Many thanks for the detailed reply, Cloudane. I think our impressions are much the same.
Cloudane wrote:I've not seen other people's reactions to it yet, it might be a case of 'to each his own'.
I am rather fond of it, as are other DW enthusiasts I know, and it was a favourite of Nicholas Courtney and Caroline John (perhaps because they got to play nastier characters, which is always fun). According to Wikipedia, "
The Daily Telegraph named
Inferno as one of the ten best
Doctor Who episodes ever" and the "serial was judged by a 2009
Doctor Who Magazine fan poll to be the finest story of the Third Doctor's era and 31st in the series overall".
Cloudane wrote:Still feels a bit more "sciencey" (particularly in the presence of Liz) and a bit less "fantasy wibbly wobbly" than New Who, including Capaldi's series.
I think that is largely due to the Doctor officially being UNIT's scientific advisor, requiring him to at least appear to be primarily a scientist.
Emoticon and contraction free since... quite a while ago.