Playstation VR
Re: Playstation VR
It's a terrible system, but yes. On the plus side, getting through Greenlight is much easier today than it used to be. Most of the bigger games only last a week or two at most before getting approval, and frequently only a few days.
Re: Playstation VR
Sounds good to me.gilesgoat wrote:No really, no jokes, we could make stuff SO super trippy to make your brain go bananas ..
"In case of a nuclear attack, the protection of records is essential, if this country is to carry on its economy, and maintain our way of life."
- gilesgoat
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 27259
- Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
- Location: Monfalcone, Italy
- Contact:
Re: Playstation VR
I think still that as idea, concept and implementation Steam's Greenlight belongs to the category "crappest things in the universe that should never existed in the first place" if they really wanted "quality" it fails miserably, but I think the only thing they want is "maximum sellability" ?Jamesac wrote:It's a terrible system, but yes. On the plus side, getting through Greenlight is much easier today than it used to be. Most of the bigger games only last a week or two at most before getting approval, and frequently only a few days.
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
"Baa"
Re: Playstation VR
Honestly, I think what Valve wants is to not be the gatekeeper of sales success on the PC front. Steam grew from a storefront for Valve to a distribution platform to being The PC Distribution Platform, not because Valve tried to take over the world but because it worked well enough for what it was and because people trusted the company despite how aloof it tends to be. The impression I get is that Valve never quite knew what to do with Steam's success, and didn't want to/care about dedicating the resources to content filtration. Managing 90-ish% (number pulled firmly from between buttocks) of PC sales isn't a responsibility the company was prepared for, wanted, and sadly doesn't seem to be very interested in managing in certain ways. It's the kind of thinking that ends up with a system like Greenlight.
The thing is, if Valve was only interested in maximizing Steam sales then I probably wouldn't have been able to buy a game like Hyperspace Invaders II on their storefront. I've always read Greenlight as a bad solution to the problem of too much content and not enough interest in being the ones to filter it.
The thing is, if Valve was only interested in maximizing Steam sales then I probably wouldn't have been able to buy a game like Hyperspace Invaders II on their storefront. I've always read Greenlight as a bad solution to the problem of too much content and not enough interest in being the ones to filter it.
- gilesgoat
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 27259
- Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
- Location: Monfalcone, Italy
- Contact:
Re: Playstation VR
I think ... "or you are prepared to put an architecture in place to filter content" - with all the associated costs and risks .. or you don't ..
The problem I have with Greenlight is that is based on a concept of "continuous increasing traction / trend" which to be really honest I don't think it's a kind of concept that could ever work with LS games, or, with quite a number of other things as well.
You may have "a pool of people" more than happy to get your game, but it does not necessarely mean "that game is to become super mainstream" and/or "the thing that bring all the internet following it" or "create a super mega buzz where everyone is talking about it", yet remaining an interesting thing in its own.
To be honest it's not even exactly clear from the definition above what is exactly that they want to see to get your game greenlighted.
"Relative interest compared to other games ?" .. so game 1 has 100 votes, game 2 has 150, game 3 has 300 .. ok .. "cleary game 3 is 3 more times wanted than game 1 and 2 more times wanted than game 2" ..
So "does it win ?" .. or not .. or you wait one more week and now things change .. now 2 is on top and 2/3 are bottom .. but wait .. another week .. things change again .. now 3 is on top and 2/3 are down ..
When/how does this stop ?
Also ..
Also all this process seems to imply "and meanwhile.. you'll be like crazy doing dunno what dunno where "all over the internet" to promote your game and get votes" .. which is .. bad ..
You know what ? The Oculus Rift store is also quite pretty in VR .. and looks quite nice on the Samsung Gear as well ..
The problem I have with Greenlight is that is based on a concept of "continuous increasing traction / trend" which to be really honest I don't think it's a kind of concept that could ever work with LS games, or, with quite a number of other things as well.
You may have "a pool of people" more than happy to get your game, but it does not necessarely mean "that game is to become super mainstream" and/or "the thing that bring all the internet following it" or "create a super mega buzz where everyone is talking about it", yet remaining an interesting thing in its own.
So basically if I get this right this becomes a sort of "voting competiton" to beat in terms of "new votes you get" other games that are there.The specific number of votes doesn't matter as much as relative interest in a game compared with other games in Steam Greenlight—we need customers to help us prioritize which games they want to see made available on Steam.
We're going to be reaching out to developers as we see their games getting traction regardless of whether they have achieved a specific number of votes or are sitting 1st or 2nd place at any given time. We are most interested in finding the games that people want, not requiring them to hit a specific number of votes.
To be honest it's not even exactly clear from the definition above what is exactly that they want to see to get your game greenlighted.
"Relative interest compared to other games ?" .. so game 1 has 100 votes, game 2 has 150, game 3 has 300 .. ok .. "cleary game 3 is 3 more times wanted than game 1 and 2 more times wanted than game 2" ..
So "does it win ?" .. or not .. or you wait one more week and now things change .. now 2 is on top and 2/3 are bottom .. but wait .. another week .. things change again .. now 3 is on top and 2/3 are down ..
When/how does this stop ?
Also ..
So this sounds me ( again a bit of "weasel words statement" ) like "ok whenever we feel like we want to publish a new game we have a look at what is and someway we'll decide who is in greelight and who not ?"We will regularly be selecting games from Steam Greenlight, based on our bandwidth to ship games on Steam.
Also all this process seems to imply "and meanwhile.. you'll be like crazy doing dunno what dunno where "all over the internet" to promote your game and get votes" .. which is .. bad ..
You know what ? The Oculus Rift store is also quite pretty in VR .. and looks quite nice on the Samsung Gear as well ..
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
"Baa"
- gilesgoat
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 27259
- Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
- Location: Monfalcone, Italy
- Contact:
Re: Playstation VR
.. Oh Jeff what you done .. oh what you done ...
.. "Neon VR" ?? ... HA .. HA HA ... HA ! .. HA ...
.. ah OK I get this "powerup" and .. .. OMG ... WTF ? .. Holy ...
HOLY FRAKING COW !!! OH MY WHAT ON EARTH AND BEYOND IS THAT !!!
Drugs don't give you this, this gives you MORE
23:45 I am still here fidding with stuff for "120 FPS always and everywhere on everywhere or death" .. it's LOT of swearing but when you see results it's all worth it.
Oh guys what are going to be in for .. you really will NOT be prepared for this

.. "Neon VR" ?? ... HA .. HA HA ... HA ! .. HA ...
.. ah OK I get this "powerup" and .. .. OMG ... WTF ? .. Holy ...
HOLY FRAKING COW !!! OH MY WHAT ON EARTH AND BEYOND IS THAT !!!
Drugs don't give you this, this gives you MORE
23:45 I am still here fidding with stuff for "120 FPS always and everywhere on everywhere or death" .. it's LOT of swearing but when you see results it's all worth it.
Oh guys what are going to be in for .. you really will NOT be prepared for this
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
"Baa"
Re: Playstation VR
I think the underlying point with Steam Greenlight is that they were originally manually approving games.
This was a lot of work and time-consuming - slowing it all down - and there's so many games to consider - so the backlog for approval was only getting bigger - and it all relies on their "deciders", making the decisions, trying to psychically predict what people want.
Basically, this is a recipe for crowd-sourcing. Why guess what people will buy when you can just have those people directly tell you? Crowd-sourcing naturally scales to the problem - you potentially have as many "deciders" as there are people with Steam accounts - so it can process it all.
But, in the end, Valve don't actually want to give up being the ultimate deciders. This is about efficient processing and market research, really, not about establishing a democracy. This is their business, they're not just handing over the keys to the masses wholesale.
Hence the language and vague criteria. It's "we've got this system to help us process all these games and conduct direct market research to try to establish what people want to inform our decisions... but this ain't a democracy and it is, ultimately, still our decision".
And, in fairness, as Valve have recognised and said so, Greenlight ain't a perfect system, even if they were willing to cede control over to it. It's better than the other thing, but it's not perfect.
You can pick up on how, say, popular YouTubers like the Yogscast could make a video about their "Yogventures" game and sail through Greenlight (and Kickstarter) nigh-on instantly, as they already have their own army of fans to back them. But a more worthy game, by a small indie developer, might not get anywhere in comparison because they can't generate that kind of hype - though it might ultimately be the better game of the two to Greenlight.
It's basically a popularity contest and those don't necessarily guarantee quality, or even basic common sense.
The language is vague deliberately. Because, ultimately, Valve make the decisions that Valve want to make. Greenlight is just a tool to expedite the process for them.
(And, to be fair, you could see the vague language as potentially in your favour, as that is Valve recognising that, yes, generating loads of hype doesn't necessarily mean the end product is any good or will actually sell. They reserve their decisions exactly because, sometimes, the hype is bollocks and they might be able to see that a game is worthy, even though its developers can't generate that big hype train of trending all over the Internet, so they reserve the right to reach down and pull them up through Greenlight anyway.)
This was a lot of work and time-consuming - slowing it all down - and there's so many games to consider - so the backlog for approval was only getting bigger - and it all relies on their "deciders", making the decisions, trying to psychically predict what people want.
Basically, this is a recipe for crowd-sourcing. Why guess what people will buy when you can just have those people directly tell you? Crowd-sourcing naturally scales to the problem - you potentially have as many "deciders" as there are people with Steam accounts - so it can process it all.
But, in the end, Valve don't actually want to give up being the ultimate deciders. This is about efficient processing and market research, really, not about establishing a democracy. This is their business, they're not just handing over the keys to the masses wholesale.
Hence the language and vague criteria. It's "we've got this system to help us process all these games and conduct direct market research to try to establish what people want to inform our decisions... but this ain't a democracy and it is, ultimately, still our decision".
And, in fairness, as Valve have recognised and said so, Greenlight ain't a perfect system, even if they were willing to cede control over to it. It's better than the other thing, but it's not perfect.
You can pick up on how, say, popular YouTubers like the Yogscast could make a video about their "Yogventures" game and sail through Greenlight (and Kickstarter) nigh-on instantly, as they already have their own army of fans to back them. But a more worthy game, by a small indie developer, might not get anywhere in comparison because they can't generate that kind of hype - though it might ultimately be the better game of the two to Greenlight.
It's basically a popularity contest and those don't necessarily guarantee quality, or even basic common sense.
The language is vague deliberately. Because, ultimately, Valve make the decisions that Valve want to make. Greenlight is just a tool to expedite the process for them.
(And, to be fair, you could see the vague language as potentially in your favour, as that is Valve recognising that, yes, generating loads of hype doesn't necessarily mean the end product is any good or will actually sell. They reserve their decisions exactly because, sometimes, the hype is bollocks and they might be able to see that a game is worthy, even though its developers can't generate that big hype train of trending all over the Internet, so they reserve the right to reach down and pull them up through Greenlight anyway.)
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
- John Maynard Keynes
- gilesgoat
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 27259
- Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
- Location: Monfalcone, Italy
- Contact:
Re: Playstation VR
You put it right is a Hype generation contest actually I think to be more precise is a Hype generation with always increasing trend contest, which means you need hype now, but more of it tomorrow and even more of it the next day and even more of it the next day.
What is really worrying is that is not "cumulative" and/or - so the extremely vague definitions seems to say - actually the only clear thing they seems to say is that "even if you reach an X of votes that is not enough", it's totally unclear how/when this trend "can stop" and/or reaches "something" that gets noted by Valve and make them think "OK", really there's not really any clear criteria/method exposed, if that would be a math definition is clearly flawed.
Long story made short, I strongly believe this kind of mechanism is never going to work for/with LS games, we may be super lucky with one maybe but "as a general rule for the type of products we create" I don't think we are even remotely in the field of "mass super hype".
Nor we are the type of company ( or should I say "people" as we are just in 2 ) that like/want to spend "massive time" hyping a product or trying to create "an internet hype sensation", we believe "the products speak for ourselves, not us for the products".
Said that when you see certain things on Valve you do not really understand how the heck they went there, I don't say "many" things are like that but I do have friends that every now and then point me to "did you see that ?" ( as in a "freak show" ) and show me some stuff on Valve store that makes you think "WTF were they thinking ?" ..
What is really worrying is that is not "cumulative" and/or - so the extremely vague definitions seems to say - actually the only clear thing they seems to say is that "even if you reach an X of votes that is not enough", it's totally unclear how/when this trend "can stop" and/or reaches "something" that gets noted by Valve and make them think "OK", really there's not really any clear criteria/method exposed, if that would be a math definition is clearly flawed.
Long story made short, I strongly believe this kind of mechanism is never going to work for/with LS games, we may be super lucky with one maybe but "as a general rule for the type of products we create" I don't think we are even remotely in the field of "mass super hype".
Nor we are the type of company ( or should I say "people" as we are just in 2 ) that like/want to spend "massive time" hyping a product or trying to create "an internet hype sensation", we believe "the products speak for ourselves, not us for the products".
Said that when you see certain things on Valve you do not really understand how the heck they went there, I don't say "many" things are like that but I do have friends that every now and then point me to "did you see that ?" ( as in a "freak show" ) and show me some stuff on Valve store that makes you think "WTF were they thinking ?" ..
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
"Baa"
- tenshi_alpha
- Baaa!

- Posts: 192
- Joined: Fri Oct 17, 2014 6:00 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: tenshi alpha
- PSN: tenshi_alpha
- Location: Sheffield
Re: Playstation VR
Yeah, hype train on Steam for LS games... probably won't work because of the people on there.
Speaking of "Hyperspace Invaders II", which is fantastic fun, I bought a copy in a sale on recommendation from a friend of mine, and then wrote a review for it, and got 5 immediate downvotes.
So I mentioned that to my friend who recommended it to me in the first place - he's a games journalist from Spain btw - and he told me I should never review a game that's non-mainstream and featured in a sale, unless I want a flood of downvotes. He said - most players on Steam just play one game, and it's usually a "multiplayer kill each other" kind of game.
When there's a sale on, they look up for a moment, follow the links to see what's in the sale, downvote all the positive reviews for games they don't like the idea of having positive reviews, don't buy anything, and go back to killing each other.
And then their imprint leaves a mark on the normal gamers to visit in the future.
I don't know whether what he says is true, or how he'd even know, but the pattern does appear to hold.
Speaking of "Hyperspace Invaders II", which is fantastic fun, I bought a copy in a sale on recommendation from a friend of mine, and then wrote a review for it, and got 5 immediate downvotes.
So I mentioned that to my friend who recommended it to me in the first place - he's a games journalist from Spain btw - and he told me I should never review a game that's non-mainstream and featured in a sale, unless I want a flood of downvotes. He said - most players on Steam just play one game, and it's usually a "multiplayer kill each other" kind of game.
When there's a sale on, they look up for a moment, follow the links to see what's in the sale, downvote all the positive reviews for games they don't like the idea of having positive reviews, don't buy anything, and go back to killing each other.
And then their imprint leaves a mark on the normal gamers to visit in the future.
I don't know whether what he says is true, or how he'd even know, but the pattern does appear to hold.
- korruptor
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 4291
- Joined: Sun Sep 22, 2002 10:35 am 0
- Location: Under The Northern Lights
- Contact:
Re: Playstation VR
If you've published on Steam you can just create an AppID without having to do GL, and you guys put stuff out on it before, yeah?
The trend thing doesn't seem to be a part of it, Lumo was getting very minor interest at the point where it was GL. It just did exceptionally well for the first couple of weeks. These days the numbers you need are so low it's basically academic. Some of my students have cruised through in two weeks with a few hundred votes.
The trend thing doesn't seem to be a part of it, Lumo was getting very minor interest at the point where it was GL. It just did exceptionally well for the first couple of weeks. These days the numbers you need are so low it's basically academic. Some of my students have cruised through in two weeks with a few hundred votes.
"Don't go into a trance boys..." :: DJ Mixes
Re: Playstation VR
Yeah, this is a good point. Greenlight is for new stuff.korruptor wrote:If you've published on Steam you can just create an AppID without having to do GL, and you guys put stuff out on it before, yeah?
If you're an established publisher on the Steam Store, then you shouldn't need to do Greenlight. You've already passed the test, as it were.
Go check, Giles. I don't think you need worry about Greenlight anyway, as you should have the required status, from already being a Steam publisher, to add more games.
(I know you've definitely published on Steam beforehand, as I bought Gridrunner Revolution and Space Giraffe there - not that they're useful to me now that I'm on Linux, but they're in my Steam library anyway. Yeah, the publisher is listed as "Llamasoft Ltd.", so you did publish it yourselves, and that account should be capable of publishing more games without needing to do Greenlight.)
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
- John Maynard Keynes
- gilesgoat
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 27259
- Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
- Location: Monfalcone, Italy
- Contact:
Re: Playstation VR
.. damn .. it means we'll have to buy that Vive and make it work then ...
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
"Baa"
Re: Playstation VR
I was at the store walking by the PS4s and was just thinking damnit! I'm going to have to buy one of these soon! and a PSVR!

Re: Playstation VR
Yes, Giles. Yes, I'm afraid it does.gilesgoat wrote:.. damn .. it means we'll have to buy that Vive and make it work then ...
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
- John Maynard Keynes
Re: Playstation VR
Greenlight isn't an issue for most developers any more, it's become a box you need to tick.
If you want to be on Steam, have even a little bit of a profile then it's no barrier to entry.
It's a lot different from the old days
If you want to be on Steam, have even a little bit of a profile then it's no barrier to entry.
It's a lot different from the old days


