The Wonderful NHS in the UK

Inane baanter or words of wisdom - you decide...
Post Reply
User avatar
venusian
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6653
Joined: Wed Nov 06, 2002 2:22 pm 0
Location: South Gloucestershire

Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK

Post by venusian »

The Australian government is currently being sued by tobacco companies because of profits lost due to government action to reduce smoking. Perhaps Coca Cola could sue the UK government for their attempts to reduce sugary drink consumption among school children? Or a private medical company could deter the NHS from offering treatments to the general population which that company can profitably supply to the rich.

One only has to look at the US patent office to see how badly bent well-meaning legislation can become, even when the legal processes behind it are relatively open. The TTIP gives corporations the tools to place themselves above the right of sovereign governments to put the wellbeing of the population before profit. There's no reason to believe they wouldn't use those tools.
User avatar
merman
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 10943
Joined: Wed Feb 16, 2005 1:44 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: merman1974
Yahoo Messenger: andrewrfisher
Location: Skegness, England
Contact:

Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK

Post by merman »

pogo wrote:Can someone please explain how TTIP means "THE END of the NHS as we know it", and all the other doom and gloom proclaimations that are being made. So far I've seen nothing to support this. E.g. from that petition site:
Although trade and investment agreements have always had a substantial impact on almost every aspect of the daily life of citizens, workers and consumers, the European Commission nevertheless prefers to negotiate secretly behind closed doors. Trade unions and civil society organisations are not actively involved in trade talks.
But unions (and 'civil society organisations' which I presume means fellow travellers on the left) don't get to take part in trade negotiations. They're not our elected representatives. They definitely shouldn't be allowed to use such negotiations to push their own agendas, after failing to do so democratically at the ballot box.

And this seems to be the main point of objection: the left is wing unhappy that they're not getting e.g. more language about trade unions into the agreement. So they make stuff up about how it will destroy the NHS, without a shred of evidence that it will. Or at least no-one's presented any evidence so far.
Because the NHS is being privatised. And when it is, TTIP will mean the companies providing healthcare will be able to sue to get themselves out of binding contracts and will be able to put profit before patients. There will be no legal recourse to reverse anything.
Twitter, Xbox, Wii U and Steam - merman1974
ZZAP is back - https://www.patreon.com/zzapmagazine
User avatar
pogo
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 14180
Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
Location: County Durham

Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK

Post by pogo »

Darkflame wrote:Companies are unelected.
Judges are unelected.
So? It's good that judges are unelected, as where they are (e.g. parts of the US) you get people who are their as political representatives, pushing an agenda, not the independent legal experts we're used to.

As for firms they too aren't elected. Does that mean they shouldn't have the right to justice? Governments already have to act fairly and reasonably towards domestic firms. This just extends that to foreign firms. It doesn't stop governments making laws, implementing policies, or at least no more than before.
venusian wrote:The Australian government is currently being sued by tobacco companies because of profits lost due to government action to reduce smoking. Perhaps Coca Cola could sue the UK government for their attempts to reduce sugary drink consumption among school children? Or a private medical company could deter the NHS from offering treatments to the general population which that company can profitably supply to the rich.
The first example is a good example. When a firm's business is disrupted by government action they should be able to challenge it. On tobacco regulations they should be allowed to ask whether what the government is doing is proportionate and necessary. And the tobacco companies lost. But governments don't always get it right. Sometimes they go too far, as the US did banning alcohol in the 1920s. Sometimes they act unfairly, by taxing or regulating foreign firms differently from local ones. Sometimes they are just wrong, as our government is now on culling badgers to stop TB – governments despite all their resources often make bad decisions, and firms and individuals affected should be able to challenge them.

I don't see how you get from that to the third point. "a private medical company could deter the NHS from offering treatments"? Really? How, exactly.
merman wrote:Because the NHS is being privatised. And when it is, TTIP will mean the companies providing healthcare will be able to sue to get themselves out of binding contracts and will be able to put profit before patients. There will be no legal recourse to reverse anything.
It's already very privatised. A lot of it happened under the last govt.. Yet we have a 'Wonderful NHS', the best in the world. There's nothing wrong with private provision of services. The TTIP doesn't change anything about how the NHS is operated or delivered. Firms won't e.g. by able to put 'profit before patients' as the contracts they sign won't let them.

The biggest fear seems to be that privatisation will be undoable after TTIP. But there are three things wrong with that. First privatisation is based on contracts. If a future Labour govt. (say) wants to stop privatisation they need only stop writing new contracts and wait for existing ones to end (though some will take quite a long time, such as the many PFI ones started under Labour). Second if Labour are so against privatisation now why did they massively expand it with PFI? Third whatever limits there might be are already in place: UK and EU firms can already sue the government for e.g. breach of contract. This doesn't change the rules for health provision at all.
User avatar
(o)(o)
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6885
Joined: Tue Jan 19, 2010 2:21 am 0

Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK

Post by (o)(o) »

I was wondering how long it would take before blowhard Pogo polluted this thread with his basic lack of comprehension.
pogo wrote:As for firms they too aren't elected. Does that mean they shouldn't have the right to administer justice?
Fixed that for you.
pogo wrote:But governments don't always get it right. Sometimes they go too far
TTIP is a clear example of that.
pogo wrote:It's already very privatised.
The Health and Social Care Act in 2012 laid the foundations for wide-reaching privatisation.

Coalitions NHS reforms came into effect in April 2013. Between April and December 2013 70% of new contracts were private. Get the picture?

The most massive reforms since the inception of the NHS, even though David Cameron pledged in the Coalition Agreement that there would be no more top-down reorganisations of the health service.

Anyway, your opinions on this matter are pollution, not shared by humans.

HOP IT!
User avatar
(o)(o)
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6885
Joined: Tue Jan 19, 2010 2:21 am 0

Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK

Post by (o)(o) »

Image
User avatar
pogo
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 14180
Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
Location: County Durham

Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK

Post by pogo »

You got that BBC headline wrong, it's
Private firms 'win 70% of NHS contracts'
And it starts:
Almost 70% of contracts for NHS services in England between April-December 2013 were won by private firms, a campaign group claims.
But later clarifies.
But the Department of Health (DoH) said the NHS Support Federation's figures "only relate to a small sample of NHS contracts and are therefore selective and misleading".

"The reality is that private sector providers only carry out around 6% of all NHS work," a spokesperson said.
You are most wrong though in your implication my views are minority ones. Health privatisation began under John Major but massively expanded under Blair/Brown. The current coalition's changes have been far more modest than Labour's. But it is the work of all three major parties, and there is broad cross-party support for limited use of the private sector.

The opposition seems to be from those implacably opposed to privatisation on ideological grounds. Union leaders like Len McCluskey who wrote Guardian piece you linked to. But few people think like that now. Labour abandoned state ownership as a guiding principal 20 years ago and have moved on. If any views are "not shared by humans" its those (old-school unionists are often labelled "dinosaurs" for this reason).

TTIP has nothing to do with this. Privatisation is happening, and has been happening for decades. TTIP won't change this or anything about it. If you want to stop privatisation vote for a party that will reverse it. If you can find one.
User avatar
(o)(o)
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6885
Joined: Tue Jan 19, 2010 2:21 am 0

Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK

Post by (o)(o) »

pogo wrote:But later clarifies.
Clarifies lol !

This forum is populated by people smart enough to see your spin.
User avatar
merman
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 10943
Joined: Wed Feb 16, 2005 1:44 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: merman1974
Yahoo Messenger: andrewrfisher
Location: Skegness, England
Contact:

Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK

Post by merman »

pogo wrote:
Darkflame wrote:Companies are unelected.
Judges are unelected.
So? It's good that judges are unelected, as where they are (e.g. parts of the US) you get people who are their as political representatives, pushing an agenda, not the independent legal experts we're used to.

As for firms they too aren't elected. Does that mean they shouldn't have the right to justice? Governments already have to act fairly and reasonably towards domestic firms. This just extends that to foreign firms. It doesn't stop governments making laws, implementing policies, or at least no more than before.
venusian wrote:The Australian government is currently being sued by tobacco companies because of profits lost due to government action to reduce smoking. Perhaps Coca Cola could sue the UK government for their attempts to reduce sugary drink consumption among school children? Or a private medical company could deter the NHS from offering treatments to the general population which that company can profitably supply to the rich.
The first example is a good example. When a firm's business is disrupted by government action they should be able to challenge it. On tobacco regulations they should be allowed to ask whether what the government is doing is proportionate and necessary. And the tobacco companies lost. But governments don't always get it right. Sometimes they go too far, as the US did banning alcohol in the 1920s. Sometimes they act unfairly, by taxing or regulating foreign firms differently from local ones. Sometimes they are just wrong, as our government is now on culling badgers to stop TB – governments despite all their resources often make bad decisions, and firms and individuals affected should be able to challenge them.

I don't see how you get from that to the third point. "a private medical company could deter the NHS from offering treatments"? Really? How, exactly.
merman wrote:Because the NHS is being privatised. And when it is, TTIP will mean the companies providing healthcare will be able to sue to get themselves out of binding contracts and will be able to put profit before patients. There will be no legal recourse to reverse anything.
It's already very privatised. A lot of it happened under the last govt.. Yet we have a 'Wonderful NHS', the best in the world. There's nothing wrong with private provision of services. The TTIP doesn't change anything about how the NHS is operated or delivered. Firms won't e.g. by able to put 'profit before patients' as the contracts they sign won't let them.

The biggest fear seems to be that privatisation will be undoable after TTIP. But there are three things wrong with that. First privatisation is based on contracts. If a future Labour govt. (say) wants to stop privatisation they need only stop writing new contracts and wait for existing ones to end (though some will take quite a long time, such as the many PFI ones started under Labour). Second if Labour are so against privatisation now why did they massively expand it with PFI? Third whatever limits there might be are already in place: UK and EU firms can already sue the government for e.g. breach of contract. This doesn't change the rules for health provision at all.
Private companies are already bailing out of NHS contracts that are proving unfavourable or unprofitable. This will inevitably lead to difficult and complex cases not being a priority.

TTIP means privatisation cannot be reversed. There are so many warning signs that privatising the NHS is NOT better for patients - more chance for fraud, more money wasted on lawyers and "competition".

It's a service, not a business. It's one of the few good things about this country.
Twitter, Xbox, Wii U and Steam - merman1974
ZZAP is back - https://www.patreon.com/zzapmagazine
User avatar
(o)(o)
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6885
Joined: Tue Jan 19, 2010 2:21 am 0

Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK

Post by (o)(o) »

merman wrote:Private companies are already bailing out of NHS contracts that are proving unfavourable or unprofitable. This will inevitably lead to difficult and complex cases not being a priority.
An example of this is GP surgeries. Private companies want in - because it gives them a role in CCGs (Clinical Commissioning Groups who have control over 60% of the NHS budget.. even thought the BMA have declared this as a conflict of interest.. and note the commercialized nomclature change from "Primary Care Trust" to "Commi$$ioning Group") - however there isn't much profit to be had in GP surgeries. So you end up with stuff like :

A private company is exiting a Newcastle GP practice contract early... Care UK has announced it will exit its five-year contract halfway through its tenure and depart at the end of January next year. The company refused to give reasons as to why the contract was ending early.

Ironically, in pogo's neck of the woods. And here's another fun article..

Corporate finance advisers Catalyst have put out a report.. "Areas such as primary care, community health services and commissioning support services are potentially worth billions of pounds."
User avatar
VNVObit
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 4072
Joined: Sun Jan 01, 2006 10:03 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: vnvobit
PSN: VNV_Obit
Location: London

Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK

Post by VNVObit »

personally I really like this quote

Image


A common issue in the tendering of contracts is the poor understanding the actual commissioners have of what the contract entails. Poorly specified contracts are a boon to private contractors as once in they can negotiate from a position of strength on known gaps within the contract. I am aware of a housing management company that operates this model very effectively and does considerable business with local authorities.

The other aspect is that just because it's private doesn't mean it is more cost effective. I am aware of cases where people are in privately operated care homes (paid for from our taxes) and despite providing alternative, quality accommodation and care for a lower cost the care home has frustrated the move (the move would save over £1000 a week per person).
"England is funny, but sometimes she scares me"
Tony Wakeford

My avatar is the cover of Tower of Babel's first single

"Sky is not roof, Earth is not bottom, the world is not yours, you are the world's" from Brown by Grotus
User avatar
pogo
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 14180
Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
Location: County Durham

Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK

Post by pogo »

merman wrote:It's a service, not a business. It's one of the few good things about this country.
This gets to the heart of why we disagree. I see nothing wrong with private companies providing NHS services. I have thought this for a long time and the longer I go on the more persuaded I am. I can offer a number of justifications.

First privatisation has been going on for decades. If it meant "THE END of the NHS as we know it" don't you think we would have noticed by now? I agree the NHS is wonderful in many ways, and privatisation is doing it no harm. This also means there's broad support for privatisation: no government has sought to undo it, all have introduced more since it started 20 years ago.

Second other countries manage with far less state or smaller state provision of healthcare. I don't mean the US (which doesn't manage) but elsewhere in Europe, which have health systems comparable to ours. One particular metric is the NHS is something like the fourth or fifth biggest employer in the world: the only bigger ones are in the US, China and India. Proportionately the NHS employs more of the population than any of them. Literally no other country does is this way, with so much done by a single provider.

Third our economy is a service economy, or at least 80% of it is. And many of the bits that aren't services are health related. Much of our manufacturing is high-tech manufacturing now, including medicines and medical equipment.
We're pretty good at taking care of these things privately. There's no indication that going private gets you a second-rate service.

Fourth a lot of the opposition to this comes from unions, which always makes me cautious. If the only person the Guardian can find to write about this is Len McCluskey then it reinforces my point about there being broad support for reforms and privatisation, with opposition mostly from a minority with no heath experience or expertise.

Fifth: the US system is badly broken, but there's broad recognition how to fix it: single payer. This means the government pays for everything but doesn't have to provide everything, and wouldn't if the US switched to single payer. Again there's recognition that the state doesn't have to provide all the services and doesn't in many single payer systems.



It's single payer that's key as it means the state guarantees everything, decides what it will pay for and pays for it. It's also the key to savings and efficiency as a single payer can get the best prices, such as from bulk-buying of drugs and equipment, or from efficiencies and best practices. And part of this is using private firms, if they can provide the same services for less. The health budget is finite and the more it can save contracting out the more it can spend elsewhere, such as hiring more staff where they're needed.
User avatar
VNVObit
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 4072
Joined: Sun Jan 01, 2006 10:03 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: vnvobit
PSN: VNV_Obit
Location: London

Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK

Post by VNVObit »

pogo wrote: If the only person the Guardian can find to write about this is Len McCluskey then it reinforces my point about there being broad support for reforms and privatisation, with opposition mostly from a minority with no heath experience or expertise.
8O at the lack of logic in the above
a very large leap of faith but no rational argument
"England is funny, but sometimes she scares me"
Tony Wakeford

My avatar is the cover of Tower of Babel's first single

"Sky is not roof, Earth is not bottom, the world is not yours, you are the world's" from Brown by Grotus
User avatar
pogo
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 14180
Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
Location: County Durham

Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK

Post by pogo »

VNVObit wrote:
pogo wrote: If the only person the Guardian can find to write about this is Len McCluskey then it reinforces my point about there being broad support for reforms and privatisation, with opposition mostly from a minority with no heath experience or expertise.
8O at the lack of logic in the above
a very large leap of faith but no rational argument
How? My point was that there's support for privatisation across the political spectrum. The opposition seems to be a small number on the left, opposed to privatisation on ideological grounds or self-interest grounds, not health grounds. E.g. unions don't like privatisation as they find it much harder to recruit members in private firms. As they can't give that as a reason their argument seems to consist of "privatisation is bad so we should not do it". But that's not an argument.
User avatar
VNVObit
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 4072
Joined: Sun Jan 01, 2006 10:03 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: vnvobit
PSN: VNV_Obit
Location: London

Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK

Post by VNVObit »

pogo wrote:
VNVObit wrote:
pogo wrote: If the only person the Guardian can find to write about this is Len McCluskey then it reinforces my point about there being broad support for reforms and privatisation, with opposition mostly from a minority with no heath experience or expertise.
8O at the lack of logic in the above
a very large leap of faith but no rational argument
How? My point was that there's support for privatisation across the political spectrum. The opposition seems to be a small number on the left, opposed to privatisation on ideological grounds or self-interest grounds, not health grounds. E.g. unions don't like privatisation as they find it much harder to recruit members in private firms. As they can't give that as a reason their argument seems to consist of "privatisation is bad so we should not do it". But that's not an argument.
Your logic is that because it was only Len McCluskey writing in the Guardian then that is evidence that your view view of broad support of reforms and privatisation. That's just spurious logic.

I'm neither a union member nor a signed up member of the left but I oppose the privatisation as it'll make it more expensive in the long run on simple economic grounds as private companies (as you've reminded us on more than one occasion) need to make a profit. They have higher cost of capital than a sovereign state therefore need higher revenues to generate an acceptable level of profit than the government.

health insurance will become a new tax for employers as this will become essential to employees. This additional cost of living will increase pressure on wage inflation unless there are adequate tax breaks to ensure that most people have insurance.

While I believe that the health service needs reform I also know that privatisation is not a panacea that will magically reform things. There are some significant strategic decisions required that would take more than 1 parliament to implement so the politicians will only tinker with things rather than address some key points, principally about managing demand on the health service (prevention is not only better than cures it is also significantly cheaper over the long term and ultimately that would have a bigger impact on the budget required).

The idea that privatisation will assist reform is laughable. Winterbourne View is a case in point just because it's private doesn't necessarily make it good/expert (not saying all are as awful as Winterbourne View just that they're not all wonderful just because they're private)
"England is funny, but sometimes she scares me"
Tony Wakeford

My avatar is the cover of Tower of Babel's first single

"Sky is not roof, Earth is not bottom, the world is not yours, you are the world's" from Brown by Grotus
User avatar
Ollie
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 4446
Joined: Mon May 03, 2004 7:04 pm 0
Location: London
Contact:

Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK

Post by Ollie »

pogo wrote:
merman wrote:Second other countries manage with far less state or smaller state provision of healthcare. I don't mean the US (which doesn't manage) but elsewhere in Europe, which have health systems comparable to ours. One particular metric is the NHS is something like the fourth or fifth biggest employer in the world: the only bigger ones are in the US, China and India. Proportionately the NHS employs more of the population than any of them. Literally no other country does is this way, with so much done by a single provider.
Other countries manage by not doing it our way, but they don't manage as well. Remember this?

Image

I guess if we don't want to retain our exemplary ranking in that table, we should steam ahead with trying to be more like the other countries.
Why are you breaking my kayak?
Post Reply