stupid physics questions

Inane baanter or words of wisdom - you decide...
Post Reply
User avatar
zip accident
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 13928
Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 1:58 pm 0
Location: Bristol, UK

Re: stupid physics questions

Post by zip accident »

pogo wrote:
zip accident wrote:Any particle with a rest mass, yes. However, it's when they are at the speed of light that they have, or appear to have, mass.
No that's just wrong. The energy required to accelerate a mass to lightspeed is infinite, so particles that go at the speed of light must have no mass. This is fundamental special relativity, and only requires high school maths. Look in particular at Lorentz factor.
We've had this discussion before, the answer was so far as I understood wikipedia indeterminate at that time, and I assume is still so at this time.
Massless particles are known to experience the same gravitational acceleration as other particles (which provides empirical evidence for the equivalence principle) because they do have relativistic mass, which is what acts as the gravity charge
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Massless_particle

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rest_mass

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Relativistic_mass

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mass_in_general_relativity
"My way is the way of not fighting":- the book of Enter the Dragon.
User avatar
pogo
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 14180
Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
Location: County Durham

Re: stupid physics questions

Post by pogo »

That's not mass as most people understand it. Photons are massless, which is clearly understood. Photons always go at the speed of light (sort of tautologically, but also necessarily). You can't then say "therefore they have mass" as if it suddenly makes sense. Again by straightforward maths it takes an infinite amount of energy to accelerate a mass to the speed of light, so is impossible. As it says at the last of the links you provide (the last two are the same article):
Although some authors present relativistic mass as a fundamental concept of the theory, it has been argued that this is wrong as the fundamentals of the theory relate to space-time. There is disagreement over whether the concept is pedagogically useful.
or see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Relativist ... ontroversy

You really shouldn't believe everything you read on Wikipedia, or at least you should read down to where it basically says "most physicists think the above is bunkum".
User avatar
zip accident
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 13928
Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 1:58 pm 0
Location: Bristol, UK

Re: stupid physics questions

Post by zip accident »

lazerwalker wrote: ... at the risk of coming across as a dick,
To me, you didn't. :D

I'm aware I have limitations, but not always what they are in particular.

Analogies are as good for working with, as they are accurate, which is what makes maths an excellent analogy, if you accept that it is. The water in pipes analogy for electricity is not particularly good when you get to details, though it's perhaps okay to get the basics across. I was a lot happier with optics than electricity. I find quantum mechanics and relativity too arguable to take for granted, I hope there's a theory that will make more sense to my intuition around the corner. Spacetime bending in strange ways for strange particles would be complicated in detail, but it might work all the way up and down the range from macro to micro. There might be some reason it can't work, but so far none has made clear sense to me, which I accept might be due to my limitations.
"My way is the way of not fighting":- the book of Enter the Dragon.
User avatar
pogo
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 14180
Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
Location: County Durham

Re: stupid physics questions

Post by pogo »

But relativity and quantum mechanics are both very well established theories. Each was able to explain many previously inexplicable phenomena. Each has been tested again and again to confirm their results. And we now have real world products that depend on them working. GPS depends on relativity: without taking it into account they would not keep time accurately. And many electronic phenomena depend on on quantum mechanics. So both are required for your iPhone to work properly, for example.

As for some better theorem coming along it may well do; scientists have a number of candidate theories for a 'theory of everything' that explains both relativity and quantum mechanics. But such theories are necessarily very abstract and so far are very complex and counterintuitive. Perhaps the best known is string theory. The problem is there are a lot of them and we have no ways of testing to see which is correct, if any. Until this happens it will be difficult for them to win broad acceptance.
User avatar
zip accident
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 13928
Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 1:58 pm 0
Location: Bristol, UK

Re: stupid physics questions

Post by zip accident »

pogo wrote:relativity and quantum mechanics are both very well established theories.
No doubt. They are however mutually incompatible, which is a bit of a theoretical problem.

This paradigm came to me because I don't particularly like the space bending description of gravity, so I thought why doesn't that work for the other forces too, so then I began to think maybe it might. Another advantage of exploring it is that if it turns out to be an incomplete analogy for the other forces, it might turn out to be a incomplete analogy for gravity for the same reasons.
"My way is the way of not fighting":- the book of Enter the Dragon.
User avatar
pogo
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 14180
Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
Location: County Durham

Re: stupid physics questions

Post by pogo »

zip accident wrote:
pogo wrote:relativity and quantum mechanics are both very well established theories.
No doubt. They are however mutually incompatible, which is a bit of a theoretical problem.
No they're not. Certainly no-one has done any science that invalidates either, so as far as the known universe goes they are compatible. If they were incompatible then there would be some prediction they make that's different. That would mean there's an experiment we can do that tells us which is right by invalidating one of them. But there's no such experiment.

What we don't have is a theory that explains both of them. Physicists think there's a theory that unifies them, and so explains both relativity and QM. In fact they have a number of such theories. But they don't know which is right, which one conforms to reality. Part of the problem is relativity and QM both work so well at explaining the universe. If there was some incompatibility a deeper theory might explain it. But they are completely compatible with each other.
User avatar
zip accident
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 13928
Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 1:58 pm 0
Location: Bristol, UK

Re: stupid physics questions

Post by zip accident »

pogo wrote:Part of the problem is relativity and QM both work so well at explaining the universe.
So you do admit there is a problem?
"My way is the way of not fighting":- the book of Enter the Dragon.
User avatar
pogo
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 14180
Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
Location: County Durham

Re: stupid physics questions

Post by pogo »

zip accident wrote:
pogo wrote:Part of the problem is relativity and QM both work so well at explaining the universe.
So you do admit there is a problem?
By problem I mean a problem for your viewpoint, that they are incompatible. You can't just assert that, you have to say why. For example, "relativity predicts x, but quantum mechanics predicts y, and x ≠ y". Something real world that we can test or at least try and examine. But so far there's nothing.

What we don't have is theories that predict both QM and relativity. There's no reason there has to be such a theory. But physicists would like to find one. Partly as it would satisfy their desire for a well-ordered universe that obeys one set of rules. But also if they find a theory it might make other predictions which lead to new science and discoveries, including ones that solve currently unsolved problems such as "what is the nature of dark matter?".
User avatar
Mr Dom
Baaaaa!
Baaaaa!
Posts: 1375
Joined: Fri Dec 03, 2004 3:03 pm 0
Location: Cardiff

Re: stupid physics questions

Post by Mr Dom »

zip accident wrote:This paradigm came to me because I don't particularly like the space bending description of gravity, so I thought why doesn't that work for the other forces too, so then I began to think maybe it might.
It's all about how you measure space relative to other things, and how you do this is the basis of gauge theories...
An analogy I have used before is the idea of cheese space...
Suppose you had a ruler that changed length in the presence of cheese. The closer you are to cheese, the shorter the ruler gets. You can then create newtons equations of motion using this ruler as your basis for measuring distance, and it is possible, but complicated, to come up with equations that describe the path of an object by cheese. (Note that the cheese doesn't affect the 'real world', just your measure).
then suppose someone comes along with a solid ruler that doesn't bend with cheese, and formulates new equations. If the equations are consistent, one in cheese space, one in real space, then both are mathematically valid. One happens to be simpler.

In effect you have the two situations, one that involves a bendy space, one that doesn't, but (and this is the point), both are equally right. However, drawing conclusions on the nature of real space from twisty bits of cheese space maths is fraught with problems, as you don't know if the effect you predict is an artifact of the maths or 'real', and while comparing the theories may help, they don't always:
e.g:
Gravitation Gauge Theory (Lasenby, Gull,Doran et al at MRAO) does this with GR, and one of the things that drops out is that the red shift may be caused by light losing energy as it travels over astronomical distances, and not an expanding universe. However, the theories don't say which it is, and you can phlisophically argue that it can be both at the same time!

So -in reference to the quoted point - yes, you can apply it to other forces. It may not be possibly with todays maths, but theoretically it could be made to work. The equations would be a nightmare, and it may not provide any actual insights into the real world (but may get mathematicians really excited about a particularly twisty equation!)

Interestingly, GGT uses Clifford Algebra, which has also been successfully applies to QM and provides some simplifications, in particular a rotation operation is naturally spin-half in nature, and the quaternion (or bi-vector in CA) is the natural expression of a rotation. I strongly suspect that clifford algebra & the flat space guage theory is a better place to start looking for a more unified theory than anywhere else.

Now onto completely personal conjecture:
My own personal take is that we do not understand enough about the nature of time yet. What it is, how it behaves. I suspect time is to do with a granularity in the rate of quantum events (much like how temperature is generally a measure of the kinetic energy of atoms). Raw energy has very few quantum events, but once it has collapsed into matter, it is capable of many more. Now the number of quantum events is strongly tied with entropy - the more states you have, the higher the entropy. Gravity can be seen as a mutual attraction between dense entropic particles (like soap bubbles sticking together), and the denser you get, the more it slows down the passage of time (or the rate of change of entropic events). If so, then gravity becomes effectively a 'time pressure' - in a way nature acts to concentrate the dense lumps of entropy together.
In GGT, time is bendier than GR, but you can establish a base universal time, and everywhere else runs local clocks that are <= to the base time dependant on gravity/entropic density (as these would be proportional so are effectively the sme thing)
Anyway, that may be all bullcrap, but in essence, I'm of the opinion that space doesn't curve, and gravity isn't a real 'force, and is in fact an artifact of time & entropy, thus will not be unifiable with electromagnetism, but electromagnetism, once constructed in a flat gauge space with an 'entropic time', could provide a unified theory of nearly everything.
Hopefully that gives you some more random spanners more to chew on ;)
- Dom
Play Games
<Haircuts are for wimps!>
User avatar
toxibunny
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 5906
Joined: Thu Jun 17, 2004 11:59 pm 0
Location: limb clock land

Re: stupid physics questions

Post by toxibunny »

Do we have any idea what anything actually *is*, at all? Is it possible to know?
I made a deviantart page.
'....The baron is a gay old rogue with an eye for the ladies....'
User avatar
Absolute_Zero
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 3564
Joined: Wed May 18, 2005 4:11 pm 0
Location: Hilbert Hotel, Heisenberg.

Re: stupid physics questions

Post by Absolute_Zero »

toxibunny wrote:Do we have any idea what anything actually *is*, at all? Is it possible to know?
It's possibly not possible to know what's possible to know. IOW, it's a wait and see situation.

Beyond the universe as a stringy hologram idea [which I can live with]... some argue that that we experience could be a simulation.

http://phys.org/news/2012-12-simulation-idea.html

My anti-argument at this point is: if we're in a simulation, why not the simulator also, ad-infinitum. Ad-infinitum = no reality = nonsense. Turtles all the way down^H^H^H^H up.
User avatar
toxibunny
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 5906
Joined: Thu Jun 17, 2004 11:59 pm 0
Location: limb clock land

Re: stupid physics questions

Post by toxibunny »

What's wrong with thinking it's all just made of stuff, instead of being a hologram or a simulation or whatever?
I made a deviantart page.
'....The baron is a gay old rogue with an eye for the ladies....'
User avatar
Absolute_Zero
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 3564
Joined: Wed May 18, 2005 4:11 pm 0
Location: Hilbert Hotel, Heisenberg.

Re: stupid physics questions

Post by Absolute_Zero »

^ recently, scientists are tending toward regarding the physical world as made of information, with energy and matter as incidental.
User avatar
toxibunny
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 5906
Joined: Thu Jun 17, 2004 11:59 pm 0
Location: limb clock land

Re: stupid physics questions

Post by toxibunny »

hmm...
I made a deviantart page.
'....The baron is a gay old rogue with an eye for the ladies....'
User avatar
5th Earth
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 2091
Joined: Thu Feb 26, 2004 12:51 am 0
Location: San Jose, California

Re: stupid physics questions

Post by 5th Earth »

pogo wrote:
zip accident wrote:
pogo wrote:Part of the problem is relativity and QM both work so well at explaining the universe.
So you do admit there is a problem?
By problem I mean a problem for your viewpoint, that they are incompatible. You can't just assert that, you have to say why. For example, "relativity predicts x, but quantum mechanics predicts y, and x ≠ y". Something real world that we can test or at least try and examine. But so far there's nothing.

What we don't have is theories that predict both QM and relativity. There's no reason there has to be such a theory. But physicists would like to find one. Partly as it would satisfy their desire for a well-ordered universe that obeys one set of rules. But also if they find a theory it might make other predictions which lead to new science and discoveries, including ones that solve currently unsolved problems such as "what is the nature of dark matter?".
My understanding has been that relativistic gravity doesn't work right at quantum distances. The calculations start giving infinite answers, or something. But I'm very fuzzy on this.
It seemed like a good idea at the time.
Post Reply