pogo wrote:After contributing over £130bn to save the banks we will be ahead by £14.3bn (an independent Rothschild report).
Politics Thread!
Re: Politics Thread!
Trippy vibes...
http://soundcloud.com/two-gapper
http://soundcloud.com/two-gapper
- VNVObit
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 4072
- Joined: Sun Jan 01, 2006 10:03 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: vnvobit
- PSN: VNV_Obit
- Location: London
Re: Politics Thread!
pogo wrote:I’d still say about even. After contributing over £130bn to save the banks we will be ahead by £14.3bn (an independent Rothschild report). Or £9.2bn (the independent OBR). Or a E17bn – £14bn loss (C4). Depending what assumptions you make, and when you do the calculations, you can come out with all sorts of answers. It’s worse now, as bank shares have fallen reducing the value of the government’s stake. Hopefully they will rise again before the government sells them.
both Rothschild and OBR numbers are before the interest costs from funding so both are misleading in that respect.
"England is funny, but sometimes she scares me"
Tony Wakeford
My avatar is the cover of Tower of Babel's first single
"Sky is not roof, Earth is not bottom, the world is not yours, you are the world's" from Brown by Grotus
Tony Wakeford
My avatar is the cover of Tower of Babel's first single
"Sky is not roof, Earth is not bottom, the world is not yours, you are the world's" from Brown by Grotus
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: Politics Thread!
That’s what C4 called it, more precisely “an independent report from financial advisers Rothschild”, and I was going by that having not read it. The OBR is certainly independent.(o)(o) wrote:pogo wrote:After contributing over £130bn to save the banks we will be ahead by £14.3bn (an independent Rothschild report).
C4 don’t disagree with them, but they also add in an estimate of the cost of borrowing, to get another value. But that’s not how you usually cost things done by the government. E.g. PFI; in theory you should subtract the cost of borrowing, as if the government had borrowed directly they would have paid interest. But you don’t, you just treat the current cost as the right one.
Anyway, with interest rates low borrowing costs do not make that big a difference. Share price movements make much more of a difference.
Re: Politics Thread!
Amazing, investment bank claims giving a load of money to banks is a good deal for the tax payer.
Meanwhile back in the real world:
https://www.nao.org.uk/highlights/taxpa ... anks-faqs/
There's currently £85bn in outstanding support, the majority of which is shares held in RBS / Lloyds. That loss predicted on RBS shares will likely be more, especially given the results just released and many view the expectation.
You can also see many services and loans were supplied to the banks below market value.
These banks exist now because of a trampoline paid for by the tax payer that will ultimately reward the banks shareholders. I understand why they were saved and the real issue is poor regulation and terrible management by the banks. But there is a huge cost to this and it's involed huge amounts of tax payers money.
Anyway. As the NAO say:
Meanwhile back in the real world:
https://www.nao.org.uk/highlights/taxpa ... anks-faqs/
There's currently £85bn in outstanding support, the majority of which is shares held in RBS / Lloyds. That loss predicted on RBS shares will likely be more, especially given the results just released and many view the expectation.
You can also see many services and loans were supplied to the banks below market value.
These banks exist now because of a trampoline paid for by the tax payer that will ultimately reward the banks shareholders. I understand why they were saved and the real issue is poor regulation and terrible management by the banks. But there is a huge cost to this and it's involed huge amounts of tax payers money.
Anyway. As the NAO say:
The income generated by fees and interest is less than would be expected from a normal market investment and has not compensated the taxpayer for the degree of risk accepted by taxpayers in providing the support. Once the opportunity cost and risks are factored in, the schemes have represented a transfer from taxpayers to the financial sector.
The fees and interest were generally set with a view of what the recipient banks could afford at the time, in keeping with the schemes’ aims for financial stability. Any transfer from taxpayers to the financial sector can be regarded as part of the cost of preserving financial stability in the crisis, and as reported in 2009, had the support not been provided, the potential costs would have been difficult to envision.
Re: Politics Thread!
Oh here's a summary of the Rothschild report from 2015

Putting aside a complete failure to factor in the cost of financing you can see that the pricing of the remaining RBS shares are the variable that make the most difference here.
They're not worth that today, the figure in NAO report £18.8bn which brings us to breakeven and they have Lloyds at £4.4bn which would adjust the report to net negative. Both of the banks shares have tumbled a bit since and Lloyds was at a 5 yr peak in 2015 which it's unlikely to see again. Thanks brexit!
That said I don't know if other income has come in from either bank since that report.

Putting aside a complete failure to factor in the cost of financing you can see that the pricing of the remaining RBS shares are the variable that make the most difference here.
They're not worth that today, the figure in NAO report £18.8bn which brings us to breakeven and they have Lloyds at £4.4bn which would adjust the report to net negative. Both of the banks shares have tumbled a bit since and Lloyds was at a 5 yr peak in 2015 which it's unlikely to see again. Thanks brexit!
That said I don't know if other income has come in from either bank since that report.
Re: Politics Thread!
The share holdings are imaginary money anyway. they're only worth what you can sell them for, and you can't dump 51 billion pounds "worth" of shares without driving the price to zero.
"massive retard™", "full of shit™", "tiny bitch™", "retarted™", "a bit of a one trick pony™", "petty™", "simple minded idealistic twat™", "miserable humourless fucker™"
Re: Politics Thread!
Oh yeah definitely. The Lloyd's shares are realisable but there's no way they could ever get the market price for RBS with that volume.tufty wrote:The share holdings are imaginary money anyway. they're only worth what you can sell them for, and you can't dump 51 billion pounds "worth" of shares without driving the price to zero.
But putting that aside pogo is still basing his "WE MADE A PROFIT!!!" numbers on a valuation that's plummeted since and the trend is likely further in the same direction
Maybe the government should short them
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: Politics Thread!
I did not write “we made a profit”. I was objecting to e.g.
I know it does not matter. Someone somewhere will do the calculations and say “but if only if they’d sold RBS on date xxx instead they would have made £1bn more!”. But it’s always the case there’s a better date to sell on. People still criticise Gordon Brown for selling our gold reserves too cheaply, 15 years ago, but he could not have known the price would rise after. No-one knew.
But they were not gifts, or grants, they were loans. Converted to shareholdings, so the government gets dividends and eventually is repaid by selling the shares. They might make a profit or loss when this happens, but that is not the point.KlaxonCow wrote:What I don't understand is why we gave the banks free money.
I know it does not matter. Someone somewhere will do the calculations and say “but if only if they’d sold RBS on date xxx instead they would have made £1bn more!”. But it’s always the case there’s a better date to sell on. People still criticise Gordon Brown for selling our gold reserves too cheaply, 15 years ago, but he could not have known the price would rise after. No-one knew.
Re: Politics Thread!
pogo wrote: But they were not gifts, or grants, they were loans. Converted to shareholdings, so the government gets dividends and eventually is repaid by selling the shares. They might make a profit or loss when this happens, but that is not the point.
Erm no, that IS the point.
The dividends do not belong to the government, the government is not a private investor (what investor would invest in a failing already bust company?) the tax payer should be paid a return, not the government. Is that happening ? No.
So as it turns out, effectively it was a gift. You would have to be some sort of a spastic to believe it was an investment.
Lork oh lordy, my bottom's on fire!
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: Politics Thread!
Utter nonsense. The government is funded in all sorts of ways. Through taxes, through duties, through fines + penalties, through asset sales, through treaties and deals with other countries, and sometimes though shareholdings. It makes no sense to inefficiently and expensively disburse any of them to taxpayers. The government needs the money for schools, hospitals and nuclear submarines so would just take it back through taxes, and it would be a pointless exercise.
But that is irrelevant. It is not a gift to the banks as everything the government paid they have been compensated for. The problem is some of that was in shares, which they cannot offload all at once as it would disrupt the markets and they would get a lower price. So many shares it would take years to get rid of them all, and prices can go up and down a lot over months and years. We won’t know until all the shares are sold, whether they made a net profit or loss, and even that may depend on what assumptions you make, as seen in the figures C4 came up with in 2015.
But that is irrelevant. It is not a gift to the banks as everything the government paid they have been compensated for. The problem is some of that was in shares, which they cannot offload all at once as it would disrupt the markets and they would get a lower price. So many shares it would take years to get rid of them all, and prices can go up and down a lot over months and years. We won’t know until all the shares are sold, whether they made a net profit or loss, and even that may depend on what assumptions you make, as seen in the figures C4 came up with in 2015.
Re: Politics Thread!
Loans converted to shareholdings, so loans with no repayment terms and where the risk is carried by the lender. 130 billion given to corrupt / incompetent institutions in order that they could carry on trading, carry on getting paid.pogo wrote:But they were not gifts, or grants, they were loans
Lest we forget
"massive retard™", "full of shit™", "tiny bitch™", "retarted™", "a bit of a one trick pony™", "petty™", "simple minded idealistic twat™", "miserable humourless fucker™"
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: Politics Thread!
Corybynomics:
Corbyn: I would put up taxes to fund public sector pay rises
One thing wrong with this is having the goal of paying public sector workers more. That‘s how Blair and Brown got into trouble, saying they were “investing” in public services by putting more money in, but without targets or reforms the money just got pocketed by civil servants, and we ended up with nothing to show for it except an ever growing budget and a deficit. I guess you can credit Corbyn for honesty: he does not pretend it’s about better public services, just richer public servants.
But the main problem is paying for it with a 50% top tax rate. We’ve tried it before, and it raised only a small fraction of the amount predicted. Furthermore the evidence suggests that setting the rate to 45% instead of 50% would raise just as much with far fewer distortionary effects, and that is the current rate, leaving no scope to raise more by raising the rate.
There are taxes he could raise, such as VAT, NI, but they would be less popular and have a wider economic impact. But in the end his plans are just too ambitious for plugging the gap with the tax code, and he will need to borrow almost all the £500bn needed for his investment bank and other promises.
Corbyn: I would put up taxes to fund public sector pay rises
One thing wrong with this is having the goal of paying public sector workers more. That‘s how Blair and Brown got into trouble, saying they were “investing” in public services by putting more money in, but without targets or reforms the money just got pocketed by civil servants, and we ended up with nothing to show for it except an ever growing budget and a deficit. I guess you can credit Corbyn for honesty: he does not pretend it’s about better public services, just richer public servants.
But the main problem is paying for it with a 50% top tax rate. We’ve tried it before, and it raised only a small fraction of the amount predicted. Furthermore the evidence suggests that setting the rate to 45% instead of 50% would raise just as much with far fewer distortionary effects, and that is the current rate, leaving no scope to raise more by raising the rate.
There are taxes he could raise, such as VAT, NI, but they would be less popular and have a wider economic impact. But in the end his plans are just too ambitious for plugging the gap with the tax code, and he will need to borrow almost all the £500bn needed for his investment bank and other promises.
Re: Politics Thread!
That's not true. We overpaid hugely.pogo wrote: But that is irrelevant. It is not a gift to the banks as everything the government paid they have been compensated for.
We pumped in a shit load of capital in return for new shares because RBS's rights issue failed.
The worth something is defined by what the market is prepared to pay. The money put into RBS by the government was set not by worth but the worth of not having it collapse.
And after that exchanging our rights to a coupon payment to MOAR SHARES was another huge mistake and loss of return for the tax payer.
It's a gift, everyone knows it
Re: Politics Thread!
It was already proposed, it's not nonsense and certainly not utter nonsense.pogo wrote:Utter nonsense. The government is funded in all sorts of ways. Through taxes, through duties, through fines + penalties, through asset sales, through treaties and deals with other countries, and sometimes though shareholdings. It makes no sense to inefficiently and expensively disburse any of them to taxpayers. The government needs the money for schools, hospitals and nuclear submarines so would just take it back through taxes, and it would be a pointless exercise..
The returns are paid and it goes to stimulate the economy as people spend it.Instead as usual they will be sold to those who can afford even though it was the people's money that was used.
Why you're warbling off on a tangent about how the government gains and distributes money is beyond me.
Lork oh lordy, my bottom's on fire!
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: Politics Thread!
Well, there are many ways of looking at it. I think we did what was necessary at the time. I criticise Gordon Brown for many things but this is one thing he got right, rapidly putting in place financing and legislation to rescue the banks.gravy wrote:It's a gift, everyone knows it
Converting to shares made a lot of sense, as it meant the government could participate in corporate governance in a normal way, and made it easy for the government to exit from the arrangement by just selling the shares, although they could not do so all at once.
The danger with shares is that prices go up and down, so the government could suffer a loss when the shares are all sold. But as with Brown’s gold sale there is nothing that could be done about this. When it’s time to sell it‘s time to sell, there is no point trying to play the market and wait for a better price.

