Politics Thread!
Re: Politics Thread!
You can't bomb ideas but if you're fighting a theology oriented around the west being meddling, bombing twats you can definitely use being bombed to entrench your position, recruit new troops and if you lose leave a ticking time bomb for the same thing to happen again.
You can trace ISIL back through Al Queada, the taliban and to the mujahadin we trained, equipped taught how to self organise.
It's just an ineffective way of achieving anything beyond short term political gain at home. Long term solutions to this kind of shit involve legitimising the "enemy" at some point. And the biggest force to making that happen is usually economic.
More than happy to listen to counter examples of air strikes working.
You can trace ISIL back through Al Queada, the taliban and to the mujahadin we trained, equipped taught how to self organise.
It's just an ineffective way of achieving anything beyond short term political gain at home. Long term solutions to this kind of shit involve legitimising the "enemy" at some point. And the biggest force to making that happen is usually economic.
More than happy to listen to counter examples of air strikes working.
Re: Politics Thread!
That's kind of true. But if you're going to take a path that doesn't work might as well choose the the one that doesn't involve high explosives being dropped on a civillian's boncegumboot wrote:Nobody's better than ISIS. It's all subjective. We kill people through inaction just as much as through action. Pretending that there's a clean way out is just stupid.
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: Politics Thread!
No, I don’t want to see the end of the EU, and will be voting for us to stay in if and when I get the opportunity.tufty wrote:That would be a "no" then.pogo wrote:... it might mean the beginning of the end for the EU.
It's the ultramate pogo fantasy
But I am serious. The EU has always been a very dynamic institution, undergoing permanent revolution. That has been its way of resolving most of its conflicts; where countries disagree on e.g. competition policy or employment law, make it an EU matter and come up with a compromise position. The name of the principal behind it is “ever closer union” and it has been the goal of many in the EU since its inception.
But that ground to a halt after the EU constitution failed. Eventually most of its measures were pushed through via the Lisbon Treaty, but I think no-one had any appetite for further reform after that, despite it being badly needed due to the accession of the former Warsaw Pact countries.
Just as it was ratified the financial crisis hit and is still not resolved in the EU. Then the refugee crisis hit and is still far from being resolved. And now security is added to this. These are putting intense pressure on the euro and the Schengen Agreement, threatening to send both into reverse. The EU never stands still and the current situation is certainly not tolerable, and we could see the end of both. And the pressure is not evenly distributed: some countries have it so bad they may end up out of the EU.
Without the euro, without Schengen, and with a handful of countries perhaps out or more semi-detached from the EU, it is in danger of losing its purpose as a superstate, and returning to a being mostly trading bloc. It might still be called the European Union but it will be the end of the EU as we know it.
Re: Politics Thread!
Thanks, that was pretty much what I was going to say, but better put.gravy wrote:That's kind of true. But if you're going to take a path that doesn't work might as well choose the the one that doesn't involve high explosives being dropped on a civillian's boncegumboot wrote:Nobody's better than ISIS. It's all subjective. We kill people through inaction just as much as through action. Pretending that there's a clean way out is just stupid.
What does it say about us as a society if we're not even going to try to find a "clean way out"?
"Oh dear lord, I slightly soiled myself. Oxfam won’t be pleased."
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: Politics Thread!
Like what? Negotiate with them? These are the people who have brutally murdered many non-Muslim civilians unlucky enough to be in their territory, including journalists and aid workers. Negotiation is not an option. The only way to stop them creating their caliphate is militarily, with force. Including air strikes. It’s impossible to prove this but I suspect they would still be expanding their territories without air strikes. Since air strikes started ISIS have gone into reverse, losing significant territory.Barney wrote:What does it say about us as a society if we're not even going to try to find a "clean way out"?
Re: Politics Thread!
Well that's pretty clear.
We should be attacking Assad then? He's killed many more civilians than ISIL so he'd be top priority?
And then after we inevitably brutally murder large swathes of innocent civilians, again in likely larger amounts that ISIL, we should then attack ourselves?
We should be attacking Assad then? He's killed many more civilians than ISIL so he'd be top priority?
And then after we inevitably brutally murder large swathes of innocent civilians, again in likely larger amounts that ISIL, we should then attack ourselves?
Re: Politics Thread!
I think the worse thing here is you don't seem inclined to spend any effort on thinking beyond getting your war on despite certain horrendous consequences balanced against unlikely gains.pogo wrote:Like what? Negotiate with them? These are the people who have brutally murdered many non-Muslim civilians unlucky enough to be in their territory, including journalists and aid workers. Negotiation is not an option. The only way to stop them creating their caliphate is militarily, with force. Including air strikes. It’s impossible to prove this but I suspect they would still be expanding their territories without air strikes. Since air strikes started ISIS have gone into reverse, losing significant territory.Barney wrote:What does it say about us as a society if we're not even going to try to find a "clean way out"?
It's really hawkish.
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: Politics Thread!
I’ve thought on it as I’m sure many others have. So if there is a viable alternative to defeating ISIS militarily what is it?gravy wrote:I think the worse thing here is you don't seem inclined to spend any effort on thinking beyond getting your war on despite certain horrendous consequences balanced against unlikely gains.
It's really hawkish.
Re: Politics Thread!
EMP weapons? Not so much against soldiers but resources and communications.
Re: Politics Thread!
I don't think there is a direct alternative right here right now to defeating (or, at least, engaging) them militarily.pogo wrote:what is it?
But there is a big difference between targetted military action and (necessarily) indiscriminate bombing, both in terms of achievement of short term military objectives, and the long term propaganda battle against radical islam. Especially as bombing campaign necessarily involves working alongside Russia, Assad and / or Turkey, none of whom have the long term welfare of the Syrian people in mind.
"massive retard™", "full of shit™", "tiny bitch™", "retarted™", "a bit of a one trick pony™", "petty™", "simple minded idealistic twat™", "miserable humourless fucker™"
- VNVObit
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 4072
- Joined: Sun Jan 01, 2006 10:03 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: vnvobit
- PSN: VNV_Obit
- Location: London
Re: Politics Thread!
it would help if there was were islamic/arab states involved in the campaign against Isis (particularly the Saudis) so it wasn't non-islam vs Islam but cannot see that happening (I know Turkey have an islamic party in power but they are still relatively speaking, at least to Isis, a secular country)tufty wrote:I don't think there is a direct alternative right here right now to defeating (or, at least, engaging) them militarily.pogo wrote:what is it?
But there is a big difference between targetted military action and (necessarily) indiscriminate bombing, both in terms of achievement of short term military objectives, and the long term propaganda battle against radical islam. Especially as bombing campaign necessarily involves working alongside Russia, Assad and / or Turkey, none of whom have the long term welfare of the Syrian people in mind.
"England is funny, but sometimes she scares me"
Tony Wakeford
My avatar is the cover of Tower of Babel's first single
"Sky is not roof, Earth is not bottom, the world is not yours, you are the world's" from Brown by Grotus
Tony Wakeford
My avatar is the cover of Tower of Babel's first single
"Sky is not roof, Earth is not bottom, the world is not yours, you are the world's" from Brown by Grotus
Re: Politics Thread!
That's a perfectly reasonable argument.pogo wrote:So your solution to ISIS enslaving, raping, brutally killing thousands of innocent civilians would be what? Ask them nicely to stop? They have made it clear that they plan to create a caliphate by conquest, and nothing is going to dissuade them from this, not even other more moderate Muslims. The only thing that will stop them is force, lethal force. They are already losing but show no signs of giving up. Why should they when they control a region the size of a small country and millions in oil revenue?
But the idea that bombing is going to actually fix that just seems completely disconnected to me. Even Cameron's own tests - which I happen to agree with - state he shouldn't be doing it!
It baffles me. I don't understand how anyone can possibly think bombing is actually the solution. I just really, totally, don't get it at all. I'm completely disconnected from that reality and logic. I can't see how it makes things better and I'm reasonably sure it makes things worse. Who in their right mind actually wants this? Why?
We should not, and in my opinion must not, commit to any plan which does not have a clear set of steps leading to the end game of "A secure and stable self governed Syria". And that's simply not in existence no matter how much people may want to wish it true.
Re: Politics Thread!
The Observer puts it well here:
http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfre ... ary-action
Brings up something I hadn't really thought of too which is that effectively we're already pointlessly doing this in Iraq.
http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfre ... ary-action
Brings up something I hadn't really thought of too which is that effectively we're already pointlessly doing this in Iraq.
Re: Politics Thread!
I have been wondering myself why they haven't bombed the oil wells, not even by mistake. Every so often there or in Iraq mistakes happen and they bomb the wrong town but they never seem to make the mistake of hitting the oil fields.pogo wrote: They make most of their money through oil sales. So one effective way to severely hamper their operations, with minimal force and loss of life, is through targeting their oil sales. Not wells as if ISIS are eventually kicked out the people who live there will want those wells left in place. But the pipelines and tankers that are taking oil to the border for export. And that is likely to involve civilian deaths, of oil workers and drivers.
I don't buy though they are not doing it because they maybe worrying about those who come after ISIS. They never worry about that kind of thing. Oil wells on fire, a gigantic polution similar to the one when Saddam bombed the Koweit fields, that could be something to avoid. They may not want to increase the worries on climate change.
There is too much propaganda and to many sides and interests in this war. The West accuses Russia of not bombing ISIS and bombing the other groups against Al Assad. Russia accuses NATO of being more worried about bombing militias that support Al Assad and not to bomb ISIS. In fact they are both bombing ISIS. One ISIS member from this country was wounded by the Russian bombs a few days before Paris attacks and died of the wounds right after. The Russians are bombing ISIS and everybody who opposes Bashar Al Assad. NATO and friends are bombing ISIS and those who support Al Assad, if not even the regular forces. Basically the Russians want Al Assad in, and Nato & Friends want whatever its name in and Al Assad out. In the meantime no one really wants to completly destroy ISIS just yet. They are the excuse for outsiders being there defending their interests. ISIS must have understood that by know and are trying to take advantage of the situation for as long as they can because they know once either al Assad is destroyed, or the non-ISIS group supported by the West disappears, whoever stays goes after ISIS. This game is dangerous and maybe an error and they may give ISIS a lot power in the meantime
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: Politics Thread!
I think avoiding oil wells should be easy as they should be known in advance and should not move. Individuals and vehicles can move, buildings can change use but wells will just stay put. In theory ISIS could be opening new ones but that seems unlikely when they can just use existing ones.
Russia is key and is a lot weaker than they like to portray themselves. They have had a number of recent reverses: the shooting down of the plane when someone has finally got fed up of them popping into NATO air space (they’ve been doing it further north for years). The passenger jet bombing in Egypt. Of course people have less sympathy for Russia, and its claims of Turkey doctoring radar data, after Russia denied it had nothing to do with the downing of Malaysia Air flight 17, itself producing false data to back its claim.
Ukraine is also going badly. They have an expensive stalemate they would like to get out of and a Crimea that is struggling under their rule. Most recently without electricity as Crimean rebels cut power from the Ukrainian side. Most of Crimea could be without power for a month or more, just a winter arrives.
Domestically they were suffering a deep recession due to sanctions already. Then the oil prices fell, hitting government finances more and stopping Putin bribing his way out of trouble. And finally the bombing in Egypt and now sanctions against Turkey also hit Russians hard as they are their two most popular holiday destinations. Though numbers were down due the recession they have now stopped going altogether.
This does not mean they are about to give up, but they face much stronger pressures domestically now than for a very long time, and it could be a long winter of disquiet. The only unknown is Putin as he’s not one to give up altogether, but he could cut Assad loose if it helps him consolidate his support closer to home.
Russia is key and is a lot weaker than they like to portray themselves. They have had a number of recent reverses: the shooting down of the plane when someone has finally got fed up of them popping into NATO air space (they’ve been doing it further north for years). The passenger jet bombing in Egypt. Of course people have less sympathy for Russia, and its claims of Turkey doctoring radar data, after Russia denied it had nothing to do with the downing of Malaysia Air flight 17, itself producing false data to back its claim.
Ukraine is also going badly. They have an expensive stalemate they would like to get out of and a Crimea that is struggling under their rule. Most recently without electricity as Crimean rebels cut power from the Ukrainian side. Most of Crimea could be without power for a month or more, just a winter arrives.
Domestically they were suffering a deep recession due to sanctions already. Then the oil prices fell, hitting government finances more and stopping Putin bribing his way out of trouble. And finally the bombing in Egypt and now sanctions against Turkey also hit Russians hard as they are their two most popular holiday destinations. Though numbers were down due the recession they have now stopped going altogether.
This does not mean they are about to give up, but they face much stronger pressures domestically now than for a very long time, and it could be a long winter of disquiet. The only unknown is Putin as he’s not one to give up altogether, but he could cut Assad loose if it helps him consolidate his support closer to home.

