Politics Thread!
Re: Politics Thread!
The press are experts at selectively quoting out of context and Corbyn, being prepared to actually discuss things, ends up getting it in the neck. His 'controversial' statements are usually (although not quite always) couched in language that most intelligent people would find highly reasonable whatever their political position.
- phattslagg
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 3578
- Joined: Fri May 14, 2004 2:04 pm 0
- Location: Worcester, England
Re: Politics Thread!
I think this is his major weakness though - despite his discomfort with the game of political bullshit, to some extent he has to learn to play along, otherwise the media will continue to use his thoughtful answers to manipulate the weak-minded and reinforce the opinions of those who don't want to like anything he says.
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: Politics Thread!
But that’s just politics. The place where you get to have discursive, philosophical discussions, to argue round “most intelligent people”, is academia. Or in political think tanks. Or down the pub. In politics you don’t get that luxury; you speak in clear statements and soundbites, as you know the press, and not just those that oppose you, are going to edit and select the most newsworthy bits for their headlines and bulletins if you don’t do it for them.Dio wrote:The press are experts at selectively quoting out of context and Corbyn, being prepared to actually discuss things, ends up getting it in the neck. His 'controversial' statements are usually (although not quite always) couched in language that most intelligent people would find highly reasonable whatever their political position.
I’m sure he knows this and is used to doing it. He’s been in politics and parliament for a very long time, had lots of time to practice, heard far more PMQs than any of us. His problem though is the statements he is used to making are on the left even of the Labour party. Someone has probably told him he can’t keep on saying he will get rid of nukes (despite being vice-chairman of CND). so he attempts to couch his statements, saying getting rid of them is up for debate, but saying he personally would not use them. Which may be honest, and trying to have a discussion, but is very bad politics.
Re: Politics Thread!
No, that's the modern corporately media press pandering to the lowest common denominator for their own best interess. It's not always been like that and there's no reason it always should be.pogo wrote:But that’s just politics. The place where you get to have discursive, philosophical discussions, to argue round “most intelligent people”, is academia. Or in political think tanks. Or down the pub. In politics you don’t get that luxury; you speak in clear statements and soundbites, as you know the press, and not just those that oppose you, are going to edit and select the most newsworthy bits for their headlines and bulletins if you don’t do it for them.
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: Politics Thread!
Yes and no. We’ve had partisan press for very long time. They are called “press barons” because they were first called that when “baron” was not a comical anachronism.
What’s changed is technology. Press has moved onto a 24 hour news cycle, with bulletins every hour. Newspapers have web sites with main pages updated as regularly. They need headlines and soundbites for these bulletins/reports, and if politicians don’t supply them ready made they will generate them through careful editing or just creative writing. Not just the partisan press, but those most people think neutral like the BBC do exactly the same. E.g.
Labour's week: Fear and loathing in SW1
What’s changed is technology. Press has moved onto a 24 hour news cycle, with bulletins every hour. Newspapers have web sites with main pages updated as regularly. They need headlines and soundbites for these bulletins/reports, and if politicians don’t supply them ready made they will generate them through careful editing or just creative writing. Not just the partisan press, but those most people think neutral like the BBC do exactly the same. E.g.
Labour's week: Fear and loathing in SW1
Re: Politics Thread!
But the other change from technology is the redundancy of "big media" for disseminating news and analysis. They exist now purely for those for whom a particular issue is tr;dr.
The Scottish independence vote and Corbyn's election both show evidence of a new layer of thoughtful discussion somewhere between the pub/pissed yatter which is Twitter and Facebook and the patriarchical approach of the BBC and the rest of the establishment.
The Scottish independence vote and Corbyn's election both show evidence of a new layer of thoughtful discussion somewhere between the pub/pissed yatter which is Twitter and Facebook and the patriarchical approach of the BBC and the rest of the establishment.
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: Politics Thread!
I would say both episodes are evidence of quite the opposite. The independence vote could have involved a lot of thoughtful decision about the costs and benefits of independence, such as how to start a new currency when you are no longer part of the pound currency area, or how to fill the large fiscal hole that would arise when subsidies from the rest of the UK end. Instead it boiled down to “what do we want? Independence! When do we want it? Now!!” The pro camp simply ignored the issues or lied about them, asserting for example an independent Scotland could keep using the pound.venusian wrote:The Scottish independence vote and Corbyn's election both show evidence of a new layer of thoughtful discussion somewhere between the pub/pissed yatter which is Twitter and Facebook and the patriarchical approach of the BBC and the rest of the establishment.
Corbyn’s election is even worse. Rather than an in depth analysis of why Labour lost in 2015, and what it needs to do to regain the trust of the electorate, a large number of members deluded themselves that they only lost as they were not left wing enough, and voted for the leader they thought best matched this delusion. Now that fantasy is colliding with reality, with Corbyn and his faithful on one side, most MPs and most voters on the other.
Social media does probably have a lot to do with it. But not as platforms for discussion, more as places for like minded people to come together and reinforce their opinions and prejudices, even if they are unrealistic or delusional. They have not had a positive effect on political discourse; quite the opposite.
Re: Politics Thread!
Well, you're buying the press line.
The alternative is that the voters actually looked at what the four candidates were saying and saw one of the four that actually excited them and that they believe gave them what they want from a party rather than just tilting at election while offering a version of politics that you don't really agree with very much.
It's about hope and honesty rather than politics. That's why I - given the choice - would likely have gone for Corbyn. Not because it makes Labour more electable, far from it, I know it makes it less electable with enough of the population that it's pretty much impossible to win a GE. But at least it more closely represents me.
Yeah, it would have been more sensible to get PR first. But fuck it. I don't want to vote for someone who's just about getting elected and doing nowt any more.
The alternative is that the voters actually looked at what the four candidates were saying and saw one of the four that actually excited them and that they believe gave them what they want from a party rather than just tilting at election while offering a version of politics that you don't really agree with very much.
It's about hope and honesty rather than politics. That's why I - given the choice - would likely have gone for Corbyn. Not because it makes Labour more electable, far from it, I know it makes it less electable with enough of the population that it's pretty much impossible to win a GE. But at least it more closely represents me.
Yeah, it would have been more sensible to get PR first. But fuck it. I don't want to vote for someone who's just about getting elected and doing nowt any more.
- merman
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 10943
- Joined: Wed Feb 16, 2005 1:44 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: merman1974
- Yahoo Messenger: andrewrfisher
- Location: Skegness, England
- Contact:
Re: Politics Thread!
WORST EVER OCTOBER DEFICIT FIGURE, £8.2 BILLION
DEBT NOW OVER £1.5 TRILLION, OR 80.5% OF GDP
Just in case pogo has trouble seeing the facts.
Osborne continues to borrow, even the experts were predicting the figure would be no worse than £6 billion.
DEBT NOW OVER £1.5 TRILLION, OR 80.5% OF GDP
Just in case pogo has trouble seeing the facts.
Osborne continues to borrow, even the experts were predicting the figure would be no worse than £6 billion.
Twitter, Xbox, Wii U and Steam - merman1974
ZZAP is back - https://www.patreon.com/zzapmagazine
ZZAP is back - https://www.patreon.com/zzapmagazine
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: Politics Thread!
The whole point of democracy is choosing the people in charge. If you (or Corbyn’s supporters) want instead vote on principle, then that’s up to you. But don’t then complain when Osbourne or Johnson gets elected in 2020 for another ten years of Tory rule.Dio wrote:It's about hope and honesty rather than politics. That's why I - given the choice - would likely have gone for Corbyn. Not because it makes Labour more electable, far from it, I know it makes it less electable with enough of the population that it's pretty much impossible to win a GE. But at least it more closely represents me.
Yeah, it would have been more sensible to get PR first. But fuck it. I don't want to vote for someone who's just about getting elected and doing nowt any more.
And PR certainly would not help. Labour still does very well out of first past the post. If the 2015 election had used PR, then the most likely coalition would be a Tory-UKIP one, as they got almost half the vote between them, and UKIP’s vote was almost certainly suppressed by their being not expected to win.
Re: Politics Thread!
Totally. Furthermore there is now a vacuum in the mainstream press, with very little reporting that isn't in accord with the propaganda model pulling it to the right. The Guardian cannot be trusted. The BBC is drenched in bias and dumbed down (like that article you just propagated pogo). The Independent is an approximation of reality but owned by an Russian oligarch and that sometimes shows. RT, but it has it's own agenda too. The Bureau of Investigative Journalism still reports what others won't but it's had it's scandal and has a tiny footprint on the British consciousness.venusian wrote:No, that's the modern corporately media press pandering to the lowest common denominator for their own best interess. It's not always been like that and there's no reason it always should be.pogo wrote:But that’s just politics. The place where you get to have discursive, philosophical discussions, to argue round “most intelligent people”, is academia. Or in political think tanks. Or down the pub. In politics you don’t get that luxury; you speak in clear statements and soundbites, as you know the press, and not just those that oppose you, are going to edit and select the most newsworthy bits for their headlines and bulletins if you don’t do it for them.
The irony of this being published in the Guardian.. oh my days..

Technology appears to put control back in the hands of the public - there is a feedback loop going on - but it also tightens the grip of hierarchical influence. The pejorative 'press baron' is returning to common parlance because it's appropriate. There's clear evidence (eg Mori polls) that the electorate are being shaped and formed by a biased media narratives. The UK is more plutocracy than free and open democracy. Corbyns ability to challenge the predicted encroaching pincer movement was always going to be the core issue, especially today with herding behaviour so finely tuned and muscle of influence ingrained.
Trippy vibes...
http://soundcloud.com/two-gapper
http://soundcloud.com/two-gapper
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: Politics Thread!
The Guardian too right wing? Are you on drugs? It’s the most unashamedly left of centre national newspaper there is. It may not be as left wing as Corbyn but little is in modern politics, with his policies being largely those Labour held when he became an MP, in 1983, and when Labour were at their lowest point electorally for a generation.
The Guardian does cover the Labour Party particularly well, as being the main newspaper for Labour supporters it knows its readership. In particular no other paper covers the internal politics of the party so well. E.g.
Like a good Marxist, Corbyn is securing his revolution from within
The Guardian does cover the Labour Party particularly well, as being the main newspaper for Labour supporters it knows its readership. In particular no other paper covers the internal politics of the party so well. E.g.
Like a good Marxist, Corbyn is securing his revolution from within
Re: Politics Thread!
I want to vote for what I believe in and that isn't "New Labour".pogo wrote:The whole point of democracy is choosing the people in charge. If you (or Corbyn’s supporters) want instead vote on principle
Why should I be punished for doing that? Why should I be irrelevant because I don't live in a marginal?
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: Politics Thread!
You are not being punished, just denying the yourself the chance of your preferred policies being enacted. And the preferred policies of many others, if Corbyn being elected rules out any chance of a Labour government any time soon.
My own constituency is far from marginal but I still vote. Partly as a civic duty, partly as I still feel lucky to do so, having lived places where I could not vote for many years. But I also hope my vote, and the vote of others like me might make a difference. Maybe they might make the seat slightly less marginal, especially after boundary changes.
My own constituency is far from marginal but I still vote. Partly as a civic duty, partly as I still feel lucky to do so, having lived places where I could not vote for many years. But I also hope my vote, and the vote of others like me might make a difference. Maybe they might make the seat slightly less marginal, especially after boundary changes.
Re: Politics Thread!
Ah, and that's my fault is it?pogo wrote:You are not being punished, just denying the yourself the chance of your preferred policies being enacted.
