pogo wrote:One thing that drives my views on this is the anthropic principle, that the universe is just right for us: the right numbers of dimensions, the right physical constants, the right amount of matter (and no antimatter), the right amount of energy, the right age. Just a small difference in any of these would make the universe uninhabitable, and we seem to be the beneficiaries of a series of incredibly lucky coincidences.
Bollocks.
I invoke the beautiful analogy that Douglas Adams told Richard Dawkins.
There's an irregular hole in the top of a rock. It starts raining. The rain fills up the hole, creating a puddle.
The puddle gains sentience and then it looks around at just how utterly perfectly it fits into the hole in which it sits and it erroneously thinks: "Wow, the rock was created perfectly, just for me. The water deities must love me, because look at how perfectly they created the rock to house my irregular form. They structured the entire universe - all of its forms, all of its laws, all of its history - in exactly just such a way that I would come to be and exactly fit into this hole."
It's completely arse backwards, of course. If there were no hole in the rock then, simply, there would have been no puddle and the universe would have ticked on by just as happily as it ever would have with the puddle, as without it.
If our level of intelligence and sentience is so fucking special to the universe, then why are we the only species on this planet to possess it? Why are we, as a species, often incredibly stupid, exercising this precious intelligence and sentience so unbelievably poorly? If the universe so adores sentient life, then why is that sentient life is instantly killed in the vast, vast majority of its volume?
Well, here's Neil Degrasse Tyson quickly demolishing the idea better than I ever could:
As he rightly notes, you can look in one little corner of the universe and think "wow, look how perfectly that all fits" (like Douglas Adams' puddle did), but you're just not looking at the other 99.99% of the universe that completely confounds and destroys that thinking entirely.
If the laws of the universe were different then, yes, we wouldn't be here. But that, unto itself, means absolutely nothing whatsoever.
The important point to remember when considering the Anthropic Principle is that its logic works backwards in time.
Yes, I exist because the entire universe and all its laws and everything, over incredible amounts of time, conspired to create exactly the right conditions that would eventually lead to my existence, sitting right here, typing this.
But it's "I exist, because the universe happened to be this way" and it's not "the universe happens to be this way, because I exist".
The former is the Anthropic Principle. The latter is just being insanely egotistical.
(I'm not having a go at the genuine Anthropic Principle. In its more generalised form, it's a brilliantly useful piece of deductive reasoning. It's why we do forensics on crime scenes to catch killers and thieves. If we look at the effects, we can often run the cause-and-effect logic backwards in time, in order to determine the causes and from those causes, catch the killers. But remember that this logic is being run backwards, not forwards. We are defying the arrow of time and though we're starting with effects and going back to their causes, this does not make effects causes and causes effects. For example, it would be completely unsound logic to deduce that the victim's parents deliberately had sex when they did and where they did, in order to place their son at exactly that place and that time, exactly so that the murderer could kill them. That it was their intent and design to have their son murdered all along. No, that "coincidence" is merely just a coincidence and nothing more than that.)
If the universe were different then, yes, we wouldn't be here. But, really, "so fucking what?", were that actually to be the case.
Out there in another alternative reality, there's a universe whose laws conspire to create creatures who have this remarkable capacity for ugamuga. Heck, if you think sentience and intelligence are good, then you ain't seen nothing yet. "Ugamuga" is truly amazing and leagues more sophisticated and impressive and stunningly beautiful to behold. In comparison to us, it makes these creatures almost god-like. If they ever met us, we'd look to their eyes, like the simplest bacteria does to ours.
And, in their universe, do you know what some of these creatures think? They think that their universe is so damned special, because it exactly conspires in all its laws to create all the right conditions to allow for "ugamuga" to exist. Unlike our universe, which doesn't.
If the laws of the universe were different, then different things would have occurred. That's entirely true. But we have no idea if those different things would have been, in fact, vastly better or vastly worse than what we've got. For all we know, we're actually in the universe that had a really bad roll of the dice. "Sentience" is the best we've got, so we're understandably - and rightly - proud of it. But who's to say that it's not actually, in the grand tombola of the multiverse, the booby prize?
Alone on this planet - and, as far as we currently know, possibly even alone in this galaxy or this entire universe - humans possess this particular form of intelligence. Other than our egos, who's to say that's even a good thing? Who's to say there couldn't have been something more sophisticated and impressive?
I mean, we ourselves have only just barely scraped together the capacity for language, above our animal cousins. We're not that much cleverer than dolphins or rats. We just struck lucky that language - the thing we mastered above them - is a lucky qualitative leap.
It allows us to record things. Pass on our wisdom. Teach each other what the previous generation worked out.
It allowed us to stand on the Shoulders of Giants - and that is, indeed, the only reason why we see further.
Evolution isn't over. Natural selection doesn't ever stop. Imagine what humans will know in several million years from now, imagine how our biology will have changed. How, indeed, with cyborg implants of organic machinery to fulfil all our superhuman needs, the whole thing might be operating on an entirely previously unknown level, in a completely different way to how it's ever worked before.
And, when Homo Superior looks back at us primitive Homo Sapiens, will it look back on us and our "sentience" and "intelligence" with any more kindness than we do to Homo Erectus or our lemur-like shared common ancestor or to the first fish that climbed out of the sea?
You're making a massive categorisation error. You're acting like we're the universe's "end product". Heck, our Sun has another 5 billion or so years to go before it runs out of fuel and starts dying. It only took 3.5 billion years from its formation to reach multi-celluar life.
And, of course, our Sun isn't that special either - its accretion disc had plenty of heavier elements than hydrogen and helium in it. We should know, we're made out of them. And we know those can only be forged naturally inside stars. We've also got a decent amount of post-lead elements too - and those are even rarer, requiring no less than a supernova to forge them.
(As I'm sure you're aware of, we literally are made of "stardust". But the crucial point here is that it's not our star's dust we're made of, it's the dust of the generations of stars that lived and died long beforehand, that left behind that big cloud of dust that slowly accreted into our Solar System, thanks to its collective gravity.)
Or, in other words, our star isn't a first generation star and our Solar System ain't a first generation star system either (indeed, it inherently can't be, because you can't make the Earth and the other planets out of hydrogen and helium alone). Other stars lived and died long, long before ours, to give birth to our star and the planets that orbit it.
We've been talking about the insanely gargantuan vastness of the universe. Truly understand just how big it is. Not just in size, but in age. How it's gone through many "stages" to get to this point and, indeed, there will be other "stages" to come after.
We're not just the tiniest speck in the vastness of space, we're the tiniest speck in the vastness of space and time (because, as you were earlier right to point out, space and time can't be so easily disassociated from one another).
Humans are special? Pull the other one.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes