... minus inflation...pogo wrote:If the budget balances then the surplus run in boom years should match the deficit run in slowdowns
Politics Thread!
Re: Politics Thread!
Re: Politics Thread!
To be clear the "golden rule" did not rule out didn't rule out running a deficit but prohibited borrowing to run the public sector. Borrowing to invest was and running a deficit was fine.
It's pretty sensible but that said Labour couldn't do it. Osborne's proposing something even harder to achieve, something no UK government has ever managed, where the only lever you can pull would be cutting the states responsibilities and obligations.
And all based on the insane idea that annual measurement of deficit is the way you'd make those decisions.
It's cobblers, he knows it's cobblers and the only sensible conclusion to draw here is it's an ideological tool to to move towards smaller government.
It's pretty sensible but that said Labour couldn't do it. Osborne's proposing something even harder to achieve, something no UK government has ever managed, where the only lever you can pull would be cutting the states responsibilities and obligations.
And all based on the insane idea that annual measurement of deficit is the way you'd make those decisions.
It's cobblers, he knows it's cobblers and the only sensible conclusion to draw here is it's an ideological tool to to move towards smaller government.
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: Politics Thread!
Not generally. It might seem like it now, as with near zero interest rates either growth or inflation will make debt reduce as a % of GDP. I think this is visible in the government’s projections for 2018-19: debt is projected to start falling before the budget is in balance. So in theory the government could run a permanent, if small, deficit and still see debt fall as a % of GDP.Dio wrote:... minus inflation...
But normally interest rates are much higher. One popular model puts the natural rate at inflation + rate of GDP growth*, which was where it was before the crisis, or a little higher, at around 5%. At such a level debt grows as fast or faster than inflation + GDP growth is able to reduce it. So real surpluses are needed to reduce it, or the budget still needs to balance over the economic cycle, to keep debt in check.
(* the model is based on the theory that in normal times interest rates need to be high enough to match the growth rate of investments in firms, which should average GDP growth + inflation. Higher or lower and too little or too much investment takes place)
Re: Politics Thread!
Basic mathematics:
- interest payments are included in the budget
- any changes in interest rates change the budget, not the actual size of the debt
- inflation therefore reduces the value of the debt in real terms
In case that's not obvious enough, consider if the budget is balanced, so the number value of the debt is constant. It's financial value is then reducing year on year.
Should be simple to see, if you've had a mortgage; blindingly so, if you've seen the figures for people who took out mortgages in the 70s or early 80s.
- interest payments are included in the budget
- any changes in interest rates change the budget, not the actual size of the debt
- inflation therefore reduces the value of the debt in real terms
In case that's not obvious enough, consider if the budget is balanced, so the number value of the debt is constant. It's financial value is then reducing year on year.
Should be simple to see, if you've had a mortgage; blindingly so, if you've seen the figures for people who took out mortgages in the 70s or early 80s.
Re: Politics Thread!
Vote for my new political party.
Once we get into power, we're going to introduce an "everything the government does is awesome!" law to ensure that we're legally obliged never to get anything wrong, ever.
And to remind us of this pledge, we're going to tattoo it on the Prime Minister's face in big letters, give everyone a 92 page booklet so they can hold us to our bullshit when we fail to deliver, and erect a 90 foot phallus in the garden of Downing Street with "Be awesome at all times!" engraved down its shaft in massive lettering.
(Because, apparently, we're so forgetful of our election promises and manifesto commitments, two seconds after obtaining power, we require quite ridiculously over-the-top methods of jogging our memory and lack sufficient self-discipline to, you know, just do as we said we were going to do, that we actually have to make it no less than illegal for us to cock it up. Not that, of course, anyone would ever actually get arrested, fined, lose their job or be incarcerated, you understand. It's a symbolic gesture. Also known as "a colossal waste of everybody's time".)
This, apparently, is all supposed to make you have immense confidence in the competence and integrity of your government. Somehow.
Once we get into power, we're going to introduce an "everything the government does is awesome!" law to ensure that we're legally obliged never to get anything wrong, ever.
And to remind us of this pledge, we're going to tattoo it on the Prime Minister's face in big letters, give everyone a 92 page booklet so they can hold us to our bullshit when we fail to deliver, and erect a 90 foot phallus in the garden of Downing Street with "Be awesome at all times!" engraved down its shaft in massive lettering.
(Because, apparently, we're so forgetful of our election promises and manifesto commitments, two seconds after obtaining power, we require quite ridiculously over-the-top methods of jogging our memory and lack sufficient self-discipline to, you know, just do as we said we were going to do, that we actually have to make it no less than illegal for us to cock it up. Not that, of course, anyone would ever actually get arrested, fined, lose their job or be incarcerated, you understand. It's a symbolic gesture. Also known as "a colossal waste of everybody's time".)
This, apparently, is all supposed to make you have immense confidence in the competence and integrity of your government. Somehow.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
- John Maynard Keynes
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: Politics Thread!
You’re right: if interest payments are included in the budget then the budget being in balance means debt interest is paid, which reduces the real value of the debt. What I was describing is achieving primary balance, excluding interest payments, which is what much of Europe is concerned with: Greece e.g. has a primary surplus, so in theory should be able to slowly reduce its debt.Dio wrote:Basic mathematics:
- interest payments are included in the budget
The comparison with the 1970s though is interesting. Back then when we had double digit inflation debt was quickly eroded by inflation. But with inflation near or at zero that is simply not happening; even when inflation recovers it would take a very long time to significantly reduce the value of debt, without surpluses.
The other reason it’s interesting is surpluses were common then. In fact we had them every year between 1947 and 1974. So it’s hardly a Dickensian fantasy to want to run surpluses again, it’s harking back to a much more recent time.
- VNVObit
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 4072
- Joined: Sun Jan 01, 2006 10:03 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: vnvobit
- PSN: VNV_Obit
- Location: London
Re: Politics Thread!
if a "Primary Surplus" is less than gross interest payments then debt will go up. So you still need a Net Surplus after Interest if you want to reduce debt.pogo wrote:You’re right: if interest payments are included in the budget then the budget being in balance means debt interest is paid, which reduces the real value of the debt. What I was describing is achieving primary balance, excluding interest payments, which is what much of Europe is concerned with: Greece e.g. has a primary surplus, so in theory should be able to slowly reduce its debt.Dio wrote:Basic mathematics:
- interest payments are included in the budget
The comparison with the 1970s though is interesting. Back then when we had double digit inflation debt was quickly eroded by inflation. But with inflation near or at zero that is simply not happening; even when inflation recovers it would take a very long time to significantly reduce the value of debt, without surpluses.
The other reason it’s interesting is surpluses were common then. In fact we had them every year between 1947 and 1974. So it’s hardly a Dickensian fantasy to want to run surpluses again, it’s harking back to a much more recent time.
if inflation rises to 1% debt falls by 1% then compounds the following year so in real terms does fall, not dramatically, but still falls. That's why businesses borrow rather than wait to save money up before investing. Debt has a lower cost of capital than equity consequently it will be cheaper in the long run to use debt for investments (by that I mean something that will generate a positive cashflow subsequent to the spend)
As for Osborne's Budgetary surplus after investment, well he can achieve that through "off balance sheet financing" through leases, PFI, adding to benefits bill. He's already doing this in affordable housing with reduction of grant and increased HB bill (even for working families!!!).
"England is funny, but sometimes she scares me"
Tony Wakeford
My avatar is the cover of Tower of Babel's first single
"Sky is not roof, Earth is not bottom, the world is not yours, you are the world's" from Brown by Grotus
Tony Wakeford
My avatar is the cover of Tower of Babel's first single
"Sky is not roof, Earth is not bottom, the world is not yours, you are the world's" from Brown by Grotus
Re: Politics Thread!
Good artilce by Toynbee
http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfre ... p-nonsense
I'd missed George's "in normal times" caveat.
Pogo, do you honestly view this as a sensible economic approach rather than a political move?
http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfre ... p-nonsense
I'd missed George's "in normal times" caveat.
Pogo, do you honestly view this as a sensible economic approach rather than a political move?
- VNVObit
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 4072
- Joined: Sun Jan 01, 2006 10:03 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: vnvobit
- PSN: VNV_Obit
- Location: London
Re: Politics Thread!
"normal times" weasel words so he isn't trapped by it. Sadly unlikely to get an honest discussion about state finances from any politician.
Osborne's now blaming labour for the loss he's proposing to take on RBS shares (that's not to say what he's aiming to get for them is undervalued , I honestly don't know that) as if it would have all been different had he been at the helm instead of Alaistair or Gordon.
Osborne's now blaming labour for the loss he's proposing to take on RBS shares (that's not to say what he's aiming to get for them is undervalued , I honestly don't know that) as if it would have all been different had he been at the helm instead of Alaistair or Gordon.
"England is funny, but sometimes she scares me"
Tony Wakeford
My avatar is the cover of Tower of Babel's first single
"Sky is not roof, Earth is not bottom, the world is not yours, you are the world's" from Brown by Grotus
Tony Wakeford
My avatar is the cover of Tower of Babel's first single
"Sky is not roof, Earth is not bottom, the world is not yours, you are the world's" from Brown by Grotus
Re: Politics Thread!
The share sell off is amazing, part of the justification is the report he asked Rothschild to complete.
Company that makes money selling shares recommends the government sells a load of shares shocka!
Equally amazing that the general public will not be allowed to invest initially, it's only going to be institutions. Osborne's said the hope is reduced government influence signalled by the sale will raise the banks value on the markets.
That's quite something. "The bank you paid for? We're selling it a loss but don't worry the share price will rise. Except you'll only be buy shares once all of that's done!"
Company that makes money selling shares recommends the government sells a load of shares shocka!
Equally amazing that the general public will not be allowed to invest initially, it's only going to be institutions. Osborne's said the hope is reduced government influence signalled by the sale will raise the banks value on the markets.
That's quite something. "The bank you paid for? We're selling it a loss but don't worry the share price will rise. Except you'll only be buy shares once all of that's done!"
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: Politics Thread!
It’s a political move yes. It’s saying they intend to stick to a balanced budget, and are daring Labour to stick to one too. It won’t in practice constrain any government from any policy. But it will require them to be upfront about it. They will have to if they want to borrow more modify the law, or the rules governing it.gravy wrote:Good artilce by Toynbee
http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfre ... p-nonsense
I'd missed George's "in normal times" caveat.
Pogo, do you honestly view this as a sensible economic approach rather than a political move?
Essentially it stops Labour doing again what Blair and Brown did, saying one thing and doing another. And as such I think it’s a good thing, for politics, if politicians are expected to be honest about their spending and taxation plans. Of course it’s only attractive to Cameron and Osbourne because of Labour’s dishonesty, both over their record pre-2010 and in their 2015 manifesto. Which means it’s an easy challenge for Labour to answer: elect a leader that’s prepared to face up to Labour’s record, and to the problems facing Britain, and then prepared to explain what they will do about them and how they will pay for them.
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: Politics Thread!
I haven’t noticed him blaming Labour for this: it’s really not a political issue, or shouldn’t be. Nor should it be an issue whether they make a profit or loss (seems they are making a loss on RBS but overall come out ahead considering the whole bailout). The bank bailout is something that needed to be done. It does remind me of something that gravy wrote earlier though:VNVObit wrote:Osborne's now blaming labour for the loss he's proposing to take on RBS shares (that's not to say what he's aiming to get for them is undervalued , I honestly don't know that) as if it would have all been different had he been at the helm instead of Alaistair or Gordon.
In a sense the bank bailout was borrowing to invest, in that the government will get back what it spent plus a little bit more. Which is what most people think of as investment: you borrow e.g. to invest in shares. Or a firm borrows to invest in expansion. In each case you hope to get back your money, when you sell the shares, or in growth and profit if you are a firm.gravy wrote:To be clear the "golden rule" did not rule out didn't rule out running a deficit but prohibited borrowing to run the public sector. Borrowing to invest was and running a deficit was fine.
But government ‘investment’ is very different. It’s on things like roads, schools, hospitals which do not make any money, they are just the normal things governments need to spend money on. As such it’s misleading to treat it differently from other sorts of borrowing. But this is exactly what the last Labour government did, shifting borrowing for off the balance sheet using PFI, then manipulating the books to ensure it stayed there.
Treasury 'manipulating' PFI books
Even worse treating it differently has a distorting effect, as if you tell people their normal spending is limited but their borrowing is not they will borrow more. If you tell them they can borrow but only for some things, such as shiny new hospitals, then we see lots of shiny new hospitals, even if keeping and fixing up ones would be cheaper and better.
- zip accident
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 13928
- Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 1:58 pm 0
- Location: Bristol, UK
Re: Politics Thread!
You keep not understanding that when shiny new things are bought, somebody is selling, and making a big profit. Sellers like making big profits. Big profits are where the Tory party and Nu Labour is at.pogo wrote:If you tell them they can borrow but only for some things, such as shiny new hospitals, then we see lots of shiny new hospitals, even if keeping and fixing up ones would be cheaper and better.
The reason for austerity, is that there are big profits to be made from it. That's the why of Austerity, it's got nothing to do with lack of money in the economy.
"My way is the way of not fighting":- the book of Enter the Dragon.
- VNVObit
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 4072
- Joined: Sun Jan 01, 2006 10:03 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: vnvobit
- PSN: VNV_Obit
- Location: London
Re: Politics Thread!
Guardian article on mansion house speechOsborne wrote:Yes, we may get a lower price than Labour paid for it. But the longer we wait, the higher the price the whole economy will pay,”
"England is funny, but sometimes she scares me"
Tony Wakeford
My avatar is the cover of Tower of Babel's first single
"Sky is not roof, Earth is not bottom, the world is not yours, you are the world's" from Brown by Grotus
Tony Wakeford
My avatar is the cover of Tower of Babel's first single
"Sky is not roof, Earth is not bottom, the world is not yours, you are the world's" from Brown by Grotus
Re: Politics Thread!
You bemoan our education in another thread and flag that as a factor for the UK's terrible productivity and now start claiming that shcools don't make money.pogo wrote:But government ‘investment’ is very different. It’s on things like roads, schools, hospitals which do not make any money, they are just the normal things governments need to spend money on.
It's classic investment; pay money now for a great return later. You think Osborne's plan to hobble the state encacting and admistering projects of long term benefit is a good thing and that's insane.
If I buy faster PCs for our business they don't 'make money' but they have a positive commercial effect
