Ok, the good:
The quests can be really, really good fun - I had a water world where an alien gave me the run-around; go here, go there, oh look, I'm not at the bottom of the ocean, I'm on the top of a hill - here, have this essential ship part for finding me. That was great fun, and the ocean was great to explore - lots of jellyfish and octopus things in there.
Then I hit a texture bug - no, that's cracks in the ice, the water surface is
ice and you can see cracks in it. Wow.
Then went to a toxic snowy wasteland and saw... Dinosaurs! And HUGE, ENORMOUS FLYING SNAKES! and HUGE FLYING WHALE THINGS!
And diving down to a planet with headphones on is a very very loud and rumbling experience, and not just a little scary
What else? The puzzles are easy enough that you'll do pretty well, but not plainly obvious at first glance. Nice. Ruins are great, there's a destroyed civilisation out there.
Space is HUGE, space stations are fun to buzz around, asteroid mining is plentiful. Not hyperspaced yet, but flying around under pulse drive is exhilarating. Watching ships land and take off at ports is beautiful.
The whole damned game is beautiful. It really is.
The bad:
The texture/geometry pop-in. It's awful, especially when flying. Not so bad on foot though.
No custom resolutions. My macbook's native res is 2880x1800, and that's supported by the halved non-retina resolution isn't. Closest to it is 1280x800, which doesn't look too great.
The UI is abysmal. Some options in the settings require you to press and hold, others just click. Inventory management is convoluted and non-obvious. Can't connect to servers - day one issue most likely. I still get credits (units) for my discoveries, but I can't upload them.
The ... combat? aiming? is bad, really bad. The problem there is the waypoints that overlay on the HUD distract you from where you're pointing, so you miss stuff. If you've got focus on an object, you should target that object IMO. And the crosshair is a tiny dot.
One thing I do wish you could do is look around whilst in the cockpit. That would rock. Also being able to look behind you as you soar upwards into space - you could do that in Frontier, and it was amazing.
Seamless planetary landings is pretty cool though.
More as I play more. God, there is so much to
do in this. Lots to investigate.
"Oh dear lord, I slightly soiled myself. Oxfam won’t be pleased."