Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary

Support Forum: http://minotaurproject.co.uk/phpBB3/viewforum.php?f=22
Post Reply
adam
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 4418
Joined: Sat Jun 24, 2006 9:15 pm 0

Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary

Post by adam »

notch seems to be a fan - wonder if he'd help out?
User avatar
venusian
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6653
Joined: Wed Nov 06, 2002 2:22 pm 0
Location: South Gloucestershire

Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary

Post by venusian »

It's all very well saying, in twenty different ways, "fight it", but Giles has already said they don't want any sort of "fight" at all and that's a perfectly understandable and reasonable position to take. Unless "Atari" back down there's only one endpoint.

Looking forward to what comes next.
User avatar
gravy
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 19572
Joined: Wed May 01, 2002 1:28 pm 0
Location: The Other Place

Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary

Post by gravy »

Aren't we all
User avatar
Markie
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 8004
Joined: Tue Apr 23, 2002 7:30 pm 0
Location: OX ford
Contact:

Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary

Post by Markie »

gravy wrote:Aren't we all
Oh my ... really, this is really rather upsetting. Having been a Llamasoft fan for so many years to get to a day where this happens is actually quite frightening! and I can completely understand Jeff being rather shaken by it all.

Is there a fight? What can be done? Is Sony going to assist to any level? or indeed can they? Crowd funding to fund a fight? So many questions and I do feel out of my depth to comment any deeper but just to say I'm with Jeff and Giles and wishing them everything I can do in support.

Looking forward to this unfolding with a hopefully happy outcome ... I want to buy a PS4 for TxK, and hope I still will ...

Good luck guys! You have a entire army of fans behind you :-)
User avatar
Jamesac
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6677
Joined: Thu Jun 19, 2003 7:23 am 0
Location: Maine
Contact:

Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary

Post by Jamesac »

Sadly, the fight's been had. A couple lawyer letters mixed with a complete inability to talk to someone who isn't a lawyer over the last slightly-under-a-year ended up with yesterday's announcement. Here's the letter Yak posted on Twitter yesterday. If you read it, try not to let your head explode by the bullshit infusion it tries to inflict-

http://minotaurproject.co.uk/YakImages/ ... smayed.pdf

Also, I'm willing to bet a leaked torrent would cause more harm than good right now. Maybe with publicity there's still hope something might come from this. A few months of no activity, though, and the actions of bad, bad people who are bad (and should feel bad) wouldn't seem so bad.
User avatar
gravy
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 19572
Joined: Wed May 01, 2002 1:28 pm 0
Location: The Other Place

Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary

Post by gravy »

Nothings over until it's over :)
User avatar
pete_uplink
Baa!
Baa!
Posts: 73
Joined: Sat Jul 12, 2014 9:35 pm 0
Location: Manchester
Contact:

Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary

Post by pete_uplink »

Dio wrote: Whatever you might think about the morals of it it's not a very valid argument legally. Rights holders have the right to transfer their creations. You might as well argue you can copy all the Beatles' back catalogue because they were sold on.

(I'm not saying there aren't valid arguments or that TxK is a rip-off or whatever, just that this one argument doesn't work).

My opinion, for the little that it's worth, is that this one is lost without Atari agreeing to a licence, and they aren't likely to do that. Had they not done T2K, I think TxK would be in a strong position to argue enough enhancement over Tempest (although some of the graphics are probably too close for comfort). But with T2K in existence, the relative leap isn't so dramatically large, and although Jeff's previous experience with being denied the royalties on the PS version may have led him to believe this sort of thing was easy to dodge, the fact was that in both cases the big company is likely to prevail over the individual; the only way to settle this is with expensive litigation and given the relative similarities of the game - no matter how enhanced - there is no way that the outcome of that is clear and obvious. It's sad but true.

I don't think it makes sense to fight on, or rage against it publicly - this industry is too small to make enemies, and Atari's calm and collected public pronouncements, however disingenuous in places, stand in sharp contrast to the less well considered utterances of the internet - and the only thing that can be done is move on as quickly as possible.
My own personal opinion on this is that if "Atari" want to protect their IP, then they should tell Jeff that he can't use the name Tempest, or any variation on it, as it is copyrighted. However, I don't think they should be able to stop him from making a game that is similar when there are other clones out there, and they definitely shouldn't be able to tell him what to do with his own code if they had no part in the creation of it. I don't recall the creators of Super Stardust ever being threatened for ripping off Asteroids. I also don't see Id Software getting arsey with other developers for making first person shooters. I'm also not hearing anything from EA about the game Road Redemption being a clone of Road Rash (and at least Id and EA are still the original companies and not just some greedy money grabber pretending to be them)... I could go on.
Former ZX81, C64 and Amiga user. I make games.
Twitter - https://twitter.com/Peteuplink Blog: https://www.acollectionofbits.co.uk/
User avatar
phattslagg
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 3578
Joined: Fri May 14, 2004 2:04 pm 0
Location: Worcester, England

Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary

Post by phattslagg »

Their refusal to even try and work out a licensing agreement, coupled with their demand for the source code makes me very suspicious, actually. I wouldn't be at all surprised if their plan is simply to steal Jeff and Giles' work, stick an "Atari" logo on it, and resell it as theirs.
User avatar
Darkflame
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18236
Joined: Mon Mar 31, 2003 11:06 am 0
Location: Not the UK

Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary

Post by Darkflame »

No, if the money was there it seems pretty clear cut win to me.

You simply cant claim "Tempest X" wasn't similar enough to be counted as Tempest yet TxK is.
That and each individual point can be broken down and demolished as well.

Some stuff is vague and hard to argue, but as soon as your claiming stolen source or assets, that can be definitively disproved.

Not that I think we can "get the money".
But kicking up a fuss and trying to get the attention of someone that isn't a Lawyer? yes. That we can do and it might help.
- this industry is too small to make enemies,
The only enemies would be "Atari", and even then maybe only the lawyers.
User avatar
Governmentyard
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 11757
Joined: Sun Oct 31, 2004 9:41 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: GovernmentYard
Yahoo Messenger: governmentyard

Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary

Post by Governmentyard »

Why are people citing other clones that Atari haven't gone for? It's no-one's business who they do or do not choose to litigate against. There's plenty of reasons to deride Atari and plenty of reasons to stick up for Llamasoft, but pointing at some other kid and saying 'but he got away with it' serves to achieve nothing other than to make Llamasoft look like they've been caught red-handed.
XBox Gamertag: GovernmentYard
Everything else: governmentyard
User avatar
Governmentyard
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 11757
Joined: Sun Oct 31, 2004 9:41 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: GovernmentYard
Yahoo Messenger: governmentyard

Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary

Post by Governmentyard »

adam wrote:notch seems to be a fan - wonder if he'd help out?
With the amount of people nagging him to do just that on Twitter, I would imagine he's already sick of hearing about it.
XBox Gamertag: GovernmentYard
Everything else: governmentyard
User avatar
Chontler
Baaaaa!
Baaaaa!
Posts: 1540
Joined: Mon Mar 07, 2011 2:21 pm 0
Location: Conwy

Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary

Post by Chontler »

Get rid of all the levels that are tubular/tunnels - keep them planar with a nice plasma checkerboard effect. Get rid of the spaceship and REPLACE IT WITH A GIRAFFE DAMN YOU!! Call it SxG or SG3K just for the finger. And add more of the weird shit we all love.
It was always the better game anyhow. Not that it's anything like tempest, of course
User avatar
Dio
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18887
Joined: Mon May 31, 2004 1:08 pm 0
Location: Newcastle UK

Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary

Post by Dio »

pete_uplink wrote:My own personal opinion on this is that if "Atari" want to protect their IP, then they should tell Jeff that he can't use the name Tempest, or any variation on it, as it is copyrighted. However, I don't think they should be able to stop him from making a game that is similar when there are other clones out there
Different creators have different views on fan works, but most of them do require (or at least try to require) some kind of licencing (if they are noticed, and if the field doesn't have legal protection for them) and almost all of them object to other people selling them for money. We've seen similar on here a few years back with Grid Wars getting C&D'ed. Despite making innovations to the game, and not even being for profit, that wasn't enough to dodge the legal banhammer.
I also don't see Id Software getting arsey with other developers for making first person shooters.
The similarities between T2K and TxK are fairly obviously more than just the genre. Indeed, both Jeff's and Sony's publicity describe TxK as a relation of T2K, and I suspect that would be problematic should this end up in court.
User avatar
Yak
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 20266
Joined: Wed Apr 17, 2002 10:22 am 0
Location: Wales
Contact:

Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary

Post by Yak »

The game *is* substantially different though if you look at it with the eyes of someone who understands game design. The claw, for example: that stupid letter goes to great lengths to describe its shape and orientation (wrongly, in fact, for some levels) but fails to mention the glaring difference between TxK and its predecessors - in Tempest and Tempest 2000 the claw is effectively just a sprite, and always fires down the centre of its channel, whereas in TxK it's actually animated and "walks" and can shift the fire origin point between its "hands", which adds a new layer of complexity to the gameplay that simply isn't there in the older games.

If you really analyse the games then you will find that TxK is full of such differences. It's more than just Tempest 2000 at 60hz.

Their description of alleged similarities is ridiculously broad. It would be like describing a FPS saying "you're a dude. With a gun. In some rooms. Other dudes are in the rooms. They shoot at you." etc.

Anyway what makes their letter less than believable most of all is the way they deliberately seek through its language to imply that I was just a cog in a machine during the creation of Tempest 2000, and not actually its creator. That, and the stupid stuff about the soundtrack being "indistinguishable from Tempest 2000", is not only misleading but also vile and despicable.
Justified and Ancient.
User avatar
pete_uplink
Baa!
Baa!
Posts: 73
Joined: Sat Jul 12, 2014 9:35 pm 0
Location: Manchester
Contact:

Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary

Post by pete_uplink »

Dio wrote:
I also don't see Id Software getting arsey with other developers for making first person shooters.
The similarities between T2K and TxK are fairly obviously more than just the genre. Indeed, both Jeff's and Sony's publicity describe TxK as a relation of T2K, and I suspect that would be problematic should this end up in court.
Yes, but using the logic that "Atari" are using you could say Gran Turismo is the same game as Forza because you drive a car around some 3d polygon tracks against some AI drivers, you can race online, you unlock cars and it has difficulty levels and driver aids (like auto brakes, racing line and traction control) that you can turn on and off... In fact, using their logic, nobody would be able to make a racing game as they all have cars on tracks with unlockables... Geoff Crammond could be sitting pretty on a small fortune in suing every race game creator that made a game after 1992 since pretty much every racing game that was released since he made Microprose Formula 1 Grand Prix in 1992 uses game play mechanics that were first introduced in his game 24 years ago. Well, he could if we all lived by "Atari's" screwed up logic.
Last edited by pete_uplink on Thu Mar 19, 2015 4:21 pm 0, edited 3 times in total.
Former ZX81, C64 and Amiga user. I make games.
Twitter - https://twitter.com/Peteuplink Blog: https://www.acollectionofbits.co.uk/
Post Reply