pogo wrote:Anyway, saying you should not fight because innocent civilians will be killed is not tenable as in most wars civilians are killed.
Holy fucking Jesus H. Christ on a pushbike. Just re-read that back to yourself. Is that really the way you think?
They make most of their money through oil sales. So one effective way to severely hamper their operations, with minimal force and loss of life, is through targeting their oil sales. Not wells as if ISIS are eventually kicked out the people who live there will want those wells left in place. But the pipelines and tankers that are taking oil to the border for export. And that is likely to involve civilian deaths, of oil workers and drivers.
Or are you suggesting that ISIS’s infrastructure should not be targeted, so they should be allowed to continue making large amounts of money, to fund terrorist organisations in Syria, Iraq and elsewhere? I’m pretty sure it’s only because they are rich they can fund something like the attacks in Paris.
pogo wrote:One of the best ways to stunt ISIS’s growth would be to cut off its oil sales.
Yes
pogo wrote:But that would almost certainly mean civilian deaths, whether those driving tankers or those manning pipelines.
Or stop people from buying it. Or flood the market in that area with cheaper oil. Or do a load of fucking things before reaching for the bomb button. Much as I hate to say it Putin's got a point about Turkey being complicit in ISILs oil economy.
But oil is like gold or diamonds, once it’s on the market it’s almost impossible to tell where it came from. ISIS aren’t small; they occupy an area bigger than many countries. They have many borders, many opportunities to trade. Just because they are at war with almost everyone around them does not mean they won’t be able to trade with them or through them. And Western governments have little say over what’s going on in and around ISIS’s territories. Unless they choose to bomb them.
You should read up about ISIL's oil distribution and production. It's fascinating and there are several vital links in the chain before sale that they have a dependence on outside agencies for. It attackable on an economic basis and you'd agree that if that's true then that should be the first course of action yeah?
And we have no say over Syria, or Syria-ISIS relations. Of course Syria would say they have nothing to do with ISIS, but ISIS was partly created by Syria, to counter the Syrian opposition, and even now Syria is more interested in crushing the opposition than ending ISIS which threatens them less directly.
It goes a lot of places. Including out of ISIL territory for refining (they can refine but don't have much capacity) and then back in.
You're just googling around to find anything to justify your knee jerk reaction. Put that aside and let's assume that there is the possibility we could break their oil industry then that should be the first thing to look at before bombing shouldn't it?
There's no time pressure here except to give France the chance for some immediate revenge.
pogo wrote:Anyway, saying you should not fight because innocent civilians will be killed is not tenable as in most wars civilians are killed.
Holy fucking Jesus H. Christ on a pushbike. Just re-read that back to yourself. Is that really the way you think?
They make most of their money through oil sales. So one effective way to severely hamper their operations, with minimal force and loss of life, is through targeting their oil sales.
Yes, agreed but... You're really saying that the best way to hamper their economic success is to bomb them? Seriously?
Not wells as if ISIS are eventually kicked out the people who live there will want those wells left in place. But the pipelines and tankers that are taking oil to the border for export. And that is likely to involve civilian deaths, of oil workers and drivers.
Oh. You really are that kind of person.
"Oh dear lord, I slightly soiled myself. Oxfam won’t be pleased."
Absolute_Zero wrote:question for those opposed in the UK: would your opinion differ if the events in Paris had occurred in London?
No.
Because bombing Syria won't stop ISIS.
Cutting the support it gets from other Arab nations is more important.
But Cameron is so close to certain key figures that he cannot criticise them for fear of losing face and valuable contracts.
gravy wrote:[...]let's assume that there is the possibility we could break their oil industry then that should be the first thing to look at before bombing shouldn't it?
That seems a little fanciful, doesn't it? How much precedent is they're for that sort of thing actually happening and being successful?
gravy wrote:There's no time pressure here except to give France the chance for some immediate revenge.
Do you suppose that everybody in places like Syria feels that there's no time pressure?
gravy wrote:[...]let's assume that there is the possibility we could break their oil industry then that should be the first thing to look at before bombing shouldn't it?
That seems a little fanciful, doesn't it? How much precedent is they're for that sort of thing actually happening and being successful?
Perhaps my sarcasm detector is busted, but I'll bite. How much precedent is (ahem) there for "just bombing" being successful?
"massive retard™", "full of shit™", "tiny bitch™", "retarted™", "a bit of a one trick pony™", "petty™", "simple minded idealistic twat™", "miserable humourless fucker™"
gravy wrote:You're just googling around to find anything to justify your knee jerk reaction. Put that aside and let's assume that there is the possibility we could break their oil industry then that should be the first thing to look at before bombing shouldn't it?
There's no time pressure here except to give France the chance for some immediate revenge.
How do we “break their oil industry”, apart from military attacks? It does make an attractive target as oil is not the sort of thing that can be smuggled out of the country in suitcases, unlike currency, gold etc.. A convoy of tankers, even one, is hard to hide in the desert. A pipeline even more so.
As for time pressure the sooner ISIS is destroyed the sooner they are unable to mount attacks like Paris. It may take a long time to wipe them out, but ending their capacity to fund their operations, whether in Iraq and Syria or in Paris, is probably necessary to defeat them.
gravy wrote:[...]let's assume that there is the possibility we could break their oil industry then that should be the first thing to look at before bombing shouldn't it?
That seems a little fanciful, doesn't it? How much precedent is they're for that sort of thing actually happening and being successful?
Perhaps my sarcasm detector is busted, but I'll bite. How much precedent is (ahem) there for "just bombing" being successful?
Fuck-all. Well, I guess there's Hiroshima (low hanging fruit left for a good pedant, there), but that's probably not winning any hearts or minds.
But since neither option is likely effective they need to be debated on merits other than that one is zero-cost when that's pretty clearly untrue.
And yeah, this phone has some ridiculous fixation on "they're" over "there", and I have to correct it pretty much every time except for when I don't spot it. It's probably trained on data from Facebook, or something.
So your solution to ISIS enslaving, raping, brutally killing thousands of innocent civilians would be what? Ask them nicely to stop? They have made it clear that they plan to create a caliphate by conquest, and nothing is going to dissuade them from this, not even other more moderate Muslims. The only thing that will stop them is force, lethal force. They are already losing but show no signs of giving up. Why should they when they control a region the size of a small country and millions in oil revenue?
Last edited by pogo on Sat Nov 28, 2015 7:51 pm 0, edited 1 time in total.
Nobody's better than ISIS. It's all subjective. We kill people through inaction just as much as through action. Pretending that there's a clean way out is just stupid.