The Wonderful NHS in the UK

Inane baanter or words of wisdom - you decide...
Post Reply
User avatar
Barney
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 2131
Joined: Tue Aug 23, 2005 7:59 pm 0
Location: UK, Broughton, Brigg

Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK

Post by Barney »

Oh, ffs. The NHS, at its very core, is the principle that it's "free at the point of delivery" because we pay our National Insurance.

Who delivers that care is irrelevant.

There are numerous private companies that work with my department and they all perform excellently; it might also be said that they perform far more efficiently than their old NHS-employed counterparts did. Patients are happier than they were before the private companies came in, staff are happier because there's more of them and the training is better.

I work inside the system. The Trusts are dying, struggling to employ enough of... well, anyone. The private companies are going to take over. And it doesn't matter a toss so long as it remains free at the point of delivery.
"Oh dear lord, I slightly soiled myself. Oxfam won’t be pleased."
User avatar
seibu
Baaaaa!
Baaaaa!
Posts: 1040
Joined: Mon Dec 20, 2004 3:24 pm 0

Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK

Post by seibu »

The private sector is not magically more efficient than the public sector. The only difference is that the private sector has to find a way to produce a profit for somebody, whereas the public sector does not.

Privatisation is a scam. It's a way for rich people to appropriate the assets of the state. This has been taking place for centuries; from enclosure in the 13th century to impropriate tithes in the 17th. Unless you're one of the people directly benefiting from it, defending privatisation is like a turkey voting for Christmas.
User avatar
Barney
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 2131
Joined: Tue Aug 23, 2005 7:59 pm 0
Location: UK, Broughton, Brigg

Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK

Post by Barney »

seibu wrote:The private sector is not magically more efficient than the public sector. The only difference is that the private sector has to find a way to produce a profit for somebody, whereas the public sector does not.

Privatisation is a scam. It's a way for rich people to appropriate the assets of the state. This has been taking place for centuries; from enclosure in the 13th century to impropriate tithes in the 17th. Unless you're one of the people directly benefiting from it, defending privatisation is like a turkey voting for Christmas.
You need to go back and read my post again. It doesn't matter who delivers the care, just so long as it's free at the point of delivery. If that's the case, then it will be the NHS regardless of who's actually doing it.

Of course we'd all prefer there to be no private companies in healthcare, but there are and they're better at it in any metric you care to measure. I know, I've experienced it first hand, being an NHS medical professional.
"Oh dear lord, I slightly soiled myself. Oxfam won’t be pleased."
User avatar
seibu
Baaaaa!
Baaaaa!
Posts: 1040
Joined: Mon Dec 20, 2004 3:24 pm 0

Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK

Post by seibu »

Barney wrote: You need to go back and read my post again. It doesn't matter who delivers the care, just so long as it's free at the point of delivery. If that's the case, then it will be the NHS regardless of who's actually doing it.

Of course we'd all prefer there to be no private companies in healthcare, but there are and they're better at it in any metric you care to measure. I know, I've experienced it first hand, being an NHS medical professional.
But why are they better? And why can't whatever techniques they employ be used by the public sector?

Then, you have the best possible service, without having to cream profit off the top. Plus the assets stay in the hands of the public, who paid for them.

I wasn't specifically replying to your post BTW, more just making my contribution to the whole thread :)
User avatar
pogo
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 14180
Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
Location: County Durham

Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK

Post by pogo »

seibu wrote:But why are they better? And why can't whatever techniques they employ be used by the public sector?
One reason is the profit motive is a wonderful motivator. Causes people not only to look for savings but to push themselves harder in all sorts of ways. Another reason is the market lets good firms rise and bad firms fall: bad practice never lasts long as it gets overtaken by better run firms.

Neither of those works in the public sector. Ask people to save money and they'll look at you suspiciously, suspecting that budgets are being cut and they're next. They may even be motivated to spend more, to e.g. preserve budgets or to make sure their allocation is spent (sounds ridiculous but there are cases of e.g. councils rushing through spending at year end to make sure money gets spent; not only do they lose any money not spent but their next year's budget is based on the current years spending so may be be cut also).

And there's no real competition within the public sector. No incentive to do better in case other nimbler and smarter firms take your business. Unless competition is introduced, such as by competitive tendering for contracts.
User avatar
Darkflame
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18236
Joined: Mon Mar 31, 2003 11:06 am 0
Location: Not the UK

Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK

Post by Darkflame »

Another reason is the market lets good firms rise and bad firms fall: bad practice never lasts long as it gets overtaken by better run firms.
Not at all.
If your making a profit, but have "bad practices" as long as you have covered your arse legally you can most certainly survive.
Countless examples of this in recent years.
HBSC money laundering, BP (and other oil companies) insanely bad safety standards, the bank fiasco to name just 3.
Or General Motors in the US that have killed people when deliberately ignoring known problems for years.

If banks can successfully claim to be "too big to fail" then medical companies can easily get into that position given long enough.

Competition is, of course, a wonderful thing - but only when there is strong selective criteria amongst those picking.
When it comes to health (unlike say tvs) theres far far more important criteria then costs, and thats were skepticism comes in as normally those choosing things are choosing based on costs.
And there's no real competition within the public sector. No incentive to do better in case other nimbler and smarter firms take your business.
...and yet somehow the NHS is one of the cheapest per-person medical cares in the world.

The only conclusion from that surely is the lack of competition is outweighed strongly by the money the private firms take off the top. (+extra admin costs to pay them +whatever they spend on advertising +inevitable political donations down the line somewhere).
Last edited by Darkflame on Tue Aug 05, 2014 4:12 pm 0, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
zip accident
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 13928
Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 1:58 pm 0
Location: Bristol, UK

Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK

Post by zip accident »

pogo wrote:One reason is the profit motive is a wonderful motivator. Causes people not only to look for savings but to push themselves harder in all sorts of ways. Another reason is the market lets good firms rise and bad firms fall: bad practice never lasts long as it gets overtaken by better run firms.

Neither of those works in the public sector. Ask people to save money and they'll look at you suspiciously, suspecting that budgets are being cut and they're next. They may even be motivated to spend more, to e.g. preserve budgets or to make sure their allocation is spent (sounds ridiculous but there are cases of e.g. councils rushing through spending at year end to make sure money gets spent; not only do they lose any money not spent but their next year's budget is based on the current years spending so may be be cut also).

And there's no real competition within the public sector. No incentive to do better in case other nimbler and smarter firms take your business. Unless competition is introduced, such as by competitive tendering for contracts.
As a Darwinist/Natural selectionist I strongly dispute that the market is necessarily competitive in any good way. Insider trading is competitive, but it's exactly anti-market, cartels are a product of the market system, and are by intention exactly about competing by the combined suppliers against their customers. There are many others, but those two are sufficient examples to show that unregulated markets are not (despite Margaret Thatcher and Milton Freedam) strictly beneficial to consumers.
"My way is the way of not fighting":- the book of Enter the Dragon.
User avatar
seibu
Baaaaa!
Baaaaa!
Posts: 1040
Joined: Mon Dec 20, 2004 3:24 pm 0

Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK

Post by seibu »

pogo wrote:
seibu wrote:But why are they better? And why can't whatever techniques they employ be used by the public sector?
One reason is the profit motive is a wonderful motivator. Causes people not only to look for savings but to push themselves harder in all sorts of ways. Another reason is the market lets good firms rise and bad firms fall: bad practice never lasts long as it gets overtaken by better run firms.

Neither of those works in the public sector. Ask people to save money and they'll look at you suspiciously, suspecting that budgets are being cut and they're next. They may even be motivated to spend more, to e.g. preserve budgets or to make sure their allocation is spent (sounds ridiculous but there are cases of e.g. councils rushing through spending at year end to make sure money gets spent; not only do they lose any money not spent but their next year's budget is based on the current years spending so may be be cut also).

And there's no real competition within the public sector. No incentive to do better in case other nimbler and smarter firms take your business. Unless competition is introduced, such as by competitive tendering for contracts.
Everybody has heard this stuff a million times before. It's dogma; pure pie-in-the-sky stuff; a fable.

Frequently, reality proves it wrong:

http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/po ... 66157.html

And yet ...

http://www.politics.co.uk/blogs/2014/08 ... e-forced-t
User avatar
VNVObit
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 4072
Joined: Sun Jan 01, 2006 10:03 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: vnvobit
PSN: VNV_Obit
Location: London

Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK

Post by VNVObit »

Barney wrote: And it doesn't matter a toss so long as it remains free at the point of delivery.
That's unlikely to remain the case as over time the cost of services will rise by more than just the cost of salaries -remember private providers are motivated to make a profit and the government has to bear the increased cost.

Ireland went from free at point of delivery to nominal (IR£10 a time, except for medical card holders - unemployed essentially) amount and is now €100 a visit to A&E (I avoided it due to reciprocal arrangements with UK) over €50 to visit a GP (medical card holders are exempt) which are covered by medical insurance - the charges were introduced before the banking crisis before someone suggests that they're solely the result of Ireland's financial predicament. Ireland has the equivalent of NI and that does not cover the cost hence health insurance has become a prerequisite for those in employment (I had it when I lived there)

So it's not too much of a stretch to say that the government will encourage private healthcare with insurance (through tax breaks) as theoretically that manages the burden. However, there will be people that effectively will be uninsurable (elderly, those with permanent conditions, etc.) that will remain the cost of the state. Then we're back to privatising profits and nationalising losses (the obligations for the uninsurable ).
"England is funny, but sometimes she scares me"
Tony Wakeford

My avatar is the cover of Tower of Babel's first single

"Sky is not roof, Earth is not bottom, the world is not yours, you are the world's" from Brown by Grotus
User avatar
pogo
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 14180
Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
Location: County Durham

Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK

Post by pogo »

zip accident wrote:As a Darwinist/Natural selectionist I strongly dispute that the market is necessarily competitive in any good way. Insider trading is competitive, but it's exactly anti-market, cartels are a product of the market system, and are by intention exactly about competing by the combined suppliers against their customers. There are many others, but those two are sufficient examples to show that unregulated markets are not (despite Margaret Thatcher and Milton Freedam) strictly beneficial to consumers.
Markets aren't perfect, as you note. They need to be regulated. Which is why they are regulated.

We have e.g. the Competition Commission to limit cartels. It has broad powers to go after cartels and monopolists. It can e.g. investigate them and go so far as to break them up with no indication of wrongdoing. See e.g. the way BAA was forced to sell off some of its airports at a loss.

If the British commission doesn't act the EU one can and does: if anything it has greater powers with its greater reach. And if neither is interested US regulators can and do take an interest in mergers with an American component. In some ways it it seems like there's too much regulation; certainly there's a lot of overlap, with large deals sometimes modified by both US and EU regulators.

Insider trading is completely different. It's illegal all the time, there are no grey areas/judgements as there are in competition cases. But it's hard to detect and hard to prove, and so is hard to entirely eliminate from trading. But it's also irrelevant to most businesses, which don't trade shares publicly.

In fact both of these are irrelevant to almost all businesses. You can have insider trading, you can have monopolists in certain sectors. But still the rest of the market functions smoothly and efficiently. We don't abandon free markets because of isolated instances of monopolistic behaviour, no more than we abandon universal healthcare because of isolated incidence of abuse.
User avatar
pogo
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 14180
Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
Location: County Durham

Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK

Post by pogo »

VNVObit wrote:Ireland went from free at point of delivery to nominal (IR£10 a time, except for medical card holders - unemployed essentially) amount and is now €100 a visit to A&E (I avoided it due to reciprocal arrangements with UK) over €50 to visit a GP (medical card holders are exempt) which are covered by medical insurance - the charges were introduced before the banking crisis before someone suggests that they're solely the result of Ireland's financial predicament. Ireland has the equivalent of NI and that does not cover the cost hence health insurance has become a prerequisite for those in employment (I had it when I lived there)
Such co-payments are common in other systems. Of course we have them here for prescriptions. And for dental treatments. And for eye tests. And for glasses. So they're common here for certain things.

The point is not to save money directly: €100 won't do much to cover the costs of an A&E visit. The intent is, by asking patients to make a payment, to make them think twice whether they need to visit A&E, or their GP. The problem with free healthcare is some people abuse it: turn up at the GP with a common cold, or at A&E with backache. This drives up costs and deprives those that actually need emergency/GP care of timely treatment.

If people are asked to pay a nominal sum it deters them from using services they don't need. You need to provide alternatives: pharmacies for cold cures, out of hours GP for non-emergency but serious problems, online and phone consultations to help people find the right service.
User avatar
rowan
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 7964
Joined: Tue Nov 25, 2003 11:53 pm 0
Location: Notts.

Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK

Post by rowan »

pogo wrote:The point is not to save money directly: €100 won't do much to cover the costs of an A&E visit. The intent is, by asking patients to make a payment, to make them think twice whether they need to visit A&E, or their GP. The problem with free healthcare is some people abuse it: turn up at the GP with a common cold, or at A&E with backache. This drives up costs and deprives those that actually need emergency/GP care of timely treatment.

If people are asked to pay a nominal sum it deters them from using services they don't need. You need to provide alternatives: pharmacies for cold cures, out of hours GP for non-emergency but serious problems, online and phone consultations to help people find the right service.
Whilst €100 may be nominal from the perspective of A&E, it no longer is for a patient.


As for profit being a good motivator - yes it can be but some services in and of themselves are difficult to run at a profit. In the public sector, this is easier to balance because there are so many diverse incomings & outgoings on the balance sheet.
However in the private sector, there is less ability for a health provider to balance costs across a portfolio of businesses. You probably wouldn't see a private medical company deciding to diversify into tobacco products for example, to prop up the med costs.
User avatar
zip accident
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 13928
Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 1:58 pm 0
Location: Bristol, UK

Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK

Post by zip accident »

pogo wrote:
zip accident wrote:As a Darwinist/Natural selectionist I strongly dispute that the market is necessarily competitive in any good way. Insider trading is competitive, but it's exactly anti-market, cartels are a product of the market system, and are by intention exactly about competing by the combined suppliers against their customers. There are many others, but those two are sufficient examples to show that unregulated markets are not (despite Margaret Thatcher and Milton Freedam) strictly beneficial to consumers.
Markets aren't perfect, as you note. They need to be regulated. Which is why they are regulated.
However they wouldn't be if doctrinaire capitalists got their way.

There are essentially two reasons for privatising the NHS, doctinaire capitalism, and making a big big profit on the quiet.
We have e.g. the Competition Commission to limit cartels. It has broad powers to go after cartels and monopolists. It can e.g. investigate them and go so far as to break them up with no indication of wrongdoing. See e.g. the way BAA was forced to sell off some of its airports at a loss.

If the British commission doesn't act the EU one can and does: if anything it has greater powers with its greater reach. And if neither is interested US regulators can and do take an interest in mergers with an American component. In some ways it it seems like there's too much regulation; certainly there's a lot of overlap, with large deals sometimes modified by both US and EU regulators.
However, there are a lot of monopolies that go completely unchallenged.
Insider trading is completely different. It's illegal all the time, there are no grey areas/judgements as there are in competition cases. But it's hard to detect and hard to prove, and so is hard to entirely eliminate from trading. But it's also irrelevant to most businesses, which don't trade shares publicly.
Most businesses are small operations with few workers and almost no capital. They won't be part of anything significant to the NHS, and they won't be the ones raking in the profits from its destruction.
In fact both of these are irrelevant to almost all businesses. You can have insider trading, you can have monopolists in certain sectors. But still the rest of the market functions smoothly and efficiently.
The market is a bad joke. There is no market. There are a lot of individuals and companies interacting. There is no institution that you can point to and say "that is the market". It is all a bunch of individual deals, being done at the same time.
We don't abandon free markets because of isolated instances of monopolistic behaviour, no more than we abandon universal healthcare because of isolated incidence of abuse.
We don't need to abandon dealing. We do need to tackle abuse, because every case that's permitted to continue increases the probability of abuse in every other deal that arises.
rowan wrote:
pogo wrote:The point is not to save money directly: €100 won't do much to cover the costs of an A&E visit. The intent is, by asking patients to make a payment, to make them think twice whether they need to visit A&E, or their GP. The problem with free healthcare is some people abuse it: turn up at the GP with a common cold, or at A&E with backache. This drives up costs and deprives those that actually need emergency/GP care of timely treatment.

If people are asked to pay a nominal sum it deters them from using services they don't need. You need to provide alternatives: pharmacies for cold cures, out of hours GP for non-emergency but serious problems, online and phone consultations to help people find the right service.
Whilst €100 may be nominal from the perspective of A&E, it no longer is for a patient.


As for profit being a good motivator - yes it can be but some services in and of themselves are difficult to run at a profit. In the public sector, this is easier to balance because there are so many diverse incomings & outgoings on the balance sheet.
However in the private sector, there is less ability for a health provider to balance costs across a portfolio of businesses. You probably wouldn't see a private medical company deciding to diversify into tobacco products for example, to prop up the med costs.
Brainfart? I almost assume you mean "public" because tobacco is terrible stuff medically, or what is going on?
"My way is the way of not fighting":- the book of Enter the Dragon.
User avatar
Darkflame
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18236
Joined: Mon Mar 31, 2003 11:06 am 0
Location: Not the UK

Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK

Post by Darkflame »

If people are asked to pay a nominal sum it deters them from using services they don't need.
....or seeking treatment early while a problem is easy to fix.
User avatar
rowan
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 7964
Joined: Tue Nov 25, 2003 11:53 pm 0
Location: Notts.

Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK

Post by rowan »

zip accident wrote:
rowan wrote:However in the private sector, there is less ability for a health provider to balance costs across a portfolio of businesses. You probably wouldn't see a private medical company deciding to diversify into tobacco products for example, to prop up the med costs.
Brainfart? I almost assume you mean "public" because tobacco is terrible stuff medically, or what is going on?
I was meaning that publicly funded healthcare can be partially funded by tax revenues from all kinds of sources, including tobacco. In the private sector that wouldn't be likely.
Post Reply