VNVObit wrote:Cost:value ratios are typically 80 to 85% for the private sector
I'm not sure about that, do you have anything to back it up?
I know some of the figures for this new house I'm living in now. The insurance rebuild cost when I bought was about 70% the purchase price, but that's a private single rebuild; Bellway's costs to build will have been less, 80% of that certainly and I wouldn't be at all surprised if it was much lower, 60% or so. Land cost was about 10% the purchase price. The substantial chunk I don't know is the general overheads like road construction, utilities and planning, but I'd be surprised if that was much more than another 10%.
So that does come out at maybe somewhere near 80%. But I bought the second last house on the whole project right at the bottom of the market in 2012 - they were giving them away and I know they were still making a profit. The other houses of the same type that weren't right on the end of the job went for 20% more, and when they started on this project in 2005, the target price for the house I'm in was
way higher, 40% more.
My guess is that in a 'normal' market, if such a thing exists any more, house builders operate on something around 60-70% cost:value for 3-4 bed detatched family houses, rising significantly with property size. So that's naturally what they prefer to build.
I'm sure the margin is much lower on smaller and particularly non-detatched properties and that's why they don't want to build in the 'affordable' segment unless their arms are twisted into doing it.
As capitalist solutions to the problem go it's, the housing association RTB plan does have some fundamental underlying logic. In theory it's lubricating market wheels without removing money from the system (since the 'giveaway' comes from the state, not the housing association). It's an attempt to put liquidity in the system and generate more building activity from the housing associations. It's not, in itself, a terrible plan the way that forcing councils to pay the discount and not allowing them to reinvest in the system was.
The main problem is that it's totally broken if you can't find affordable land to rebuild on (London, Oxford, the South West, the Lakes etc. but I suspect that on a local level almost every part of the country has the problem to some extent).