No, that makes no sense. If any organic crop had higher yields it would be cheaper and quickly replace its non-organic equivalent. Even if yields were only 5-25% lower organic food would cost almost the same as non-organic – not only do you save money on chemicals but much of the cost of fresh food is storage, packaging, distribution. But organic costs usually much more; sometimes twice as much as the the same non-organic produce. This is not just due to yield, though that's the main contribution, but also higher energy inputs as efficient chemical herbicides are replaced by energy intensive mechanical weeding.(o)(o) wrote:Organic yields can be 5-25% lower.. they can also be higher in 'best practice' scenarios (so use best practice then!!).. but if you care about things like biodiversity, not eating toxins/pesticides/fungicides (includes bioaccumulators), the production and transportation and pollution of chemicals eg dead spots in river inlets caused by nitrate bleeding, the quality of soil - which becomes richer year upon year in organic farming.. or indeed just the overall goddamn quality of the food you are eating... organic makes sense..
As for eating toxins/pesticides/fungicides food is the most heavily regulated industry the world, and nothing is used knowingly in the food chain without it being safe. Besides many chemicals are much safer than their organic replacements. E.g. the job done by nitrogen fertilisers was once done mostly by shit. You better was your food very thoroughly if it's been grown in shit, and where it's still extensively used it's a major vector for diseases.
The problem though is there's not enough shit to go around. If we tried only using organic fertiliser there's nowhere near enough of it. We'd be looking at seriously reduced yields, taking us back to before the Green Revolution, and just be unable to feed ourselves. We would destroy the world's rain forests trying, both for agriculture and for cattle (industrial shit making machines that they are), but it would not be enough.









