That's not what I said. I expressed a higher priority than electability. If Corbyn or anyone else for that matter could get a Labour government into power which would ensure a high floor to society without also handing over elements of the state to the vested interests of the rich and without imposing shite like ID cards, I'd be cock-a-hoop.Dio wrote:It's a specific point to what GY said. He specifically said he doesn't want / care about electability. That's baffling to me. If you're not caring about electability, you're removing your vote from the process to some extent. While we're stuck in FPTP, you have no choice but to make electability your primary concern. As a voter you have to consider your other voters and group with them, unless you're in an utterly safe seat - in which case your vote means the square root of fuck all anyway.
In reality, people in the UK have a different priority - tilting at whatever windmills they are pointed towards and thinking "what's best for me personally" without realising that what's best for anyone personally is ensuring those around them are able to achieve a decent minimum quality of life. And they'll vote accordingly. It's an issue led political discourse in the UK, not a principal led one and that, to me, is the root cause of so many of our problems currently.
While the party I am now (suddenly) a member of gaining power would be preferable in most cases over a Tory government, I'm more concerned that whichever centre-right bunch are currently running things are kept in check by a strong, indefatigable minority opposition. I have seen what happens when a Labour government goes unchecked by weak Tory opposition, by an opposition who agree with the government on so many things, not least of all war and (until convenient just before the 2010 election) on financial policy.
The 'win or bust' mentality ignores the fact that you then create a country with 30 million-odd disenfranchised losers in it. It can't be surprising that we broke with the EU when we break with each other as a matter of routine. Nor can it be surprising that when someone comes along and doggedly sticks to making principled statements about how society should be, millions are drawn to them, regardless of statements to the contrary by those who've done very well (for themselves) out of a realpolitik narrative that these days excludes all else.







