Cloudane wrote:Or at least, until the last minute or so. I was enjoying their "warm banter / well meaning sarcasm" all episode. There was a lot of warmth between them, while still keeping the gruff and sarcastic sort of "flavour" as well. Then he goes back to just being a dick to her at the end (no need to call her a "good Doctor" the same way a Dalek says it, that's just nasty). I get that there's probably some parallel between his behaviour and the malfunctioning Dalek or something like that (given the "it's just cuz I was suffocating" point), but aw come on! Just get him around to being nice and be done with it

The way I read it was that he wasn't denying that she did well, but was denying that the word "good" should be applied to her behaving like him.
"You were an expectional Doctor, Clara...but goodness had nothing to do with it" - a reference to the "am I a good man?" question he's been wrestling with.
He wasn't disputing that she'd filled his shoes perfectly, but was questioning whether to do so - to behave as he does - actually qualifies as "good". If he is not, in fact, a good man, then her imitating him - becoming like him - would not be a good thing at all.
Was it "good" that his influence is rubbing off on her? Is what he does genuinely a good thing? Is he a good man?
That's how I interpreted it. He was twisting the semantics. When she asked "was I a good Doctor?", she meant "did I imitate you well?". But, when he answered, he was answering as if she was asking "am I a good person, when I behave as you do?".
She copied him excellently.
But he was disputing whether this was a good act. Whether his actions are for the good. Whether he's a good man.
Whether goodness had anything to do with what happened.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes