Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary

Support Forum: http://minotaurproject.co.uk/phpBB3/viewforum.php?f=22
Post Reply
User avatar
fog
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6022
Joined: Sun Jan 30, 2005 1:08 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: Dense Fog
PSN: DenseFog
Location: Newcastle, England
Contact:

Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary

Post by fog »

zbandito wrote:My point is that they may share liability, from a certain perspective which may be entertained by courts. As such, it may behoove them to sometimes legally support the developers that create software for their platforms and help make their business model viable.
It's pretty standard that the developer has to sign a document declaring they have the rights to all code or media used in their project along with any trademarks, copyrights etc and they are solely responsible for any resulting legal issues.

I'm pretty sure that's why the likes of Apple and Google don't care that their stores are full of clones. They get their cut with little of the legal risks.
User avatar
zip accident
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 13928
Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 1:58 pm 0
Location: Bristol, UK

Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary

Post by zip accident »

fog wrote:They get their cut with little of the legal risks.
I'm sure their cut is downgraded (from their POV) to account for that reduced risk.
"My way is the way of not fighting":- the book of Enter the Dragon.
precious_pony
Baa!
Baa!
Posts: 90
Joined: Sat Nov 19, 2011 3:34 am 0

Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary

Post by precious_pony »

There is some drama unfolding around the new PC version of Atari's Rollercoaster Tycoon game (a Theme Park genre of game).

NOTE : Not all of these entries are in sequential order

March 19, 2014: Chris Sawyer distances himself from the franchise.

http://www.pockettactics.com/news/ios-n ... -tycoon-4/

March 25, 2014 : Hints at PC version

PCGamer (25th March, 2014) : http://www.pcgamer.com/rollercoaster-ty ... atari-say/

August 8, 2014 : Announcement of PC Version

http://www.rollercoastertycoon.com/roll ... oon-world/

With RollerCoaster Tycoon World, Atari is bringing back the incredible theme park ** experience to PC gamers and introducing a variety of thrilling new features.
** Emphasis added by myself .. not in original text.

Surely referencing the name of the the game of which you have cloned explicitly is passing off. When I think of Rollercoaster Tycoon, I think of Theme Park. It is impossible not to. Are they the same game, no. Of course not. Clones are awesome. But the #1 rule of cloning is that you don't reference the original game in your advertising or promotional material. Reviewers will do it, but you don't do it yourself.
Developed by Pipeworks, RollerCoaster Tycoon World will be released as a full premium PC experience, giving fans the ability to enjoy a micro-transaction free amusement park.
I have a lot of respect for pipeworks actually in actually trying to forgo micro-transactions.

September 14, 2014 : Teaser video

http://www.polygon.com/2014/8/14/600353 ... d-pc-atari

November 18, 2014 : Pipeworks (developer of RCTW) sold to Digital Bros

http://www.gpbullhound.com/news/gp-bull ... pipeworks/

December 11, 2014 : Area 52 Games takes over project

http://www.rollercoastertycoon.com/upda ... oon-world/

March 5, 2015 : Trailer released for RCTW

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nzgAhPffWsM

Criticism of graphics, 5th March 2015

Some commentators were concerned that the graphics for the title looked slightly dated.

20 March, 2015: Damage Control

PCGamer (20th Match ,2015) : http://www.pcgamer.com/atari-addresses- ... -concerns/
IGN (21st March, 2015): http://uk.ign.com/articles/2015/03/21/r ... to-unity-5
Polygon (21st March, 2015) : http://www.polygon.com/2015/3/21/827051 ... r-gameplay

Executive Producer "Mattlab" responded with a blog post:
Regarding the current state of game graphics, we have been exploring prototypes for a while and are happy to announce we will be upgrading to the Unity 5 Engine. We hope to be able to share the results of the upgrade by this summer. We hope to take full advantage of the many new environmental, lighting, and shadow improvements as well as many other features in our original Unity 4.6-based engine to create a game that looks great. Our early results are extremely promising. We know that today these words must ring hollow, but trust that we are doing everything we can to make the game look excellent.
"Everything we can"
"New Engine"
"New Effects"

None of which promise that work is being done on producing higher quality assets. But perhaps they are. I should stress here that low poly models are not indicitive of a game that is not fun. The game could still be awesome .. but out of the entirety of the above paragraph "all we can" speaks loudest.

Anyway - nothing to see here, move along. Development is underway, everything will be fine ......

12 March, 2015 : Pipeworks, Inc. et al v. RCTO Productions, L.L.C. et al, one week after trailer, 8 days before engine upgrade announcement

This legal filing is against RCTO Productions, L.L.C. and Atari Interactive, Inc.

http://dockets.justia.com/docket/new-yo ... 901/439734

The plaintiffs in the case are Pipeworks, Inc. and Digital Bros. S.p.A. "Pipeworks" which were developers on the project until late last year.
Nature of Suit: Other Contract
The cause of action is "28:1332".

http://forms.lp.findlaw.com/form/courtf ... 000010.pdf

The new Roller Coaster Tycoon's holding company seems to be registered in Delaware (an excellent place to incorporate a company).

http://www.bizapedia.com/de/RCTO-PRODUCTIONS-LLC.html

In summary

I don't know what happened to create the handover but any 3rd party finger pointing should wait until we hear the circumstances of the break up. It may be simply a factor of the original budget.

Whatever happened, it seems that Area 52 Games was a good choice to take over the project, but I have a feeling that Area 52 are a "build your own engine" type of studio, which may lead to some issues in handing over the project. I think if they are given enough time and resources, then good things can only come of it. Their pedigree is impeccable. Their blog posts suggest that they know what they are doing. To my knowledge the pipeworks filing hasn't been reported in the media yet, and I don't have a clue as to where Digital Bros. S.p.A. fits into things. It will be interesting to watch this story unfold.
User avatar
oddbob0
Baaaaa!
Baaaaa!
Posts: 1727
Joined: Mon Mar 01, 2004 7:43 pm 0
Location: Liverpool

Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary

Post by oddbob0 »

zbandito wrote:Where's Sony in all of this, with their own army of lawyers, paid in part by royalties from games like Tempest X and TxK?

Seems like an easy opportunity for them to earn some goodwill here, and if anyone is on the hook to get involved it is Sony.
Well. Supporting Jeff where they can, mainly. At least, that's been my experience working with the same folks.

But this isn't the sort of thing that gets solved by wading in guns blazing regardless, there's always the potential for things to be made worse and no-one wants that. And of course, even if they did get involved, you can't just walk over to Atari and say "leave it" or "here's a few mil, give us Tempest and sling your hook"

Which is to say that if anyone from a big megacorp went to bat for Jeff, it's all need to be done way more delicately. But it's also, sadly, worth remembering that Sony is many arms and the will of one arm is not necessarily the will of another and that even in fairly straightforward cases where the evidence is totally stacked against the aggressor (see EA vs Langdell), these things have a big habit of dragging out for a long time because people -can- drag it out for a long time. It's all pretty fucking messy which is obv. why Atari go about things the way they do. That's the whole point.

All that said, yeah, of course it'd be nice and I'd like to see it but I just wanted to jump in and say that Jeff has -a lot- of support from a faceless megacorp and that's how TxK got to exist in the first place etc... but this isn't the kind of thing Sony could just wade into easily and go and fix everything.
\m/
User avatar
gravy
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 19572
Joined: Wed May 01, 2002 1:28 pm 0
Location: The Other Place

Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary

Post by gravy »

precious_pony wrote: 12 March, 2015 : Pipeworks, Inc. et al v. RCTO Productions, L.L.C. et al, one week after trailer, 8 days before engine upgrade announcement

This legal filing is against RCTO Productions, L.L.C. and Atari Interactive, Inc.

http://dockets.justia.com/docket/new-yo ... 901/439734

The plaintiffs in the case are Pipeworks, Inc. and Digital Bros. S.p.A. "Pipeworks" which were developers on the project until late last year.
Nature of Suit: Other Contract
Hey cheers for that, the case is self dismissed now. I checked on PACER and the details were redacted due to commercial sensitivity but with an order to file an unredacted version by 30th March or a full explanation for the redaction. The case was withdrawn voluntarily a few days later.
User avatar
The Gardner
Baaa!
Baaa!
Posts: 117
Joined: Mon Aug 17, 2009 6:34 am 0

Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary

Post by The Gardner »

I realize that this is easy for me to say, I'm not taking the risks, but it really seems to me like llamasoft would be best off just calling 'Atari's bluff, and releasing TxK. Most of their claims are for things that just plain aren't copyrightable, and so should be thrown out of court immediately. The few actual copyright claims they made are pretty easily dis-proven. I think Atari is just blowing smoke. Heck, if they sue in the UK, doesn't it fall under the "English Rule" where the loser pays the court costs?

I might consider changing the ship shape, just because that is fairly recognizable, but that could also be taken as an "admission of guilt," and the TxK ship is obviously not a "stolen art asset" so it doesn't really fall under copyright, I don't think.

On the other hand, IANAL.
User avatar
KlaxonCow
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 8447
Joined: Fri Dec 13, 2002 3:46 am 0
Location: A large grassy field.

Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary

Post by KlaxonCow »

But something else to consider is the "moral hazard" implicit in fighting this.

The lawyers invent some bullshit. Both sides - Llamasoft AND "Atari" - have no doubt had to pay a few grand each, just to barely communicate with each other, poorly, even before any proper legal proceedings begin in earnest. If it does go to court, then they're paying the lawyers even more. In court, even with the claims that are easily dismissed, they're going to stretch it out and keep this running as long as is possible. All the time, both sides are just haemorrhaging cash into their lawyer's pockets.

It is, in fact, perfectly standard corporate practice - an entire common strategy - to simply win by attrition. Your claims don't have to be right. Your claims don't even have to make any sense whatsoever. You just have to keep ramping up the costs, by dragging it out indefinitely, until the one side is forced to concede - forced to fold - regardless of whether it's right or just to do so, regardless of the moral and legal hand they're holding, just because it's all become far too rich for their blood and continuation would be an existential threat to one's finances.

But, notice, all through this, there's one variable here that just keeps increasing. The lawyer's fees.

They win, they lose - what do they care? It profits them greatly either way. The majority of their lengthy list of claims is utter bullshit that surely will collapse in court? What do they care? They profit more, the longer the trial pointlessly drones on.

This is the "moral hazard" I speak of. The lawyers have already nicely profited here, just from making the threats. They'll make even more of a mint if this proceeds to court, as they drain both sides of cash, by stretching it out for as long as they're legally able to do so.

If "Atari" wins, then they will have succeeded in preventing Llamasoft from releasing the TxK ports.

But, really, what the fuck for?

"Atari" don't gain or lose anything by the fact that Llamasoft are selling TxK. It would be different if they had any intention of creating their own Tempest game, if their own Tempest game was already out there and was being harmed in its sales by having the competition of a superior "TxK" undermining it. But "Atari" doesn't have a Tempest game, "Atari" is showing no signs of wanting to develop any Tempest games in the window in which TxK is on sale, "Atari" doesn't even really make games anymore - they, apparently, are all about those "gay social casinos" these days, by their own comical admission.

If "Llamasoft" wins, then what has all that struggle and heartache and threat of financial ruin been for?

Simply the ability to carry on normally. "Business as usual". To do the shit that they were intending to do anyway, before this nonsense appeared on their doorstep.

But, regardless of the outcome, the parties who always win are the lawyers. They win, they profit. They lose, they profit. The action doesn't proceed, they've already profited.

There's no disincentive here for the lawyers. This is the "moral hazard". Whatever happens here, you can be sure that they'll be urging "Atari" to continue with more and more "IP trolling". They'll urge to "Atari": "you need to stop these guys, and these guys and these guys over here". But, really, why?

"Atari" have no Tempest game on offer. "Atari" has no fucking games on offer. "Atari" has even cancelled the trademark on Tempest 2K.

The trick here is in realising that "Atari" are also a victim in all of this too. They're losing money to the lawyers too, in order to prosecute actions that really don't serve their business interests in any way whatsoever.

Sure, they might win compensation if they win. But look at the claims being offered up by the lawyers - half this shit is entirely demonstrable as utter bullshit from the off. The rest of it is highly dubious. Particularly because there are precedents from higher courts that you really can't claim ownership of mere gameplay mechanics. You, indeed, quite rightly, can't claim ownership of the concept of "jumping" because that's absurdly silly, and even all the lawyers collectively couldn't manage to argue their way around that bit of tangible reality and logic.

It is, indeed, very "half and half" whether any of these claims have any legal merit whatsoever. Certainly, a whole bunch of them absolutely do not and will never stand up (the claims on the soundtrack are beyond bogus, they're just plain absurd).

There's no guarantee that "Atari" will get anywhere with this dodgy bunch of nonsense.

But, as always, I draw your attention to the fact that it is entirely 100% guaranteed that the lawyers profit either way. And they'll do it again, and again, and again. They'll do it until they destroy "Atari". These are not parasites who have to worry greatly about observing the principle of not killing off their host. Because they'll just jump hosts and they prey on some other victim instead.

So, arguably, the logical thing to do here is just comply. Let "Atari" have their way and the TxK ports don't happen. Don't give these lawyers their pound of flesh. Concede and they profit least. Maybe if this happens enough, the lawyers might reconsider their strategies when it turns out that launching spurious legal actions at folks doesn't actually result in the vast fortunes they were hoping for. If this happens enough times in succession, maybe - just maybe - it might dawn on "Atari" that "wait a minute, why are we paying these lawyers all this money, when we've not actually materially benefited from any of it at any point?".

The enemy here is not "Atari". They're fellow victims of the true enemy, which is all these lawyers, inventing a profitable existence for themselves out of absolutely nowhere, on the basis of sheer nonsense. And the dangerous, dangerous "moral hazard" that all of this has created over time, to the point where the entire planet is litigation happy and everyone's suing everyone in all directions - and guess who's the party that never ever loses from all of this perpetually going on? The lawyers.

Strange game.

The only way to win is not to play.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
User avatar
skip
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 2455
Joined: Mon Sep 02, 2002 1:23 pm 0
Yahoo Messenger: oz_skip
Location: Adelaide, South Australia

Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary

Post by skip »

User avatar
fog
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6022
Joined: Sun Jan 30, 2005 1:08 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: Dense Fog
PSN: DenseFog
Location: Newcastle, England
Contact:

Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary

Post by fog »

Indeed. The accusations in the Atari letter almost look like they were copied directly from the recent Yeti Town case that 6Waves lost.

The main points they lost on:
- Name inspired by original game.
- Accusations of access to original game code.
- Bloggers pointing out similarities goes against the defendant.
- The court did not consider any differences between the games (new features, improvements), only the similarities.
User avatar
Jamesac
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6677
Joined: Thu Jun 19, 2003 7:23 am 0
Location: Maine
Contact:

Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary

Post by Jamesac »

Just because the law is so insanely complicated that it'd be crazy to go it alone doesn't mean it's the fault of the people who studied for years to be able to practice it that they're in high demand. Sure, win or lose, lawyers will get paid. Time is valuable and their work is hard, and that's what the money is for. It's Atari and the companies bleeding the defendant dry by endless tactics designed to drive the cost of defense up that are wearing the black hats here.
User avatar
zip accident
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 13928
Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 1:58 pm 0
Location: Bristol, UK

Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary

Post by zip accident »

This reminds me of the Apple computers claim all GUIs case. Atari (the Tramiel Atari) said sue us, Microsoft said sue us, Commodore said sue us, Digital Research makers of GEM said, please we don't have any money, we'll stop making GEM. Eventually it came to court and Microsoft won, because in this case they were in the right.
"My way is the way of not fighting":- the book of Enter the Dragon.
User avatar
KlaxonCow
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 8447
Joined: Fri Dec 13, 2002 3:46 am 0
Location: A large grassy field.

Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary

Post by KlaxonCow »

Jamesac wrote:Sure, win or lose, lawyers will get paid.
And you see absolutely no "moral hazard" to be implicit in this state of affairs?

Without consequence, what is the self-correcting force here? Is there any such force? Because there most certainly needs to be. We're dealing with ordinary human lives and abuse of power, no less. The stakes could be no more dire than this.

Their conscience? But we know perfectly well that there exists a class of human beings out there for which this is no impediment at all. Sociopaths, for whom empathy is entirely optional. There are no tests nor barriers to prevent their entry into the profession, so surely some must number amongst them?

I ask the most ancient known political question of them all.

Quis Custodiet Ipsos Custodes?
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
User avatar
Jamesac
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6677
Joined: Thu Jun 19, 2003 7:23 am 0
Location: Maine
Contact:

Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary

Post by Jamesac »

The law! The point of lawyers is to have someone to help you navigate the law. You don't understand it well enough and neither do I to take it on by ourselves. That's what a lawyer is for. The misuse of the law by large corporations is a serious issue, but I'm supposed to see lawyers as evil money-grubbing bastards because hiring one costs money? Put the blame where it belongs, on corporations misusing and abusing legal tactics to wear down people without the money for a proper defense, rather than being pissed that the defense isn't free.
User avatar
Little stoned kiwi
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 4598
Joined: Mon Oct 27, 2003 6:05 am 0
Location: Christchurch

Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary

Post by Little stoned kiwi »

I don't know about this level of legal action, but is there any way to cut defense costs? It's possible to hire legal advice without having a lawyer present all the time. A lot of court time is just routine process where lawyers get paid to sit and do nothing.
It still costs, but would cost Atari even more. Dragging out the process makes it even costlier for them.
User avatar
Dio
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18887
Joined: Mon May 31, 2004 1:08 pm 0
Location: Newcastle UK

Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary

Post by Dio »

Little stoned kiwi wrote:I don't know about this level of legal action, but is there any way to cut defense costs? It's possible to hire legal advice without having a lawyer present all the time. A lot of court time is just routine process where lawyers get paid to sit and do nothing.
It still costs, but would cost Atari even more. Dragging out the process makes it even costlier for them.
Given that one could end up paying that cost if one loses, and this is not obviously a trivially winnable case (that's not to say it's a definite loser, just that in a few respects Atari's claim does look well founded) that's a rather high risk strategy.
Post Reply