Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary
Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary
This sucks. TxK is an amazing game, and isn't guilty of anything except innovating on an existing genre. Comparing it to Tempest is a given, like comparing Call of Duty to Battlefield in the FPS genre; similar but not the same.
Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary
Yeah, this really sucks. Barring a deep-pocketed fairy godmother appearing, the only thing I can think of is to give up on the TxK name and soundtrack, but find a way to reuse the source code so far to create a new awesome psychedelic game in the tube-shooter genre. I hope something like that would work, anyway... :S

I made a deviantart page.
'....The baron is a gay old rogue with an eye for the ladies....'
'....The baron is a gay old rogue with an eye for the ladies....'
Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary
This has made me feel so bloody angry, yet at the same time, so bloody ineffectual.
In addition, it adds further to my deep distrust of lawyers. Don't these people feel any remorse when grinding the little guy under their heel?
Utter sociopathic cunts.
In addition, it adds further to my deep distrust of lawyers. Don't these people feel any remorse when grinding the little guy under their heel?
Utter sociopathic cunts.
- Portland
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 8828
- Joined: Thu Apr 06, 2006 8:16 am 0
- Location: Swinton, South Yorkshire
Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary
The anger is strong in this one. Disgraceful.

Portland 3.0.1.0 public release rolled out
- mamemeister
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 7464
- Joined: Mon Apr 29, 2002 10:21 pm 0
- Location: Livingston
- Contact:
Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary
It's clear the Atari we all knew and loved is no-more and I'm sure all those involved in the original company would be as upset reading all of this as we are. Yeah, it plays like Tempest but it's been polished and had so many additions that it's moved on significantly. Suffice to say I dislike Tempest with a passion but fucking love TxK. Says it all really.
The talent you guys have is for all to see so dust yourselves off and re-use the code and make something even more awesome and make these twats wish they'd teamed up as you suggested.
The talent you guys have is for all to see so dust yourselves off and re-use the code and make something even more awesome and make these twats wish they'd teamed up as you suggested.
Never judge a man until you have walked in his mocassins for 2 moons.........
Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary
Blimey this site's been hard to log into for the past few hours :-)
Absolutely flabbergasted by this news, how horrible. Difficult to see how anyone wins out of this. Really hoping it resolves well for you, Jeff
Absolutely flabbergasted by this news, how horrible. Difficult to see how anyone wins out of this. Really hoping it resolves well for you, Jeff
Steam: SteelyDamn
- phattslagg
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 3578
- Joined: Fri May 14, 2004 2:04 pm 0
- Location: Worcester, England
Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary
The soundtrack (assuming we are talking about the music) is a different beast, I think. The artists retain copyright, and each piece would have to be challenged individually. None of the pieces is even remotely infringing any of those from the original, and it would require a different legal process altogether for "Atari" to challenge this in court.toxibunny wrote:Yeah, this really sucks. Barring a deep-pocketed fairy godmother appearing, the only thing I can think of is to give up on the TxK name and soundtrack, but find a way to reuse the source code so far to create a new awesome psychedelic game in the tube-shooter genre. I hope something like that would work, anyway... :S
- pete_uplink
- Baa!

- Posts: 73
- Joined: Sat Jul 12, 2014 9:35 pm 0
- Location: Manchester
- Contact:
Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary
What really grinds my gears about this whole affair is this "Atari" that's saying Jeff Minter is stealing their IP aren't the Atari that existed in 1994 when Tempest 2000 was made. It's basically the reanimated corpse of Atari being controlled by greed and cashing in on the name of a once great company. At the time when Tempest 2000 was made and released "Atari" were called Infogrames in from 1983 to 1994, Hasbro Interactive in 1995 and didn't take the name Atari until 1998, and in the intervening years took out Ocean Software and Microprose. Now this company, who's only real connection to Atari is that they took the name, are telling a man who created a game that he can't make a sequel to that game because it's stealing their IP, when they had nothing to do with the creation of it.
It's a bit like someone who has no clue about music buying the rights to all of Queens single and album releases calling himself Freddie Mercury and saying that he was the one that recorded all the songs and nobody is allowed to do a cover version without his say so.
Personally I think it's beyond disgusting...
It's a bit like someone who has no clue about music buying the rights to all of Queens single and album releases calling himself Freddie Mercury and saying that he was the one that recorded all the songs and nobody is allowed to do a cover version without his say so.
Personally I think it's beyond disgusting...
Former ZX81, C64 and Amiga user. I make games.
Twitter - https://twitter.com/Peteuplink Blog: https://www.acollectionofbits.co.uk/
Twitter - https://twitter.com/Peteuplink Blog: https://www.acollectionofbits.co.uk/
Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary
Man this sucks. I'd completely understand if you didn't want to take this on, but if you did maybe a Kickstarter could fund a lawyer.
- Governmentyard
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 11757
- Joined: Sun Oct 31, 2004 9:41 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: GovernmentYard
- Yahoo Messenger: governmentyard
Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary
I tell you what, it'd be an awful shame if some unknown beta tester leaked the PC version as a torrent or something, wouldn't it?
XBox Gamertag: GovernmentYard
Everything else: governmentyard
Everything else: governmentyard
Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary
Oh man, I am so going to get flamed for this...
Was anyone else disappointed when they heard that the next big release was going to be TxK? I mean, just a teensy bit? Am I truly, genuinely, the only one who thought "Oh dear, another version/reworking/re-imagining of Tempest...".
Here's the thing - I've posted here since Day #1 and my record stands as a hardcore LS / Yak fan. My first game purchase was Gridrunner on the VIC-20. I've bought just about every LS product since, often buying new or exotic foreign hardware (N501) just to play one game. I figure I've done my bit to support LS over the last 35ish years, and established my credentials as someone who is devoutly in their corner.
LS does great stuff in the 'reworking' space. T2K rocked. Space Giraffe rocked. The Minotaur Project stuff rocked. Llamatron rocked. No complaint, no contest.
But the best times I've had with LS products has been with the original stuff. The stuff that bends your mind and makes you re-evaluate your place in the universe. The stuff that starts hard, gets bastard harder, and then pats you on the head and says "Well done" when you finally master the controls, gameplay model, power-up ladder, KML syntax, whatever.
Atari died a long time ago, and what it is now is not the revered game/hardware power I rejoiced to play with in the 80s. It's a decaying elephant corpse with a jackal's head protruding from the arse, licking its lips and chewing at the last vestiges of flesh clinging to the bleaching bones. It is indefensible, and should be terminated and buried in the newly-excavated ET Cartridge hole in the desert. I hate what they are, what they do, and what they're doing to LS. Do not misunderstand that.
But might this be a blessing in disguise? I didn't buy TxK, or the hardware to play it on, because I couldn't get enthused about it. So maybe this is a message, that LS should decamp from the 'reworking' arena and focus on doing what they do best. What Yak does best. Creating mind-numbing, original, digital narcotics.
I'd buy 'em. Hell, I'd commit to a KS and give Yak £100 in cold hard cash today if he said LS was going to build ColourSpace 2015, or MetaLlama II, or Iridis Beta.
/Yes, that's mine, the one with the asbestos lining, thanks.
Was anyone else disappointed when they heard that the next big release was going to be TxK? I mean, just a teensy bit? Am I truly, genuinely, the only one who thought "Oh dear, another version/reworking/re-imagining of Tempest...".
Here's the thing - I've posted here since Day #1 and my record stands as a hardcore LS / Yak fan. My first game purchase was Gridrunner on the VIC-20. I've bought just about every LS product since, often buying new or exotic foreign hardware (N501) just to play one game. I figure I've done my bit to support LS over the last 35ish years, and established my credentials as someone who is devoutly in their corner.
LS does great stuff in the 'reworking' space. T2K rocked. Space Giraffe rocked. The Minotaur Project stuff rocked. Llamatron rocked. No complaint, no contest.
But the best times I've had with LS products has been with the original stuff. The stuff that bends your mind and makes you re-evaluate your place in the universe. The stuff that starts hard, gets bastard harder, and then pats you on the head and says "Well done" when you finally master the controls, gameplay model, power-up ladder, KML syntax, whatever.
Atari died a long time ago, and what it is now is not the revered game/hardware power I rejoiced to play with in the 80s. It's a decaying elephant corpse with a jackal's head protruding from the arse, licking its lips and chewing at the last vestiges of flesh clinging to the bleaching bones. It is indefensible, and should be terminated and buried in the newly-excavated ET Cartridge hole in the desert. I hate what they are, what they do, and what they're doing to LS. Do not misunderstand that.
But might this be a blessing in disguise? I didn't buy TxK, or the hardware to play it on, because I couldn't get enthused about it. So maybe this is a message, that LS should decamp from the 'reworking' arena and focus on doing what they do best. What Yak does best. Creating mind-numbing, original, digital narcotics.
I'd buy 'em. Hell, I'd commit to a KS and give Yak £100 in cold hard cash today if he said LS was going to build ColourSpace 2015, or MetaLlama II, or Iridis Beta.
/Yes, that's mine, the one with the asbestos lining, thanks.
Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary
totally ...y'know, these things happen!Governmentyard wrote:I tell you what, it'd be an awful shame if some unknown beta tester leaked the PC version as a torrent or something, wouldn't it?
Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary
There are some interesting discussions on the legal matters in the comments for this article:
http://arstechnica.com/gaming/2015/03/a ... pest-2000/
http://arstechnica.com/gaming/2015/03/a ... pest-2000/
- Deckard
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 10748
- Joined: Fri Jun 18, 2004 11:27 pm 0
- Location: Falmouth, Cornwall, UK
Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary
Fair point bud well made but sadly in this case TxK just rocked, only game I have played weekly since release and really the only game I play on my Vita - it is that good. To be honest the perfect mobile shoot em up but yeah I'm always interested in new IP.Istar wrote:Oh man, I am so going to get flamed for this...
Was anyone else disappointed when they heard that the next big release was going to be TxK? I mean, just a teensy bit? Am I truly, genuinely, the only one who thought "Oh dear, another version/reworking/re-imagining of Tempest...".
Here's the thing - I've posted here since Day #1 and my record stands as a hardcore LS / Yak fan. My first game purchase was Gridrunner on the VIC-20. I've bought just about every LS product since, often buying new or exotic foreign hardware (N501) just to play one game. I figure I've done my bit to support LS over the last 35ish years, and established my credentials as someone who is devoutly in their corner.
LS does great stuff in the 'reworking' space. T2K rocked. Space Giraffe rocked. The Minotaur Project stuff rocked. Llamatron rocked. No complaint, no contest.
But the best times I've had with LS products has been with the original stuff. The stuff that bends your mind and makes you re-evaluate your place in the universe. The stuff that starts hard, gets bastard harder, and then pats you on the head and says "Well done" when you finally master the controls, gameplay model, power-up ladder, KML syntax, whatever.
Atari died a long time ago, and what it is now is not the revered game/hardware power I rejoiced to play with in the 80s. It's a decaying elephant corpse with a jackal's head protruding from the arse, licking its lips and chewing at the last vestiges of flesh clinging to the bleaching bones. It is indefensible, and should be terminated and buried in the newly-excavated ET Cartridge hole in the desert. I hate what they are, what they do, and what they're doing to LS. Do not misunderstand that.
But might this be a blessing in disguise? I didn't buy TxK, or the hardware to play it on, because I couldn't get enthused about it. So maybe this is a message, that LS should decamp from the 'reworking' arena and focus on doing what they do best. What Yak does best. Creating mind-numbing, original, digital narcotics.
I'd buy 'em. Hell, I'd commit to a KS and give Yak £100 in cold hard cash today if he said LS was going to build ColourSpace 2015, or MetaLlama II, or Iridis Beta.
/Yes, that's mine, the one with the asbestos lining, thanks.
Now with a new Mac Mini Pro so dont judge me !
Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary
Whatever you might think about the morals of it it's not a very valid argument legally. Rights holders have the right to transfer their creations. You might as well argue you can copy all the Beatles' back catalogue because they were sold on.pete_uplink wrote:What really grinds my gears about this whole affair is this "Atari" that's saying Jeff Minter is stealing their IP aren't the Atari that existed in 1994 when Tempest 2000 was made. It's basically the reanimated corpse of Atari being controlled by greed and cashing in on the name of a once great company. At the time when Tempest 2000 was made and released "Atari" were called Infogrames in from 1983 to 1994, Hasbro Interactive in 1995 and didn't take the name Atari until 1998, and in the intervening years took out Ocean Software and Microprose. Now this company, who's only real connection to Atari is that they took the name, are telling a man who created a game that he can't make a sequel to that game because it's stealing their IP, when they had nothing to do with the creation of it.
(I'm not saying there aren't valid arguments or that TxK is a rip-off or whatever, just that this one argument doesn't work).
My opinion, for the little that it's worth, is that this one is lost without Atari agreeing to a licence, and they aren't likely to do that. Had they not done T2K, I think TxK would be in a strong position to argue enough enhancement over Tempest (although some of the graphics are probably too close for comfort). But with T2K in existence, the relative leap isn't so dramatically large, and although Jeff's previous experience with being denied the royalties on the PS version may have led him to believe this sort of thing was easy to dodge, the fact was that in both cases the big company is likely to prevail over the individual; the only way to settle this is with expensive litigation and given the relative similarities of the game - no matter how enhanced - there is no way that the outcome of that is clear and obvious. It's sad but true.
I don't think it makes sense to fight on, or rage against it publicly - this industry is too small to make enemies, and Atari's calm and collected public pronouncements, however disingenuous in places, stand in sharp contrast to the less well considered utterances of the internet - and the only thing that can be done is move on as quickly as possible.





