Politics Thread!
- phattslagg
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 3578
- Joined: Fri May 14, 2004 2:04 pm 0
- Location: Worcester, England
Re: Politics Thread!
It is absolutely unethical to prescribe a placebo if there is an alternative treatment with proven efficacy. Remember - evidence-based medicines *also* benefit from the placebo effect, but also offer something in addition to this.
When people forego treatment for serious conditions because they believe homeopathy is a valid treatment, lives are at stake. Placebo is mostly effective for pain relief, and certain conditions where conventional medicines have been used already, so there can be an appropriate physiological or psychological response to the pretend stimulus.
When people forego treatment for serious conditions because they believe homeopathy is a valid treatment, lives are at stake. Placebo is mostly effective for pain relief, and certain conditions where conventional medicines have been used already, so there can be an appropriate physiological or psychological response to the pretend stimulus.
Re: Politics Thread!
And the more likely scenario, used in conjunction with other treaments?phattslagg wrote:It is absolutely unethical to prescribe a placebo if there is an alternative treatment with proven efficacy. Remember - evidence-based medicines *also* benefit from the placebo effect, but also offer something in addition to this.
When people forego treatment for serious conditions because they believe homeopathy is a valid treatment, lives are at stake. Placebo is mostly effective for pain relief, and certain conditions where conventional medicines have been used already, so there can be an appropriate physiological or psychological response to the pretend stimulus.
Should people should be told they're idiots for getting better?
Re: Politics Thread!
Is that the same place where you feed heart surgery post-operatives greasy full english breakfasts with slappings of bacon and eggs? Frankly I'm appalled at the misuse of terminology.Barney wrote:In medical circles (which is where I work), anything that is believed to work without any supporting evidence - i.e, no RCTs have been done, no peer-reviewed research - is deemed homeopathic in nature.
I worked on human trial data and RCTs aren't all they are cracked up to be. By the human trial stage so much is invested there are huge incentives to get that product to market. Pharmas really don't want to be pursuing human trials if it's not almost a certainty to succeed as it's massively expensive. They will do what they legally and formally can to ensure the 'correct result' is achieved. Extraordinary profits await!
Couple of things to note:
I don't know if the law has changed recently in the UK, but in the USA Pharma's are not legally obliged to release their trial data. So they cherry pick, and IIRC something like 65% of trials are kept secret.
Bedside manner IS hugely important. The suggestion of duplicating control groups - leading to up to SIX groups for comparison has been made in the industry to eliminate bedside manner as a variable (additional groups- Drs administer the medicine in both a positive and negative light). Bedside manner has been shown to be an effective treatment in some instances, and we know for example that people of faiths have better outcomes in many areas.
Scale of effectiveness (often against no treatment) is rarely discussed 'in medical circles' let alone the public. A good proportion of prescribed treatments are important and effective and I agree with phattslagg homeopathy shouldn't be offfered as a substitute for a treatment with a known efficacy for a serious condition. But a ridiculous number of prescitipsons written each year are fundamentally bollocks.. overzealous dishing out of anti-depressants is a classic example. They barely have any proven efficacy except for those who are proper-proper 'boo hoo'. Consider statins - which according to a lot of research is less effective than eating well and moving about a bit.
I'm not saying homeopthy works, but some people who have faith in it, are into Ayurvedic medicine holistic practitioners etc etc often get as good if not better results than those who don't: the power of the mind should be a treatment aspect.
The real point here though is this is just another smear tactic on Corbyn. It's so utterly pathetic and desperate. Why are people so desperate to avoid REASON when dealing with Corbyn? Seems like the more his popularity grows the more the truth hurts.
Trippy vibes...
http://soundcloud.com/two-gapper
http://soundcloud.com/two-gapper
Re: Politics Thread!
There are some other issues. A common take on this is "Wheres the harm?"; the trouble is that there is some evidence that there is indeed some risk of harm. Practitioners of homeopathy sometimes have a higher-than-average of recommending other "alternative" practices that are definitely harmful, such as being anti-vaccination, or recommending homeopathic malarial treatments. Or consider acupuncture - sticking many small needles in people is a health risk in itself, and there have been cases of punctured lungs as a result. Some very ingeniously derived trials have replicated the claimed health effect (almost certainly due to the placebo effect in the first place) using "needles" that don't actually puncture the skin but simulate the sensation of having done so.gravy wrote:I don't get why people have a pop at stuff because "it's no better than placebo" as a placebos have been shown again and again to be beneficial.
Convincing people homeopathy is bollocks is basically destroying potential treatment for them
Edit: theres also been incidents where sufferers of terminal disease have paid much monies to alternate health practitioners which had no effect on the outcome of their illness, other than to leave their grieving families having to deal with the resulting debts.
"Stars don't twinkle in space." - Char Aznable.
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: Politics Thread!
Yes, all that: recommending or even turning a blind eye to a alternative medicines used by a patient can be harmful to them, and can at least waste money.
The placebo effect is a real thing but that does not mean policy should be based on it. Mostly as it requires deception: you tell people a treatment will work and for some people it does. Asking doctor’s to lie is very dubious.
It also does not work for everyone, and when it does it mostly does no better than a cheap drug, such as paracetamol. Yet these are not cheap, but are expensive. It’s a multi-billion dollar industry, founded on dubious theories and deceptive practices. No right minded person should be recommending it.
The placebo effect is a real thing but that does not mean policy should be based on it. Mostly as it requires deception: you tell people a treatment will work and for some people it does. Asking doctor’s to lie is very dubious.
It also does not work for everyone, and when it does it mostly does no better than a cheap drug, such as paracetamol. Yet these are not cheap, but are expensive. It’s a multi-billion dollar industry, founded on dubious theories and deceptive practices. No right minded person should be recommending it.
Re: Politics Thread!
All that stuff you wrote is true but :F-ZeroOne wrote:There are some other issues. A common take on this is "Wheres the harm?"; the trouble is that there is some evidence that there is indeed some risk of harm.gravy wrote:I don't get why people have a pop at stuff because "it's no better than placebo" as a placebos have been shown again and again to be beneficial.
Convincing people homeopathy is bollocks is basically destroying potential treatment for them
1. Plenty of harm is also caused by orthodox treatments - on a massive scale.
2. Acupuncture is harmless unless you're talking about total quackery which is rare.
You're talking abou extreme stuff there is a much larger middle ground of people who do homeopathy or whatever for minor ailments but will go the GP for something serious.
Consider the 60+% of people in the UK claim to be Christians so arguably benefit from faith woo - some just praying to get better - how do you rate the relative concern for homeopathy against the scale of that
Trippy vibes...
http://soundcloud.com/two-gapper
http://soundcloud.com/two-gapper
Re: Politics Thread!
Well a lot of regularly prescribed conventional medicines actually have efficacy at the same level as placebo. If that level of efficacy is good enough for conventional medicines, why is it not good enough for fake medicines?phattslagg wrote:It is absolutely unethical to prescribe a placebo if there is an alternative treatment with proven efficacy. Remember - evidence-based medicines *also* benefit from the placebo effect, but also offer something in addition to this.
I would say that it's unethical to prescribe a drug that has potentially harfmul side effects when a placebo would be much safer and just as effective.
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: Politics Thread!
(o)(o), I’m surprised you of all people would support it. Alternative medicine is big business. $34 bn in the US, according to one recent report:
Alternative Medicine Is a $34 Billion Industry, But Only One-Third of the Treatments Have Been Tested
As profit driven as any other, but much more deceptive, in their marketing and packaging. They get away with it as if you try and call them on it they assert it is all true. But they don’t really believe it, it is all spin and deception. They also are very effective at lobbying, buying politicians and votes. Though there’s a limit to that as there’s only so far you can go with genuine bullshit, even in the US.
Alternative Medicine Is a $34 Billion Industry, But Only One-Third of the Treatments Have Been Tested
As profit driven as any other, but much more deceptive, in their marketing and packaging. They get away with it as if you try and call them on it they assert it is all true. But they don’t really believe it, it is all spin and deception. They also are very effective at lobbying, buying politicians and votes. Though there’s a limit to that as there’s only so far you can go with genuine bullshit, even in the US.
Re: Politics Thread!
Total bollocks from pogo as is par for the course. Beside manner is a form of "deception" and it's employed daily by Doctors. It's fundamental to the hippocratic oath that Doctors do their very best for patients and if that involves them not rebutting a bit of woo that works they do that.pogo wrote:The placebo effect is a real thing but that does not mean policy should be based on it. Mostly as it requires deception: you tell people a treatment will work and for some people it does. Asking doctor’s to lie is very dubious.
Corbyn hasn't announced homeopathy as a policy objective so it's just the same old SHIT SMEARING tactic employed by cretins in absence of authentic concerns.
Trippy vibes...
http://soundcloud.com/two-gapper
http://soundcloud.com/two-gapper
Re: Politics Thread!
It's not a binary position you muppet.pogo wrote:(o)(o), I’m surprised you of all people would support it. Alternative medicine is...
Constantly seeing everything in polar extremes is a problem certain individuals suffer from which placebos appear unable to resolve.
Trippy vibes...
http://soundcloud.com/two-gapper
http://soundcloud.com/two-gapper
Re: Politics Thread!
If you used that argument in any other context it would be an insult to everybody's intelligence. You think you can get away with it here?F-ZeroOne wrote:A common take on this is "Wheres the harm?"; the trouble is that there is some evidence that there is indeed some risk of harm. Practitioners of homeopathy sometimes have a higher-than-average of recommending other "alternative" practices that are definitely harmful, such as being anti-vaccination, or recommending homeopathic malarial treatments.
Sounds plausible.F-ZeroOne wrote:Or consider acupuncture - sticking many small needles in people is a health risk in itself, and there have been cases of punctured lungs as a result.
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: Politics Thread!
He wrote this(o)(o) wrote:Corbyn hasn't announced homeopathy as a policy objective so it's just the same old SHIT SMEARING tactic employed by cretins in absence of authentic concerns.
So not a policy, but without one it’s viable to question the beliefs and statements of a politician until they act on them, by announcing a policy or by clearly stating his views today.I believe that homeo-meds works for some ppl and that it compliments 'convential' meds. they both come from organic matter...
Looks like Ben Goldacre has also noticed it and tweeted the following.
@jeremycorbyn @leftoutside i know the tweet’s old and prob not your main preoccupation, but evidence really matters especially when it comes to healthcare, a lot of harm is done and money wasted when we dont demand good data.
i don’t mean that frank homeopathic quackery is the biggest cause of avoidable morbidity and mortality but politicians tolerating it is part of a wider malaise of tolerating poor standards of evidence in medicine.
Re: Politics Thread!
No-one is denying that certain medical treatments can have harmful effects. It is, in fact, one of the things that distinguishes medicine from "alternative" treatments; it may take a while, and the process is not perfect, but sooner or later the harm will be recognized and the effects mitigated or stopped. That is not the same as saying every medical intervention can be harmful, or that the harm done outweighs the good.(o)(o) wrote:All that stuff you wrote is true but :F-ZeroOne wrote:There are some other issues. A common take on this is "Wheres the harm?"; the trouble is that there is some evidence that there is indeed some risk of harm.gravy wrote:I don't get why people have a pop at stuff because "it's no better than placebo" as a placebos have been shown again and again to be beneficial.
Convincing people homeopathy is bollocks is basically destroying potential treatment for them
1. Plenty of harm is also caused by orthodox treatments - on a massive scale.
2. Acupuncture is harmless unless you're talking about total quackery which is rare.
You're talking abou extreme stuff there is a much larger middle ground of people who do homeopathy or whatever for minor ailments but will go the GP for something serious.
Consider the 60+% of people in the UK claim to be Christians so arguably benefit from faith woo - some just praying to get better - how do you rate the relative concern for homeopathy against the scale of that
Now compare that to, say, the anti-vaccine movement in the U.S, which has caused a good deal of harm. Yet its supporters are virtually impervious to any evidence contrary to their views to the extent that there is virtually no evidence that can be provided to them at all, no matter how well researched, that will ever change their position.
There is also a difference between "feeling" better and actually being better. The trouble with "alternative" treatments is that they often have no basis in evidence (outside the placebo effect, which is an effect, which does not actually require crystals, dilutions, energy points or similar to be invoked and which is not a universal cure-all). Taking "alternative" treatments may deceive a patient that they are getting better when in fact the opposite is true, and when an effective treatment can no longer be administered.
You state that acupuncture is harmless unless you're talking about "total quackery", but this is exactly the point - acupuncture is total quackery; its supposed benefits can be replicated without actually sticking pointy things in patients, and in at least some cases harm has been done (probably more than is usually reported; many "alternative" treatments aren't as regulated as much as actual treatments are and again, there have been cases when treatments supposed homeopathic in nature have turned out to be anything but).
"Stars don't twinkle in space." - Char Aznable.
Re: Politics Thread!
...? Sorry, I am probably being dense, but in what other contexts would I be insulting other peoples intelligence? What am I getting away with?gumboot wrote:If you used that argument in any other context it would be an insult to everybody's intelligence. You think you can get away with it here?F-ZeroOne wrote:A common take on this is "Wheres the harm?"; the trouble is that there is some evidence that there is indeed some risk of harm. Practitioners of homeopathy sometimes have a higher-than-average of recommending other "alternative" practices that are definitely harmful, such as being anti-vaccination, or recommending homeopathic malarial treatments.
"Stars don't twinkle in space." - Char Aznable.
Re: Politics Thread!
Saying that something is bad because it's higher-than-baseline association with something that is actually bad.
You know. Like homosexuality and AIDS.
You know. Like homosexuality and AIDS.

