(o)(o) wrote:Again, simply a fiction. Labour have put forward credible economic policies.
No. To make it clear I am talking about the 2015 election, as no-one expects Corbyn to have a detailed programme this far from an election. But in May:
* Labour did not say when they aimed to eliminate the deficit, unlike the Tories.
* Therefore they did not say how much they would cut, as the rate of reducing the deficit largely determines that.
* Their tax raising measures were vague and implausible. E.g. they said they would raise “hundreds of millions” from taxing non-doms. But how many hundreds? Two? Twenty? Or none, if Ed Balls in January was to be believed when he said changing the law “would cost Britain money”
* Other tax raising measures included reinstating the 50% rate and a mansion tax. But that meant their tax depended on asking the same few people to pay more in two or three different ways. We know from the last time the rate was at 50%, and from Ed Balls slip, that such tax measures simply don’t work. They raise little to none of the money expected.
* Worst they failed to own up to their contribution to the deficit. The scale of the cuts the Tories have been able to make, cutting a million jobs without impacting services, shows there was massive waste and overspend in the civil service. But Miliband failed again and again to address this, most tellingly dodging the issue when directly confronted with it by voters on Question Time.
The latter, though not part of their plan, led many people to doubt their economic competence and honesty. They needed a clear, properly costed and plausible economic policy to counter it. They did not have one. They let the Tories get away with not breaking down their welfare savings as Labour were far vaguer.