VNVObit wrote:Cost:value ratios are typically 80 to 85% for the private sector
I'm not sure about that, do you have anything to back it up?
Work in housing development for last 17 years and the typical margin on sales for residual land valuations is between 15 and 20%
Fair enough .
It has to surely vary by a lot more than 80-85% across the range though. If you can be 90% cost:value at £100k, you must be waaaay lower than that at £300-400k. Or, from another angle, if you can build a house you sell at £200k in Newcastle or £150k in Middlesborough you're surely making a shitload more profit if it's selling at £500k in Luton or Windsor, it can't all be eaten up by increased land cost and the rest of the build cost doesn't rise that much.
VNVObit wrote:A considerable proportion of properties sold under RTB are now rented out in the private sector which wasn't the original intention.
There’s no surprise in that; there was nothing in the RTB that prevents owners selling them on or renting them out years later. Schemes like RTB might help some people buy in the short term, but do nothing for overall supply if no more houses are built as a result. Prices depend on supply and demand, and higher prices force more people to rent.
Because they have no overall effect subsidies like RTB, Help To Buy end up making houses cheaper for some people but more expensive for others, though the effect might be small. It’s real though: those not eligible for subsidies cannot compete for the subsidised properties and their limited choice drives up the price they pay. Rent control has the same effect but on [uncontrolled] rents, New York being the classic example.
There was also a measure for the rental sector. 3% extra on stamp duty if the house is buy to let. Not sure of the effect it will have; in theory it will depress buy to let but as with stamp duty in general the amount seems too small to be much of a drag on the market. And in places like London there’s a large fraction of the population who simply cannot afford to buy. Tweaking buy to let taxes will have little impact on this.
VNVObit wrote:Cost:value ratios are typically 80 to 85% for the private sector
I'm not sure about that, do you have anything to back it up?
Work in housing development for last 17 years and the typical margin on sales for residual land valuations is between 15 and 20%
Fair enough .
It has to surely vary by a lot more than 80-85% across the range though. If you can be 90% cost:value at £100k, you must be waaaay lower than that at £300-400k. Or, from another angle, if you can build a house you sell at £200k in Newcastle or £150k in Middlesborough you're surely making a shitload more profit if it's selling at £500k in Luton or Windsor, it can't all be eaten up by increased land cost and the rest of the build cost doesn't rise that much.
There are regional variations in some costs but as land value is derived as a residual based on the value you can sell property built on it so it does eat up a considerable proportion (and the associated financing for 18 to 36 months depending on planning and whether offer is subject to planning or not) of the variation
"England is funny, but sometimes she scares me"
Tony Wakeford
VNVObit wrote:A considerable proportion of properties sold under RTB are now rented out in the private sector which wasn't the original intention.
There’s no surprise in that; there was nothing in the RTB that prevents owners selling them on or renting them out years later. Schemes like RTB might help some people buy in the short term, but do nothing for overall supply if no more houses are built as a result. Prices depend on supply and demand, and higher prices force more people to rent.
Because they have no overall effect subsidies like RTB, Help To Buy end up making houses cheaper for some people but more expensive for others, though the effect might be small. It’s real though: those not eligible for subsidies cannot compete for the subsidised properties and their limited choice drives up the price they pay. Rent control has the same effect but on [uncontrolled] rents, New York being the classic example.
There was also a measure for the rental sector. 3% extra on stamp duty if the house is buy to let. Not sure of the effect it will have; in theory it will depress buy to let but as with stamp duty in general the amount seems too small to be much of a drag on the market. And in places like London there’s a large fraction of the population who simply cannot afford to buy. Tweaking buy to let taxes will have little impact on this.
Tweaking buy to let SDLT has damn all effect on RTB as the first purchaser is a homeowner. It'll affect small time investors not those who build to let though their VAT vehicles won't be as efficient
"England is funny, but sometimes she scares me"
Tony Wakeford
pogo wrote:I don’t think it’s a cartel.... What instead is I think happening is developers are making individual choices..
It's not a cartel it's TACIT COLLUSION between government and developers, landlords, land owners et al
It's no coincidence they are all major party donors.
The market supply is carefully controlled to keep the bubble growing without it blowing up in their faces. Surely this is obvious?
Osbourne appears to be trying to turn defeat by the Lords on Tax Credits to his advantage. He doesn't have this £37bn. That's 5 years projections splurged in one leadership bid!
(o)(o) wrote:It's not a cartel it's TACIT COLLUSION between government and developers, landlords, land owners et al
It's no coincidence they are all major party donors.
The market supply is carefully controlled to keep the bubble growing without it blowing up in their faces. Surely this is obvious?
Osbourne appears to be trying to turn defeat by the Lords on Tax Credits to his advantage. He doesn't have this £37bn. That's 5 years projections splurged in one leadership bid!
How reliable are those projections again?
Nonsense. A few large builders may be party donors, as are other firms. But the thousands of smaller developers, hundreds of thousands of landlords? The latter must be very unhappy with all the moves the government is taking against them – not just the 3% stamp duty rise but changes to capital gains tax and tax relief. The latter is probably the biggest change; tax relief on mortgage payments will only be available at basic rate, not the higher rate. This picks on higher rate tax payers in particular, something I would have thought you would approve of, and makes buy to let a uniquely unattractive investment for the rich, at least when it is mortgage financed.
Quite the opposite. Small scale landlords largely escape the measures. Those with small incomes so basic rate taxpayers will not be hit by the tax relief change. The capital gains change will hit those making large profits most. And the stamp duty increase as well as being less for smaller/cheaper properties will surely be avoided by some by treating a house they buy as their main home, perhaps living in it for a few months, before renting it out.
Those hit hardest will be richest landlords; those making enough to pay the higher rate, those with multiple properties that cannot be treated as the family home, and those in the most expensive parts of the country. Problem is it won’t make renting or buying any cheaper. Some people might be driven out of buy to let but others will take their place. There’s no shortage of money available to invest in e.g. London property, still seen as a bastion of security and stability compared to other markets around the world.
pogo wrote:Those hit hardest will be richest landlords;
pogo wrote:A few large builders may be party donors, as are other firms. But the thousands of smaller developers, hundreds of thousands of landlords? The latter must be very unhappy with all the moves the government is taking against them
You've contradicted yourself again !
When have the Tories ever hit anyone with wads of cash hard who isn't 'out of line'?
Pogo, what was the issue John McDonnell was raising by quoting Mao?
It was the fact that Osborne had sold £10 billion worth of Government assets to Chinese investors.
The Institute for Fiscal Studies makes it clear - this is not an end to austerity, there is no giveaway. Public services will be hard hit. Families will be worse off (since both tax credits and Universal Credit are limited to the first two children).
And a THIRD of current childcare cost claimants are now ineligible. He promised 30 hours of free childcare this year during the March budget, postponed it to 2016 in July and put it back to 2017 in the Autumn Statement.
Promised? Then I’m sure he will be punished at the polls. Or more likely the general public will not pay so much attention to every single “promise” as ministers make so many statements and predictions they cannot be held to them all.
On Mao it’s not so much the quote which was fairly boring and pointless. It was that he thought pulling out and waving the Red Book at all was a good idea. It shows not just his background but his age; it’s decades since even China put much trust in Mao’s wisdom. He’s still revered as “The Great Helmsman” but since the 1980s Mao’s approach has been steadily abandoned; now China is nothing like when he was alive.
The quote wasn’t that interesting. If it had been especially relevant and insightful he might have been applauded for using it, and excused the source. The link to China’s nuclear investment was lost on most people, as it was notable at the time but that was a month ago. No-one now is worrying about it, except clearly some on the left. All that’s left is an old man waving Mao’s Red Book. Probably the image he will be remembered by.
Promised? Then I’m sure he will be punished at the polls. Or more likely the general public will not pay so much attention to every single “promise” as ministers make so many statements and predictions they cannot be held to them all.
There have been calls for political lying to be criminal offence. Your Tories would be fucked then wouldn't they!
(o)(o) wrote:There have been calls for political lying to be criminal offence. Your Tories would be fucked then wouldn't they!
No more than the last Labour government. Remember Blair and Brown’s promise of “an end to boom and bust”, never mind their involvement in Iraq. Fact is that governments in power often say things that are wrong. They change policy for political reasons, as the situation changes, as new information arises. They often have to withhold information for security or fairness reasons.
The law actually recognises this, giving politicians freedom (“parliamentary privilege”) to say things in parliament without fear of being prosecuted for lying, slander etc. This is partly a recognition of the problems they face, but also as they are not employed, they cannot just be fired. They can be voted out and voters get to judge them on their honesty. You may find they are dishonest, but many people found Labour more dishonest about their policies in May, when they refused to explain how they would pay for them.
(o)(o) wrote:There have been calls for political lying to be criminal offence. Your Tories would be fucked then wouldn't they!
No more than the last Labour government. Remember Blair and Brown’s promise of “an end to boom and bust”, never mind their involvement in Iraq. Fact is that governments in power often say things that are wrong. They change policy for political reasons, as the situation changes, as new information arises.