So, what you're saying is that the only instrument of our defence - the law - can only be sensibly wielded by these self-appointed "overseers", as it is out of reach for anyone else by its sheer complexity?Jamesac wrote:The law! The point of lawyers is to have someone to help you navigate the law. You don't understand it well enough and neither do I to take it on by ourselves. That's what a lawyer is for.
Pleading the necessity of lawyers - and, without doubt, they certainly are entirely necessary - hardly helps your case here.
That makes it worse, not better. What you're implicitly saying is that we ordinary mortal beings can't even be entirely sure, thanks to that over-complication and complexity of law, whether, in fact, our self-proclaimed "noble overseers of the law" are even abusing their power or not. It's far too subtle and obscure for the likes of us.
(And you're over-reacting to the accusation actually being made. Earlier in this thread, I mentioned the possible interest and assistance of the Electronic Frontier Foundation, perhaps. And I entirely meant it in terms of their expert lawyers and legal expertise. Hardly the "all lawyers are bad guys" straw man you're accusing me of, when I was actually amongst the first to make a potential recommendation of a bunch of lawyers, on the strength that they are "the good guys".
The fundamental difference, of course, is that the EFF is funded by donations. Their lawyers are paid independently of court proceedings, so there isn't quite the implicit "conflict of interest" - the "moral hazard" - that I was speaking of, with these guys.)
Understand what I am saying and what I'm not saying. I return to that fundamental point.
There is a potential "moral hazard" - an implicit conflict of interest - here, due to how lawyers must, of course, be necessarily paid. Do you disagree with that assertion? If so, explain how exactly, so I can follow your reasoning.
And, if that potential for corruption exists, then what pragmatic mechanisms exist for self-correction or for society to correct such abuse?
You surely see the circular logic in claiming that our defence from lawyers is the law, in the same breath as saying that the only qualified people to wield that defence is the lawyers themselves?







