Microsoft Surface : their tablet
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: Microsoft Surface : their tablet
Definitely not, as in it would do nothing for Apple's iPad. Tablets with pens have a long history: pre-iPad if you wanted a tablet then you were looking at a Windows tablet with something like Windows for Pen Computing, XP Tablet PC edition or similar on it. A pen makes a lot of sense with Windows as it can emulate a mouse.
Except such devices were and are really niche devices: people just weren't interested in them. I would think they're even less popular now given the iPad, as being the most popular tablet with the most popular tablet OS eliminates one of the main reasons to use tablet Windows PCs. But I don't know as they just don't register as a category. There's simply not the market for Apple to be building something into the OS. Instead it's a third party opportunity on the iPad, and something other tablet makers can use to differentiate their product.
Except such devices were and are really niche devices: people just weren't interested in them. I would think they're even less popular now given the iPad, as being the most popular tablet with the most popular tablet OS eliminates one of the main reasons to use tablet Windows PCs. But I don't know as they just don't register as a category. There's simply not the market for Apple to be building something into the OS. Instead it's a third party opportunity on the iPad, and something other tablet makers can use to differentiate their product.
Re: Microsoft Surface : their tablet
I should point out that before the iPad it was a case of "pen or fingernail only", and then the iPad was "finger only". These new devices just add an invisible Wacom layer. If you want you can still only use your finger and it's still capacitive - you're losing nothing, and gaining the ability to be more precise when you need to (or use it in winter without special gloves or a sausage) 
Apple fans mock it and call it old fashioned now, but if Tim Cook strolled onto the stage showing off how awesome the new iPen is, (lol, iPenis) the same people would be gushing about what a great idea it is.
Apple fans mock it and call it old fashioned now, but if Tim Cook strolled onto the stage showing off how awesome the new iPen is, (lol, iPenis) the same people would be gushing about what a great idea it is.
Re: Microsoft Surface : their tablet
Indeed. The idea that pens arnt mass market friendly is crazy, frankly.
Pens predate computers, they intuitive for everyone and far nicer to draw or take notes with.
The fact that the iPad was successful without them doesn't mean it wouldn't have been even more so with them.
If anything, I'd guess its a cost/licensing/software issue for Apple rather then anything their research showed.
Hell, having even a plastic stick stylus didn't hurt Nintendo when they made the DS did it?
Anywho...
Microsoft really missed a opportunity with leapmotion I think;
Build that into their surface and suddenly it would have had a lot more mass appeal.
Pens predate computers, they intuitive for everyone and far nicer to draw or take notes with.
The fact that the iPad was successful without them doesn't mean it wouldn't have been even more so with them.
If anything, I'd guess its a cost/licensing/software issue for Apple rather then anything their research showed.
Hell, having even a plastic stick stylus didn't hurt Nintendo when they made the DS did it?
Anywho...
Microsoft really missed a opportunity with leapmotion I think;
Build that into their surface and suddenly it would have had a lot more mass appeal.
-
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: Microsoft Surface : their tablet
You could just as easily say having a keyboard on a Blackberry didn't hurt it. Which is true: the Crackberry in its prime was the phone to have. There were phones, PDAs and the Blackberry which had the high-end smartphone and corporate markets to itself. Then the iPhone came along and showed that a phone is much better off without a keyboard. In the same way the iPad showed that a tablet PC makes much more sense without a pen. And the iOS platform as a whole (i.e. the iPad, iPhone and iPod) are all much better game machines than the DS.Darkflame wrote:Hell, having even a plastic stick stylus didn't hurt Nintendo when they made the DS did it?
The latter may seem controversial until you look at sales figures. The 3DS, currently the best selling console of any type, sells around 150,000 units a week globally.
http://www.vgchartz.com/weekly/41378/Global/
Apple sells about 400,000 iPhones every day, or 2.8m every week. They sell more each quarter than the 3DS installed base.
http://www.apple.com/pr/library/2013/04 ... sults.html
They sell half as many again iPads. Not all are used to play games but disproportionately many are: surveys have shown that comparing iOS with Android the former buy and use far more apps, the most popular category of which are games.
So having a plastic stick didn't hurt Nintendo in 2004. But not having an answer to iOS is hurting them now. Or maybe not so much now. Their big challenge is persuading users and especially developers that whatever they next bring out is relevant, and doesn't suffer the fate of the PS Vita.
Re: Microsoft Surface : their tablet
Pfft. Thats pretty obviously a apples and oranges comparison.
If things sold better without stylus, then the DS wouldn't have outsold the PSP (or, for that mater, the GBA and everything else before it).
The fact the DS didn't outsale the iPhone has nothing whatsoever to do with it having a stylus, and everything to do with it being a completely different category of product.
Nothing you have said remotely points to stylus's being unattractive for consumers.
Not having a keyboard is a separate issue, as clearly that effects the form factor a lot and is (sort of) a either/or choose with device size and screen space. But as has been pointed out, a stylus doesn't effect anything else screenwise.
Your argument seems to be "look how great the iphone sales....the iphone doesn't have a stylus....ergo it sales because it doesn't have a stylus!"
You need to make a connection between the two; why does not having a stylus help sales?
(also, dont muddy the water by saying "having a stylus didn't hurt sales in 04.....but they need a answer to iOS" as thats again, a comparison between two independent things, not a either/or.
A stylus can help sales [brain training, various art software,layton etc] and the lack of iOS like cheapy games can be hurting them. )
If things sold better without stylus, then the DS wouldn't have outsold the PSP (or, for that mater, the GBA and everything else before it).
The fact the DS didn't outsale the iPhone has nothing whatsoever to do with it having a stylus, and everything to do with it being a completely different category of product.
Nothing you have said remotely points to stylus's being unattractive for consumers.
Not having a keyboard is a separate issue, as clearly that effects the form factor a lot and is (sort of) a either/or choose with device size and screen space. But as has been pointed out, a stylus doesn't effect anything else screenwise.
Your argument seems to be "look how great the iphone sales....the iphone doesn't have a stylus....ergo it sales because it doesn't have a stylus!"
You need to make a connection between the two; why does not having a stylus help sales?
(also, dont muddy the water by saying "having a stylus didn't hurt sales in 04.....but they need a answer to iOS" as thats again, a comparison between two independent things, not a either/or.
A stylus can help sales [brain training, various art software,layton etc] and the lack of iOS like cheapy games can be hurting them. )
Provided you ignore the games sure.And the iOS platform as a whole (i.e. the iPad, iPhone and iPod) are all much better game machines than the DS.
-
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: Microsoft Surface : their tablet
Do I? I was only refuting the suggestion that the iPad would do better with a stylus, e.g.Darkflame wrote:You need to make a connection between the two; why does not having a stylus help sales?
My point was we don't need to speculate about this, as devices with styluses are available now. Not only are they available but they're available for less, had a several year head start on Apple and in the case of the DS pretty much had the portable gaming market sewn up. MS have been making versions of Windows for stylus/pen computers for even longer.Darkflame wrote:The fact that the iPad was successful without them doesn't mean it wouldn't have been even more so with them.
If anything, I'd guess its a cost/licensing/software issue for Apple rather then anything their research showed.
But the reaction on the iPhone's launch wasn't "it would be great if only it had a stylus". Instead the fact that it worked without a stylus, or keyboard, was welcomed. Technical users appreciated how the OS, designed from the ground up to be touch-friendly, made a keyboard or stylus unnecessary. Ordinary people just appreciated how intuitive and easy it was to use.
I don't dispute that there are some applications for a stylus. Just as there are applications for a gamepad-like controller, or a barcode scanner, or a memory card reader. But for most people these are unnecessary and if bundled would add cost and inconvenience and so, yes, hurt sales.
Edit: and I doubt very much it's a licensing or software issue. The Apple Newton came with a stylus, which was used for handwriting recognition. So Apple have experience with stylus input and must have licences for such hardware, though patents from that time have probably expired by now. It was simply a choice not to include stylus support.
- gilesgoat
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 27259
- Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
- Location: Monfalcone, Italy
- Contact:
Re: Microsoft Surface : their tablet
The way I see it is that "a tablet is a tablet" so fundamentally "there's only a limited subsets of things a tablet can do, what a tablet does".
At this point there's already one "gold standard" reference which is the iPad, the question is "what another tablet can give me better/worse compared to that ?".
One answer could be "lower price same quality for comparable similar functions".
The other answer could be "something really more that iPad cannot".
Now for me one thing that really would be something very interesting would be "a properly working smooth and fast and accurate stylus to write/sketch real notes on not those kind of gimmicks that look more like a baton", and so far I've seen only ONE Andorid tablet that can actually do it.
The other "big thing" would be "a tablet that REALLY RUNS laptop/desktop SW" and that in theory is what surface should do but "the cost" is another factor, thing is "is it really going to do it that well as a laptop would ?" if so MAYBE the cost is worth.
And the third big thing would be "a tablet that you can REALLY read in THE FULL SUN" and work with to the extent you could at least edit text on it while in the full sun.
In short what I'd love to do is :
- being able to edit ( don't say run but at least write it down and then go back in to test it ) C++ code while I am under a tree in the garden
- being able to carry something as light as an iPad with a similar form factor and retina display and be able when I need to take out a wireless KB and a wireless mouse/trackball and have "a full desktop machine" working with ALL the usual "desktop SW" I need ( and maybe also able to connect to a wireless disk server where I have some gbytes of storage in a real disk not a flash card )
- being able to edit and check while under the tree text written in LaTEX or such
Now the curious thing is that I believe that 'the second' could be done if the iPad would run some sort of OSX made for ARM instead of iOS and/or it would have an Intel processor and run OSX for real .. but I don't think this can happen.
For all the rest .. "you can sell me all the clouds and facebook or twitter you want" and I don't give it a crap.
Now surface seems to promise this .. but the price sounds a bit high .. however as I said "it it does it well" that could be another story.
At this point there's already one "gold standard" reference which is the iPad, the question is "what another tablet can give me better/worse compared to that ?".
One answer could be "lower price same quality for comparable similar functions".
The other answer could be "something really more that iPad cannot".
Now for me one thing that really would be something very interesting would be "a properly working smooth and fast and accurate stylus to write/sketch real notes on not those kind of gimmicks that look more like a baton", and so far I've seen only ONE Andorid tablet that can actually do it.
The other "big thing" would be "a tablet that REALLY RUNS laptop/desktop SW" and that in theory is what surface should do but "the cost" is another factor, thing is "is it really going to do it that well as a laptop would ?" if so MAYBE the cost is worth.
And the third big thing would be "a tablet that you can REALLY read in THE FULL SUN" and work with to the extent you could at least edit text on it while in the full sun.
In short what I'd love to do is :
- being able to edit ( don't say run but at least write it down and then go back in to test it ) C++ code while I am under a tree in the garden
- being able to carry something as light as an iPad with a similar form factor and retina display and be able when I need to take out a wireless KB and a wireless mouse/trackball and have "a full desktop machine" working with ALL the usual "desktop SW" I need ( and maybe also able to connect to a wireless disk server where I have some gbytes of storage in a real disk not a flash card )
- being able to edit and check while under the tree text written in LaTEX or such
Now the curious thing is that I believe that 'the second' could be done if the iPad would run some sort of OSX made for ARM instead of iOS and/or it would have an Intel processor and run OSX for real .. but I don't think this can happen.
For all the rest .. "you can sell me all the clouds and facebook or twitter you want" and I don't give it a crap.
Now surface seems to promise this .. but the price sounds a bit high .. however as I said "it it does it well" that could be another story.
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
"Baa"
Re: Microsoft Surface : their tablet
Even so, I doubt that people buy an iphone purely for the games; people do buy 3DS units solely for games. You can't compare the two, they're in (overlapping, to a point) different markets.pogo wrote: The latter may seem controversial until you look at sales figures. The 3DS, currently the best selling console of any type, sells around 150,000 units a week globally.
http://www.vgchartz.com/weekly/41378/Global/
Apple sells about 400,000 iPhones every day, or 2.8m every week. They sell more each quarter than the 3DS installed base.
http://www.apple.com/pr/library/2013/04 ... sults.html
They sell half as many again iPads. Not all are used to play games but disproportionately many are: surveys have shown that comparing iOS with Android the former buy and use far more apps, the most popular category of which are games.
"Oh dear lord, I slightly soiled myself. Oxfam won’t be pleased."
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: Microsoft Surface : their tablet
People don't buy a smartphone purely to take notes, organise their lives, etc. But PDAs as a product category are pretty much dead. People don't take compact cameras with them to parties, events now, they use their phones. Hand-held GPS devices are similarly being replaced by phones. As are handheld game consoles. Sales are down 50% over three years. It's not like home consoles where the leading platforms are at the end of their cycle – both manufacturers have launched brand new devices in the last three years.Barney wrote:Even so, I doubt that people buy an iphone purely for the games; people do buy 3DS units solely for games. You can't compare the two, they're in (overlapping, to a point) different markets.
I don't see any other explanation for such a massive drop except people now prefer smartphones. In fact given that phones from one manufacturer, Apple, are outselling all the consoles together by an order of magnitude I'm surprised sales are holding up so well. I think this is in large part due to the installed base upgrading. But this would mean they're selling few to new customers, especially young people (all of whom seem to prefer phones), and the platforms are slowly dying.
Re: Microsoft Surface : their tablet
Or, alternatively, it just could be that smartphones aren't very good at many types of games.
Re: Microsoft Surface : their tablet
Smartphone's are good at playing smartphone games which right now seem to me to have a greater diversity than desktop or console games.
If your main interest is playing incrementally enhanced versions of established genres designed for completely different machines / interfaces then they're awful at that.
But it's a mistake to see those tropes as a definition of what games are.
If your main interest is playing incrementally enhanced versions of established genres designed for completely different machines / interfaces then they're awful at that.
But it's a mistake to see those tropes as a definition of what games are.
Re: Microsoft Surface : their tablet
I don't think smartphone games are dramatically more diverse than console - at least, for games with rapid pacing - in most ways except thematically. The limit on complexity imposed by the limitations of user interaction seems likely to put the breaks on gameplay creativity to some extent.
Certainly, they have opened up some new game types, and that might make them seem more diverse due to novelty. But underlying that is a strong degree of similarity in the underlying games e.g. the large numbers of physics-based puzzle games. Compare the Wii, initially praised for opening up diversity, until everyone realised that 'diversity' meant 'another mini-game game' and in the end it's (arguably) got the most homogenous game lineup of any console (particularly if you include XBLA, etc.) and in my opinion that's primarily responsible for the steep and sudden hill its sales slid down - more than its lack of computational horsepower.
I see signs the same "novelty implies diversity" fallacy could be in play in the smartphone market.
However, it's hugely compounded by with the perennial problem (as being discussed in the Origin thread) that digital hasn't worked out how to stop the same ten games getting significant attention at any one time and half of them are Angry Birds. Indeed, for smartphones the problem is compounded: as since the user base is still expanding, the same games are still selling to new customers, so they're pretty much guaranteed to be in the top ten until the userbase stops expanding..
I think it's far from obvious that diversity on the platform is higher than elsewhere. Although, certainly, the total games space is more diverse for having smartphones in it.
Certainly, they have opened up some new game types, and that might make them seem more diverse due to novelty. But underlying that is a strong degree of similarity in the underlying games e.g. the large numbers of physics-based puzzle games. Compare the Wii, initially praised for opening up diversity, until everyone realised that 'diversity' meant 'another mini-game game' and in the end it's (arguably) got the most homogenous game lineup of any console (particularly if you include XBLA, etc.) and in my opinion that's primarily responsible for the steep and sudden hill its sales slid down - more than its lack of computational horsepower.
I see signs the same "novelty implies diversity" fallacy could be in play in the smartphone market.
However, it's hugely compounded by with the perennial problem (as being discussed in the Origin thread) that digital hasn't worked out how to stop the same ten games getting significant attention at any one time and half of them are Angry Birds. Indeed, for smartphones the problem is compounded: as since the user base is still expanding, the same games are still selling to new customers, so they're pretty much guaranteed to be in the top ten until the userbase stops expanding..
I think it's far from obvious that diversity on the platform is higher than elsewhere. Although, certainly, the total games space is more diverse for having smartphones in it.
- gilesgoat
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 27259
- Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
- Location: Monfalcone, Italy
- Contact:
Re: Microsoft Surface : their tablet
Maybe we could also/simply discuss over the fact that "lot of people that before were getting cameras/laptops/etc. in reality did not need them as such", I mean "what the phone does now and the form factor it has is what they really wanted".
It's like there will be always the "pro" or "super aficionados" that needs/wants the 'mega special camera with Zeiss optics and mega sensors and pro tripod and such" costing $5000 or more and ready to buy it, but for the other mayority of people willing to snap and instantly put on facebook that's the phone for.
Before, they did not have alternatives but buy a cheaper camera, now they can do it all with the phone.
And so for the rest, of course now certain market is in "decline" because simply "the people REALLY needing those objects were not so many".
I still want to see a camera with a Foevon sensor, I yet have not managed to see one in action as "too specialist" no shop I've been in ever had one ...
The other thing is that in case of this 'camera comparision' is also that cameras on phones really got pretty good, good enough probably for 80% of people just wanting to get 'a quick snap'.
So maybe you could say "compared to before now the camera market is shrunk to 20%" .. well "proabably yes, because all the others bought a phone instead".
Even that .. "phone" ... "portable computer with phone option" .
It's like there will be always the "pro" or "super aficionados" that needs/wants the 'mega special camera with Zeiss optics and mega sensors and pro tripod and such" costing $5000 or more and ready to buy it, but for the other mayority of people willing to snap and instantly put on facebook that's the phone for.
Before, they did not have alternatives but buy a cheaper camera, now they can do it all with the phone.
And so for the rest, of course now certain market is in "decline" because simply "the people REALLY needing those objects were not so many".
I still want to see a camera with a Foevon sensor, I yet have not managed to see one in action as "too specialist" no shop I've been in ever had one ...
The other thing is that in case of this 'camera comparision' is also that cameras on phones really got pretty good, good enough probably for 80% of people just wanting to get 'a quick snap'.
So maybe you could say "compared to before now the camera market is shrunk to 20%" .. well "proabably yes, because all the others bought a phone instead".
Even that .. "phone" ... "portable computer with phone option" .
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
"Baa"
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: Microsoft Surface : their tablet
Microsoft Cuts Surface Tablet Prices Amid Weak Demand
This is the RT Surface, not the Pro/x86 one. It's understandable it's not doing well; the Pro model is at least able to run all the x86 software that's already out there, and in theory function as a full sized (if expensive) PC with an external display, keyboard, mouse etc. The RT model not only needs software writing especially for it but is slower and much more limited (no classic Windows, only Metro). I would think developers aren't fond of it either so there's little software for it.
But $349 is still too expensive. You can get an iPad (mini) for less and an Android tablet for much less. Yes, the iPad only comes with 16GB but that's as iOS needs so little and will happily run on an 8GB device, while Windows RT won't fit on anything less than 32GB.
This is the RT Surface, not the Pro/x86 one. It's understandable it's not doing well; the Pro model is at least able to run all the x86 software that's already out there, and in theory function as a full sized (if expensive) PC with an external display, keyboard, mouse etc. The RT model not only needs software writing especially for it but is slower and much more limited (no classic Windows, only Metro). I would think developers aren't fond of it either so there's little software for it.
But $349 is still too expensive. You can get an iPad (mini) for less and an Android tablet for much less. Yes, the iPad only comes with 16GB but that's as iOS needs so little and will happily run on an 8GB device, while Windows RT won't fit on anything less than 32GB.
Re: Microsoft Surface : their tablet
And yet I run a full desktop OS in only 345MB.pogo wrote:Yes, the iPad only comes with 16GB but that's as iOS needs so little and will happily run on an 8GB device, while Windows RT won't fit on anything less than 32GB.
What the hell has happened to OS's these days that they need GBs of space to install?
"Oh dear lord, I slightly soiled myself. Oxfam won’t be pleased."

