pogo wrote:They are migrants. That is the most accurate word for them as they are not all or even mostly refugees.
They may not all be asylum seekers but technically most are refugees not migrants.
How do you know that? If they are refugees then they are in a safe country and should apply for asylum there. It is despite recent attacks a very safe and civilised country. They have no need to flee France for their safety, so their primary reason for wanting to come here is economic. Understandable, given the state of France’s economy, but we have no moral or legal obligation to let in everyone who wants to come and work here.
pogo wrote:but we have no moral or legal obligation to let in everyone who wants to come and work here.
That's a handy argument, isn't it, given that the route in is via continental Europe rather than through the Gibraltar straits and up the Atlantic coast of Spain, Portugal and France.
You really are a soulless fucking cunt. I hope you get arse cancer.
"massive retard™", "full of shit™", "tiny bitch™", "retarted™", "a bit of a one trick pony™", "petty™", "simple minded idealistic twat™", "miserable humourless fucker™"
I stand by what I wrote. We should do more. We should have acted earlier before refugees took things into their own hands and came to Europe. As should have other countries. But there is no way we can or should take all the migrants who want to come here.
Suppose we did. Suppose we opened up our borders and said anyone who wanted could come. There would be a flood of people, drawn to our strong economy and already diverse ethnic mix. Probably we would be one of the top three destinations for migrants, with Sweden and Germany, so receiving hundreds of thousands a year, and we would not be able to cope.
Sweden and Germany should not have to deal with this either. But they signed an agreement with other countries to abolish national borders, without creating a central border or refugee authority. It’s still not too late for them to stem the tide, perhaps by tying debt relief to aid to Greece for a proper migrant processing system. As it is, with relationships and finances so fragile because of the economic crisis, Germany cannot expect any help from other countries with its migrant problem.
Maybe they should just cancel the Eurostar, open up the Chunnel and let everyone who wants to come walk through.
Britain is so rich, all the gold in the Bank of England and all the money in the City could easily pay for millions of people to come to the UK and settle there.
If Germany takes in 1 million people per year, why couldn't Britain do the same or more?
Boy: "Have you met monsters before?" The Doctor: "Yes."
Boy: "Are you scared of them?" The Doctor: "No, they are scared of me!"
Germany is a much bigger country than here. And even they are struggling with so many. The crisis is ongoing there but looks like it could claim the biggest scalp in European politics, Angela Merkel, as it could be fatal to her political support. The problem again is the Schengen agreement. While migrants can roam freely across much of Europe they are naturally gravitating towards the most welcoming, accepting, prosperous countries. Merkel’s open door policy has backfired horribly for her.
The way it’s meant to work is refugees stop when they reach a safe country, are processed and then if they cannot go back are resettled often to another country. The problem is that’s not been happening. They have been reaching camps in Turkey, Lebanon where they can be processed. But resettlement has not been happening quickly enough as countries have been too slow and miserly in the numbers they will take. Refugees have been taking matters into their own hands and making their own way to Europe, getting mixed up with economic migrants taking advantage of the same routes.
What I disagree with is opening up our borders to anyone who wants to come here, as I really do think that would lead to hundreds of thousands coming here, comparable numbers to Germany who are barely coping. We might even get some from Germany if they decided they would be better off here. If you have open borders then you get what is happening in the Schengen zone: migrants who are mostly after the same things almost all going to the same two or three countries. And the UK would be one of those countries, maybe the most popular.
I don’t think Schengen will survive this in its current form. Maybe the members will introduce much stronger and more centralised mechanisms for refugees, so those arriving can be sure of equal treatment wherever they apply. Or maybe they will bring back national borders, border fences and checks for everyone, like it was before Schengen.
What I disagree with is opening up our borders to anyone who wants to come here, as I really do think that would lead to hundreds of thousands coming here, comparable numbers to Germany who are barely coping.
20,000 over five years is far too low, 20,000 a year would be much better. And not for five years but more open ended, so the total depends on the time it is necessary.
The problem is it needs another 20+ countries to make similar commitments to really make a difference. Whatever we do on our own is not enough. Of course some countries are struggling with migrants reaching the EU of their own accord, but that is partly due to not enough being done to help refugees stuck in camps in the Middle East.
As Charles Grant, the director of the Centre for European Reform, observes in a forthcoming European Commission position paper, Britain is increasingly “unpopular” in Europe and – thanks to our response to the migrant crisis – is now often seen as the “nasty” country.
As some 300 of Britain most senior judges wrote in an open letter this week, the British response – to take 20,000 refugees over five years, when Germany will take a million this year – is “inadequate”. In Brussels the word more often used is “shameful”.
The thing to remember about Germany is it did not volunteer to take a million migrants, not refugees as that last quote implies. If they knew 12 or 24 months ago what they know now I’m sure they would have suspended their open borders policy long ago, and forced the rest of the Schengen Area to come up with a response. It’s too late now; the migrants are in Germany and other countries are in no hurry to relieve Germany of its burden. So saying we are taking too few refugees by comparing us to Germany’s migrant problem makes no sense.
Germany is part of the Schengen Area, which like the euro has proven itself to be a badly designed EU concept and not fit for purpose. Like the financial crisis showed the flaws in the euro, now the refugee crisis is showing the flaws in the Schengen Agreement. I really can’t see it coming out the other end of this without major changes.
merman wrote:Cameron going heavy on the pigswill at PMQs.
New Hinckley reactor "on target" - that's funny, EDF Energy announced they are struggling to find backers
Google tax bill - Corbyn challenged him on Google only paying the equivalent of 3% tax. Cameron disputed the figure. Yes, tax experts are saying it's closer to 2.7%.
"Bunch of migrants" - in trying to put down Corbyn, Cameron called the refugees struggling to survive in the "Jungle" camps near Calais (fleeing persecution, war and the mess the West created in Iraq and Afghanistan) this hateful phrase, on Holocaust Memorial Day of all days.
#CameronMustGo
And now everyone's talking about the "bunch of migrants" comment, instead of the Google sweetheart deal and the illegal bedroom tax. Job done, I'd say.
Ollie wrote:And now everyone's talking about the "bunch of migrants" comment, instead of the Google sweetheart deal and the illegal bedroom tax. Job done, I'd say.
Job done by Corbyn, after he recently visited the camp in Calais to put this at the top of the agenda. Credit to him for doing what he thinks is right, but there are no votes in it. Even among Labour supporters there’s little support for more immigration; remember last election that UKIP came second in many solidly Labour constituencies.