Politics Thread!
- merman
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 10943
- Joined: Wed Feb 16, 2005 1:44 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: merman1974
- Yahoo Messenger: andrewrfisher
- Location: Skegness, England
- Contact:
Re: Politics Thread!
Public sector borrowing for November 2015 up to £14.2 billion, a billion more than November 2014.
Borrowing for the year has reached £66.8 billion, just £2 billion short of Osborne's target for the WHOLE FINANCIAL YEAR.
Total debt is now up to 80.5% of GDP and rising.
And the Office for National Statistics has revised down the second and third quarter growth estimates, and is now saying growth for the year will be 2.1% not the 2.3% Osborne based his calculations for the Autumn Statement on.
However you look at it his figures are increasingly inaccurate.
Borrowing for the year has reached £66.8 billion, just £2 billion short of Osborne's target for the WHOLE FINANCIAL YEAR.
Total debt is now up to 80.5% of GDP and rising.
And the Office for National Statistics has revised down the second and third quarter growth estimates, and is now saying growth for the year will be 2.1% not the 2.3% Osborne based his calculations for the Autumn Statement on.
However you look at it his figures are increasingly inaccurate.
Twitter, Xbox, Wii U and Steam - merman1974
ZZAP is back - https://www.patreon.com/zzapmagazine
ZZAP is back - https://www.patreon.com/zzapmagazine
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: Politics Thread!
Cherrypicking meaningless data again. November is just one month. The year to date borrowing is down, and that is expected to be so in the final figures. Whether we will hit the government’s target of eliminating the deficit by the end of this parliament is unclear but reducing the deficit every year is the right way to do it. While we have a deficit the debt is not going down, obviously, though the ratio of debt to GDP may peak before the deficit is eliminated due the economy growing.
As for “increasingly inaccurate” the ONS revises data all the time, by the odd fraction of a percent, making it more accurate. The revisions here are not that significant, especially on government finances; government revenues often overshoot or undershoot by much more from year to year. Even the odd day, such as an extra bank holiday, can make more of a difference (1 day being about 0.3% of the year).
As for “increasingly inaccurate” the ONS revises data all the time, by the odd fraction of a percent, making it more accurate. The revisions here are not that significant, especially on government finances; government revenues often overshoot or undershoot by much more from year to year. Even the odd day, such as an extra bank holiday, can make more of a difference (1 day being about 0.3% of the year).
Re: Politics Thread!
Osbourne is no archer. No dartsman. He misses his targets wide.merman wrote:Public sector borrowing for November 2015 up to £14.2 billion, a billion more than November 2014.
Borrowing for the year has reached £66.8 billion, just £2 billion short of Osborne's target for the WHOLE FINANCIAL YEAR.
Total debt is now up to 80.5% of GDP and rising.
And the Office for National Statistics has revised down the second and third quarter growth estimates, and is now saying growth for the year will be 2.1% not the 2.3% Osborne based his calculations for the Autumn Statement on.
However you look at it his figures are increasingly inaccurate.
But now we're locked in. A surplus is required. There's nothing left to cut! What's he gonna do ?
In local news. The Tatton conservative club, has been vacated, and will soon be occupied by Samantha Cameron's mums "luxury furniture business". I find this very suspect. This building has been occupied by Tories since 1912.
http://www.knutsfordguardian.co.uk/news ... ring_2016/
And our local Tory councillor "offed" himself, due to inappropriate behaviour..
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-ma ... r-35047198
Trippy vibes...
http://soundcloud.com/two-gapper
http://soundcloud.com/two-gapper
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: Politics Thread!
We will see. I recall five years ago that many on the left said there should be no cuts, that cuts would cause permanent harm to the economy. Yet the cuts happened, and the economy still recovered. That job cuts would result in mass long-term unemployment, except we now have the lowest unemployment for almost a decade and record numbers in work. The economy is in a much better state now, so will be even better able to cope with spending cuts.(o)(o) wrote:Osbourne is no archer. No dartsman. He misses his targets wide.
But now we're locked in. A surplus is required. There's nothing left to cut! What's he gonna do ?
Arguably it’s the best time for them: the BOE is getting closer and closer to raising rates, but one thing that might delay that is a drop in demand from government as it makes savings. Make savings now, get govt. spending back into surplus, so when the next recession arrives it will be easier to increase spending to soften the pain of it.
Re: Politics Thread!
The problem with all these things is that you don't get to run the experiment twice. It is perfectly possible we would have had a faster recovery had the cuts not gone in. And, of course, in the end due to Osbourne shifting the goalposts the actual cuts he ran were actually more similar to the ones that Labour had proposed than to his original plan.pogo wrote:We will see. I recall five years ago that many on the left said there should be no cuts, that cuts would cause permanent harm to the economy. Yet the cuts happened, and the economy still recovered. That job cuts would result in mass long-term unemployment, except we now have the lowest unemployment for almost a decade and record numbers in work.
As to the latter, it still feels to me like there is something funny going on in the job market. Usually when employment dips to this level wages start to rise quite precipitately but they're being held down this time. What is causing that? Or is it that the unemployment figures aren't accurately comparable to previous ones?
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: Politics Thread!
The problem with that hypothesis – that we could have had a faster recovery without cuts – is “no cuts” was simply not an option. In that sense it was impossible. We had a massive deficit, perhaps the largest in the world, and no other way to reduce it. I do not recall Labour’s plans but I doubt they involved a civil service pay freeze and cutting a million civil service jobs. The unions would simply have not allowed it.Dio wrote:The problem with all these things is that you don't get to run the experiment twice. It is perfectly possible we would have had a faster recovery had the cuts not gone in. And, of course, in the end due to Osbourne shifting the goalposts the actual cuts he ran were actually more similar to the ones that Labour had proposed than to his original plan.
I suspect it’s largely psychological. We have just recovered from the worst recession in living memory. Although unemployment did not get too high many people lost their jobs, in government, in manufacturing, in the city, and have had to find new work. The recovery in the EU is still fragile, and a significant number of people here are refugees from that. So many people are not pushing for higher wages, they are just happy to have work at all.As to the latter, it still feels to me like there is something funny going on in the job market. Usually when employment dips to this level wages start to rise quite precipitately but they're being held down this time. What is causing that? Or is it that the unemployment figures aren't accurately comparable to previous ones?
This could continue for a while. The supply of unemployed people from the continent in particular is not about to run out. Unless the government contrives to lose the referendum and we leave the EU. That would let them at least meet their immigration targets, but the consequences for the labour market, for trade, for tourism, for the city would be dire.
- merman
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 10943
- Joined: Wed Feb 16, 2005 1:44 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: merman1974
- Yahoo Messenger: andrewrfisher
- Location: Skegness, England
- Contact:
Re: Politics Thread!
pogo wrote:Cherrypicking meaningless data again. November is just one month. The year to date borrowing is down, and that is expected to be so in the final figures. Whether we will hit the government’s target of eliminating the deficit by the end of this parliament is unclear but reducing the deficit every year is the right way to do it. While we have a deficit the debt is not going down, obviously, though the ratio of debt to GDP may peak before the deficit is eliminated due the economy growing.
As for “increasingly inaccurate” the ONS revises data all the time, by the odd fraction of a percent, making it more accurate. The revisions here are not that significant, especially on government finances; government revenues often overshoot or undershoot by much more from year to year. Even the odd day, such as an extra bank holiday, can make more of a difference (1 day being about 0.3% of the year).
Borrowing was up in October, the worst October figure ever. Barring a huge tax windfall every month and growth way beyond what has been achieved so far Osborne cannot meet his own borrowing target - which he revised three times anyway. And last November's figures were boosted by one-off fines netting the Treasury £1billion, making this year's figure even worse. He cannot rely on selling off assets to balance the books, especially when he sells off things that bring an income in.
The ONS revised four of its last seven quarter growth estimates. That's significant. Services growth is down again. Manufacturing continues to shrink. Retail sales are slumping, even with Christmas. There is no miracle recovery.
Even if Osborne left 11 Downing Street tomorrow, he has added over £800 BILLION to the public debt. That's not responsible and certainly not the way to run the economy. He was supposed to be reducing debt, but now it is higher than ever at 80.5% of GDP. He has saddled future generations with repayments, having lost the AAA credit rating.
Twitter, Xbox, Wii U and Steam - merman1974
ZZAP is back - https://www.patreon.com/zzapmagazine
ZZAP is back - https://www.patreon.com/zzapmagazine
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: Politics Thread!
You keep making this point. But the only way for him to be reducing debt would be for the budget to be in surplus by now. That would have required much deeper, faster cuts, at least twice as fast as actually happened. Are you really saying we should have done this?merman wrote:Even if Osborne left 11 Downing Street tomorrow, he has added over £800 BILLION to the public debt. That's not responsible and certainly not the way to run the economy. He was supposed to be reducing debt, but now it is higher than ever at 80.5% of GDP. He has saddled future generations with repayments, having lost the AAA credit rating.
Or what other policy are you advocating, that would have eliminated the deficit by now? There really is none, the deficit was too large for economic growth or tax rises to eliminate it, it had to be mostly cuts.
Re: Politics Thread!
What ?pogo wrote:We will see. I recall five years ago that many on the left said there should be no cuts, that cuts would cause permanent harm to the economy. Yet the cuts happened, and the economy still recovered. That job cuts would result in mass long-term unemployment, except we now have the lowest unemployment for almost a decade and record numbers in work. The economy is in a much better state now, so will be even better able to cope with spending cuts.(o)(o) wrote:Osbourne is no archer. No dartsman. He misses his targets wide.
But now we're locked in. A surplus is required. There's nothing left to cut! What's he gonna do ?
.
You seriously equate cutting one job in into two and hence creating a workforce of part-timers that struggle to get by as much as those that are out of work as 'record numbers in work' ie: double the workforce with half the actual 'reall' jobs?
Forgive me. Let's not forget the most pious of social consciousness of attacking 0-H contracts that the tories cleverly used as the diversionary scapegoat that takes away from their business as usual plan to cook the employment books and make the country look as if it's working, on part time contracts.
You gotta fucking laugh !
Lork oh lordy, my bottom's on fire!
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: Politics Thread!
Rather than ask you where you got your “data” from I checked the ONS for what has actually been happening. From here e.g. is the graph of number of people in work and hours worked, both indexed to 100 from just after the 2010 election, or around when the new govt.’s economic policies were starting to come into effect.k345y wrote:You seriously equate cutting one job in into two and hence creating a workforce of part-timers that struggle to get by as much as those that are out of work as 'record numbers in work' ie: double the workforce with half the actual 'reall' jobs?

As you can see the hours worked has risen faster than the number in work, which itself has recovered well. That means hours worked per person has increased, not decreased, implying less part time work. Notably the recovery in hours worked started before the recovery in employment, in early 2011, suggesting the economy was already getting back on track then. The headline unemployment rate took a little longer to improve, and GDP growth wobbled a little in 2012 around the Olympics, so it was not until 2013 that the trend was obvious. But by then the recovery had been underway for a couple of years.
As I’ve written before I think the rapid growth in employment, and fall in unemployment, has been very healthy. I have not been worried about e.g. low wage growth as that should have returned to normal when unemployment falls enough. And it [wage growth] has. It looks low still but with zero inflation wage growth of 2% is quite healthy. If it were much higher the BoE would probably start raising rates (they have said so explicitly).
And similarly I am not worried about too many people working part time. That was a natural consequence of the recession and there not being as much work to go around, and was one reason unemployment did not rise too high. But the best antidote to that is a recovery and lots of new, full time, jobs being created. Which is what we’ve had, with average hours moving up as many people who want to move back from part time to full time.
Re: Politics Thread!
Averaging hours worked over people in work doesn't mean more people are working full time.
And it still doesn't account for the thousands on 0-H and below accountable contracts, if they're lucky to even hold one, that are not counted as in the employ of a countable employer.
There's many, many people working over their hours, that graph is yet another typical cold figure that you and your ilk seem to think is the real world.
And it still doesn't account for the thousands on 0-H and below accountable contracts, if they're lucky to even hold one, that are not counted as in the employ of a countable employer.
There's many, many people working over their hours, that graph is yet another typical cold figure that you and your ilk seem to think is the real world.
Lork oh lordy, my bottom's on fire!
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: Politics Thread!
My point is that the data shows not only are more people in work but they are working longer. This does not automatically mean less people are working part time but that’s as the number working “part time” is based on a largely arbitrary measure, less than 30 or 35 hours I think, so is a less useful indicator. E.g. someone I worked with took an afternoon off each week for family reasons, with a job that was normally 37.5 hours a week, so worked less than 35 but was not considered part time (he did it by sacrificing his annual leave, so worked as much as any of us).
Long term the number of people working part time has been growing. Very long term, not just in the last five or ten years. One of the main reasons is the growth of women in the labour force. Here e.g. is the ONS again:
Long term the number of people working part time has been growing. Very long term, not just in the last five or ten years. One of the main reasons is the growth of women in the labour force. Here e.g. is the ONS again:
And most people would say it’s a positive that more women are working. The proportion of women working part time has been pretty steady, but with more of them in the workforce the % working part time has gone up.Over the past 40 years there has been a rise in the percentage of women aged 16 to 64 in employment and a fall in the percentage of men. In April to June 2013 around 67% of women aged 16 to 64 were in work, an increase from 53% in 1971. For men the percentage fell to 76% in 2013 from 92% in 1971.
In April to June 2013, looking at the not seasonally adjusted series, around 13.4 million women aged 16 to 64 were in work (42% part-time) and 15.3 million men (12% part-time). For those who worked full-time there were differences in the average hours worked per week. For example, full-time men worked on average 44 hours per week whilst full-time women worked 40 hours per week. While there have been increases in the number of women in work, the percentage of them doing a part-time role has fluctuated between 42-45% over the past 30 years.
Re: Politics Thread!
Yeah, that's a good thing, isn't it?pogo wrote: The proportion of women working part time has been pretty steady, but with more of them in the workforce the % working part time has gone up.
Let's create more part time positions for 'them' and be thankful for the scraps of work we offer them, at leat it looks like more folks are working. Hoorah! Hoorah for the recovery.
Lork oh lordy, my bottom's on fire!
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: Politics Thread!
It is a good thing, that more and more women are working. For their benefit, for the benefit of society. Fact is they are more likely to work part time, about three times as likely as men, and this has been true for a long time. So if more women work the proportion working part time goes up.
It’s not the only factor. The decline of traditional industries such as coal mining, steelmaking, manufacturing, where everyone would work to the same hours or fixed shifts for practical reasons. Service sector work is much more flexible, allowing for a greater range of working hours including part time. These factors are of course related, as many traditional industries did not welcome women, so their decline has led to more equality in the workforce.
These are long term, positive changes, as is the growth of part time employment. The vast majority of people working part time do so because it suits them. The few who would rather be working full time should now be able to find such work, now the labour market has recovered. But the number of people working part time will not return to pre-recession levels, due the long term changes in the market.
It’s not the only factor. The decline of traditional industries such as coal mining, steelmaking, manufacturing, where everyone would work to the same hours or fixed shifts for practical reasons. Service sector work is much more flexible, allowing for a greater range of working hours including part time. These factors are of course related, as many traditional industries did not welcome women, so their decline has led to more equality in the workforce.
These are long term, positive changes, as is the growth of part time employment. The vast majority of people working part time do so because it suits them. The few who would rather be working full time should now be able to find such work, now the labour market has recovered. But the number of people working part time will not return to pre-recession levels, due the long term changes in the market.

