You'd better not go outside! You might be sat on by an elephant!Darkflame wrote:Just because we ignored the issue, and you have called it "risk assessment" does not make it any more sane.Dio wrote:It's called risk assessment. We do it every day, including when we put on a kettle or get in a car.Darkflame wrote:I never liked the "its unlikely at any specific time, so lets do nothing about it" attitude of, well, our species.
Down the route of accepting no risk at all lies insanity.
A low probability event will eventually happen. To think otherwise, or to think "its ok because it wont happen to me" is a flaw in logic. A human flaw maybe. But still a flaw.
SPACE
Re: SPACE
- Absolute_Zero
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 3564
- Joined: Wed May 18, 2005 4:11 pm 0
- Location: Hilbert Hotel, Heisenberg.
- zip accident
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 13928
- Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 1:58 pm 0
- Location: Bristol, UK
Re: SPACE
We're pretty vulnerable too. We take a long time to grow up. We're very dependant on medicine. We're currently on the edge of space, and we need to get out into it in a sustainable way. A catastrophe that put us back to the stone age would mean waiting another 5k years for space, and that's a long time.pogo wrote:Since life began there have been four or five major extinction events. The one we are familiar with, the one that wiped out the dinosaurs, isn't the biggest. The biggest occurred between the Permian and Triassic periods. But all have left enough species alive to repopulate the Earth. I would contend we would survive any such collision. As a species we are uniquely found on every continent. We are more mobile than any other species, particularly over both land and see. And mostly we are adaptable.
FTFYThere probably isn't an unknown rock big enough to wipe us out in the inner solar system.
Nope. What it is, is that any that were in unstable orbits were already deflected, any of the ones that are left can be in an orbit that's currently marginally unstable but hasn't been deflected yet. It's unlikely that they will be deflected soon, but it's not impossible, and the probability of it happening rises toward certainty as time moves toward infinity.All the masses large enough are in stable orbits away from larger masses that might deflect them.
Personally I think of the Oort cloud as part of the solar system, just like the Kuiper Belt.The smaller masses that do occasionally get deflected are just too small. The only plausible risk is something from outside the solar system.
I suppose there must be rocks from supernovae, the nebulae expand over time so why not? I don't think a big one's likely to hit Earth in a trillion years.But the chance of that though unknown must be vanishingly small. Space is incredibly vast, filled with large voids between stars with nothing between. Stars, the sources of both heavy elements and energy that might power an explosion, are necessarily massive themselves so have enough gravity to prevent almost everything escaping.
The exception would be a supernova. But these are very unlikely - they happen often enough within the galaxy but it would need to be close to affect us, and the history of this not happening is highly indicative that it's very unlikely. Plus we can see nebulae, the remnants of supernova explosions, in the sky and none are especially close.
"My way is the way of not fighting":- the book of Enter the Dragon.
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: SPACE
It does all come down to probability. And we know a lot about them. We know the probability (of a random person) of being struck by lightning, or dying from a snakebite, or from ebola. In the same way we know the probability of being killed by a meteorite: zero. So it's not worth worry about.
The other reason for not worrying about it is there's little we can do. We could e.g. enforce strict road safety laws and slash the number of road traffic accident deaths. That would take little but political will.
In comparison it would be massively expensive to protect against rocks from space. Billions of dollars to develop and deploy the satellites. And it's unclear we'd be doing much in the way of protection. Kepler, looking for planets by monitoring brightness variations in stars, could have been designed instead to stare at the gaps between stars. But it would have been able to look at much less sky doing so. Kepler could only look at 0.25% of the sky, so a satellite looking for asteroids would be able to look at even less. we would need hundreds if not thousands, each costing hundreds of millions if not billions of dollars.
And even then we don't know if would spot everything. Rocks unlike stars are very hard to spot (which is why so far all the extra-solar planets we've detected we've detected indirectly as they pass in front of or deflect their star). And even if we detect them there's little we could do about a km-wide rock.
The other reason for not worrying about it is there's little we can do. We could e.g. enforce strict road safety laws and slash the number of road traffic accident deaths. That would take little but political will.
In comparison it would be massively expensive to protect against rocks from space. Billions of dollars to develop and deploy the satellites. And it's unclear we'd be doing much in the way of protection. Kepler, looking for planets by monitoring brightness variations in stars, could have been designed instead to stare at the gaps between stars. But it would have been able to look at much less sky doing so. Kepler could only look at 0.25% of the sky, so a satellite looking for asteroids would be able to look at even less. we would need hundreds if not thousands, each costing hundreds of millions if not billions of dollars.
And even then we don't know if would spot everything. Rocks unlike stars are very hard to spot (which is why so far all the extra-solar planets we've detected we've detected indirectly as they pass in front of or deflect their star). And even if we detect them there's little we could do about a km-wide rock.
Re: SPACE
Kilometer isn't that bad. You can vapourise that much rock with a nuke - after all, the Tsar Bomba was built to prove there really isn't much limit to the amount of energy you can get out of one of the things, and I've little doubt we could crash a project to do that in a year or so.
It's when you get to 10km+ that brute force and ignorance ceases to be a workable plan.
It's when you get to 10km+ that brute force and ignorance ceases to be a workable plan.
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: SPACE
You'd need to get the nuke up there though - and 'up there' might be well past the moon, perhaps even out past Mars's orbit, to avoid just creating a shower of rocks which would potentially be just as destructive. Within maybe weeks or days of detecting it.
There are things you can do to facilitate this. You could park a nuke or nukes up in space, to avoid the time, trouble and complexity of the launch through our atmosphere which is always the hardest/most expensive bit. You could create a number of them and have them orbiting in the asteroid belt, on the assumption that rocks either start there or pass through there. But all this would massively expensive. All for something we think happens once in a hundred million years at most.
There are things you can do to facilitate this. You could park a nuke or nukes up in space, to avoid the time, trouble and complexity of the launch through our atmosphere which is always the hardest/most expensive bit. You could create a number of them and have them orbiting in the asteroid belt, on the assumption that rocks either start there or pass through there. But all this would massively expensive. All for something we think happens once in a hundred million years at most.
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: SPACE
The other thing, and this comes back to risk in general, is we blissfully accept much larger risks.
We know for example some day a really big earthquake will hit a major city. Maybe on the US west coast, or in Japan, both seem likely. And soon - within many of our lifetimes probably. Like the big one in California in 1908 it will be devastating. Even if we're much better at building now there are earthquakes that level pretty much everything. We also live much more densely now, ensuring any collapse, fire or flooding caused has much greater impact.
But people still live there, even though they must be aware that they or their children will probably experience such a quake.
People live in places like New Orleans, even though they know that they're at risk from floods. Again it requires once in 100 year rains or floods, but that's hardly exceptional. You can include the whole of the US Gulf Coast, all of which is at risk from "The Big One" hitting them dead on. Or the high risk of twisters along tornado alley. Not only do people live in such places but they seem to do little to mitigate their risks - the sorts of houses they live in, often wood-framed and isolated, are much less able to withstand extreme weather than e.g. the concrete buildings seen in parts of Asia prone to typhoons.
If people accept such risks they're going to be much less concerned about a risk that's only a one in a million chance of happening to them.
We know for example some day a really big earthquake will hit a major city. Maybe on the US west coast, or in Japan, both seem likely. And soon - within many of our lifetimes probably. Like the big one in California in 1908 it will be devastating. Even if we're much better at building now there are earthquakes that level pretty much everything. We also live much more densely now, ensuring any collapse, fire or flooding caused has much greater impact.
But people still live there, even though they must be aware that they or their children will probably experience such a quake.
People live in places like New Orleans, even though they know that they're at risk from floods. Again it requires once in 100 year rains or floods, but that's hardly exceptional. You can include the whole of the US Gulf Coast, all of which is at risk from "The Big One" hitting them dead on. Or the high risk of twisters along tornado alley. Not only do people live in such places but they seem to do little to mitigate their risks - the sorts of houses they live in, often wood-framed and isolated, are much less able to withstand extreme weather than e.g. the concrete buildings seen in parts of Asia prone to typhoons.
If people accept such risks they're going to be much less concerned about a risk that's only a one in a million chance of happening to them.
Re: SPACE
Bad analogy; I could see/hear an elephant coming. Steps (quite literal steps) could be taken to avoid it long before it happened.Dio wrote:You'd better not go outside! You might be sat on by an elephant!Darkflame wrote:Just because we ignored the issue, and you have called it "risk assessment" does not make it any more sane.Dio wrote:It's called risk assessment. We do it every day, including when we put on a kettle or get in a car.Darkflame wrote:I never liked the "its unlikely at any specific time, so lets do nothing about it" attitude of, well, our species.
Down the route of accepting no risk at all lies insanity.
A low probability event will eventually happen. To think otherwise, or to think "its ok because it wont happen to me" is a flaw in logic. A human flaw maybe. But still a flaw.
I guess lighting strikes would be a better analogy as it would be too impractical for everyone to avoid storms completely - yet a individual strike we get no warning off.
Still, we warn people not to hold golf clubs in the air etc. Or to get into our little personal faraday cages if we are in open areas.
Relatively small efforts to ensure a little bit of safety.
To me, monitoring our neighborhood is basic analogous to those small steps - albeit scaled up.
-
Incidentally, has there really been more people in cities sat on by elephants in the last hundred years then asteroid impacts?
I know you were joking, but I think you cant start thinking these strikes are that unlikely (to happen outside of russia).
===
Indeed....But people still live there, even though they must be aware that they or their children will probably experience such a quake.
Although this isn't "risk assessment" so much as guaranteed killing some of your future descendants.No, Its simple a risk taken because no politician thinks the problem will effect them. Pretty much the same logic behind building on known natural danger spots.
Short-term thinking at its best.
Its part of our species flaw for short-term benefits over long term ones. Something that I believe has been pretty established psychology wise.
-
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: SPACE
I think the better animal is the hippopotamus: more people are killed by them than by lions, elephants etc.
On risk people really do seem to take some extreme risks with where they live, what they do. But perhaps this part of our character as a species. We would not have colonised the world so often, most of it well before we had access to modern civilising technologies, if we were averse to risk. Think of the people crossing the land-bridge from Siberia to Alaska to colonise the Americas, or those who crossed thousands of miles of Pacific in canoes to colonise Easter Island. They were taking there life in their hands doing so, as probably were many more we don't know about who didn't make it.
So the risk of being hit by a rock is not a big deal. Something to speculate over but not something to lose much sleep over or waste much effort on. Sure if there were a chance all life would be wiped out but there's no evidence that will ever happen: it's not happened in the hundreds of millions of years since life started, and if anything is less likely now than in the past.
On risk people really do seem to take some extreme risks with where they live, what they do. But perhaps this part of our character as a species. We would not have colonised the world so often, most of it well before we had access to modern civilising technologies, if we were averse to risk. Think of the people crossing the land-bridge from Siberia to Alaska to colonise the Americas, or those who crossed thousands of miles of Pacific in canoes to colonise Easter Island. They were taking there life in their hands doing so, as probably were many more we don't know about who didn't make it.
So the risk of being hit by a rock is not a big deal. Something to speculate over but not something to lose much sleep over or waste much effort on. Sure if there were a chance all life would be wiped out but there's no evidence that will ever happen: it's not happened in the hundreds of millions of years since life started, and if anything is less likely now than in the past.
Re: SPACE
But they have Jesus in large quantities in the Southern states, so it is all OK.pogo wrote:Not only do people live in such places but they seem to do little to mitigate their risks - the sorts of houses they live in, often wood-framed and isolated, are much less able to withstand extreme weather than e.g. the concrete buildings seen in parts of Asia prone to typhoons.
If people accept such risks they're going to be much less concerned about a risk that's only a one in a million chance of happening to them.
Holier than thou
Re: SPACE
Don't go outside, you could be shot by a sniper!Darkflame wrote:Incidentally, has there really been more people in cities sat on by elephants in the last hundred years then asteroid impacts?
I know you were joking, but I think you cant start thinking these strikes are that unlikely (to happen outside of russia).
Don't stay inside, an aeroplane could crash into your house and you might not see it coming!
Picking holes in the one example I gave is mind-bogglingly stupid because there are an insane number of other things I could pick instead.
The ubiquity of risk acceptance is a very simple point and it's really woolly thinking to blissfully ignore it.
Re: SPACE
Actually, you do, or at least, in many cases you do. You can feel, and hear, the potential buildup.Darkflame wrote:I guess lighting strikes would be a better analogy as it would be too impractical for everyone to avoid storms completely - yet a individual strike we get no warning off.
How do I know this? Went, with a friend, to watch an impending storm in one of the piste security cabins on one of the nearby peaks. Mountains, plus savage storms, plus unimpeded 360º view, in the dry, was too good an opportunity to miss. In hindsight, not such a good idea - the storm hit about half an hour earlier than predicted, meaning we were out, in the open, on an exposed ridge when it arrived. Ever held on to a Van-der-Graaf generator? It's a bit like that, only more so. When you can feel it crackling in your ears, you lie the fuck down, and fast. In short, we spent 20 minutes or so lying face down in rock and mud whilst be hailed on, with lightning strikes within feet of where we were. And this wasn't a little "2 rumbles of thunder and it's over" storm, this was 100mph winds, lightning strikes every 30 seconds or so.
As a motorcyclist, I've probably been significantly closer to actually dying, but I've never been so fucking afraid in all my life.
"massive retard™", "full of shit™", "tiny bitch™", "retarted™", "a bit of a one trick pony™", "petty™", "simple minded idealistic twat™", "miserable humourless fucker™"
-
llamaprotector
- Baaaa!

- Posts: 648
- Joined: Fri Apr 23, 2010 2:00 am 0
Re: SPACE
Would kill all life on this planet at even much further distances away IIRC but the beam of destruction is a very narrow field and a direct hit is required. The ultimate game of chanceAbsolute_Zero wrote:Define close. A gamma-ray burst could take us out from thousands of light years away. e.g. WR 104 at 8,000.pogo wrote:The exception would be a supernova. But these are very unlikely - they happen often enough within the galaxy but it would need to be close to affect us
Re: SPACE
Not sure how long this is going on for - but the ISS is streaming live footage of Earth at the moment:
http://www.meteorwatch.org/iss-live-video-earth/
http://www.meteorwatch.org/iss-live-video-earth/
- merman
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 10943
- Joined: Wed Feb 16, 2005 1:44 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: merman1974
- Yahoo Messenger: andrewrfisher
- Location: Skegness, England
- Contact:
Re: SPACE
Rest in peace, Colin Pillinger.
Twitter, Xbox, Wii U and Steam - merman1974
ZZAP is back - https://www.patreon.com/zzapmagazine
ZZAP is back - https://www.patreon.com/zzapmagazine