Politics Thread!
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: Politics Thread!
No they don’t ("by default get compen"). The example that keeps coming up, of Philip Morris suing the Australian govt.? The tobacco company lost, badly, as they deserved to.
http://www.theguardian.com/australia-ne ... -packaging
https://www.theguardian.com/business/20 ... -australia
Some cases are decided for the firms, some for the government. The tribunals would not exist if cases were always decided one way or the other. Firms can and do lose, and the cost of doing so is high, in both $ and international reputation, so no firm will take a case to a tribunal frivolously – they will only do so if they have good reason.
http://www.theguardian.com/australia-ne ... -packaging
https://www.theguardian.com/business/20 ... -australia
Some cases are decided for the firms, some for the government. The tribunals would not exist if cases were always decided one way or the other. Firms can and do lose, and the cost of doing so is high, in both $ and international reputation, so no firm will take a case to a tribunal frivolously – they will only do so if they have good reason.
Re: Politics Thread!
The cases are costly for all sides. You think a good use of government money is defending sensible public health legislation?
Or paying for the costly fallout of companies making profit from a product that puts a massive strain on government infrastructure?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Philip_Morris_v._Uruguay
That happened because it's allowed by a bilateral trade deal between Switzerland and Uraguay. The same mechanism as in TTIP
This is something that should not happen, not be legislated to make more likely to happen.
And FWIW the Australian case was far from being a failure for Phillip Morris. To avoid a similar costly case New Zealand reversed plans to similar plain packaging legislation which is more than likely the exact reason for the case in the first place.
Or paying for the costly fallout of companies making profit from a product that puts a massive strain on government infrastructure?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Philip_Morris_v._Uruguay
That happened because it's allowed by a bilateral trade deal between Switzerland and Uraguay. The same mechanism as in TTIP
This is something that should not happen, not be legislated to make more likely to happen.
And FWIW the Australian case was far from being a failure for Phillip Morris. To avoid a similar costly case New Zealand reversed plans to similar plain packaging legislation which is more than likely the exact reason for the case in the first place.
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: Politics Thread!
Governments do not win compensation, no – a win for them just confirms their course of action was correct. But they can and do recover costs. I had not heard of the Uruguay case. That’s been going on for a very long time. And it is almost identical to the Australia case, so is almost certain to lose. They lost the Australia case badly. The court labelled their attempt to bring it “an abuse of rights” and found unanimously against them.
I wrote earlier that a firm risks bearing both legal and reputational costs, bringing such a case. Philip Morris hardly seems rational doing so, bringing two near identical cases. Both Australia and Uruguay are tiny markets, and even if they won the impact would be limited. Plain packaging is only one of many anti-smoking measures being introduced by such governments.
But the prize for them is not in those countries, but to establish a precedent, that they have a right to brand their products. They have lost that battle; plain packaging is now happening in the UK, France, Ireland and probably other EU countries. The Uruguay case therefore is largely moot, and they will have to accept countries have a right to introduce plain packaging.
I wrote earlier that a firm risks bearing both legal and reputational costs, bringing such a case. Philip Morris hardly seems rational doing so, bringing two near identical cases. Both Australia and Uruguay are tiny markets, and even if they won the impact would be limited. Plain packaging is only one of many anti-smoking measures being introduced by such governments.
But the prize for them is not in those countries, but to establish a precedent, that they have a right to brand their products. They have lost that battle; plain packaging is now happening in the UK, France, Ireland and probably other EU countries. The Uruguay case therefore is largely moot, and they will have to accept countries have a right to introduce plain packaging.
Re: Politics Thread!
Benito Mussolini wrote:Fascism should more appropriately be called corporatism because it is the merger of state and corporate power.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
- John Maynard Keynes
Re: Politics Thread!
Phillip Morris's turnover is nearly double Uruguay's GDP. They may roll over and whatever the outcome it'll definitely make other countries pause for thought before bringing in legislation to the benefit of their citizens that may conflict with corporate interests.pogo wrote:Governments do not win compensation, no – a win for them just confirms their course of action was correct. But they can and do recover costs. I had not heard of the Uruguay case. That’s been going on for a very long time. And it is almost identical to the Australia case, so is almost certain to lose. They lost the Australia case badly. The court labelled their attempt to bring it “an abuse of rights” and found unanimously against them.
I'm pretty PM see the outcome of NZ dropping similar legisaltion worth the cost of the Oz case.
And to be clear Philip Morris say that the TTIP type deal they're prosecuting states through leaves them with no choice, they have to sue. You think that's good?
And as for reputational costs?
"Man I thought those cigarette companies were okay but it turns out they're just interested making money! I'm beginning to think those guys might be jerks!"
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: Politics Thread!
“no choice”? Self-serving PR. And yes, reputational risks for tobacco companies are rather different. It’s more about establishing a precedent. It’s not a reputation that they are a good company, engaged in a worthwhile industry. More the reputation that they are not to be tangled with, that they will fight even governments to get their way.gravy wrote:And to be clear Philip Morris say that the TTIP type deal they're prosecuting states through leaves them with no choice, they have to sue. You think that's good?
And as for reputational costs?
"Man I thought those cigarette companies were okay but it turns out they're just interested making money! I'm beginning to think those guys might be jerks!"
Re: Politics Thread!
Actually of all the bullshit they spout the "have no choice" line rings the most true. This is exactly like minimizing tax, something you've defended on the basis of companies having a legal obligation to do to maximise shareholder worth.
Hey, tobacco companies are spending huge amounts of money lobbying the EU about what goes into TTIP.
But that's okay, this is completely transparent and correspondance has to be released under FOI requests.
Unfortunately the reality doesn't quite work out that way:
http://corporateeurope.org/sites/defaul ... dacted.pdf
Hey, tobacco companies are spending huge amounts of money lobbying the EU about what goes into TTIP.
But that's okay, this is completely transparent and correspondance has to be released under FOI requests.
Unfortunately the reality doesn't quite work out that way:
http://corporateeurope.org/sites/defaul ... dacted.pdf
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: Politics Thread!
Much as it’s for governments, sometimes in cooperation with other governments, to close down loopholes and eliminate opportunities for tax arbitrage, it’s for governments to introduce health legislation to reduce smoking.gravy wrote:Actually of all the bullshit they spout the "have no choice" line rings the most true. This is exactly like minimizing tax, something you've defended on the basis of companies having a legal obligation to do to maximise shareholder worth.
Companies do have a legal obligation to work in the best interest of their shareholders. But this can be highly antisocial. It can lead to pollution, to worker exploitation, to monopoly behaviour, to other exploitative and damaging behaviour.
Which is why for capitalism to work you also need a robust regulatory system, run by a government able and willing to intervene when necessary. This includes laws and regulations, introduced by government. It includes regulators and investors appointed by them. And it includes courts to go after firms who are unwilling or unable to abide by the laws and regulations.
It certainly includes health regulation, on things like how cigarettes are sold. It is right that for the government to introduce such regulations, where there is good reason to think they will help. Tobacco firms may object but there is little they can do. Health concerns trump their need to make a profit, as it should.
- merman
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 10943
- Joined: Wed Feb 16, 2005 1:44 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: merman1974
- Yahoo Messenger: andrewrfisher
- Location: Skegness, England
- Contact:
Re: Politics Thread!
Privatisation at Whitehall offices has cost £4 million more than it savedpogo wrote:That chart was just to show that, contrary to some of the histrionics here, the NHS is not threatened by too much privatisation, as we have a lot less than it than comparable economies. If you think more privatisation will harm the NHS, then has it harmed the health service in France? or Germany? or Italy? No, it hasn’t.
On TTIP the negotiating parties have made it clear, and made repeated commitments, that it will not affect the NHS. E.g.
http://europa.eu/rapid/press-release_ST ... 646_en.htmThe thing you seem worried about, thatUS and EU trade agreements do not prevent governments, at any level, from providing or supporting services in areas such as water, education, health, and social services.
Furthermore, no EU or US trade agreement requires governments to privatise any service, or prevents governments from expanding the range of services they supply to the public. Moreover, these agreements do not prevent governments from providing public services previously supplied by private service suppliers; contracting a public service to private providers does not mean that it becomes irreversibly part of the commercial sector.
Private sector activities can improve the availability and diversity of services, to the benefit of people in the United States and the European Union. Defining the appropriate balance between public and private services is up to the discretion of each government.
EU and US trade agreements do not impede governments' ability to adopt or maintain regulations to ensure the high quality of services and to protect important public interest objectives, such as the protection of health, safety, or the environment.
The United States and the European Union are following this same approach in TTIP and TiSA.Sounds scary but it is normal. If the government decides to cancel a contract early, putting in jeopardy the business and employees of a firm, it has to pay compensation. But that is the law now, TTIP does not change that.k345y wrote:when the NHS in any area of the UK decides to cancel their supplier and/or services from state side ran businesses the UK government will have to compensate any financial loss to that business
Privatisation in the NHS will not solvePublic and Commercial Services union general secretary Mark Serwotka said: “This is an all-too-familiar story of Tory ministers cutting and privatising, only to find they have wasted money and damaged services.
- delays in A&E
- bed shortages
- staffing levels
- high agency staff fees
- mistakes and malpractice
And it will COST MORE as the "internal market" leads to more contract tenders, more lawyers poring over the contracts and contracts having to be re-bid as companies pull out.
And it will certainly not reverse the massive shortfalls in social care caused by cuts to council budgets forced through in the name of austerity.
Twitter, Xbox, Wii U and Steam - merman1974
ZZAP is back - https://www.patreon.com/zzapmagazine
ZZAP is back - https://www.patreon.com/zzapmagazine
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: Politics Thread!
That headline is highly misleading as it tells only part of the story.merman wrote:Privatisation at Whitehall offices has cost £4 million more than it saved
Public and Commercial Services union general secretary Mark Serwotka said: “This is an all-too-familiar story of Tory ministers cutting and privatising, only to find they have wasted money and damaged services.
https://www.nao.org.uk/report/shared-service-centres/
The changes has to date achieved savings of £90m, with costs of £94m. But they are two different things. The savings are ongoing savings that should continue being achieved, and grow as the new system is adopted. The costs are one off and will not need to be repeated. That is why they write:
I.e. they expect far greater savings than the £4m the Guardian is complaining about.The Cabinet Office currently estimates that the two contracts will generate savings of £484 million in total by 2023-24 at a cost of £159 million.
Re: Politics Thread!
So why do we persist in having such a law on the statute books?pogo wrote:Companies do have a legal obligation to work in the best interest of their shareholders. But this can be highly antisocial.
It creates highly antisocial behaviour. It creates a climate of damaging short-termism.
It doesn't even necessarily guarantee the desired outcome: What's really in the best interests of the shareholders? To make a ton of money right now, or to forgo that temporarily to invest it in improving and expanding the business to make an even bigger ton of money in the future?
It's a matter of interpretation and risk. But the former has to be favoured over the latter - hence the short-termism - because there's no interpretation that a ton of money right now is not, at least in the narrow short term, clearly in the favour of the shareholders. The other option is merely an "opportunity cost" and so can be waved away as money that only theoretically could exist. So the safe option here is to grab the money and run right now, however ultimately better and much more brilliant the long-term option could have been.
It's a naively simplistic law applied to a complex and chaotic reality. It can't help - at a systemic level - getting things horribly wrong.
(E.g. in the long term, smoking is doomed. Arguably, it makes more sense for Philip Morris to adapt their business and, say, get into vaping instead - just as, in fact, a heck of a lot of their customers, in rising numbers, are doing, so that really is only chasing the market - so that they can eventually junk the doomed part of their business and live on, in healthy profits, well into the future. And, if they did so, they could even arguably be a force for good - all that muscle re-assigned towards encouraging smokers onto a much safer option for them (N.B. I did not say "safe" but "safer") - helping to stop 100,000 people dying unnecessarily every year in the UK alone. They could actually start sleeping with a clear conscience. They could stop being evil and still make plenty of lovely cash going forward. Short-termism and "tradition" blinds them from seeing that, actually, doing the right thing is actually doing the right thing. Not just morally, but ultimately in terms of their wallets too, as smoking is facing an existential threat going forward and cannot survive. This is the damage that short-termism can do - it actually makes people pick the wrong options for their own long-term self-interest, as they're not looking far enough ahead to see the future possibilities and new markets - and there is actually a law on the statue books that encourages and insists that they do this shit. Get rid of that law!!)
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
- John Maynard Keynes
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: Politics Thread!
Which law? There isn’t a “capitalist law”. We have a capitalist system but that is the default. Or perhaps the default is anarchy, but we have enough rules, regulations, customs and habits to make it a well regulated capitalist system.KlaxonCow wrote:So why do we persist in having such a law on the statute books?
It’s not perfect. Like democracy, capitalism is perhaps the worst system there is, apart from all the others. And we know as we’ve tried the others. We’ve tried feudal systems, command economies, religiously inspired ones, communes. They all work, but by far the most successful has been a capitalist system, with a democratic political system.
- VNVObit
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 4072
- Joined: Sun Jan 01, 2006 10:03 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: vnvobit
- PSN: VNV_Obit
- Location: London
Re: Politics Thread!
You left out some key detailspogo wrote:That headline is highly misleading as it tells only part of the story.merman wrote:Privatisation at Whitehall offices has cost £4 million more than it saved
Public and Commercial Services union general secretary Mark Serwotka said: “This is an all-too-familiar story of Tory ministers cutting and privatising, only to find they have wasted money and damaged services.
https://www.nao.org.uk/report/shared-service-centres/
The changes has to date achieved savings of £90m, with costs of £94m. But they are two different things. The savings are ongoing savings that should continue being achieved, and grow as the new system is adopted. The costs are one off and will not need to be repeated. That is why they write:I.e. they expect far greater savings than the £4m the Guardian is complaining about.The Cabinet Office currently estimates that the two contracts will generate savings of £484 million in total by 2023-24 at a cost of £159 million.
and it is significantly behind schedule with only 2 of the 26 customer departments moving to the single platform that underpin its savings which would indicate that there is probably some optimism bias in the forecast numbersfrom NAO Summary report wrote: However, these savings
are less than those originally forecast in the Strategy of around £128 million per year.
Capitalism is an economic system not a political onepogo wrote:Which law? There isn’t a “capitalist law”. We have a capitalist system but that is the default. Or perhaps the default is anarchy, but we have enough rules, regulations, customs and habits to make it a well regulated capitalist system.KlaxonCow wrote:So why do we persist in having such a law on the statute books?
It’s not perfect. Like democracy, capitalism is perhaps the worst system there is, apart from all the others. And we know as we’ve tried the others. We’ve tried feudal systems, command economies, religiously inspired ones, communes. They all work, but by far the most successful has been a capitalist system, with a democratic political system.
http://www.dictionary.com/browse/capitalism
Capitalists can be legitimate business people who are concerned about others and hold strong social values or at the other end of the spectrum be involved in illegal activity (still providing goods and service just outside of the law) with no regard for others.
sadly the former are relatively rare with disregard for social consequence or ethics being a more prevalent approach.
Interestingly many MBA programs in the US beefed up their focus on ethics in the wake of the financial crash in 2008
"England is funny, but sometimes she scares me"
Tony Wakeford
My avatar is the cover of Tower of Babel's first single
"Sky is not roof, Earth is not bottom, the world is not yours, you are the world's" from Brown by Grotus
Tony Wakeford
My avatar is the cover of Tower of Babel's first single
"Sky is not roof, Earth is not bottom, the world is not yours, you are the world's" from Brown by Grotus
Re: Politics Thread!
The law that requires companies to act in the interests of the shareholders above all else. It is very strongly worded. It is very much an enshrinement of the capitalist principle in law and generally forces companies to act in the goal of profit above all else except when very specifically authorised otherwise.pogo wrote:Which law? There isn’t a “capitalist law”. We have a capitalist system but that is the default. Or perhaps the default is anarchy, but we have enough rules, regulations, customs and habits to make it a well regulated capitalist system.KlaxonCow wrote:So why do we persist in having such a law on the statute books?
It’s not perfect. Like democracy, capitalism is perhaps the worst system there is, apart from all the others. And we know as we’ve tried the others. We’ve tried feudal systems, command economies, religiously inspired ones, communes. They all work, but by far the most successful has been a capitalist system, with a democratic political system.
- zip accident
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 13928
- Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 1:58 pm 0
- Location: Bristol, UK
Re: Politics Thread!
In the UK?Dio wrote:The law that requires companies to act in the interests of the shareholders above all else. It is very strongly worded. It is very much an enshrinement of the capitalist principle in law and generally forces companies to act in the goal of profit above all else except when very specifically authorised otherwise.pogo wrote:Which law? There isn’t a “capitalist law”. We have a capitalist system but that is the default. Or perhaps the default is anarchy, but we have enough rules, regulations, customs and habits to make it a well regulated capitalist system.KlaxonCow wrote:So why do we persist in having such a law on the statute books?
It’s not perfect. Like democracy, capitalism is perhaps the worst system there is, apart from all the others. And we know as we’ve tried the others. We’ve tried feudal systems, command economies, religiously inspired ones, communes. They all work, but by far the most successful has been a capitalist system, with a democratic political system.
"My way is the way of not fighting":- the book of Enter the Dragon.
