Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary

Support Forum: http://minotaurproject.co.uk/phpBB3/viewforum.php?f=22
Post Reply
User avatar
Yak
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 20266
Joined: Wed Apr 17, 2002 10:22 am 0
Location: Wales
Contact:

Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary

Post by Yak »

This has been going on behind the scenes for a while now. I'd kept it on the down low all this time because I had hoped we could maybe work something out, maybe "Atari" would commission an officially licensed version from us; we made it clear we'd be willing to negotiate about that sort of thing.

I even thought maybe they might be interested in my doing updated versions of some of the other Atari IP. After all i do have a track record of doing decent reworkings of old games like theirs and I'd've really enjoyed a crack at some of those old things.

However they never gave an inch and just continued with threats and bullying. Specifically they had their lawyers present a number of legal accusations about a variety of things; we consulted a lawyer who told us that if we wanted to fight against it then it'd be expensive because we'd need to address separately each of the things they were accusing me of.

The accusations were addressed not only to Llamasoft as a company but also directed at me personally.

Basically most of it came down to "looks like Tempest 2000", and it included such gems as:

- in order to create TxK I must have had access to, and stolen secrets from, Atari's source code, in order to steal the work of the other people who worked on Tempest 2000. (I *wrote* the source code for Tempest 2000, and didn't need to refer to it at all to create TxK, even if I still had it. The only other people who worked on the game were Joby Woods who did bitmaps (TxK has no bitmaps apart from one 64x64 graduated dot) and the Imagitec musicians (TxK has neither a modplayer nor any of Imagitec's music). So I stole my own work out of my own brain I guess.
- The soundtrack to TxK sounds identical to the soundtrack of Tempest 2000. (In fact the TxK soundtrack is entirely original and highly acclaimed; it won a Develop award and went to #1 on Bandcamp).
- The player ship can jump. Apparently Atari owns jumping.
- There is an AI Droid in TxK. Yes there is, and there has been an AI Droid in almost every game I've made since Llamatron. Which I made 3 years before Tempest 2000. The AI Droid is a staple of my design style.
- I deliberately set out to cash in on Atari's copyrighted Tempest name (by giving my game a deliberately obscure name of TxK).
- I deliberately set out to cash in on Atari's stellar reputation by associating my game with their illustrious name. (I never mentioned Atari at all as the last thing I really wanted was for Llamasoft to be associated with the undead Atari responsible for turning Star Raiders into a fucking slot machine).

All abject bollocks, but set up legally so as to be expensive for anyone to contest. Even just going back and forth a few times with letters responding to their threats ended up running up a couple of grand in legal bills, and there is simply no way on God's earth I can afford any kind of a legal battle.

I think they thought I was somehow making loads and loads of money on the Vita version of TxK, I guess because it did garner excellent reviews and a bit of positive press. But the Vita isn't a massive market, TxK made back it's development advance and a bit more and that was it. They kept hassling us and eventually I sent them sales statements so that they could see for themselves that we weren't getting super rich out of it. I even tried to point out that if there was any serious money to be made out of it it would likely be from the ports we were making, and that we were willing to negotiate about obtaining "official" branding for, if it meant they could at least be released, but we were met with nothing more than intransigence.

Even after having shown them that, they are still trying to insist that I remove from sale Vita TxK (even though it's plainly at the end of its run now and only brings in a trickle these days) and sign papers basically saying I can never make a Tempest style game ever again. So no chance of releasing the ports.


Wouldn't it be nice if there were actually some kind of precedent set that determined how different a game had to be to be considered a different game legally? Well, it just so happens there is, and it involves Tempest 2000 and Atari! Do you remember there was a Playstation port of Tempest 2000 called "Tempest X"? I always wondered why the name was changed, and other little aspects of the gameplay were altered. years later I managed to chat online with the guy who did the port, and he told me that the changes were made "to reduce the royalty burden".

How so? Well, my original arrangement with Atari was that I was to receive a royalty on any ports of Tempest 2000. "Tempest X" was made exactly enough different that it would be legally considered a different game, cutting me out of any royalties.

Now Tempest X:

- was derived from my source code;
- had exactly the same soundtrack;
- used the same kind of powerup progression as Tempest 2000;
- had a changed name, some extra background effects, and some different web shapes;
- but was close enough to Tempest 2000 that *Tempest 2000 was available as a hidden unlockable by entering a specific word into the highscore table*.

(Furry friends will be amused to hear that that word was "yiff").

Yet now "Atari" claim that TxK is in fact *closer* legally to Tempest 2000 than Tempest X was.
Justified and Ancient.
User avatar
pyroxian
Baaaaa!
Baaaaa!
Posts: 1308
Joined: Sat Nov 06, 2004 2:05 pm 0
Location: OX-ford

Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary

Post by pyroxian »

:( This sucks
User avatar
Deckard
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 10748
Joined: Fri Jun 18, 2004 11:27 pm 0
Location: Falmouth, Cornwall, UK

Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary

Post by Deckard »

Just tossers.
Now with a new Mac Mini Pro so dont judge me !
User avatar
disciple
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 13941
Joined: Mon Oct 27, 2003 11:33 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: LiberMentis
PSN: Prime_Heretic
Location: Greenfield
Contact:

Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary

Post by disciple »

Ah bloody hell that's fucking rotten - all the best man. That "going forward" clause is just a kick in the teeth.
and sign papers basically saying I can never make a Tempest style game ever again
I'm having this though https://txk-ost.bandcamp.com/album/txk-the-original-soundtrack, it looks like it's gonna be the closest I'll get to TxK on my PS4 (+PC). :| :tea:
PS4 : Prime_Heretic
Steam: bitstorm
Elite Dangerous: Cmdr Britain
User avatar
lazerwalker
Baaaaa!
Baaaaa!
Posts: 1319
Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 10:22 pm 0
Location: (Very) sarf of the river

Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary

Post by lazerwalker »

That's really awful, and all this legal crap hanging over you must have been, (must continue to be), horribly stressful.

Even if the ghost of Atari is now just a scummy IP enforcement machine, they're *still* doing it wrong because, as you say, they'd surely make a lot more money by licensing it to you so it could be released on many more systems from which they could get their undeserved cut.
User avatar
Cloudane
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 7937
Joined: Wed Jun 15, 2005 6:05 pm 0
Location: VRchat

Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary

Post by Cloudane »

Going down the legal bullying route? Classic signs of a company that is fading into irrelevance. It's such a shame that these big corporations can't just die gracefully instead of making everyone hate them first :?
User avatar
hyphz
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 2856
Joined: Tue Aug 13, 2002 4:24 pm 0
Yahoo Messenger: hyphz
Location: Reading, which is deep and dark apparantly
Contact:

Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary

Post by hyphz »

That is stupid and ridiculous :(

I believe the BCS has gotten involved before in cases of programmers being told they could not use any programming techniques they learned working for a previous employer, because those techniques were now embodied in the source code that the previous employer owned.
User avatar
Darkflame
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18236
Joined: Mon Mar 31, 2003 11:06 am 0
Location: Not the UK

Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary

Post by Darkflame »

Is there any hope in trying to get various games websites to post about this? Trying to highlight how insane "Atari" is being here?
At the very least they deserve some bad press. It might be once in a blue moon, but I have heard of cases where getting the "right people" to know of things on twitter and such can result in positive movements.
Sometimes one arm a company hasn't a clue what another one is doing, and maybe this is "lawyers run amok"
c64audio
Baaaaa!
Baaaaa!
Posts: 1657
Joined: Thu Apr 25, 2002 5:34 pm 0
Location: In the Mobile Sphere
Contact:

Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary

Post by c64audio »

I'm guessing that having put up with this shit, you probably wouldn't _want_ to do another version of Tempest.

Man, this so needs a millionaire or a pro-bono.
Chris Abbott
Remixer and mobile thingywotsit.
User avatar
Valgalder
Baaa!
Baaa!
Posts: 152
Joined: Mon Apr 22, 2002 6:04 pm 0
Location: Chicago

Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary

Post by Valgalder »

Absolutely disgusting.

Guess I better that Vita asap so I can at last get TxK before that disappears.. was really holding out on a console version...
User avatar
Junosix
Baaaaa!
Baaaaa!
Posts: 1959
Joined: Sun Jul 14, 2002 4:12 pm 0
Location: Plymouth

Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary

Post by Junosix »

Do they actually have copyright over Tempest? They let the Tempest 2000 trademark lapse in 2006, and the original Tempest would have gone to Atari Games/Midway during the Tramiel split, surely? Or is it not as clear-cut as that?
wicked skills
User avatar
Baggypants
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 5328
Joined: Sun Mar 19, 2006 12:54 pm 0
Location: Salford(UK);
Contact:

Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary

Post by Baggypants »

What's needed is for Notch to buy Atari, sack everyone, and bury it.
"The eggs, get them!"
User avatar
Sir_LANs-a-lot
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 12143
Joined: Mon Mar 10, 2003 1:00 am 0
Location: Here

Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary

Post by Sir_LANs-a-lot »

Yeah, this just sucks - I was really looking forward to picking up TxK for the PS4

Can't believe that a company/brand I used to revere so much has come to this.

A sad day for gamers everywhere.

:tea: :(
[Sir_LANs-a-lot]

Meat is murder.
Tasty, tasty murder.
c64audio
Baaaaa!
Baaaaa!
Posts: 1657
Joined: Thu Apr 25, 2002 5:34 pm 0
Location: In the Mobile Sphere
Contact:

Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary

Post by c64audio »

Baggypants wrote:What's needed is for Notch to buy Atari, sack everyone, and bury it.
He could do worse than fund a legal team for Jeff.
Chris Abbott
Remixer and mobile thingywotsit.
User avatar
Baggypants
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 5328
Joined: Sun Mar 19, 2006 12:54 pm 0
Location: Salford(UK);
Contact:

Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary

Post by Baggypants »

c64audio wrote:
Baggypants wrote:What's needed is for Notch to buy Atari, sack everyone, and bury it.
He could do worse than fund a legal team for Jeff.
I did think of that, then I thought of the one I posted and decided that would be more satisfactory.
"The eggs, get them!"
Post Reply