Politics Thread!
Re: Politics Thread!
Very much enjoying pogo's extremely eloquent silence on clusterfuckgeddon 2016 
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: Politics Thread!
Not sure what I can add. He is clearly motivated by a desire to damage the government ahead of the Brexit vote. I can’t believe he is suddenly against benefit cuts or surprised by them. It would be hard to believe of any Conservative minister, doubly so IDS. Nor is it a desire to hurt the government next election. It’s far too early for that; the election will hinge much more on who is leading Labour in 2020 than a political row in 2016. Remember the “omnishambles” budget and how that was supposedly a fatal mistake by Osbourne?
So it’s about Brexit. And looking on the bright side if IDS feels he needs to throw himself on the bonfire to kickstart their campaign it must be going badly. If IDS now feels free to dedicate himself full time to it then it can only help the In case.
So it’s about Brexit. And looking on the bright side if IDS feels he needs to throw himself on the bonfire to kickstart their campaign it must be going badly. If IDS now feels free to dedicate himself full time to it then it can only help the In case.
Re: Politics Thread!
I completely agree, IDS is a lying liar and his resignation letter comes from pure self interest coupled with an infamously petulant rage. That and he's a bit thick.
The core of it is true though; the cons are using economics to pursue an ideological agenda to try and deliver what's best for them and their's rather than the country as a whole.
He's on Marr right now. Says he didn't know about the tax cuts in the budget until they were publicly announced. Is that really right? Imagine trying to run a business that way.
As for the rest of them? The shine's definitely coming off of Osbourne as a safe pair of hands to be the next leader.
Putting the economics aside the budget was incredibly badly sold and a story now dominated by his attacks on the vulnerable, an embarrassing U turn and IDS's Geoffrey Howe impersonation. All that tax money he's given away, no one seems to care.
He's got a (self promoted) reputation for smart and astute political manoeuvring which is what's needed to pick up after Cameron but is looking like a bit of clown this morning.
The truth is IDSageddon was avoidable if at the least they'd pretended to listen to him. High handed arrogance could well likely have much wider ramifications for Cameron / Osbourne.
In fairness to him orderly succession is a near impossible task when the Tory party decides to self immolate. Hugely entertaining for everyone else to watch though.
The core of it is true though; the cons are using economics to pursue an ideological agenda to try and deliver what's best for them and their's rather than the country as a whole.
He's on Marr right now. Says he didn't know about the tax cuts in the budget until they were publicly announced. Is that really right? Imagine trying to run a business that way.
As for the rest of them? The shine's definitely coming off of Osbourne as a safe pair of hands to be the next leader.
Putting the economics aside the budget was incredibly badly sold and a story now dominated by his attacks on the vulnerable, an embarrassing U turn and IDS's Geoffrey Howe impersonation. All that tax money he's given away, no one seems to care.
He's got a (self promoted) reputation for smart and astute political manoeuvring which is what's needed to pick up after Cameron but is looking like a bit of clown this morning.
The truth is IDSageddon was avoidable if at the least they'd pretended to listen to him. High handed arrogance could well likely have much wider ramifications for Cameron / Osbourne.
In fairness to him orderly succession is a near impossible task when the Tory party decides to self immolate. Hugely entertaining for everyone else to watch though.
- phattslagg
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 3578
- Joined: Fri May 14, 2004 2:04 pm 0
- Location: Worcester, England
Re: Politics Thread!
http://standardissuemagazine.com/in-the ... this-fate/
This is what voting for these bastards means to vulnerable people. And it's not like we weren't warned - we were. It's just that some of us chose to listen, and others didn't. It's taken something as blatant as this indefensible budget to alert people to what kind of government we have in this shower of cunts, but it's a tad too fucking late, isn't it?
This is what voting for these bastards means to vulnerable people. And it's not like we weren't warned - we were. It's just that some of us chose to listen, and others didn't. It's taken something as blatant as this indefensible budget to alert people to what kind of government we have in this shower of cunts, but it's a tad too fucking late, isn't it?
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: Politics Thread!
I just don’t believe he was surprised by any of it. This is not some radical change of course by the government, it is what was in their manifesto, including £12bn cuts to benefits and the 40% threshold rising to £50,000.
Raising the 40% threshold is overdue as for decades it has been falling in real terms. This is has meant more and more people are paying tax at 40%. It’s gone from a tax on the rich to include more and more middle class professionals such as senior teachers and nurses. The number paying tax at 40% has more than doubled. That is not only unfair to the merely well off who are being roped into paying a tax meant for the rich but unbalanced: raising more and more income from the higher rate, rather than the basic rate and other taxes, is less stable and generates more uncertainty in forecasts.
Raising the 40% threshold is overdue as for decades it has been falling in real terms. This is has meant more and more people are paying tax at 40%. It’s gone from a tax on the rich to include more and more middle class professionals such as senior teachers and nurses. The number paying tax at 40% has more than doubled. That is not only unfair to the merely well off who are being roped into paying a tax meant for the rich but unbalanced: raising more and more income from the higher rate, rather than the basic rate and other taxes, is less stable and generates more uncertainty in forecasts.
Re: Politics Thread!
Not entirely. Another area Osbourne highlighted for cuts was disabled children. I believe that idea was dispensed with as too politically sensitive.VNVObit wrote:the only area left are the pensioners and they have actually been hit, albeit indirectly, through the capping of benefit at Local Housing Allowance (effectively cutting funding to services needed by the elderly)gravy wrote:Anyone have any idea how the Cons are now supposed to fill the gap of £5.5bn of announced cuts being scrapped?
Going after the elderly would be a more balanced approach than what they are doing. The baby boomer generation had free higher education, historically high wages, improved equalities, free excess cash from the housing bubble to stockpile and reinvest, help with heating, TV, health etc. Compare that to the youth now who face no housing support, tens of thousands in debt for education, massively increased lowering of social mobility, can't get on the housing ladder, pension age vanishing into the horizon etc. “Putting the next generation first”.
This business with IDS isn't going to stop Tories in their pursuance of abandonment of welfare and offsetting any outgoing payments against productive input from recipients. "Meritocracy." Because why should a cripple get cash when they're just sitting there doing nothing??
IDS is so obviously sociopathic it's hard to think of anything more obviously deceitful than his resignation letter. His approach to cutting benefits is almost frenzied, as if he gets sexual gratification from others suffering.
Trippy vibes...
http://soundcloud.com/two-gapper
http://soundcloud.com/two-gapper
Re: Politics Thread!
Are you saying he should have been psychically aware that budget would have substantive tax cuts after they weren't mentioned at the cabinet meeting on Budget day?pogo wrote:I just don’t believe he was surprised by any of it. This is not some radical change of course by the government, it is what was in their manifesto, including £12bn cuts to benefits and the 40% threshold rising to £50,000.
Conversely you keep saying no one should be surprised when they don't keep their election promises either. The deficit is still here (but but but macroeconomics, labour, what would you have done!!!) and the chances of it being gone by the of this term are slimmer than Charles Hawtrey.
Which one is it? Sticking to their manifiesto and not sticking to their manifesto are equally non surprising?
Re: Politics Thread!
Human beings aren't rational machines so I don't believe sin taxes should be used unless they target effectively and with discrimination. Those two things aren't true of a sugar tax on sugary drinks that aren't fruit juices. Otherwise society at large should take the burden and address the issue through other measures that trickle down to correct unhealthy behaviours.gravy wrote:Do you think that people should be able to make lifestyle choices with a long term societal cost and for that cost not to be factored in?
Sugary drink tax is :
Regressive. Would you on your income skip a can of pepsi cos it's 76p rather than 70p?
Indiscriminate. Healthy people have to pay more for the pleasure too. Unlike cigarettes, sugary drinks are not necessarily unhealthy.
Unlikely to be effective. Where it's been tried sugar tax has been hit and miss, and where it's resulted in a drop in sugary drink consumption people turn to consuming a fuckton of doughnuts instead.
The Danes tried to tax sugar, sweets, saturated fats it didn't work they're throwing in the towel IIRC. For it to work you have to tax excessively like a pack of fags costing £8 sin tax makes up £6+ of that figure. So yeah, I'm sure a can of pepsi costing £3 would make most people think twice.. Smoking, IMO it's cumulative assimilation of reality (actual - often committed smokers will give up when they experience direct consequences on their health) and percolation of social behaviours that are the biggest influencers in adulthood at least. I didn't choose to give up for cost reasons or anything else it was an epiphany.
Trippy vibes...
http://soundcloud.com/two-gapper
http://soundcloud.com/two-gapper
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: Politics Thread!
You mean the deficit is still here after they promised it would be eliminated by 2015? Sure, because the recovery was much worse than expected, in large part due to the idiots in Brussels and Frankfurt who are in charge of the eurozone economy.gravy wrote:Conversely you keep saying no one should be surprised when they don't keep their election promises either. The deficit is still here (but but but macroeconomics, labour, what would you have done!!!) and the chances of it being gone by the of this term are slimmer than Charles Hawtrey.
Which one is it? Sticking to their manifiesto and not sticking to their manifesto are equally non surprising?
As for whether the deficit will be gone by 2020, I think that target is achievable. I also think it won’t be achieved as the chance of things going seriously pear shaped are too high. We could leave the EU. Or Greece could. The Chinese economy could tank. The US could elected a racist demagogue and ruin its own economy. Or something else I’ve not thought of.
The eurozone and China in particular have still large unresolved debt problems to work out. They could hang on for a decade, or it could come to a head this year or next, tipping much of the world economy back into recession, which will have a significant effect here.
Re: Politics Thread!
So, getting people to be fitter and healthier. Let's, for sake of argument, say sugar is the problem but equally acknowledge that it could be dairy, or meat, or mushrooms.
Should the government try to get people to eat less sugar? Or is it none of their business?
If so, how should they try to do it? Only by explaining that it's bad for you, or by making it more expensive (i.e. tax), or by making it less accessible (limited sales to licensed shops)? How?
Should the government try to get people to eat less sugar? Or is it none of their business?
If so, how should they try to do it? Only by explaining that it's bad for you, or by making it more expensive (i.e. tax), or by making it less accessible (limited sales to licensed shops)? How?
Re: Politics Thread!
Yeah right. You happily proportion blame to Brown and Labour for a global downturn, but when Tories fuck up the economy?pogo wrote:You mean the deficit is still here after they promised it would be eliminated by 2015? Sure, because the recovery was much worse than expected, in large part due to the idiots in Brussels and Frankfurt who are in charge of the eurozone economy.gravy wrote:Conversely you keep saying no one should be surprised when they don't keep their election promises either. The deficit is still here (but but but macroeconomics, labour, what would you have done!!!) and the chances of it being gone by the of this term are slimmer than Charles Hawtrey.
Which one is it? Sticking to their manifiesto and not sticking to their manifesto are equally non surprising?
It's someone else's fault.
Recovery worse than expected? How about totally ignoring the massive pile of evidence that Tories strangulated growth.
Trippy vibes...
http://soundcloud.com/two-gapper
http://soundcloud.com/two-gapper
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: Politics Thread!
No, Brown and Blair did not cause the global downturn. The thing they are responsible for is the size of the deficit in 2010, which was partly due to the recession, partly due to the high levels of borrowing and spending adopted by the government before it. Hence the need for cuts, to return spending to sustainable levels.
No the government didn’t “strangulate” growth. That was the prediction of some on the left, that Tory cuts would stop the recovery and tip the country back into recession. It didn‘t happen, the economy recovered and is still growing, unemployment is back to pre-crisis levels.
No the government didn’t “strangulate” growth. That was the prediction of some on the left, that Tory cuts would stop the recovery and tip the country back into recession. It didn‘t happen, the economy recovered and is still growing, unemployment is back to pre-crisis levels.
Re: Politics Thread!
The question supposes there's a magic bullet.venusian wrote:So, getting people to be fitter and healthier. Let's, for sake of argument, say sugar is the problem but equally acknowledge that it could be dairy, or meat, or mushrooms.
Should the government try to get people to eat less sugar? Or is it none of their business?
If so, how should they try to do it? Only by explaining that it's bad for you, or by making it more expensive (i.e. tax), or by making it less accessible (limited sales to licensed shops)? How?
The US of A have been more successful at lowering sugary drink consumption through policy measures and education than tax. But before you choose an approach what is the goal? If it's obesity - that continues to rise in the USA despite a lowering of sugar drinky consumption so it's a multifaceted problem that's not being addressed effectively.
There are some simple approaches that do work. Stuff like, getting used to the feeling hungry being the natural state. Driving those ideas into individuals behaviour is pretty hard to do in a corporate driven consumer society. I've got some pretty good approaches (go vegan! for one) but it's a sophisticated problem do you want an essay? I'd begin by looking at how culture evolves...
A pretty trivial problem in real terms and now only a historical footnote that's irrelevant today, so when within the next 20-30 years do you think you might shut the fuck up about it?pogo wrote:No, Brown and Blair did cause the global downturn. The thing they are responsible for is the size of the deficit in 2010,
This is where you go against pretty much every economist and independent measure of repute. You can fixate on atomising the situation to evade the truth ("Labour said we'd be tipped back into recession! They were only very close to the being correct therefore everything they've ever said is wrong!") but the Tory-led UK recovery was one, if not the, worst in history. Heck, Tories can't even stop missing their own targets as figures get revised down and down.. deeper and down...pogo wrote:No the government didn’t “strangulate” growth.
You're just asserting opinion as fact as usual... despite a fuckton of evidence that shows Tories have strangled the economy. Where's your DATA to the contrary?
Another thing I take issue with is people taking a glib overview of the economic outlook as opposed to examining across the spectrum. Some rather wealthy people did very well out of the recession and that might look good on the balance sheet, but they're closing the libraries, dementia wards, childcare centres, hospitals, they're removing access to proper healthcare, housing, education, support for living costs etc. You've got a balance sheet for any given moment, the real cost to society extends far beyond that.
Trippy vibes...
http://soundcloud.com/two-gapper
http://soundcloud.com/two-gapper
- Absolute_Zero
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 3564
- Joined: Wed May 18, 2005 4:11 pm 0
- Location: Hilbert Hotel, Heisenberg.
Re: Politics Thread!
quote edit?(o)(o) wrote:A pretty trivial problem in real terms and now only a historical footnote that's irrelevant today, so when within the next 20-30 years do you think you might shut the fuck up about it?pogo wrote:No, Brown and Blair did cause the global downturn. The thing they are responsible for is the size of the deficit in 2010,
Re: Politics Thread!
Nah, freudian slip..Absolute_Zero wrote:quote edit?(o)(o) wrote:A pretty trivial problem in real terms and now only a historical footnote that's irrelevant today, so when within the next 20-30 years do you think you might shut the fuck up about it?pogo wrote:No, Brown and Blair did cause the global downturn. The thing they are responsible for is the size of the deficit in 2010,
Trippy vibes...
http://soundcloud.com/two-gapper
http://soundcloud.com/two-gapper
