pogo wrote:Personal computers and computer systems have rendered many repetitive clerical jobs obsolete.
Have they fuck. All they've done is moved those jobs on to servicing the electronic monstrosity that was supposed to make them redundant.
I'll admit, there's less switchboard girls these days, though.
Yes they have. Typing pools have been mentioned already. Telephone switchboard operators and answerers. Just had to call the council and after a couple of rounds of “press 1 for xxx, 2 for yyy” I got through to the right person directly.
But also computer systems have dramatically reduced the cost of other tasks. No more using a pocket calculator or pen and paper to tot up a bill, a till or other terminal does it for you. Instead of someone reading your meter and entering it into a little book which someone has to type in, they enter it into a terminal. Or you enter your meter readings online. Or your meter talks to their computers directly. Electronic payments have largely replaced cheques and other forms of paper payment. Library systems which used to consist of large amounts of paper/card to catalogue collections and track borrowings are all electronic.
And this has only accelerated as computers have gone from expensive specialist devices to exceedingly common, in the form of smartphones and tablets. These have transformed the way people do business and meant businesses can find many more of their customers online.
Maintenance jobs of computers (and robots) is no where near at the same ratio as the jobs the computers replace.
Just because jobs are created doesn't mean the same quantity is - and that's a problem if we stick to our current economic systems.
(It is not, however, a bad thing intrinsically - you want to ditch that combine harvester?, you might have a problem feeding the currently population - at least, without the current population suddenly having to spend far more of their income on food)
--
I agree. The march of technology has by and large been job destroying. But this is not a new thing or a bad thing. As computers and machines improve the jobs they take over are the routine ones, the mindless ones, the repetitive ones, whether on a farm, on a production line in a factory, or in an office.
It would be a problem if the jobs were not replaced but they are. As already noted we have record numbers of people in work today. Where jobs disappear due to automation and productivity improvements it does not destroy economic activity but generates more of it, which helps support new jobs, new businesses, even whole new industries elsewhere in the economy.
Darkflame wrote:It is not, however, a bad thing intrinsically - you want to ditch that combine harvester?, you might have a problem feeding the currently population - at least, without the current population suddenly having to spend far more of their income on food
Combine Harvesters are not new, or in any way related to computers, I was in my twenties when the first home computer showed up, but there were combine harvesters before I was born, quite possibly before WW2.
*checks Wikipedia* Invented between 1927 and 1934 (oops, misread that, should be 1826 and 1834). That's almost a (two) century(s) ago.
"My way is the way of not fighting":- the book of Enter the Dragon.
It’s a good example though. I would pick two even earlier events. The Agricultural Revolution which vastly improved agricultural efficiency. And the Industrial Revolution where factory production lines replaced many cottage industries. Both were associated with large scale displacement of jobs, but other jobs rapidly arose to employ those affected. Some fought against the change. The Luddites in particular organised against the Industrial Revolution. But they were wrong, failed to stop it, and “Luddite” is now a pejorative term for anyone ignorantly resistant to change.
pogo wrote:It’s a good example though. I would pick two even earlier events. The Agricultural Revolution which vastly improved agricultural efficiency. And the Industrial Revolution where factory production lines replaced many cottage industries. Both were associated with large scale displacement of jobs, but other jobs rapidly arose to employ those affected. Some fought against the change. The Luddites in particular organised against the Industrial Revolution. But they were wrong, failed to stop it, and “Luddite” is now a pejorative term for anyone ignorantly resistant to change.
You've bought into the old wives tale version of Luddite hook line and sinker.
The term Luddite isn't pejorative to the true meaning :
Despite their modern reputation, the original Luddites were neither opposed to technology nor inept at using it. Many were highly skilled machine operators in the textile industry. Nor was the technology they attacked particularly new. Moreover, the idea of smashing machines as a form of industrial protest did not begin or end with them...
The Luddite disturbances started in circumstances at least superficially similar to our own. British working families at the start of the 19th century were enduring economic upheaval and widespread unemployment. A seemingly endless war against Napoleon’s France had brought “the hard pinch of poverty,” wrote Yorkshire historian Frank Peel, to homes “where it had hitherto been a stranger.” Food was scarce and rapidly becoming more costly. Then, on March 11, 1811, in Nottingham, a textile manufacturing center, British troops broke up a crowd of protesters demanding more work and better wages.
gravy wrote:I'm still waiting to found out what's wrong with a Greek History degree
A degree in literature might have pointed out "find" and "full stop" :)
Oddly enough, one of the best programmers I ever hired had a classics degree.
"massive retard™", "full of shit™", "tiny bitch™", "retarted™", "a bit of a one trick pony™", "petty™", "simple minded idealistic twat™", "miserable humourless fucker™"
pogo wrote:It’s a good example though. I would pick two even earlier events. The Agricultural Revolution which vastly improved agricultural efficiency. And the Industrial Revolution where factory production lines replaced many cottage industries. Both were associated with large scale displacement of jobs, but other jobs rapidly arose to employ those affected. Some fought against the change. The Luddites in particular organised against the Industrial Revolution. But they were wrong, failed to stop it, and “Luddite” is now a pejorative term for anyone ignorantly resistant to change.
You've bought into the old wives tale version of Luddite hook line and sinker.
The term Luddite isn't pejorative to the true meaning :
Despite their modern reputation, the original Luddites were neither opposed to technology nor inept at using it. Many were highly skilled machine operators in the textile industry. Nor was the technology they attacked particularly new. Moreover, the idea of smashing machines as a form of industrial protest did not begin or end with them...
The Luddite disturbances started in circumstances at least superficially similar to our own. British working families at the start of the 19th century were enduring economic upheaval and widespread unemployment. A seemingly endless war against Napoleon’s France had brought “the hard pinch of poverty,” wrote Yorkshire historian Frank Peel, to homes “where it had hitherto been a stranger.” Food was scarce and rapidly becoming more costly. Then, on March 11, 1811, in Nottingham, a textile manufacturing center, British troops broke up a crowd of protesters demanding more work and better wages.
To be fair to Pogo here, he wasn't saying that the term was originally a pejorative, just that this is what it's become in common parlance. And he's right, it has. We don't employ the term to people with an admirable grasp of new technology, do we?
"Oh dear lord, I slightly soiled myself. Oxfam won’t be pleased."
The referbce to the word being pejorative, was just the icing on the cake of a comprehensive misunderstanding of what the Luddites were about and the effects of technology and 'automation' on society..
(o)(o) wrote:The referbce to the word being pejorative, was just the icing on the cake of a comprehensive misunderstanding of what the Luddites were about and the effects of technology and 'automation' on society..
Turns out mommy held £200k of Dodgy Dave's inheritance so he could avoid paying £70k IHT.
OH DEAR OH DEAR OH DEAR....
He's gotta go hasn't he..
LoLs
Yeah,
he has gotta go.
In any other free country in the world he would be as good as gone. But, this is Britain and the electorate just accept this type of piss time and time again. It's as if they accept the actions of their 'betters'!
pogo wrote:No, there has been a massive increase in the skill level of the workforce.
fuckin shut the fuck fuckin up you fucking headcase.
Skill levels are increased only in relevant terms.
An educated post degree worker with no job to go to is not a skilled worker, he or she is surplus wastage.