Excellent comment from the
Grauniad's article on how the UK has joined Greece at the bottom of the wage-growth chart in Europe:
Predictably, the armchair economists have established that immigration from low wage countries is the sole variable that has driven down wage growth in the UK. Alas, reality is far more complex with many factors at work making such simplistic, one variable explanations “x causes y” claims very difficult.
In no other area of economics is this more relevant than in the realm of labour economics. Labour, unlike capital or land is not as mobile as capital, particularly in Europe with various natural barriers such as language, culture, recognition of degrees etc. etc. And often factors such as the proximity of close family members, availability of benefits, gender, age, marital status, presence of younger children in the household etc. make labour mobility even more sluggish. Despite these barriers, I see at least 3 categories of forces at work that affect migration:
1) Pull or demand forces from UK employers responding to market opportunities
2) Push or supply forces, such as unemployment & poverty, primarily in E.Europe and perhaps Iberia.
3) UK government policies with respect to wage inflation, minimum wage policies, the balance between worker protection vs flexibility for firms, FDI, competitiveness of UK exports and other macroeconomic considerations also come into play.
The interplay of these forces make certain categories of workers want to move to the UK and that sometimes can depress wages for certain types of UK workers.
However, not all immigrant labour is the same and not all immigrants depress wages for UK workers. For the sake of simplicity, let me lump immigrant labour into two groups:
a) specialist labour
b) unskilled labour.
One of the mistakes that people make while discussing migration is that they lump the two categories of immigrants together. In the market for expert economists, specialist software engineers, anaesthetists, paediatric nurses etc., immigrants often do not compete on price but by bringing specialist skills to the table. For instance, it is safe to say that the Canadian economist Mark Carney who migrated to the UK to head the Bank of England did not depress wages for economists. The same applies to medical personnel who move to work in the NHS or software engineers.
With regard to unskilled labour, there is massive demand for backbreaking, repetitive and seasonal labour in fields, hotels, hospitals, in cleaning agencies etc. Government policies starting with Thatcher and continued by ersatz Tories like Blair have weakened trade unions for the unskilled and immensely strengthened the bargaining power of employers. Employment conditions are appalling, zero hour contracts flourish and firms like Sports Direct, Ryan Air etc. have exploited foreign workers to hold wages of UK employees down. Indeed, the zero hour contract epitomises the damage that Thatcher and her ilk have wrought on the UK working classes. The poor quality jobs that are available to unskilled workers do not appeal to UK workers, especially if they entail travel. Why would a single mom on benefits uproot herself and her children from her city to take a temporary, low paid gig in another city? Especially if her kids are in school and she probably has parents in the vicinity who might be able to help with child care etc. etc. ? Such jobs might appeal to people in countries that do not have a welfare net, have massive un-employment and also have many young, mobile workers.
In conclusion, I will agree with many here who suggest that immigration holds wages down for UK natives, usually unskilled labour. But immigration is not the sole cause of low wages. Low wage growth is due to UK government policy to hold wage inflation down by wrecking unions, tipping the playing field in favour of employers and allowing firms to treat a human being as a commodity to be bought and sold. Rather than immigrants or the EU, blame for this sordid state of affairs falls fairly and squarely on the UK government.
Brexit won’t solve it though - you still have the same Thatcherites at the helm of affairs.