Makes a change from locking it away in Warehouse 13 like they did with HOTOL in the 80s...F-ZeroOne wrote:Wait - someone in the U.K. is making a revolutionary space engine and they actually managed to get the government to fund it?!
SPACE
Re: SPACE
"I am a very considerate person. If I want to go out all night on my miniature golf course and shoot lizards, well, no reason to keep the neighbours awake..."
Re: SPACE
Actually, I think BBC2 did a pretty good documentary on HOTOL/Skylon a little while back. Some of the same engineers are involved with Skylon (one of them worked on "Black Arrow!"), and although there were certainly some problems due to the design becoming "classified" for years, there were also some design problems with HOTOL as well, which Skylon is designed to resolve.
"Stars don't twinkle in space." - Char Aznable.
- RedOktober
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 4788
- Joined: Sun Sep 04, 2005 11:15 pm 0
- Location: Stalin's Organ
- Contact:
Re: SPACE
Bring us some chicken back, and don't be shy wi' chips.
Sponsoring terrorism at £1 per mile.
- axel000
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 2905
- Joined: Thu Sep 29, 2005 4:02 am 0
- PSN: huckwee
- Location: Philadelphia, USA
Re: SPACE
Interesting article on the 1960s atmospheric nuclear tests ran by the US, USSR and UK which almost prevented Apollo. Apparently the largest US detonation increased the radiation around the Earth 12 fold for a period of a couple of years.
http://arstechnica.com/science/2013/08/ ... or-apollo/
http://youtu.be/KZoic9vg1fw
http://arstechnica.com/science/2013/08/ ... or-apollo/
http://youtu.be/KZoic9vg1fw
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Gamertags:
[Steam] scottish_usa
[PSN] huckwee
[Star Citizen] Zander9
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Gamertags:
[Steam] scottish_usa
[PSN] huckwee
[Star Citizen] Zander9
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Re: SPACE
Apparently radiation levels due to testing can be used for dating recent items - like illegal ivory.
-
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: SPACE
More interesting pictures. Someone had the idea to point Curiosity's mast cam at Deimos as Phobos passed in front of it, taking the first ever photos of this unusual eclipse (they're small so it must be hard to observe, though it probably is visible somewhere on Mars every time they complete their orbits).
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: SPACE
I could write what I think but this sums it up pretty well:
Proof of alien life? You need a lot more evidence than this
In science the simplest explanation is usually the best and that's that any life in our atmosphere is from Earth. There are numerous ways it could get up there. The alternative, that it's from space, is simply fantastical. From where exactly? And how did it get into our atmosphere? Things that fall from space tend to burn up, so get too hot for life.
Proof of alien life? You need a lot more evidence than this
In science the simplest explanation is usually the best and that's that any life in our atmosphere is from Earth. There are numerous ways it could get up there. The alternative, that it's from space, is simply fantastical. From where exactly? And how did it get into our atmosphere? Things that fall from space tend to burn up, so get too hot for life.
Re: SPACE
There's a simple test.
Sequence its DNA, if it has any.
All life on Earth is related by common descent. Thus, even very distantly-related life has gene sequences in common - inherited way, way, way back from some ancient common ancestor.
If it doesn't have DNA but something else that serves the same function, then that's major evidence of extraterrestrial origin, because no life on this planet that we've so far discovered differs from this basic mechanism. So, to find something that does greatly differ, very strongly suggests it's not of this world.
Mind you, it's quite possible that, even with independent origin, alien life could still have DNA. It might simply be that, due to the chemistry of the elements themselves, only DNA - or at least something DNA-like - is ever likely to emerge to do that particular job (i.e. "convergent evolution").
But, nonetheless, if, in sequencing the DNA, we find that it has radically different patterns in its genes to anything else on this planet then this also very strongly indicates independent origin and evolution.
If it evolved elsewhere, then it necessarily won't have common ancestry with anything on this planet. Therefore, it simply won't fit neatly anywhere in the genetic "tree of life" we've been compiling from DNA of things we know are from Earth.
You know, it's that thing of "humans share 95% of their genes in common with chimps and 50% of their genes in common with bananas".
It's a bit of a silly headline-grabbing way of putting it that way, granted, but the basic idea being that, as all life shares common ancestry right back to the emergence of life on this planet, DNA has been inherited, changed slightly, inherited, changed slightly, inherited, changed slightly, etc. all the way along, so you can put it all into chronological order, because there are common patterns and sequences (from inheritance) by which you can see DNA's long lineage throughout all life over time.
So, if you sequence the DNA of this thing - presuming it even has "DNA as we know it" - and it simply doesn't fit neatly anywhere in the tree, that's empirical evidence of independent origin and independent evolution. Which must necessarily be the case for something that's never previously been anywhere near this planet, because it came from elsewhere in the universe. Ergo, it's an alien.
Or, at least, I'd say that this is the very minimum empirical test which something needs to pass - and it's something that we do have the technology to test for - before we start declaring we've actually discovered alien life.
It needs to be compared against the DNA catalogue of life we've already got and, indeed, if it really doesn't seem to neatly fit anywhere in that catalogue, then, okay, that's very compelling evidence that we've got something very deeply unusual on our hands (because nothing else on this planet fits that bill, so that does very strongly imply that we could be looking at something that isn't of this planet).
Put it this way, until someone does a test along those lines, I won't be biting. It's an extraordinary claim, so it needs extraordinary evidence - and simply speculating "we can't work out any other way that it could have got up there" just isn't anywhere near "extraordinary evidence" enough to be scientifically convincing.
Sequence its DNA, if it has any.
All life on Earth is related by common descent. Thus, even very distantly-related life has gene sequences in common - inherited way, way, way back from some ancient common ancestor.
If it doesn't have DNA but something else that serves the same function, then that's major evidence of extraterrestrial origin, because no life on this planet that we've so far discovered differs from this basic mechanism. So, to find something that does greatly differ, very strongly suggests it's not of this world.
Mind you, it's quite possible that, even with independent origin, alien life could still have DNA. It might simply be that, due to the chemistry of the elements themselves, only DNA - or at least something DNA-like - is ever likely to emerge to do that particular job (i.e. "convergent evolution").
But, nonetheless, if, in sequencing the DNA, we find that it has radically different patterns in its genes to anything else on this planet then this also very strongly indicates independent origin and evolution.
If it evolved elsewhere, then it necessarily won't have common ancestry with anything on this planet. Therefore, it simply won't fit neatly anywhere in the genetic "tree of life" we've been compiling from DNA of things we know are from Earth.
You know, it's that thing of "humans share 95% of their genes in common with chimps and 50% of their genes in common with bananas".
It's a bit of a silly headline-grabbing way of putting it that way, granted, but the basic idea being that, as all life shares common ancestry right back to the emergence of life on this planet, DNA has been inherited, changed slightly, inherited, changed slightly, inherited, changed slightly, etc. all the way along, so you can put it all into chronological order, because there are common patterns and sequences (from inheritance) by which you can see DNA's long lineage throughout all life over time.
So, if you sequence the DNA of this thing - presuming it even has "DNA as we know it" - and it simply doesn't fit neatly anywhere in the tree, that's empirical evidence of independent origin and independent evolution. Which must necessarily be the case for something that's never previously been anywhere near this planet, because it came from elsewhere in the universe. Ergo, it's an alien.
Or, at least, I'd say that this is the very minimum empirical test which something needs to pass - and it's something that we do have the technology to test for - before we start declaring we've actually discovered alien life.
It needs to be compared against the DNA catalogue of life we've already got and, indeed, if it really doesn't seem to neatly fit anywhere in that catalogue, then, okay, that's very compelling evidence that we've got something very deeply unusual on our hands (because nothing else on this planet fits that bill, so that does very strongly imply that we could be looking at something that isn't of this planet).
Put it this way, until someone does a test along those lines, I won't be biting. It's an extraordinary claim, so it needs extraordinary evidence - and simply speculating "we can't work out any other way that it could have got up there" just isn't anywhere near "extraordinary evidence" enough to be scientifically convincing.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
- John Maynard Keynes
Re: SPACE
Sounds much like the "red rain" claims from a few years back.
-
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: SPACE
According to the reports there's no DNA, just a silica structure like a diatom. Such could in theory have been formed by natural processes not involving life: crystallisation of some sort. But it does sound more like something made by a diatom, on Earth. There's no indication it comes from outer space, and suggesting so raises more questions than it answers: where from? how did it get on the balloon? Diatoms are very common on Earth, occurring in all bodies of water, and are easily small enough to be carried by wind in water droplets.
Another objection is if life were seeded from space (which we can't rule out as we have no direct evidence of how life arose) the seeds would have been much more primitive: RNA, proteins, amino acids. Nothing like this has survived in the fossil record but we know pretty well from genetics what the ultimate ancestor of all life on Earth must have consisted of. Diatoms are simply one of their descendants, not a candidate for the ultimate ancestor of us all.
Another objection is if life were seeded from space (which we can't rule out as we have no direct evidence of how life arose) the seeds would have been much more primitive: RNA, proteins, amino acids. Nothing like this has survived in the fossil record but we know pretty well from genetics what the ultimate ancestor of all life on Earth must have consisted of. Diatoms are simply one of their descendants, not a candidate for the ultimate ancestor of us all.




