No Man's Sky
Re: No Man's Sky
I have a terrible feeling that it got nerfed for the PS4.
Because the thing is that it's not just the missing features seen in the trailers, as there was a post on Reddit where a guy went through the entire list of promised things that aren't in the actual game and he links to videos where you've got Sean Murray actually playing debug and development versions of the game. Letting other people play it.
And there's rivers. There's a planet with sand dunes. Someone else is playing - not Sean - and he directs them to use their binoculars to mark a waypoint on the map and it works. There's more variety of buildings, some with moving parts on them.
In one of the videos, there was a portal - like a stargate - on the side of a structure and it's activated. The interesting thing is that these structures do still exist in the game - folks have found them - though they do not come up on scans, they can't be activated and do nothing. Just static geometry. It looks like these portals were once part of the game, but then they got cut and instead of removing them (probably might have required too much work changing the algorithms at a late stage in development), they're still there but just now do nothing.
It's clearly not just a case of rigging up stuff to look better for the trailers - a bit of false advertising, a la "Colonial Marines" - as these things really did once exist in the game.
And when it was first revealed, this was a PC game. They said that PC was the lead platform. And, come on, with its grandiose ambition, that makes sense to the PC's capabilities.
But then Sony got interested and involved, and the PS4 became a target and it was released for PS4 first.
(As I picked up on before in another thread, this is actually not unprecedented. Someone discovered that if you tweaked the config files of "Watchdogs" on PC, you could actually unlock the much better graphics that they demoed at E3:
So, in that instance, the actually released PC game ships with the superior E3 graphics, but the config files nerf them. And it's not because of performance issues, as that's just fine - perfectly reasonable - when you turn it all back on.
It's beyond mere false advertising. This game actually ships capable of what was promised by the trailers - you can turn it all back on, so that version of the game really does exist - but it's all been strangely turned off for release.)
And one has to suspect that the reason is because, though the PC can do it, the consoles can't. And there's perhaps a deliberate nerfing of these games for console, which is then maintained on PC too, because they don't want the PC release to obviously outshine the console release. Not when Sony is the one marketing and funding you anyway.
Because the thing is that it's not just the missing features seen in the trailers, as there was a post on Reddit where a guy went through the entire list of promised things that aren't in the actual game and he links to videos where you've got Sean Murray actually playing debug and development versions of the game. Letting other people play it.
And there's rivers. There's a planet with sand dunes. Someone else is playing - not Sean - and he directs them to use their binoculars to mark a waypoint on the map and it works. There's more variety of buildings, some with moving parts on them.
In one of the videos, there was a portal - like a stargate - on the side of a structure and it's activated. The interesting thing is that these structures do still exist in the game - folks have found them - though they do not come up on scans, they can't be activated and do nothing. Just static geometry. It looks like these portals were once part of the game, but then they got cut and instead of removing them (probably might have required too much work changing the algorithms at a late stage in development), they're still there but just now do nothing.
It's clearly not just a case of rigging up stuff to look better for the trailers - a bit of false advertising, a la "Colonial Marines" - as these things really did once exist in the game.
And when it was first revealed, this was a PC game. They said that PC was the lead platform. And, come on, with its grandiose ambition, that makes sense to the PC's capabilities.
But then Sony got interested and involved, and the PS4 became a target and it was released for PS4 first.
(As I picked up on before in another thread, this is actually not unprecedented. Someone discovered that if you tweaked the config files of "Watchdogs" on PC, you could actually unlock the much better graphics that they demoed at E3:
So, in that instance, the actually released PC game ships with the superior E3 graphics, but the config files nerf them. And it's not because of performance issues, as that's just fine - perfectly reasonable - when you turn it all back on.
It's beyond mere false advertising. This game actually ships capable of what was promised by the trailers - you can turn it all back on, so that version of the game really does exist - but it's all been strangely turned off for release.)
And one has to suspect that the reason is because, though the PC can do it, the consoles can't. And there's perhaps a deliberate nerfing of these games for console, which is then maintained on PC too, because they don't want the PC release to obviously outshine the console release. Not when Sony is the one marketing and funding you anyway.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
- John Maynard Keynes
Re: No Man's Sky
The big problem is releasing it as the same time on Steam for PC
PC Master Race are a lot less forgiving than er.. normal gamers
As an aside Watchdogs sold 10m units. I'm a bit WHAATTT at that. However I've not played it. The internet narrative was the game was ruined by falling short of what was promised but that's the sound of the loudest mouths on the internet. Sales seem to indicate they may not be representative of everyone.
FWIW I wish they'd done a bit more development of released it for a cheaper price but that may not have been possible; they have to pay bills.
I have enjoyed NMS though and hope they layer in some of the features originally planned as free updates. We'll see.
PC Master Race are a lot less forgiving than er.. normal gamers
As an aside Watchdogs sold 10m units. I'm a bit WHAATTT at that. However I've not played it. The internet narrative was the game was ruined by falling short of what was promised but that's the sound of the loudest mouths on the internet. Sales seem to indicate they may not be representative of everyone.
FWIW I wish they'd done a bit more development of released it for a cheaper price but that may not have been possible; they have to pay bills.
I have enjoyed NMS though and hope they layer in some of the features originally planned as free updates. We'll see.
Re: No Man's Sky
by all accounts the game has sold a ridiculous amount ~ and at full price for a pretty small team. I'm hoping they can sit back, employ some more staff and fully load the game up with features now. I've seen a few videos online with lots of lush veg and several beasties - not quite the same quality of the trailers, but not too far off.
Re: No Man's Sky
There is that.gravy wrote:PC Master Race are a lot less forgiving than er.. normal gamers
Because when the PS4 version got released, just before the PC release, the consensus was that it was a great game.
It's with PC release that it's now been deemed "overhyped crap".
Hopefully.gravy wrote:I have enjoyed NMS though and hope they layer in some of the features originally planned as free updates. We'll see.
It's kind of shame, in a certain sense, that it got overhyped and sold to the public as this mega-epic AAA title. Because the £20 early access indie survival game that it actually is, is one of the better examples of the genre.
That is, if this had just come out without any of the hype for £20, then folks would be praising it as rather awesome from a small indie team. But because it had all the hype of "infinite variety" then when you see two plants or animals that don't really look that much different to each other, you're disappointed that it doesn't seem as "infinite" as was promised. But imagine that hype hadn't happened and you didn't know anything about the game, so weren't expecting any variety at all. You'd actually look at it and think "hey, this game's got a ton of variety in the wildlife that no other game (save Spore) comes close to matching. That's cool".
As the saying goes, "the secret to happiness is low expectations". Then everything's a wonderfully pleasant surprise to you.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
- John Maynard Keynes
Re: No Man's Sky
I don't think it is repetition, well not for PC people anyway, more the quality (or rather lack thereof) of the graphics. I mean it's a good game but looks really dated in the visuals and I'm in no way a 'graphics are eveything' person. I like gameplay first and foremost but this doesn't even look like a recent-ish game.KlaxonCow wrote:There is that.gravy wrote:PC Master Race are a lot less forgiving than er.. normal gamers
Because when the PS4 version got released, just before the PC release, the consensus was that it was a great game.
It's with PC release that it's now been deemed "overhyped crap".
Hopefully.gravy wrote:I have enjoyed NMS though and hope they layer in some of the features originally planned as free updates. We'll see.
It's kind of shame, in a certain sense, that it got overhyped and sold to the public as this mega-epic AAA title. Because the £20 early access indie survival game that it actually is, is one of the better examples of the genre.
That is, if this had just come out without any of the hype for £20, then folks would be praising it as rather awesome from a small indie team. But because it had all the hype of "infinite variety" then when you see two plants or animals that don't really look that much different to each other, you're disappointed that it doesn't seem as "infinite" as was promised. But imagine that hype hadn't happened and you didn't know anything about the game, so weren't expecting any variety at all. You'd actually look at it and think "hey, this game's got a ton of variety in the wildlife that no other game (save Spore) comes close to matching. That's cool".
As the saying goes, "the secret to happiness is low expectations". Then everything's a wonderfully pleasant surprise to you.
Re: No Man's Sky
If it counts for anything, I found a planet with rivers
Sit down you little bastard
Re: No Man's Sky
A little of item A, a little of item B.
Klaxon is probably right about the PS4 nerf though. Rivers have been found - I've seen them myself. The creature AI is actually pretty fun when you see them doing something interesting - had a crab spider charge into a herd of about 10 or 15 beasts and watched them scatter; the crab thing caught one and killed it. But you don't see that kind of behaviour often.
The portals are in, but inactive. The giant sandworms are there as part of the procedural creature assets, but nobody's seen them yet (if they've not been deactivated). All the parts needed to build the dinosaurs are in, but nobody's really seen exactly those from the video. I've certainly seen creatures that size though. The creatures do not affect their environment, sadly. I've not seen a crashed ship as large as the demo'd one, but I'd imagine that it's possible - I found one that was pretty damned big and the game wouldn't let me repair it but I did plunder it for tech.
Flight and combat in space suffers greatly from a low frame rate - I've since upgraded to a nice new PC and with the UI and resolution mods in it plays fantastically with really great fun dogfights. There are space combat wars going on up there in some systems, and you can pick a side; just start firing. You get bonus rep if you side with that system's dominant race (or really the only race as it seems to be one per system).
With some updates to fix the bugs and add back the features taken out for the PS4, this could be exactly what was promised. As it is I'm still having fun, it's very very chilled (unless you get a hot storm miles from shelter when it becomes a nerve-wracking fight to survive).
So IMO it's not everyone's cup of tea and that's the most obvious thing on the internet atm. And that's fine, because for me it's an astonishing achievement.
Klaxon is probably right about the PS4 nerf though. Rivers have been found - I've seen them myself. The creature AI is actually pretty fun when you see them doing something interesting - had a crab spider charge into a herd of about 10 or 15 beasts and watched them scatter; the crab thing caught one and killed it. But you don't see that kind of behaviour often.
The portals are in, but inactive. The giant sandworms are there as part of the procedural creature assets, but nobody's seen them yet (if they've not been deactivated). All the parts needed to build the dinosaurs are in, but nobody's really seen exactly those from the video. I've certainly seen creatures that size though. The creatures do not affect their environment, sadly. I've not seen a crashed ship as large as the demo'd one, but I'd imagine that it's possible - I found one that was pretty damned big and the game wouldn't let me repair it but I did plunder it for tech.
Flight and combat in space suffers greatly from a low frame rate - I've since upgraded to a nice new PC and with the UI and resolution mods in it plays fantastically with really great fun dogfights. There are space combat wars going on up there in some systems, and you can pick a side; just start firing. You get bonus rep if you side with that system's dominant race (or really the only race as it seems to be one per system).
With some updates to fix the bugs and add back the features taken out for the PS4, this could be exactly what was promised. As it is I'm still having fun, it's very very chilled (unless you get a hot storm miles from shelter when it becomes a nerve-wracking fight to survive).
So IMO it's not everyone's cup of tea and that's the most obvious thing on the internet atm. And that's fine, because for me it's an astonishing achievement.
"Oh dear lord, I slightly soiled myself. Oxfam won’t be pleased."
Re: No Man's Sky
Went back to where I left my ship last night and upon loading my save found that while I'd been away someone else had arrived in the system, discovered the rest of the planets and even named one of them "wholelottagold".
Not so extremely unlikely to bump into anyone else in those quintillions of planets then!
Not so extremely unlikely to bump into anyone else in those quintillions of planets then!
Justified and Ancient.
Re: No Man's Sky
That problem does my head in, sometimes. Procedural generation is meant to imply things are the same when you revisit and that's where continuity comes from. If you try to upgrade the algorithms to introduce new features then massive chaos effect can take over and continuity collapses; so you have to restrict the changed algorithms to undiscovered areas (somewhat penalizing active explorers who've established a large space of legacy boring worlds).gravy wrote:I have enjoyed NMS though and hope they layer in some of the features originally planned as free updates. We'll see.
But that spoiler video guy did say that part of what makes a good discovery good is that it's so rare. What would be the point if every world contained a cool thing from the trailers?
Sounds like a classic case of srand(time(NULL)).Yak wrote:Not so extremely unlikely to bump into anyone else in those quintillions of planets then!
- RiK
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 16092
- Joined: Tue Apr 23, 2002 11:32 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: Dr Olpin
- PSN: Dr Thumpy
- Location: The Shire
- Contact:
Re: No Man's Sky
RiK
Yakyak Admin
Martial Arts: http://www.BlackBeltAcademy.info
Photography: http://www.richardolpinphotography.co.uk
Yakyak Admin
Martial Arts: http://www.BlackBeltAcademy.info
Photography: http://www.richardolpinphotography.co.uk
Re: No Man's Sky
Ouch 
And largely correct, too.
And largely correct, too.
"Oh dear lord, I slightly soiled myself. Oxfam won’t be pleased."
Re: No Man's Sky
There is a hell of a back lash on this game. People are mostly annoyed that there is no online when clearly Sean said their was. It does crash a lot. I normally get 1 crash every 3-4 of hours. Not too big of a deal b/c it constantly saves. I think it is the scale of the thing. B/C it is the biggest game ever made I think, this may cause some of the crashes. It also feels a little rough around the edges. It doesn't feel triple A, It's not a polished. But overall I'm enjoy it, even if it is a bit simplistic.
Star systems explained. Yellow is Standard. Blue has the prettiest planets etc.
https://www.reddit.com/r/NoMansSkyTheGa ... r_systems/
Star systems explained. Yellow is Standard. Blue has the prettiest planets etc.
https://www.reddit.com/r/NoMansSkyTheGa ... r_systems/
.
.
.
.
....I'm the BEST thing that has ever happened to ME............I think therefore I'm a Yam.
.
.
.
....I'm the BEST thing that has ever happened to ME............I think therefore I'm a Yam.
- RiK
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 16092
- Joined: Tue Apr 23, 2002 11:32 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: Dr Olpin
- PSN: Dr Thumpy
- Location: The Shire
- Contact:
Re: No Man's Sky
No, it's really not.Meow wrote:B/C it is the biggest game ever made I think
RiK
Yakyak Admin
Martial Arts: http://www.BlackBeltAcademy.info
Photography: http://www.richardolpinphotography.co.uk
Yakyak Admin
Martial Arts: http://www.BlackBeltAcademy.info
Photography: http://www.richardolpinphotography.co.uk
Re: No Man's Sky
Clearly missed the whole point of procedural generation really....
Re: No Man's Sky
I can't think of a bigger open world to explore....off hand.RiK wrote:No, it's really not.Meow wrote:B/C it is the biggest game ever made I think
No, No I have not. I understand perfectly well how procedural generation works.Whiteball wrote:Clearly missed the whole point of procedural generation really....
.
.
.
.
....I'm the BEST thing that has ever happened to ME............I think therefore I'm a Yam.
.
.
.
....I'm the BEST thing that has ever happened to ME............I think therefore I'm a Yam.





