Bigger, Faster, Stronger!

Inane baanter or words of wisdom - you decide...
Post Reply
User avatar
gravy
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 19572
Joined: Wed May 01, 2002 1:28 pm 0
Location: The Other Place

Re: Bigger, Faster, Stronger!

Post by gravy »

(o)(o) wrote:Human physiology is complex and it's clear there is great variation from person to person. Reducing it down to "Do X Don't do Y" is nonsense. Advocating one weight loss approach over others is nonsense.
(o)(o) wrote:Point is, anything will work for weight loss, so long as there's a calorific deficit. I think somebody recently posted a successful twinkie diet ? I've also seen a potato only diet. Compliance is the key.
Brilliant. In the course of one post.
User avatar
VNVObit
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 4072
Joined: Sun Jan 01, 2006 10:03 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: vnvobit
PSN: VNV_Obit
Location: London

Re: Bigger, Faster, Stronger!

Post by VNVObit »

typical day at present

breakfast
scrambled eggs (3) and 2 slices of brown toast

Lunch
sushi (mainly salmon, avocado, tuna) or meat and salad (usually including some avocado)

evening

bran, fruit (bananas, berries) and some nuts (almond, cashew) with yoghurt

I don't tend to snack before 5 but need something around then to get me home (75 min commute) usually something like granola bar if I am not prepared but if I am some nakd bars

I still eat cake occasionally (weekends)

This all goes out the window when going to rugby matches or change in work routine (working from home, commuting by bike - when my carb intake increases)

not low carb but definitely lower
"England is funny, but sometimes she scares me"
Tony Wakeford

My avatar is the cover of Tower of Babel's first single

"Sky is not roof, Earth is not bottom, the world is not yours, you are the world's" from Brown by Grotus
User avatar
starshipcommand
Baaaaa!
Baaaaa!
Posts: 1726
Joined: Thu Jun 24, 2004 7:27 pm 0
Location: UK

Re: Bigger, Faster, Stronger!

Post by starshipcommand »

Typical working day:

Breakfast:
Nothing. Not particularly hungry, and don't have much spare time in the morning.

Lunch:
Usually salad (quite a big one, with goat's cheese, sun dried tomatoes, chilli olives, etc).
Sometimes chicken & vegetables for a change.
A few cups of tea over the course of a day (with one sugar)

Dinner:
Meat, usually cooked in oven or griddle thing, and vegetables, with gravy or ketchup.
Small amount of dessert (e.g. a kit-kat finger, a biscuit and unsweetened yoghurt in a bowl).
User avatar
(o)(o)
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6885
Joined: Tue Jan 19, 2010 2:21 am 0

Re: Bigger, Faster, Stronger!

Post by (o)(o) »

gravy wrote:(o)(o) Taubes has an Applied Physics Degree from Harvard and Aerospace Engineering one from Stanford. Is that all that relevant? Not really, the point I was making is his education isn't in what he's been writing about. You're not being clever here.
You said he's a Physicist. He's not. He's a journalist. He doesn't call himself a Physicist, he calls himself a journalist. Because that's what he is.

Sorry if this is confusing for you. Perhaps this quote from Gary will help ?

Gary Taubes: "If [my recommendations] kill you, I apologise.. but I'm just a journalist.. who takes health advice from a journalist anyway.. hahaha.. " (circling gesture to indicate a mental case)
gravy wrote:
bumblebee wrote:And one more thing some of you might find interesting... well, at least I did..
A presentation by Christopher Gardner from the Stanford School of Medicine. He shows data from various studies on different diets.



As for everyone is different.. Yes, to a degree. If a person is already obese there is a good reason to believe that they can't handle carbohydrates as good as another person and then a diet is not = to a diet.
It's a good video, I posted it a while back.

(o)(o) rubbished it.
This one is a straight out lie.

Very weird one.

Gravy didn't post it, I did, as recommended viewing.

At this point gravy is looking like a mental case.
gravy wrote:
(o)(o) wrote:Human physiology is complex and it's clear there is great variation from person to person. Reducing it down to "Do X Don't do Y" is nonsense. Advocating one weight loss approach over others is nonsense.
(o)(o) wrote:Point is, anything will work for weight loss, so long as there's a calorific deficit. I think somebody recently posted a successful twinkie diet ? I've also seen a potato only diet. Compliance is the key.
Brilliant. In the course of one post.
Those statements compliment each other. Weight loss "approaches" are a subset of "calorie deficit". It helps if you don't remove the context.
User avatar
(o)(o)
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6885
Joined: Tue Jan 19, 2010 2:21 am 0

Re: Bigger, Faster, Stronger!

Post by (o)(o) »

bumblebee wrote:
(o)(o) wrote:You can't do much better than Harvard for balanced objective information on nutrition IMO..
Not necessarily. I trust experience and observation a lot more. As well as common sense.
Right, but I was talking about objective information, which is "in addition" to subjective judgement. You might also read the latest research papers. Being informed helps when making decisions and in no ways dictates what you do.

Anecdotes and personal observations are great, but I'm sure you only put so much stock in them. For example, smoking is now universally understood to be bad for you, but in the 50s you would be forgiven for thinking it's healthy. That was the popular opinion at that time.
User avatar
bumblebee
Baaaaa!
Baaaaa!
Posts: 1693
Joined: Sat Jun 03, 2006 7:33 pm 0
Location: Snobdorf, Germany
Contact:

Re: Bigger, Faster, Stronger!

Post by bumblebee »

(o)(o) wrote:Right, but I was talking about objective information, which is "in addition" to subjective judgement. You might also read the latest research papers. Being informed helps when making decisions and in no ways dictates what you do.

Anecdotes and personal observations are great, but I'm sure you only put so much stock in them. For example, smoking is now universally understood to be bad for you, but in the 50s you would be forgiven for thinking it's healthy. That was the popular opinion at that time.
Not subjective judgement - I learn from tradition and the experience of those before me. Subjective are the conclusions I make. Scientific research is very good but I approach reports with caution. As for popular opinion.. Today's popular opinion is that yoghurt with less fat and added flavours is better than high-fat plain one. It's not what I believe.
"This nail is bent and broken, straighten it out with the hands of love" — Sivert Høyem
Tumblog | Twitter
User avatar
(o)(o)
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6885
Joined: Tue Jan 19, 2010 2:21 am 0

Re: Bigger, Faster, Stronger!

Post by (o)(o) »

bumblebee wrote:I learn from tradition and the experience of those before me. Subjective are the conclusions I make. Scientific research is very good but I approach reports with caution. As for popular opinion.. Today's popular opinion is that yoghurt with less fat and added flavours is better than high-fat plain one. It's not what I believe.
Sounds good to me. :wink:

Speaking of tradition, looking at "Blue Zones" is cool too. Blue Zones are regions in the world where people live measurably longer. This lecture is very interesting!

http://www.ted.com/talks/dan_buettner_h ... e_100.html
User avatar
Duck Turkin
Baaaaa!
Baaaaa!
Posts: 1682
Joined: Wed Mar 08, 2006 4:51 am 0
Location: Down South

Re: Bigger, Faster, Stronger!

Post by Duck Turkin »

gravy wrote:
Dio wrote:There's nothing magic about beer that makes you fat, it's just about the balance of in vs. out. (At least, for some subset of people, I'm unconvinced it's true for everyone).
Wouldn't mind addressing the calories in / out hypotheses with regards to fat accumulation.

It's kind of nonsense isn't it?

That would mean it's impossible to gain fat while in calorific deficit.

It'd also mean that the body is pretty much the same as a calorimeter in how it extracts energy from completely different substances.

But both are not true. Your body choosing to store fat is a complex process that has variability across different people and can change even in one person according to their health or age. Here's a good example of how you can store and put on fat without eating more than you normally would. Type 1 diabetics have to inject insulin to to help control their glucose levels. It's important when injecting insulin that you rotate the injection points over time. Why? Because if you inject in the same place continually over time you will accumalate fat deposits. This is pretty much irrespective of what you're eating. It doesn't matter, the insulin injections will cause fat to deposit locally. Here's what can happen:
You state that as if it's obvious, but if you were to ask any qualified medical professional the vast majority would disagree. Research clearly points to increased fat intake leading to increased body weight. And you appear to be overly-defensive of criticism of this fad diet (despite inviting discussion on the subject). Why is that? You can't pick from a few medical cases in defending this idea where there is clearly a disorder (type I or type II diabetes) and apply it to the rest of the population. They have other problems with metabolizing food related (but not restricted) to dysfunctional HDL cholesterol (the 'good' type). For the vast majority of people, you get fat when you take in excess calories, no matter what the source. Most of the new diets (such as the misnamed Paleo diet) are to do with calorie restriction. Couple this with exercise and you will lose weight. I'd agree that a big fat steak will keep me feeling full longer, and I will reduce my calorie intake if I forgo the carbs found in macaroni and cheese or french fries as sides. The meals you posted a bit later suggest they are low calorie, although I obviously don't know the quantities eaten or any other specifics.

A frequent criticism of Gary Taubes is that he's highly selective of the evidence supporting his idea, and the way he ignores findings that don't support him borders on unscientific.
Your body doesn't digest fibre but it does burn in a calorimeter.
True, but insoluble dietary fiber does not contain any calories, and (in the US at least) is not counted.

Basically, as stated by others, if it makes you healthier, then do it. Just because medical opinion is against the inflated, pseudo-medical claims of Taubes (amongst others) doesn't mean that you can't lose weight by cutting carbs (only that the reasons for the weight loss are different). There is a definite case to be made about satiety and protein intake, which must make the diet easier to follow, although I have some reservations about eating increased quantities of meat (coronary heart disease).
User avatar
Duck Turkin
Baaaaa!
Baaaaa!
Posts: 1682
Joined: Wed Mar 08, 2006 4:51 am 0
Location: Down South

Re: Bigger, Faster, Stronger!

Post by Duck Turkin »

(o)(o) wrote:
bumblebee wrote:I learn from tradition and the experience of those before me. Subjective are the conclusions I make. Scientific research is very good but I approach reports with caution. As for popular opinion.. Today's popular opinion is that yoghurt with less fat and added flavours is better than high-fat plain one. It's not what I believe.
Sounds good to me. :wink:

Speaking of tradition, looking at "Blue Zones" is cool too. Blue Zones are regions in the world where people live measurably longer. This lecture is very interesting!

http://www.ted.com/talks/dan_buettner_h ... e_100.html
To be fair Wikipedia says he got an MS in applied physics and aerospace engineering. He then got a masters in journalism.
User avatar
gravy
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 19572
Joined: Wed May 01, 2002 1:28 pm 0
Location: The Other Place

Re: Bigger, Faster, Stronger!

Post by gravy »

Duck Turkin wrote:
gravy wrote:Here's a good example of how you can store and put on fat without eating more than you normally would. Type 1 diabetics have to inject insulin to to help control their glucose levels. It's important when injecting insulin that you rotate the injection points over time. Why? Because if you inject in the same place continually over time you will accumalate fat deposits. This is pretty much irrespective of what you're eating. It doesn't matter, the insulin injections will cause fat to deposit locally. Here's what can happen:
You state that as if it's obvious, but if you were to ask any qualified medical professional the vast majority would disagree.
That repeated insulin injections in the same place cause fat deposits is obvious. It happens. It's why health professionals stress to type 1 diabetics they should rotate where they inject. Are you responding to something else I've posted and quoted the wrong bit?

The rest is hard to deal with. You're countering points I haven't made. If you'd read the rest of the thread you'd see I'm not saying you don't lose or gain weight through eating less or more. I'm pretty clear that one of the benefits from low carb is naturally not eating as much and getting a weight loss benefit from that. I am saying that the measurement of calories is flawed and that your body reacts differently to different food stuffs. That's true. I'm also saying switching away from carbohydrates makes it easier to eat less.

BTW it varies on a country by country basis whether fibre calories count towards the total calorie count on packaging. It does in the UK.

Something I would say is Taubes predicts a bunch of other health benefits from lowering your carb intake: lower triglycerides, better BP, better lipid health

I've had all of those benefits. It's not just about shedding weight.
User avatar
Duck Turkin
Baaaaa!
Baaaaa!
Posts: 1682
Joined: Wed Mar 08, 2006 4:51 am 0
Location: Down South

Re: Bigger, Faster, Stronger!

Post by Duck Turkin »

gravy wrote:
Duck Turkin wrote:
gravy wrote:Here's a good example of how you can store and put on fat without eating more than you normally would. Type 1 diabetics have to inject insulin to to help control their glucose levels. It's important when injecting insulin that you rotate the injection points over time. Why? Because if you inject in the same place continually over time you will accumalate fat deposits. This is pretty much irrespective of what you're eating. It doesn't matter, the insulin injections will cause fat to deposit locally. Here's what can happen:
You state that as if it's obvious, but if you were to ask any qualified medical professional the vast majority would disagree.
That repeated insulin injections in the same place cause fat deposits is obvious. It happens. It's why health professionals stress to type 1 diabetics they should rotate where they inject. Are you responding to something else I've posted and quoted the wrong bit?

The rest is hard to deal with. You're countering points I haven't made. If you'd read the rest of the thread you'd see I'm not saying you don't lose or gain weight through eating less or more. I'm pretty clear that one of the benefits from low carb is naturally not eating as much and getting a weight loss benefit from that. I am saying that the measurement of calories is flawed and that your body reacts differently to different food stuffs. That's true. I'm also saying switching away from carbohydrates makes it easier to eat less.

BTW it varies on a country by country basis whether fibre calories count towards the total calorie count on packaging. It does in the UK.

Something I would say is Taubes predicts a bunch of other health benefits from lowering your carb intake: lower triglycerides, better BP, better lipid health

I've had all of those benefits. It's not just about shedding weight.
Definitely it is indicated to vary the insulin injection site for frequent (2-3 times daily) applications. However you have to admit that comparing the effects of a hormone at high concentration in a particular body part is not the same as insulin produced by the pancreas. What annoys me with Gary Taubes is that he conveniently ignores decades of research that contradicts his ideas. Taubes makes no predictions that weren't already known, and exaggerates others.

Its well documented that the body reacts differently to different foods. However, research by real experts (not Taubes) shows a correlation between high calorie intake and weight gain. Where those calories come from makes no difference. BTW of course I know calories are counted differently in different countries, I never wrote otherwise.

I don't disagree though that cutting carbs is an easy ways to reduce caloirie intake, and is relatively benign if done right.
User avatar
gravy
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 19572
Joined: Wed May 01, 2002 1:28 pm 0
Location: The Other Place

Re: Bigger, Faster, Stronger!

Post by gravy »

Hoorah! First faltering steps towards a triathlon for 2013. I'm feeling slightly embarrased about having any pride about this given the exceptionally slow times for cycling and running but I've not really done either much for nearly 30 years. Also there was a fair bit of time between each activity.

But it's a start. So:

Running 5km - 28m hilly course though :D
Swimming 400m - 16:09m - very slow! And hard work. And I got cramp
Cycling 13km - 42m again slow but I'll get faster

So at least I have a base to build from and an easy one to improve on. Both cycling and, in particular swimming, felt very much like day #1 on Couch To Five K :)
arcaic
Baaa!
Baaa!
Posts: 145
Joined: Sun Jan 28, 2007 8:05 pm 0

Re: Bigger, Faster, Stronger!

Post by arcaic »

What were your transition times?

Most beginners have time to make a sandwich and have a cuppa in their first races :-)

Well done!

Andy
User avatar
gravy
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 19572
Joined: Wed May 01, 2002 1:28 pm 0
Location: The Other Place

Re: Bigger, Faster, Stronger!

Post by gravy »

Nah it wasn't a triathlon at all, it was just all done on the same day :D I'm pretty used to running and the cycling was easy. I don't think there'd be any trouble doing those back to back. But the swimming? Ooof. Long way to go on that front.

But as I say a start :)
User avatar
Dave_M
Baaaa!
Baaaa!
Posts: 616
Joined: Tue May 04, 2004 9:00 am 0
Location: Down the pub with Chuffy...
Contact:

Re: Bigger, Faster, Stronger!

Post by Dave_M »

I've been finding the discussion on low carb fascinating. As a distance runner my diet has consisted of carbs and lots of them. So I was sceptical of the approach for my own situation but interested nonetheless. I have been keeping a food diary and counting calories otherwise I would just eat cake from morning till night. I am an OK weight (10st 6 for 5ft 7) but could be leaner and lose a little flab around the middle.

The aim was to hit low 10st. Looking back I was shocked to find I've been trying to shift these remaining lbs for the last 6 months and have got nowhere.

Last Wednesday I decided to give the low carb approach a 21 day trial. Worst case scenario is that I lose no weight and my running get hard for a few weeks.

One week on and I have already achieved my goal. I was 10st 1 today. It has been fairly easy going with no hunger and my running has not suffered at all. In fact my long run in the forest last Saturday (no breakfast with nuts+beef jerky for snacking) went just fine.

I appreciate that there will be some fluid loss in the weight drop but I am looking forward to seeing what happens in the remaining few weeks. And then I will need to adjust my diet going forward as there is no point in putting it all back on again.

A typical days food:

breakfast: 2 bits bacon, 3xeggs scrambled, parmesan cheese
lunch: Protein shake, ham and cheese, cottage cheese with blueberries
snack: Protein shake, a couple of slices of meat, cheese.
tea: 2xgrilled turkey steaks cut up with mayo, green leaf salad with blue cheese on top and olives. Blueberries and greek yoghurt for pudding.
snack: Protein shake. Berries with double cream.
supper: 3xBacon, lettuce, tomato and mayo chopped up.
Post Reply