Windows 10 free for Windows 7/8 users for first year
- Little stoned kiwi
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 4598
- Joined: Mon Oct 27, 2003 6:05 am 0
- Location: Christchurch
Re: Windows 10 free for Windows 7/8 users for first year
I assumed, pogo, when you talked of the store being compulsory you were talking about it being a component of Windows. Not the only method of installing software.
What leads you to believe the store will be only way to install software on desktop systems?
What leads you to believe the store will be only way to install software on desktop systems?
- Absolute_Zero
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 3564
- Joined: Wed May 18, 2005 4:11 pm 0
- Location: Hilbert Hotel, Heisenberg.
Re: Windows 10 free for Windows 7/8 users for first year
It's unsupported, period.pogo wrote:There are lots of good reasons people are still on XP.Absolute_Zero wrote:I'm assuming that those connected to the internet using XP on W7 capable hardware, ~1 year out of extended support, is a cause lost to ignorance or insanity. VM usage aside.
8< 8<
Sob.Free updates as this thread’s title indicates are therefore a very good idea. But it’s not free for XP users who presumably will have to pay the full price.
Want to bet? The loser has to vote SWP or nearest equivalent at the subsequent election.pogo wrote:Apple’s Mac app store is entirely optional;We’ll see.Who said it would be any different for W10 PC?
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: Windows 10 free for Windows 7/8 users for first year
I am speculating, on the assumption that MS would only be giving away their OS for free if they could monetise it some other way. It may not be that it becomes the only way, but that ‘Classic’ apps are relegated to a secondary status, not benefitting from additional OS improvements in Windows 10.Little stoned kiwi wrote:I assumed, pogo, when you talked of the store being compulsory you were talking about it being a component of Windows. Not the only method of installing software.
What leads you to believe the store will be only way to install software on desktop systems?
There’s signs of this in another of their announcements, Universal Apps, i.e. apps that run identically on PC and phone so developers only need make them once. Sounds like a terrible idea and Apple definitely have this right; iOS and Mac apps are completely separate things. But if MS do this I’m pretty sure Universal Apps will be app-store only.
Re: Windows 10 free for Windows 7/8 users for first year
Lots of people drive unwarranted cars, use unwarranted tvs, dishwashers long since stopped being made.It's unsupported, period.
The idea of things needing to be "supported" to be of use is not something that is necessarily logical to a lot of people.
-
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
Re: Windows 10 free for Windows 7/8 users for first year
Can't see MS enforcing the app store on PCs any time soon. On their low power tablets, sure. But on the desktop? Even Apple didn't go there, and they're the world's biggest fans of walled gardens - OS X probably has its own bucket full of chewed fingernails over at Cupertino
Now, I would say that both Apple and MS ultimately want to go there and are trying to gradually nudge things in that direction via mobile devices and incrementally making the desktop releases more "mobile-like", adding warnings for applications installed outside of the app store etc. But I don't think either of them are suicidal enough to just go full walled garden cold turkey. We're talking 5, 10, maybe 15 years of gradual effort and getting users fully accustomed to (maybe even happy with) the idea.

At least it's not just Apple getting blanket hate
I couldn't get on with the start screen. I gave it a chance though, for months, but just couldn't get on with the option of either a big mess of tiles or a fully expanded start menu warts and all (when you go down to the "all applications" arrow) and so went back via Start8 to having submenus.
To be fair, this is more a fault of the convention applications have of creating a folder in the start menu and filling it with web links, help file shortcuts, uninstallers, separate utilities etc. I'm much more used to the "app" style method now where you get one icon and that's it. (I hate it when something like Adobe CS treats OS X's /Applications folder as a start menu and puts huge subfolders of junk in it). This might go away over time if things start being written for Metro more. I'd then maybe be more interested in full screen start menus.
==
Overall I like what they're doing. Technically they keep trailing behind Apple and doing what they do a few years later IMO, but of course in market share they're still way on top so it benefits everyone when they say "gee we'd better listen to our users' feedback this time huh?" and actually involve them a bit. This is the most involved I've seen them. Windows 11 will no doubt go back down the "we know best even if 90% of the users want to nuke it from orbit" route again, maybe there'll be an 11.1 to calm people down a bit, then for Windows 12 they'll listen again.. that seems to be the pattern.
Now, I would say that both Apple and MS ultimately want to go there and are trying to gradually nudge things in that direction via mobile devices and incrementally making the desktop releases more "mobile-like", adding warnings for applications installed outside of the app store etc. But I don't think either of them are suicidal enough to just go full walled garden cold turkey. We're talking 5, 10, maybe 15 years of gradual effort and getting users fully accustomed to (maybe even happy with) the idea.
Oh I completely understand that - I'd say the majority of people hate change especially if it's perceived as unnecessary. It's just amusing with the thread (and most of the internet) going "RAWR how dare they develop a new version I don't want / that can't run on old hardware / don't like / etc, not force me to use it, and offer it for free"MattyP wrote:Aye its the problem with Windows. People just get used to what they know and don't like change. ( or don't feel a need to upgrade - and pay - to change something that works for them)
At least it's not just Apple getting blanket hate
You can indeed, there's a maximise button on the start menu in the latest build they were showing which brings back the full screen one for people who liked it. I got the impression it remembers your preference, of course.I personally initially looked at Windows 8 and thought WTF?!. I then had to use it for development stuff at work so changed over from Win7 around 3 years ago. Would never want to go back to 7 now.
It's been rock solid for me and actually prefer the separate start screen now and navigating a pop-up start menu which I find very messy going back. I certainly hope you can configure windows 10 to use the start screen again.
I couldn't get on with the start screen. I gave it a chance though, for months, but just couldn't get on with the option of either a big mess of tiles or a fully expanded start menu warts and all (when you go down to the "all applications" arrow) and so went back via Start8 to having submenus.
To be fair, this is more a fault of the convention applications have of creating a folder in the start menu and filling it with web links, help file shortcuts, uninstallers, separate utilities etc. I'm much more used to the "app" style method now where you get one icon and that's it. (I hate it when something like Adobe CS treats OS X's /Applications folder as a start menu and puts huge subfolders of junk in it). This might go away over time if things start being written for Metro more. I'd then maybe be more interested in full screen start menus.
==
Overall I like what they're doing. Technically they keep trailing behind Apple and doing what they do a few years later IMO, but of course in market share they're still way on top so it benefits everyone when they say "gee we'd better listen to our users' feedback this time huh?" and actually involve them a bit. This is the most involved I've seen them. Windows 11 will no doubt go back down the "we know best even if 90% of the users want to nuke it from orbit" route again, maybe there'll be an 11.1 to calm people down a bit, then for Windows 12 they'll listen again.. that seems to be the pattern.
- Absolute_Zero
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 3564
- Joined: Wed May 18, 2005 4:11 pm 0
- Location: Hilbert Hotel, Heisenberg.
Re: Windows 10 free for Windows 7/8 users for first year
If they don't mind losing their fiscal creds or being a member of a botnet etc, have at it and be happy.Darkflame wrote:Lots of people drive unwarranted cars, use unwarranted tvs, dishwashers long since stopped being made.It's unsupported, period.
The idea of things needing to be "supported" to be of use is not something that is necessarily logical to a lot of people.
Re: Windows 10 free for Windows 7/8 users for first year
They pay for an antivirus for that dont they?
Kinda pointless even having a PC if you cant run what you like. - not to mention making everything on PC 30% more expensive will just go down great with anyone doing work on the things.
30% more on 3DSMax, Maya, Adobe stuff, Autocad....yeah, fuck that.
Indeed.Can't see MS enforcing the app store on PCs any time soon.
Kinda pointless even having a PC if you cant run what you like. - not to mention making everything on PC 30% more expensive will just go down great with anyone doing work on the things.
30% more on 3DSMax, Maya, Adobe stuff, Autocad....yeah, fuck that.
-
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: Windows 10 free for Windows 7/8 users for first year
No, it would not lead automatically to higher prices. 30% is pretty reasonable when you compare it to other means of distribution. Retail in particular you often have much higher costs with physical manufacturing, distribution, retail margins, stock retention and return costs. The experience on Apple’s app stores bears this out. On the Mac App Store developers have seen revenues rise compared to non-App Store distribution. The iOS store doesn’t allow such comparisons but the success of that store for developers and Apple speaks for itself.Darkflame wrote:30% more on 3DSMax, Maya, Adobe stuff, Autocad....yeah, fuck that.
Re: Windows 10 free for Windows 7/8 users for first year
Mac App Store apps are often cheaper than the standalone equivalents from what I've seen, and have the advantage of one purchase applying to all your devices. But no, I just don't see MS trying for a full walled garden (yet). They sometimes shoot themselves in the foot, but their aim and determination isn't quite that good
How they plan to monetise it is a good question, but I have a few theories (some or all of which may or may not apply)
a) Sitting it out this time profits-wise while they rebuild the trust and respect of their customers after the bad reception 8 got and try to get people to, as they put it in the presentation, "love Windows" again instead of just tolerating it. They can afford to do this, they have shitloads of money so they can invest a free release to build up goodwill if they really believe people will like this one.
b) Having it so that you'll really want to use the cloud services by deeply integrating them into the OS and making it feel a bit crippled without them, and charging for the cloud services (or at least extra storage)
c) Just making the app store popular (not enforcing it). Currently only something like 10% of PC users have Windows 8 or later and they've barely nudged the mobile device market, so hardly anyone bothers with it (users or developers alike, in the usual chicken-and-egg problem). They'll have seen Apple's success with bringing everyone up to date via free updates and bragging about their 70% install base of Yosemite or whatever, and will be hoping for similar, so that the app store even has a chance of taking off. (Indeed, another reason I can't see them locking it down any time soon - lock it down to what? There's hardly anything on it.)
d) Hardware sales and OEM licensing. Particularly those hybrid tablet/laptops, which looked a lot more attractive an idea with Win10 on them, switching so easily between tablet and desktop modes.
How they plan to monetise it is a good question, but I have a few theories (some or all of which may or may not apply)
a) Sitting it out this time profits-wise while they rebuild the trust and respect of their customers after the bad reception 8 got and try to get people to, as they put it in the presentation, "love Windows" again instead of just tolerating it. They can afford to do this, they have shitloads of money so they can invest a free release to build up goodwill if they really believe people will like this one.
b) Having it so that you'll really want to use the cloud services by deeply integrating them into the OS and making it feel a bit crippled without them, and charging for the cloud services (or at least extra storage)
c) Just making the app store popular (not enforcing it). Currently only something like 10% of PC users have Windows 8 or later and they've barely nudged the mobile device market, so hardly anyone bothers with it (users or developers alike, in the usual chicken-and-egg problem). They'll have seen Apple's success with bringing everyone up to date via free updates and bragging about their 70% install base of Yosemite or whatever, and will be hoping for similar, so that the app store even has a chance of taking off. (Indeed, another reason I can't see them locking it down any time soon - lock it down to what? There's hardly anything on it.)
d) Hardware sales and OEM licensing. Particularly those hybrid tablet/laptops, which looked a lot more attractive an idea with Win10 on them, switching so easily between tablet and desktop modes.
Re: Windows 10 free for Windows 7/8 users for first year
Company slogan should be "because Seven ate Nine"
- zip accident
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 13928
- Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 1:58 pm 0
- Location: Bristol, UK
Re: Windows 10 free for Windows 7/8 users for first year
The reason that the Windows app store isn't going to be compulsory is that SteamOS is waiting in the wings for that to happen. Fear of the Windows app store being compulsory was what started the development of SteamOS, Steam is an app store more or less, and if MS killed it dead, Valve needed somewhere to go to make money, which SteamOS gives them.
"My way is the way of not fighting":- the book of Enter the Dragon.
- Absolute_Zero
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 3564
- Joined: Wed May 18, 2005 4:11 pm 0
- Location: Hilbert Hotel, Heisenberg.
Re: Windows 10 free for Windows 7/8 users for first year
It's not the reason... they art legion, most of which are blindingly obvious to all except for the FUD-farming, fruitco-fellating fanboy.zip accident wrote:The reason that the Windows app store isn't going to be compulsory is that...
Re: Windows 10 free for Windows 7/8 users for first year
....like buying direct from the company's own website were they dont have to pay anything to Microsoft?pogo wrote:No, it would not lead automatically to higher prices. 30% is pretty reasonable when you compare it to other means of distribution.Darkflame wrote:30% more on 3DSMax, Maya, Adobe stuff, Autocad....yeah, fuck that.
30% is INSANE thing to add to any expensive PC app. Its not reasonable on any level. These apps already can cost thousands.
Autodesk isn't going to cut their own profits by 30% to compensate why should they? What do they get in return? Hosting costs? Thats trivial to nothing as percentage of cost on apps that expensive.
Do you really think the people buying these industrial apps are doing to buy more of them because they see them in the OS Store?
This isnt Angry Birds. It isnt impulse buy/convenience giving things getting a boast.
-
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: Windows 10 free for Windows 7/8 users for first year
That’s very much a second best approach for many firms though.Darkflame wrote:....like buying direct from the company's own website were they dont have to pay anything to Microsoft?pogo wrote:No, it would not lead automatically to higher prices. 30% is pretty reasonable when you compare it to other means of distribution.Darkflame wrote:30% more on 3DSMax, Maya, Adobe stuff, Autocad....yeah, fuck that.
* You potentially lose far more to piracy, unless you’re able to include OS-level industrial grade DRM which few companies have the expertise or resources to integrate.
* You lose the free international distribution that comes with Apple's store, unless you have web sites in every major market you do business in. Sure you can run it all from one web site but purchasing systems, legal systems, languages are different and extra work
* You lose the free advertising and easy purchasing; Apple’s store offers one-click purchases, or not much more. On your own web site customers have to do much more work, and have to trust you
And all that isn’t free. There are credit card fees, currency exchange costs, web hosting costs. You’ll need to hire a web designer unless you want it to look like shit. And pay someone else to do all the processing, handle problems. Very soon it all adds up. No-one is forced to pay Apple 30%. That so many do is testament to the good value it offers.
The few firms this doesn’t suit are those who have already done all the work themselves. Adobe for example. Or MS who kept Office off iOS for a long time, until they saw sense and realised how much business they were losing.
