Misfit wrote:I guess that is swinging me towards the Pro then. I wonder what that extra 270g will be like as I lug it around on business trips to London.
Did want to go with the Air as I'm somewhat annoyed they didn't improve the graphics on the 13" Retina Pro.
Been going backwards and forwards on this one for the last week.
Was swinging towards the pro because of the dual video and had a quick look at a one in PC world today. Was impressed that it's actually small than the air (not thinner), but couldn't pick it up to compare weight.
So was leaning that way. But then I saw the base model is only marginally faster than the base Air and a lot slower than the 15 and then read chat about image retention and then realised you don't get all that resolution and in fact in full retina mode you are still getting a 1280x800 resolution which is less than the 1440x900 of the air (you can up to 1680x1050, but it sounds like you get a performance hit) so it's swinging back towards the Air now.
This review over at the Verge pretty much nailed the coffin:
http://www.theverge.com/2012/11/1/35850 ... lay-review
The summary...
I spent the entire time I was reviewing the 13-inch MacBook Pro with Retina Display thinking about the MacBook Air. Not the current Air, which has become the best overall laptop on the market, but the very first Air — the one from 2008 that was ridiculously underpowered, featured terrible integrated Intel graphics, had just 2GB of RAM and an 80GB hard drive, and cost an absurd $1,799. I know people who bought that computer and felt an immediate combination of intense love and deep regret — while it was blindingly clear that all laptops would be that thin and beautiful in the future, it was equally clear that Apple was too far ahead of the performance curve in the present. Four years later, the Air has become Apple’s mainstream product and the PC industry is still working to catch up. The curve has flattened out.
It’s the same thing with the 13-inch Pro — it’s hard not to love this thing when you first see it. Just look at that screen. But you’re paying a lot of money for a computer that once again offers a single tantalizing glimpse of the future only to be limited by the realities of the present in almost every other way. One day all computer displays will look this good. One day we’ll sit around campfires, drinking moonshine and telling our children nightmare tales of visible pixels and display resolutions under 200ppi. That day will be wonderful. It will also have a reasonable graphics chip, more than 128GB of storage, and cost less than $1,699.
Until that day comes, you should either trade up to the 15-inch MacBook Pro with Retina Display or buy a MacBook Air and save your wistful Retina dreams for a $499 iPad on the side.
Ideally I'd like to wait until next year to see if they do a Retina Air (which will need to be higher res to cope with 1440x900 and possible why it didn't happen on the Air) or see if the Pro gets discreet graphics. But I can't. My current (late 2010) Air is still close to perfect really, except I need 8GB of RAM as I need to use multiple VMs at the same time the 4GB isn't enough.
I see Apple have a refurbished top spec Air (2GHz i7 with 512GB SSD) for £100 less than a base Retina with 256GB SSD which is very very tempting right now...