The Dr Who thread
- Harlequin
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 6505
- Joined: Wed Jun 05, 2002 4:19 am 0
- Location: London, directly above the centre of the Earth.
Re: The Dr Who thread
We saw River Song physically die in 2008. Even though her spirit/mental self lived on in the Library, that will also eventually cease to function. She was a time traveller, though, and we're following the adventures of time travellers (their non-linear intersections being one of the major points of her character). That written, she did also hint at a further secret in The Name of the Doctor.
While no one need to be permanently dead in much SF or fantasy (and I maintain that DW has always been far more the latter than the former), I gather that George R R Martin is notorious for refusing to resurrect characters.
While no one need to be permanently dead in much SF or fantasy (and I maintain that DW has always been far more the latter than the former), I gather that George R R Martin is notorious for refusing to resurrect characters.
Emoticon and contraction free since... quite a while ago.
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: The Dr Who thread
Dead characters staying dead is the norm even in fantasy. Sometimes resurrection is exceptional and has special significance, but it’s rarely commonplace. GRRM only gets a bad rep as he’s fond of killing off characters, but he has so many it would be quite a challenge keeping them all around for whatever ending he might eventually write.
With time travel though it’s trivially easy to kill someone, then unkill them again. Go back in time and kill them, or their parents. Then go back in time even further and do something to protect them such as hide them. This shows how time travel is impossible nonsense of course, but then it means any show including it can pretty much do as they like.
Doctor Who gets around this by having a policy of non-intervention in history. He then goes and intervenes, again and again. So they introduced the idea of unavoidable events, or fixed points in time. Which he of course finds a way around. Or they just separate him from the TARDIS, so he has to use something other than time travel to get out of trouble.
With time travel though it’s trivially easy to kill someone, then unkill them again. Go back in time and kill them, or their parents. Then go back in time even further and do something to protect them such as hide them. This shows how time travel is impossible nonsense of course, but then it means any show including it can pretty much do as they like.
Doctor Who gets around this by having a policy of non-intervention in history. He then goes and intervenes, again and again. So they introduced the idea of unavoidable events, or fixed points in time. Which he of course finds a way around. Or they just separate him from the TARDIS, so he has to use something other than time travel to get out of trouble.
Re: The Dr Who thread
Well, it depends on how you look at it. Doctor Who has (mostly) had a strong theory of time travel basically defined by the needs of dramatic consistency.
The set of rules I've found to describe it are:
- there are many 'tracks' of time on which time proceeds in a mostly linear manner
- On removing himself from a track, he can return to the point at which he left or an arbitrary amount of time in the future reasonably easily
- it is hard to move within a time track.
- the Doctor's appearance within a timeline creates a fork in the track. These forks are localised and the time stream merges forks further down the line (at fixed points in time, or whatever). This is the most important rule: travelling into the past can't effectively and predictably affect the future.
It's a good set of rules for drama. It prevents Bill-and-Tedding, and it allows for the linearities of time that we see (i.e. current day Earth is current day Earth). The last rule, as well as keeping the drama intact, also allows endless space for self-contradiction: we're simply on a different fork.
The set of rules I've found to describe it are:
- there are many 'tracks' of time on which time proceeds in a mostly linear manner
- On removing himself from a track, he can return to the point at which he left or an arbitrary amount of time in the future reasonably easily
- it is hard to move within a time track.
- the Doctor's appearance within a timeline creates a fork in the track. These forks are localised and the time stream merges forks further down the line (at fixed points in time, or whatever). This is the most important rule: travelling into the past can't effectively and predictably affect the future.
It's a good set of rules for drama. It prevents Bill-and-Tedding, and it allows for the linearities of time that we see (i.e. current day Earth is current day Earth). The last rule, as well as keeping the drama intact, also allows endless space for self-contradiction: we're simply on a different fork.
- Harlequin
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 6505
- Joined: Wed Jun 05, 2002 4:19 am 0
- Location: London, directly above the centre of the Earth.
Re: The Dr Who thread
I doubt that anyone involved in the writing and production of DW thinks in terms of those rules, although they may follow them intuitively. There have also been more explicit rules such as not being able to interfere with one's own direct past without creating reality-destroying paradoxes. The forking idea seems to emerge from the fact that, aside from a self-absorbed spell in the eighties, nothing has never been canonical in the series beyond what has been viewed up to about a year or so before the currently airing episode.
I think it has been established (as much as anything is) that the Doctor's actions can effectively, although not necessarily predictably, affect the future up to at least 700 years in The Ark and a century in Bad Wolf. Even over a shorter period, in the first Tennant season he apparently destroyed Britain's upcoming Golden Age by removing Harriet Jones from power, creating a hole subsequently filled by the Master.
Aside from rebooting the universe, I think Moffat was clever in establishing "the Doctor lies" as a primary rule. It implies that many statements made in the past were simply untrue, from the people the Doctor said he had met, his age, and even stuff about time travel itself such as, "You can't rewrite history. Not one line."
I think it has been established (as much as anything is) that the Doctor's actions can effectively, although not necessarily predictably, affect the future up to at least 700 years in The Ark and a century in Bad Wolf. Even over a shorter period, in the first Tennant season he apparently destroyed Britain's upcoming Golden Age by removing Harriet Jones from power, creating a hole subsequently filled by the Master.
Aside from rebooting the universe, I think Moffat was clever in establishing "the Doctor lies" as a primary rule. It implies that many statements made in the past were simply untrue, from the people the Doctor said he had met, his age, and even stuff about time travel itself such as, "You can't rewrite history. Not one line."
Emoticon and contraction free since... quite a while ago.
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: The Dr Who thread
Speculation:
Spoiler: show
- Harlequin
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 6505
- Joined: Wed Jun 05, 2002 4:19 am 0
- Location: London, directly above the centre of the Earth.
Re: The Dr Who thread
Trailer for episode 1, The Magician's Apprentice (hidden because even the default image could be considered a spoiler for some):
I am surprised that after having only a single two-part story since mid-2011, it looks like we only have two single-parters this year. I wonder if Capaldi found last year's workload a little heavier than he expected or if the series has faced budget cutbacks.
Spoiler: show
Spoiler: show
Emoticon and contraction free since... quite a while ago.
Re: The Dr Who thread
I don't think you can legitimately cry 'Spoilers!' about events that were screened over four years ago.Cloudane wrote:Oi. I'm 2 episodes into that. (Granted, it's the most spoiled event since the second Star Wars, but still)
...He's actually dead.
...He's actually his father.
...He invented him from things he could see in the office.
...They were all dead at the end.
...It was just a dream.
...Maggie did it.
...etc.
- Baggypants
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 5328
- Joined: Sun Mar 19, 2006 12:54 pm 0
- Location: Salford(UK);
- Contact:
Re: The Dr Who thread
AerisdiesIstar wrote:I don't think you can legitimately cry 'Spoilers!' about events that were screened over four years ago.Cloudane wrote:Oi. I'm 2 episodes into that. (Granted, it's the most spoiled event since the second Star Wars, but still)
...He's actually dead.
...He's actually his father.
...He invented him from things he could see in the office.
...They were all dead at the end.
...It was just a dream.
...Maggie did it.
...etc.
"The eggs, get them!"
- Governmentyard
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 11757
- Joined: Sun Oct 31, 2004 9:41 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: GovernmentYard
- Yahoo Messenger: governmentyard
Re: The Dr Who thread
What will be interesting is whether with more 2-parters we see better world building... I've found the 45 minutes to be insufficient to properly make many of the settings really click. "Here we are, a whole new alien world full of everything! But never mind all that, here's some running abut and generic Doctor Who stuff!". Quite often we'll be taken somewhere remarkable and the remarkableness of it is almost entirely lost.Harlequin wrote:I am surprised that after having only a single two-part story since mid-2011, it looks like we only have two single-parters this year. I wonder if Capaldi found last year's workload a little heavier than he expected or if the series has faced budget cutbacks.
So many of the places aren't characters in the way they used to be. Paradise Towers is few people's favourite setting, but it felt like a real place. The Library was another good one.
XBox Gamertag: GovernmentYard
Everything else: governmentyard
Everything else: governmentyard
- Harlequin
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 6505
- Joined: Wed Jun 05, 2002 4:19 am 0
- Location: London, directly above the centre of the Earth.
Re: The Dr Who thread
For most stories I find lengthy worldbuilding to be no more necessary than in, say, a forty-odd minute episode of classic Star Trek. There have been some, though, particularly those where societies rather than character drama have been the core of the narratives, which I think would indeed have benefited from more time. In explaining the change in length, Moffat has said, "It’s not just about being longer, sometimes it’s about going deeper," so I do hope that is what he means, especially as it sounds like this season is going to be far less Earth-bound than previous ones this century.
Emoticon and contraction free since... quite a while ago.
- Baggypants
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 5328
- Joined: Sun Mar 19, 2006 12:54 pm 0
- Location: Salford(UK);
- Contact:
Re: The Dr Who thread
this made me chortle
http://io9.com/5898445/10-times-the-doc ... doctor-who
http://io9.com/5898445/10-times-the-doc ... doctor-who
"The eggs, get them!"
Re: The Dr Who thread
I don't have the issue to hand, but in a recent interview in SFX I think that Moffat did indeed claim that the increased number of 2-parters is to expand the stories a bit more (I can't recall the exact words though).Governmentyard wrote:What will be interesting is whether with more 2-parters we see better world building... I've found the 45 minutes to be insufficient to properly make many of the settings really click. "Here we are, a whole new alien world full of everything! But never mind all that, here's some running abut and generic Doctor Who stuff!". Quite often we'll be taken somewhere remarkable and the remarkableness of it is almost entirely lost.Harlequin wrote:I am surprised that after having only a single two-part story since mid-2011, it looks like we only have two single-parters this year. I wonder if Capaldi found last year's workload a little heavier than he expected or if the series has faced budget cutbacks.
So many of the places aren't characters in the way they used to be. Paradise Towers is few people's favourite setting, but it felt like a real place. The Library was another good one.
"Stars don't twinkle in space." - Char Aznable.
- Harlequin
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 6505
- Joined: Wed Jun 05, 2002 4:19 am 0
- Location: London, directly above the centre of the Earth.
Re: The Dr Who thread
That reminds me of another story in which we saw the consequences of the Doctor's actions over the course of centuries, although we never saw the original actions themselves: The Mind of Evil, in which he had effectively created Leela's entire civilisation.Baggypants wrote:this made me chortle
http://io9.com/5898445/10-times-the-doc ... doctor-who
I took my quote from http://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/doctorwho/en ... 1742250f57.F-ZeroOne wrote:I don't have the issue to hand, but in a recent interview in SFX I think that Moffat did indeed claim that the increased number of 2-parters is to expand the stories a bit more (I can't recall the exact words though).
Emoticon and contraction free since... quite a while ago.
Re: The Dr Who thread
I always saw the Bill-and-Ted films as satirising Doctor Who in a good-natured way.Dio wrote: It prevents Bill-and-Tedding
"I am a very considerate person. If I want to go out all night on my miniature golf course and shoot lizards, well, no reason to keep the neighbours awake..."
Re: The Dr Who thread
Given River Song has (or will meet) multiple versions of the Doctor, which is the first one she meets? Is it Capaldi's version? Will we ever get to see her first meeting with the Doctor (but obviously it won't be for him and thus we get a reversal of Silence In The Library)?
Lie with passion and be forever damned...
Xbox: Mayhem64
Xbox: Mayhem64

