But New Labour were supposed to be different. An end to boom and bust. Gordon Brown’s “Golden Rule”. BoE independence. No more lowering rates and running up debts for a pre-election boost, only for a recession to arrive after as the bills arrive. Essentially it’s their own rhetoric that tripped them up. It doesn’t excuse them that previous governments also ran deficits.Claim One When will you apologise for running a structural deficit even before the recession the recession?
Fact one, apologise for what for being a deficit denier? Structural deficits, budget deficits and government borrowings PSNB have occurred in nearly every year since records began. The fact is very rarely have we had surpluses - OBR page 104.
If they had instead made the case for higher spending, including higher taxes, then they might have had more success in 2010. Or even if they had lost it would have left them in a much better position to argue their case since.








