us out.
Note my point about 'provably' above. There was plenty of good scientific work to show that the LHC would not do so, not to mention that far higher energy collisions than the LHC take place miles above your head every second.
So your talking only of people thinking rationally then, fair enough.
So what rational reasons are there to expect aggression?
That's not what I said. I said we wouldn't lose anything. You're arguing that we wouldn't potentially gain something.
Semantics.
If we get whipped out by our inaction or lack of knowledge its the exact same thing. In both cases we "lose everything"
Your argument is simply gambling, with the lives of the entire species. Isn't any chance of utter annihilation - even if small - most sensibly not taken? Would you play roulette if the penalty for the 0 was the forfeiture of your life, rather than your bet? You've a 97.3% chance of survival. How many spins would you play for? How many alien races might be out there?
Id say its gabbling as much as the LHC was - unless a bunch of evolutionary scientists and physicists start saying
"actually, it does make sense energy wise for a species to do this" then I dont think your reasoning makes sense at all.
Its counter to all (apparent) logic. While I do fully understand there may be factors I haven't considered I am not going to assume hiding in our corner is "safer" unless new evidence, or at least, hypothesis come to light.