The Dr Who thread
Re: The Dr Who thread
I always liked the idea that Bond was a Time Lord myself.
-
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
Re: The Dr Who thread
Theres actually a print book (or ebook edition) you can get, as well.Cloudane wrote:Oh god these are so funny!![]()
If I wasn't being so careful not to make a noise I'd be crying with laughter!
http://wifeinspace.com/2011/03/the-web-planet/
This is just an example. Basically this guy subjects his wife to Classic Who and posts her commentary and a few of his own remarks.
Good lord, puppet Capaldi is adorable!
"Stars don't twinkle in space." - Char Aznable.
- Governmentyard
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 11757
- Joined: Sun Oct 31, 2004 9:41 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: GovernmentYard
- Yahoo Messenger: governmentyard
Re: The Dr Who thread
He's not though. He's The Doctor. Same guy, different face. You don't see common personality traits amongst them?Little stoned kiwi wrote:You say that as if the Doctor isn't a new character every regeneration.Governmentyard wrote:We could also have female James Bond, female Robin Hood, etc. Or maybe we could just come up with new, better female characters in the first place and leave the existing ones as they are because they work fine now.
XBox Gamertag: GovernmentYard
Everything else: governmentyard
Everything else: governmentyard
- Governmentyard
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 11757
- Joined: Sun Oct 31, 2004 9:41 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: GovernmentYard
- Yahoo Messenger: governmentyard
Re: The Dr Who thread
If that's your view of what intrinsic masculinity is, I think that's all the more reason for The Doctor to remain male - too few genuinely complex, positive, non-cartoonish male characters in leading roles on TV*.pogo wrote:The thing about The Doctor though is it's not an intrinsically male character the way the womanising James Bond is.
Once again, we need to create more of these characters, of both genders.
* That said, isn't he actually a frightful tart since the reboot? Episode 1 - pulls Rose, episode 2 - tree lady. Then on through Madame du Pompadour, River Song, your lass with the eyes thing from Smith's final episode, Queen Elisabeth I, Daisy off of Spaced, Kylie, Her off Eastenders... even his own car. He's as bad as Bond nowadays. Either way, I still fall in favour of him remaining a bloke. I think his essence is masculine, he's too good a male role model to be regendered, there's too few like him already.
XBox Gamertag: GovernmentYard
Everything else: governmentyard
Everything else: governmentyard
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: The Dr Who thread
To counter that, again since the reboot, he's been a very reluctant lover of both River Song, with all the affection there seeming very one sided, and Amy Pond, when she tried to corner him. When a machine cloned him the result was feminine. He flirts a lot but that means little.
But of course we don't have to speculate, we've already been told that The Doctor can choose his gender, under the right circumstances:
Otherwise the implication is it's random, but clearly Time Lords including The Doctor can change gender.
But of course we don't have to speculate, we've already been told that The Doctor can choose his gender, under the right circumstances:
Otherwise the implication is it's random, but clearly Time Lords including The Doctor can change gender.
- Little stoned kiwi
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 4598
- Joined: Mon Oct 27, 2003 6:05 am 0
- Location: Christchurch
Re: The Dr Who thread
What traits do you notice, and which ones can only be portrayed by a male actor?Governmentyard wrote:He's not though. He's The Doctor. Same guy, different face. You don't see common personality traits amongst them?
Re: The Dr Who thread
Be fair, I think pogo was saying being a womaniser is an intrinsic male trait, not an intrinsic trait of males is being a womaniser.Governmentyard wrote:If that's your view of what intrinsic masculinity is, I think that's all the more reason for The Doctor to remain malepogo wrote:The thing about The Doctor though is it's not an intrinsically male character the way the womanising James Bond is.
(Of course, that might also be wrong, but not as wrong. )
Thinking about it, children's tv aside, asexual characters are probably the most rare things,
-
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
- Governmentyard
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 11757
- Joined: Sun Oct 31, 2004 9:41 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: GovernmentYard
- Yahoo Messenger: governmentyard
Re: The Dr Who thread
Come on, there's acres of forums devoted to which Doctor the new one (every time we get a new one) is most like and why.Little stoned kiwi wrote:What traits do you notice, and which ones can only be portrayed by a male actor?Governmentyard wrote:He's not though. He's The Doctor. Same guy, different face. You don't see common personality traits amongst them?
I did not say only a male actor could portray anything, either. Only that the character should be male. It's not exactly working out badly so far, is it?
XBox Gamertag: GovernmentYard
Everything else: governmentyard
Everything else: governmentyard
- Little stoned kiwi
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 4598
- Joined: Mon Oct 27, 2003 6:05 am 0
- Location: Christchurch
Re: The Dr Who thread
Communality with specific previous Doctors isn't the same thing as common personality traits with all of them (apart from the obvious one that's the subject of this discussion). And as you agree, a female actor can portray selected traits while adding their own.Governmentyard wrote:Come on, there's acres of forums devoted to which Doctor the new one (every time we get a new one) is most like and why.Little stoned kiwi wrote:What traits do you notice, and which ones can only be portrayed by a male actor?
I did not say only a male actor could portray anything, either. Only that the character should be male. It's not exactly working out badly so far, is it?
You never know, it might work out even better.
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: The Dr Who thread
One change since the reboot that I don't think's been mentioned is the companions have all been sexy young women (excepting perhaps Donna). This has been an understandable change with the change of Saturday night TV. It's no longer Larry Grayson's Generation Game, Secret Army, John Denver and The Muppets. It's talent shows, dating shows, reality shows, all of which are partly sold on sex appeal: the sexy singers, sexy dancers, the antics on the dating shows and reality shows. Even dramas and soaps have been sexed up - today's sexy companion was formerly of the (once very dull) Emmerdale.
But The Doctor didn't really change, at least not initially and under RTD. Moffat though has seen the possibilities and run with them, first with Mme du Pompadour, then with the whole River Song/Amy Pond thing, giving her a boyfriend to lose and re-find, then giving her a baby to lose and re-find even more dramatically, all the while as River Song works her way back through time to marry The Doctor. Then starting all over again with Clara.
What's notable is the main romances have not involved The Doctor. Rose and Mickey. Amy and Rory. Clara and Danny. Mdm Vastra and Jenny. His romance with River Song never really happened, just lots of hints then a marriage done for plot reasons. No obvious reason why that couldn't have all happened with a female Doctor. You'd still have the sexy companion or companions, but the story would be able to go off in new and interesting directions.
But The Doctor didn't really change, at least not initially and under RTD. Moffat though has seen the possibilities and run with them, first with Mme du Pompadour, then with the whole River Song/Amy Pond thing, giving her a boyfriend to lose and re-find, then giving her a baby to lose and re-find even more dramatically, all the while as River Song works her way back through time to marry The Doctor. Then starting all over again with Clara.
What's notable is the main romances have not involved The Doctor. Rose and Mickey. Amy and Rory. Clara and Danny. Mdm Vastra and Jenny. His romance with River Song never really happened, just lots of hints then a marriage done for plot reasons. No obvious reason why that couldn't have all happened with a female Doctor. You'd still have the sexy companion or companions, but the story would be able to go off in new and interesting directions.
- Governmentyard
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 11757
- Joined: Sun Oct 31, 2004 9:41 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: GovernmentYard
- Yahoo Messenger: governmentyard
Re: The Dr Who thread
Specific previous doctors? My point is that there's always plenty of people who see any given Doctor in any other Doctor.Little stoned kiwi wrote:Communality with specific previous Doctors isn't the same thing as common personality traits with all of them (apart from the obvious one that's the subject of this discussion). And as you agree, a female actor can portray selected traits while adding their own.Governmentyard wrote:Come on, there's acres of forums devoted to which Doctor the new one (every time we get a new one) is most like and why.Little stoned kiwi wrote:What traits do you notice, and which ones can only be portrayed by a male actor?
I did not say only a male actor could portray anything, either. Only that the character should be male. It's not exactly working out badly so far, is it?
You never know, it might work out even better.
XBox Gamertag: GovernmentYard
Everything else: governmentyard
Everything else: governmentyard
Re: The Dr Who thread
Were I the show runner, the way I'd do it is that, on his travels, the Doctor finds Romana (an excuse for why she's not inside the Time Lock with the rest of the Timelords would be needed, but one was already invented for the Master already).
She joins him on his travels (after all, there's no easy way to get back to Gallifrey, so there's nowhere much else to go). Then, after a few episodes, there's one where the Doctor tries to land in a precise spot but, when they get there, it's somewhere completely different. Somehow, the TARDIS has been redirected to... well, who knows when and where this place is?
Due to the events of the episode, the Doctor is outside the TARDIS, and Romana and the human companion have returned to the TARDIS (maybe, for example, the Doctor convinces Romana to take their human companion back to the safety of the TARDIS). And then the TARDIS initiates an emergency materialisation.
Right, so the basic idea here is that the Doctor is now stranded somewhere in time and space - and Romana doesn't actually know exactly where it is - and we've got Romana, with human companion, in charge of the TARDIS in his place.
And we can keep this configuration for a few series, nominally as Romana flies about, trying to find the Doctor again. Because as she doesn't know exactly where he is (and the TARDIS isn't always reliable anyway), then we end up on many exciting adventures on the quest to find him (the story arc can be that they increasingly find clues and hints throughout their adventures that make them think they're narrowing in on where he is).
So, there you go. A female Timelord in charge of the TARDIS, with a human companion in tow, going on adventures. She temporarily takes over as the lead character, while the Doctor is missing.
Rather than turn the Doctor into a female Timelord, just get a female Timelord - and we have the perfect one already in Romana, who was once his companion - to take over for a while in his stead.
This gives you a woman in the lead role, in charge of the TARDIS, who is a Timelord (so she's as capable as the Doctor - indeed, as we know, she's arguably more capable, as she's smarter and more qualified than he ever was).
But it's not the same character, so the writers are free not to try to ram the Doctor's character into a woman, but rather can, in fact, have some fun examining how she isn't the Doctor and doesn't do things the way he does (but, by the nagging of the human companion that the Doctor would have done something about that and such, she increasingly starts behaving a bit like him - in his shoes, she increasingly realises why he's the way he is and sees enough of the universe to see why he intervenes as he does). So, you know, narratively, this isn't just an exercise in filling a quota, it's potentially a path to telling a damn good story unto itself.
You might think that there's a danger in having a show without its titular character. Well, one, "Blake's 7" got away with it and, two, this is a show that, by its nature, can certainly get away with it too, because it keeps changing the actor for its titular character all the time anyway. The fear that the audience might not like the new lead is exactly the same as if you regenerated the Doctor. It's really no different. This is, amusingly enough, the safer way to do it. In that you leave the Doctor alone. He is still who he is. You can eventually find him and restore him to being back in charge of the TARDIS once more, at any point.
Think laterally.
If the point here is that it'd be good to have a female Timelord in charge, then put a female Timelord in charge. But you don't have to regenerate the Doctor to do that. There are other alternative ways to get to the same point and, frankly, it'd be more narratively interesting not to just do it in the normal way, but to start telling a different kind of story, with a character who isn't the same as the Doctor, so the show can explore doing things in ways it's not done before (Romana does not necessarily always share the Doctor's want to constantly save the universe). But it is, to all intents and purposes, the same show and it can carry on, until they decide that they want to re-discover the Doctor and put him back in the lead role again.
It won't happen. But that's how I'd do it.
She joins him on his travels (after all, there's no easy way to get back to Gallifrey, so there's nowhere much else to go). Then, after a few episodes, there's one where the Doctor tries to land in a precise spot but, when they get there, it's somewhere completely different. Somehow, the TARDIS has been redirected to... well, who knows when and where this place is?
Due to the events of the episode, the Doctor is outside the TARDIS, and Romana and the human companion have returned to the TARDIS (maybe, for example, the Doctor convinces Romana to take their human companion back to the safety of the TARDIS). And then the TARDIS initiates an emergency materialisation.
Right, so the basic idea here is that the Doctor is now stranded somewhere in time and space - and Romana doesn't actually know exactly where it is - and we've got Romana, with human companion, in charge of the TARDIS in his place.
And we can keep this configuration for a few series, nominally as Romana flies about, trying to find the Doctor again. Because as she doesn't know exactly where he is (and the TARDIS isn't always reliable anyway), then we end up on many exciting adventures on the quest to find him (the story arc can be that they increasingly find clues and hints throughout their adventures that make them think they're narrowing in on where he is).
So, there you go. A female Timelord in charge of the TARDIS, with a human companion in tow, going on adventures. She temporarily takes over as the lead character, while the Doctor is missing.
Rather than turn the Doctor into a female Timelord, just get a female Timelord - and we have the perfect one already in Romana, who was once his companion - to take over for a while in his stead.
This gives you a woman in the lead role, in charge of the TARDIS, who is a Timelord (so she's as capable as the Doctor - indeed, as we know, she's arguably more capable, as she's smarter and more qualified than he ever was).
But it's not the same character, so the writers are free not to try to ram the Doctor's character into a woman, but rather can, in fact, have some fun examining how she isn't the Doctor and doesn't do things the way he does (but, by the nagging of the human companion that the Doctor would have done something about that and such, she increasingly starts behaving a bit like him - in his shoes, she increasingly realises why he's the way he is and sees enough of the universe to see why he intervenes as he does). So, you know, narratively, this isn't just an exercise in filling a quota, it's potentially a path to telling a damn good story unto itself.
You might think that there's a danger in having a show without its titular character. Well, one, "Blake's 7" got away with it and, two, this is a show that, by its nature, can certainly get away with it too, because it keeps changing the actor for its titular character all the time anyway. The fear that the audience might not like the new lead is exactly the same as if you regenerated the Doctor. It's really no different. This is, amusingly enough, the safer way to do it. In that you leave the Doctor alone. He is still who he is. You can eventually find him and restore him to being back in charge of the TARDIS once more, at any point.
Think laterally.
If the point here is that it'd be good to have a female Timelord in charge, then put a female Timelord in charge. But you don't have to regenerate the Doctor to do that. There are other alternative ways to get to the same point and, frankly, it'd be more narratively interesting not to just do it in the normal way, but to start telling a different kind of story, with a character who isn't the same as the Doctor, so the show can explore doing things in ways it's not done before (Romana does not necessarily always share the Doctor's want to constantly save the universe). But it is, to all intents and purposes, the same show and it can carry on, until they decide that they want to re-discover the Doctor and put him back in the lead role again.
It won't happen. But that's how I'd do it.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
- John Maynard Keynes
- Governmentyard
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 11757
- Joined: Sun Oct 31, 2004 9:41 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: GovernmentYard
- Yahoo Messenger: governmentyard
Re: The Dr Who thread
From where I was sat, the plot looked like a misguided attempt by Moffat to a: look clever and b: tie things up with regard to the marriage that he'd already established long ago in 'Silence'.pogo wrote:His romance with River Song never really happened, just lots of hints then a marriage done for plot reasons.
He didn't have a coherent masterplan for all this River Stuff. If he did, it wouldn't have been so weak.
XBox Gamertag: GovernmentYard
Everything else: governmentyard
Everything else: governmentyard
- Governmentyard
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 11757
- Joined: Sun Oct 31, 2004 9:41 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: GovernmentYard
- Yahoo Messenger: governmentyard
Re: The Dr Who thread
Indeed, but I think it's not about that, it's about being able to do something, therefore those who want it will be noisy until they get their way, regardless of how necessary or apt it is. If someone came into run the show with a real artistic or narrative need to change The Doctor's gender, then that would be one thing, but this isn't that.KlaxonCow wrote:All that stuff
To paraphrase Jasper Carrot on people who climb Everest "because it is there" - "an elephant's arse is there but you don't go climbing up it."
XBox Gamertag: GovernmentYard
Everything else: governmentyard
Everything else: governmentyard
Re: The Dr Who thread
Oh, indeed. I did end that post with "It won't happen". 
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
- John Maynard Keynes
