The Apple thread
- merman
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 10943
- Joined: Wed Feb 16, 2005 1:44 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: merman1974
- Yahoo Messenger: andrewrfisher
- Location: Skegness, England
- Contact:
Re: The Apple thread
Twitter, Xbox, Wii U and Steam - merman1974
ZZAP is back - https://www.patreon.com/zzapmagazine
ZZAP is back - https://www.patreon.com/zzapmagazine
Re: The Apple thread
Actually, a more plausible reason is that if you leave the account with the old password, somebody else who knows the original password might use it to clean up.pogo wrote:Except it now seems that it was not the thoughtless act of a local official, but the FBI itself which ordered the password changed. They deliberately changed the password, in effect stopping Apple getting the data for them. Why? Hard to believe they did not know what they were doing, especially in such an important case. The only plausible reason is they did it to put Apple on the spot. I.e. the real prize is not the data in a largely solved case, but Apple’s compliance, as if Apple can be forced to break their encryption now they will be unable to refuse in future cases.
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: The Apple thread
How? The phone is in FBI hands, no-one else is going to have access to it.
Also why not just change it back? I mean for the FBI to tell the local officials to change the password they must have had some record of the original password, and presumably made note of the new one. Can’t they just change it back? Apple might impose some restrictions (some services stop you re-using recent passwords) but could surely disable this for this account. Then with the old password restored the phone would do a backup. Unless the FBI changed the password and threw away the records of them.
Also why not just change it back? I mean for the FBI to tell the local officials to change the password they must have had some record of the original password, and presumably made note of the new one. Can’t they just change it back? Apple might impose some restrictions (some services stop you re-using recent passwords) but could surely disable this for this account. Then with the old password restored the phone would do a backup. Unless the FBI changed the password and threw away the records of them.
Re: The Apple thread
Purging the back-ups, not the phone itself. That's a separate problem.pogo wrote:How? The phone is in FBI hands, no-one else is going to have access to it.
If anybody knows the original password, then there's been a fundamental fuck-up in Apple's security implementation.pogo wrote:Also why not just change it back? I mean for the FBI to tell the local officials to change the password they must have had some record of the original password, and presumably made note of the new one. Can’t they just change it back?
Password reset requests don't rely on knowing the original password. You don't ask to be told what your original password was.
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: The Apple thread
Who is going to purge the backups? The shooters worked with no-one. They are hardly likely to give someone else their password and say “if the worst happens go online and wipe my backups”. Or, if they were that paranoid about backups they would just disable them, and/or not use the phone for anything important.
I was assuming that whoever reset it had access to the original password. I.e. his employers who issued the phone may have set up the account for him. Which makes sense if they were then able to change the password. That’s normally only possible if you have the current password, or are the legitimate owner of the phone and can prove it.
I was assuming that whoever reset it had access to the original password. I.e. his employers who issued the phone may have set up the account for him. Which makes sense if they were then able to change the password. That’s normally only possible if you have the current password, or are the legitimate owner of the phone and can prove it.
Re: The Apple thread
Y'all gotten me confused. There's the phone 4 digit passcode that the Feds want. There's the iCloud password that needs to be set on iCloud and the device has to match that else the phone won't backup anymore. You can change iCloud password in a browser and access some stuff there if the phone has whatever apps synced. Unless they used iTunes for backups. But then the Feds only want the phone unlocked so they can trace recent usage so all they need is the passcode that they want to be able to brute force, which wouldn't be that brutey with a 4 digit code. There's no way apple would let anyone bypass that the lock screen bit.
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: The Apple thread
I think it’s six digits, which would take a very long time to brute force, and anyway the iPhone would stop accepting tries after a few failed attempts and lock the phone for good. the FBI want Apple to write software that disables the locking, so they can make as many tries as they want. And software that accepts tries electronically over the Lightning connector so they can do it in a reasonable time and not drive a series of interns crazy.
Apple have argued that this is unreasonable: no reading of the law allows the FBI to compel a company to invest time and effort making something new, especially a company that done nothing wrong itself.
They have also argued that it is incredible to claim that this is meant to be used only once. Once created there is no shortage of locked phones out there in the hands of law enforcement. In the last few days I think New York have said they have over a hundred phones they would like to use this on, and that’s just one state. Once it is created and precedent established Apple will find it hard to refuse and it will become a common tool for law enforcement.
And what about other countries? If Apple cannot refuse a legal request from US cops what about those in Europe? Or Russia? Or China? Again, once it is created other countries could demand similar access, and Apple would find it hard to refuse without seriously pissing off the relevant governments.
Apple have argued that this is unreasonable: no reading of the law allows the FBI to compel a company to invest time and effort making something new, especially a company that done nothing wrong itself.
They have also argued that it is incredible to claim that this is meant to be used only once. Once created there is no shortage of locked phones out there in the hands of law enforcement. In the last few days I think New York have said they have over a hundred phones they would like to use this on, and that’s just one state. Once it is created and precedent established Apple will find it hard to refuse and it will become a common tool for law enforcement.
And what about other countries? If Apple cannot refuse a legal request from US cops what about those in Europe? Or Russia? Or China? Again, once it is created other countries could demand similar access, and Apple would find it hard to refuse without seriously pissing off the relevant governments.
Re: The Apple thread
Now this is the almighty FBI, isn't it? Couldn't they just take the iPhone apart, desolder the flash chips and read them directly? I can't remember if the iPhone uses some kind of FS encryption at boot or something...
They always boast about stuff like how they could decode a nulled HD by reading the platters with electron microscopes or whatever. Apparently the prowess of the agencies isn't as good as advertised...
They always boast about stuff like how they could decode a nulled HD by reading the platters with electron microscopes or whatever. Apparently the prowess of the agencies isn't as good as advertised...
Re: The Apple thread
If Apple did their job right (and they probably did in this instance) the decryption keys required to make any sense of the rest of the mass storage will be stored within the CPU SoC.
If not for that, you could trivially back up the flash, make a few attempts, then restore the flash and carry on trying. If it were only four digits then it'd be done by now.
If not for that, you could trivially back up the flash, make a few attempts, then restore the flash and carry on trying. If it were only four digits then it'd be done by now.
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: The Apple thread
It’s reportedly six digits. Even if they found a way to disable / bypass the logic that destroys the data after ten attempts it would take a very long time to try all million combinations. That’s why the FBI wants a way to do it electronically.
The encryption is done by combining the passcode with a code in the secure area. So you need both, with one being in the hands of the owner and the other unreachable in the phone, to decrypt the data. As for backing it up there’s no way to do that.
Apart from Apple’s iCloud backups. Those must have limited encryption as they partly exist to allow users to transfer their data to a new phone. That won’t work if the encryption is tied to the secure area of a particular phone. And we know Apple can deliver the data in iCloud backups if they exist. In this case the FBI changed the iCloud password so backups stopped being made, but there is one from only a few weeks before.
The encryption is done by combining the passcode with a code in the secure area. So you need both, with one being in the hands of the owner and the other unreachable in the phone, to decrypt the data. As for backing it up there’s no way to do that.
Apart from Apple’s iCloud backups. Those must have limited encryption as they partly exist to allow users to transfer their data to a new phone. That won’t work if the encryption is tied to the secure area of a particular phone. And we know Apple can deliver the data in iCloud backups if they exist. In this case the FBI changed the iCloud password so backups stopped being made, but there is one from only a few weeks before.
- merman
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 10943
- Joined: Wed Feb 16, 2005 1:44 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: merman1974
- Yahoo Messenger: andrewrfisher
- Location: Skegness, England
- Contact:
Re: The Apple thread
The FBI wants Apple to bypass all the security on the phone so they don't need to guess the pass code - because if you try more than 10 times the device locks up.pogo wrote:It’s reportedly six digits. Even if they found a way to disable / bypass the logic that destroys the data after ten attempts it would take a very long time to try all million combinations. That’s why the FBI wants a way to do it electronically.
The encryption is done by combining the passcode with a code in the secure area. So you need both, with one being in the hands of the owner and the other unreachable in the phone, to decrypt the data. As for backing it up there’s no way to do that.
Apart from Apple’s iCloud backups. Those must have limited encryption as they partly exist to allow users to transfer their data to a new phone. That won’t work if the encryption is tied to the secure area of a particular phone. And we know Apple can deliver the data in iCloud backups if they exist. In this case the FBI changed the iCloud password so backups stopped being made, but there is one from only a few weeks before.
Then the FBI want to install software on the device so they can check for deleted files and messages.
The two combined are a massive security risk for every Apple device.
Twitter, Xbox, Wii U and Steam - merman1974
ZZAP is back - https://www.patreon.com/zzapmagazine
ZZAP is back - https://www.patreon.com/zzapmagazine
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: The Apple thread
Not immediately but eventually. The FBI only want this for one device and are happy to let Apple control the whole process, so it is done at Apple and the software never leaves Apple.
But if the FBI win then law enforcement up and down the US will want the same access, which Apple will find hard to resist once the software is written and legal precedent is established. Then once the US has it other countries will insist on similar access. China in particular will want it to better keep an eye on their citizens. It’s hard to see Apple keeping control of it then.
Anyway, it‘s all BS. I was reminded of this by the news today of Ashley Guindon, the US cop shot and killed on her first day on the job, when attending a domestic violence incident. That could only happen in the US, as could the San Bernardino shooting, because of the prevalence of guns. Introduce sensible gun laws as here and radical nutjobs won’t have access to guns of any sort, never mind the military weapons they used. Unlocking the phone is just a sideshow, like the other distractions they come up with when there’s a mass shooting, like mental health.
But if the FBI win then law enforcement up and down the US will want the same access, which Apple will find hard to resist once the software is written and legal precedent is established. Then once the US has it other countries will insist on similar access. China in particular will want it to better keep an eye on their citizens. It’s hard to see Apple keeping control of it then.
Anyway, it‘s all BS. I was reminded of this by the news today of Ashley Guindon, the US cop shot and killed on her first day on the job, when attending a domestic violence incident. That could only happen in the US, as could the San Bernardino shooting, because of the prevalence of guns. Introduce sensible gun laws as here and radical nutjobs won’t have access to guns of any sort, never mind the military weapons they used. Unlocking the phone is just a sideshow, like the other distractions they come up with when there’s a mass shooting, like mental health.
- Deckard
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 10748
- Joined: Fri Jun 18, 2004 11:27 pm 0
- Location: Falmouth, Cornwall, UK
Re: The Apple thread
Good point actually - I presume the odds of dying from a terrorist attack there are nothing compared to just being gunned down in the USA because of the prevalence of guns.pogo wrote:Not immediately but eventually. The FBI only want this for one device and are happy to let Apple control the whole process, so it is done at Apple and the software never leaves Apple.
But if the FBI win then law enforcement up and down the US will want the same access, which Apple will find hard to resist once the software is written and legal precedent is established. Then once the US has it other countries will insist on similar access. China in particular will want it to better keep an eye on their citizens. It’s hard to see Apple keeping control of it then.
Anyway, it‘s all BS. I was reminded of this by the news today of Ashley Guindon, the US cop shot and killed on her first day on the job, when attending a domestic violence incident. That could only happen in the US, as could the San Bernardino shooting, because of the prevalence of guns. Introduce sensible gun laws as here and radical nutjobs won’t have access to guns of any sort, never mind the military weapons they used. Unlocking the phone is just a sideshow, like the other distractions they come up with when there’s a mass shooting, like mental health.
http://www.techjuice.pk/a-data-scientis ... st-attack/
Now with a new Mac Mini Pro so dont judge me !
Re: The Apple thread
Even in the US, the biggest risk factor for getting shot is owning a gun.
Re: The Apple thread
The odds of a gunman getting shot from a civilian owning a gun for their own protection are even greater.
..but still, Piers Morgan apparently has it all figured out.
..but still, Piers Morgan apparently has it all figured out.
http://gizmodo.com/piers-morgan-doesnt- ... 1761617866Piers Morgan wrote:Let Apple open the damn back door, let the FBI know what's on the phone, then close it again.
This isn't difficult.


