k345y wrote:It was already proposed, it's not nonsense and certainly not utter nonsense.
Where was it proposed (apart from by you) that the money loaned to the banks should not be repaid to the government but given out to taxpayers? The problem is the government needs that money. If it does not get it from the banks it will raise it in tax, so take it back off the people who received it. After all, with a sudden windfall from the banks, they will be able to afford an extra tax contribution. And so nothing will have been achieved except a massive amount of pointless paperwork.
It would be different if it were redistributive, so e.g. different people paid more tax to those who received it. But if you want to redistribute money through the tax system there are much simpler ways to do it, such as varying existing taxes and benefits, bearing in mind the limitations of doing so (see my Corbynomics post above). It‘s also easier to explain to voters, instead of a convoluted scheme involving the bank bailouts.
Well, there are many ways of looking at it. I think we did what was necessary at the time.
I'm in agreement
pogo wrote:Converting to shares made a lot of sense, as it meant the government could participate in corporate governance in a normal way, and made it easy for the government to exit from the arrangement by just selling the shares, although they could not do so all at once
I'm not talking about that. We owned the majority of the bank with a class of shares that paid an annual coupon (~£600m). We converted the preference shares to ordinary shares and dumped the coupon. We already owned enough to basically tell the bank what to do but were receiving cash payments that reduced the speculative risk.
Changing that was a big mistake IMHO
As for the share purchase in the first place? We're saying the bank is an essential piece of national infrastructure that we cannot let fail. That's fine but there should also be legislation specifically for company's we're underwriting to reduce the risk of having to do it. That or plan our economy in a way that these institutions can fail.
Basically there should be an insurance cost rather than relying on having to overpay for a banks shares to exert some influence.
gravy wrote:That or plan our economy in a way that these institutions can fail
There will be from 2019, when ring-fencing rules come into force. Then banks can make stupid bets on the money markets, and those bits of them can be allowed to fail, while the systemically important retail bits are protected.
gravy wrote:That or plan our economy in a way that these institutions can fail
There will be from 2019, when ring-fencing rules come into force. Then banks can make stupid bets on the money markets, and those bits of them can be allowed to fail, while the systemically important retail bits are protected.
The consensus is that crises like 2008-09 don’t come along very often. The one before was in the 1920s after all. Our banks won’t be over-extending themselves in the money markets any time soon, they are too busy rebuilding their reserves and returning to reliable profitability.
So these are very much long term measures, and there is no urgency to do it earlier than 2019. The biggest danger is long term. Not that these measures won’t work, but that in a few decades time the lessons of this crisis will have been forgotten and these rules will no longer seem necessary, and may be ignored or repealed. That’s what happened in the US: they had laws to stop a crisis happening, the Glass-Stegall act enacted in 1933. It was repealed in 1999 as they thought it no longer necessary, and we all know what happened next.
pogo wrote:I think we did what was necessary at the time.
I'm in agreement
We're all in agreement, as no-one on this thread has suggested otherwise.
I'll re-emphasise the basic point.
Society was just fine (relatively speaking) and the banks were teetering on the brink of collapse. Now, society is suffering and the banks are doing just fine and dandy, thank you very much.
However the mechanism that delivered it, there has been a transfer of prosperity from wider society to the banks.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
The consensus is that crises like 2008-09 don’t come along very often.
They come more frequently if the banks know they are "safe" though. Demonstrating "we wont let you fail" changes the rules by itself, so any predictions based on history are worthless. If they were worth anything to start. This isn't radioactive decays, its people, and world conditions might change the change of something year by year.
Not that these measures won’t work, but that in a few decades time the lessons of this crisis will have been forgotten and these rules will no longer seem necessary, and may be ignored or repealed. That’s what happened in the US: they had laws to stop a crisis happening, the Glass-Stegall act enacted in 1933. It was repealed in 1999 as they thought it no longer necessary, and we all know what happened next.
Yes that's very true.
Some parallels with their racism too. "ohh...look at these old anti-racism laws. No need to have them any more is there!"
Forgetting what can go wrong is dangerous.
KlaxonCow wrote:Society was just fine (relatively speaking) and the banks were teetering on the brink of collapse. Now, society is suffering and the banks are doing just fine and dandy, thank you very much.
However the mechanism that delivered it, there has been a transfer of prosperity from wider society to the banks.
No, there hasn’t. The banks that were bailed out are worth a small fraction what they were before the crisis. They have suffered massive losses, not gains “from wider society”. Yes, we may suffer a loss on the bailout but that’s as share prices have fallen further since, not because the bailouts were too generous.
This is a myth promoted by some on the left: that we only have austerity as money was given to the banks – we would not need austerity if banks paid their “fair share”. But no, we had to make cuts as we could not afford the size of state we had before 2008. We could not afford it then, can afford it even less now.
KlaxonCow wrote:Society was just fine (relatively speaking) and the banks were teetering on the brink of collapse. Now, society is suffering and the banks are doing just fine and dandy, thank you very much.
However the mechanism that delivered it, there has been a transfer of prosperity from wider society to the banks.
No, there hasn’t. The banks that were bailed out are worth a small fraction what they were before the crisis. They have suffered massive losses, not gains “from wider society”. Yes, we may suffer a loss on the bailout but that’s as share prices have fallen further since, not because the bailouts were too generous.
This is a myth promoted by some on the left: that we only have austerity as money was given to the banks – we would not need austerity if banks paid their “fair share”. But no, we had to make cuts as we could not afford the size of state we had before 2008. We could not afford it then, can afford it even less now.
Except austerity (as exacted by UK Govt) has been thoroughly discredited, and it takes significant levels of willfull self-ignorance to be blind to the very IN YOUR FACE evidence that the richest in society have benefited from the recession - including fat cat bankers and city executives - at the expense of everybody else. The shitcunts who drove austerity are on record saying 'we're gonna keep shrinking the state anyway' which basically gives the game away.
Cuts (or spending!) might have been needed from a monetary POV but austerity has been an ideological programme of very excessive regressions that will blight generations to come. That's what we predicted and that's what happened. It wasn't necessary to turn the NHS into a basketcase to balance the books for example.
k345y wrote:It was already proposed, it's not nonsense and certainly not utter nonsense.
Where was it proposed (apart from by you) that the money loaned to the banks should not be repaid to the government but given out to taxpayers?
Can't find a link, perhaps you have better search skills than I.
Please don't misconstrue what I said.
The taxpayers would get a share of the dividend when the banks were sold off,not that the money loaned would go to the tax payer instead of the government. I mean seriously, come on to fuck...
Ah I misunderstood – I thought you meant all repayments. The amounts of just dividends are much smaller, but the same applies: why create a novel and separate scheme to distribute dividends, when we have many ways to channel money to voters and taxpayers already? Just cut taxes, or raise benefits.
The problem is, if the government needs the money, it would just have to find it somewhere else, perhaps with tax rises or spending cuts, so the net effect is zero. Except for the cost and effort of creating this scheme which would be non-trivial. So better that the government retains the money, and uses it to help repay the money used to bailout the banks. One day when the deficit has been eliminated and government debt is decreasing, we can maybe afford tax cuts for everyone. But not yet.