Politics Thread!
Re: Politics Thread!
Lol, vehement purging of new members by the NEC and he still increases his share of the vote.
Re: Politics Thread!
Apparently the hall was half empty as they had all fucked off to the Momentum conference.
Teehee.
Come to Scotland lads, we have viable non tories up here...oh wait a moment ....

DOH!
Personally under Corbyn I'd consider defecting back to Labour but alas we have Scottish 'up their own arse' Labour who are an even bigger fuck up!
Teehee.
Come to Scotland lads, we have viable non tories up here...oh wait a moment ....

DOH!
Personally under Corbyn I'd consider defecting back to Labour but alas we have Scottish 'up their own arse' Labour who are an even bigger fuck up!
Lork oh lordy, my bottom's on fire!
Re: Politics Thread!
I've got a mate who's saying that the members who signed up recently to stop Corbyn were prevented from voting...gravy wrote:Lol, vehement purging of new members by the NEC and he still increases his share of the vote.
"Oh dear lord, I slightly soiled myself. Oxfam won’t be pleased."
Re: Politics Thread!
The number sounds about right. But if they are unwilling to represent the wishes of the party members, then they *should* fuck off, either to an existing party (which will, in all probability, lose them their seats), or to a "new new labour" party in the hope they will be able to pull the existing labour voters to their side. But if they aren't representing those labour voters *now*, as they say, "good luck with that".Dio wrote:Effectively. But it's more likely to be a gang of 44 than 4 this time I think.
That's around my estimate of how many MPs will decide that A. they will inevitably get reselected and B. they want a chance at staying an MP. The real underlying uncertainty is how many of those decide to ride out the short term shock in the hopes of a later Labour comeback vs. how many decide the party really has left them behind.
"massive retard™", "full of shit™", "tiny bitch™", "retarted™", "a bit of a one trick pony™", "petty™", "simple minded idealistic twat™", "miserable humourless fucker™"
Re: Politics Thread!
Parties traditionally haven't required particularly tight agreement with the leader. (I mean Corbyn himself would have been booted out of Labour many years ago otherwise)
It's probably not that healthy for a party to all be that tight to the leader's view, it generates a monoculture of self-think.
But amusingly currently the same situation exists in both main parties, to a different degree. Tory voters were, what, 60%+ Leave - and the estimate is that among the party membership it was more like 80% - but their MPs were almost all Remain?
I'd be wary of conflating Labour voters and Labour party members here. That the two have very similar views on Corbyn is unproven.
It's probably not that healthy for a party to all be that tight to the leader's view, it generates a monoculture of self-think.
But amusingly currently the same situation exists in both main parties, to a different degree. Tory voters were, what, 60%+ Leave - and the estimate is that among the party membership it was more like 80% - but their MPs were almost all Remain?
I'd be wary of conflating Labour voters and Labour party members here. That the two have very similar views on Corbyn is unproven.
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: Politics Thread!
Two different things though. Corbyn was elected by 300,000 or so members. Over 9 million voted Labour at the last election. Party members are not at all representative of Labour voters. They need a leader that is not just a reflection of themselves but one who appeals to voters.tufty wrote:The number sounds about right. But if they are unwilling to represent the wishes of the party members, then they *should* fuck off, either to an existing party (which will, in all probability, lose them their seats), or to a "new new labour" party in the hope they will be able to pull the existing labour voters to their side. But if they aren't representing those labour voters *now*, as they say, "good luck with that".
And not just Labour voters. 9m people voted Labour last election, 11m voted Tory. To win Labour need to improve on this, and the only way to do this is with Tory votes, i.e. by persuading Tory voters who were voting Labour not long ago to support them. They need to move to the centre to do this, in the opposite direction to Corbyn’s.
Re: Politics Thread!
Jeremy Corbyn has consistently encompassed a broad church view and is driving forward democratisation - even allowing defectors to return and contribute their views. Much of what MSM report as infighting is democracy in action.Dio wrote:Parties traditionally haven't required particularly tight agreement with the leader. (I mean Corbyn himself would have been booted out of Labour many years ago otherwise)
It's probably not that healthy for a party to all be that tight to the leader's view, it generates a monoculture of self-think.
Those against a broad church are the PLP rebels.. who insisted on causing disruption and damaging party unity. Now it's time to reverse that vote of no-confidence and back your elected leader.
I'm not one of those who believes Labour is unelectable in 3.5 years - not even remotely. But PLP rebels do need to STFU with 'talking up' unelectability and show party unity.
Pretty hilarious of the Guardian to put a begging note in it's news feed of the result, whilst desperately try to find something negative to pin on Corbyn. Apparently financial support from the readership is at an all time low LOL!
Trippy vibes...
http://soundcloud.com/two-gapper
http://soundcloud.com/two-gapper
- Baggypants
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 5328
- Joined: Sun Mar 19, 2006 12:54 pm 0
- Location: Salford(UK);
- Contact:
Re: Politics Thread!
Hey snap! I've got a mate who's saying that the members who signed up recently to support Corbyn were prevented from voting too!Barney wrote:I've got a mate who's saying that the members who signed up recently to stop Corbyn were prevented from voting...gravy wrote:Lol, vehement purging of new members by the NEC and he still increases his share of the vote.
"The eggs, get them!"
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: Politics Thread!
No, Dio is spot on. Labour before Corbyn came along were a broad church, allowing dissenting views, such as Corbyn himself.(o)(o) wrote:Jeremy Corbyn has consistently encompassed a broad church view and is driving forward democratisation - even allowing defectors to return and contribute their views. Much of what MSM report as infighting is democracy in action.
Now though it is Corbyn unwilling to compromise. He is saying he will wipe the slate clean and the party should come together, but around him. He is not offering any concessions to the centre-left. He is not saying how he will change to improve his woeful performance. He is even proposing measures which will entrench his position, such as members electing shadow cabinet members – never mind the time and money such polls would require.
It puts Labour MPs in a horrible position. If they back Corbyn they know they are backing a losing candidate, and look weak and dishonest (as they will have to say nice things about him and his election prospects which they know aren’t true). Or they keep opposing him and the party is in permanent revolt, with leadership elections year after year. Or they quit the party, and split the left vote even further at the next election.
Re: Politics Thread!
I was trying to decide whether I disagreed with boobs or not and I can't make up my mind.
I'm not sure how much of it is just an artifact of the sheer size of the dissenting blob, so it appears that tolerance has narrowed when in fact it's just that opinion has shifted.
Maybe the more worrying evidence for a narrowing of scope is Momentum and the various claims of intimidation. My dad was a Labour district chair back in the Militant days: Preston was definitely out on the fringes of all of that so while he never really saw any of it himself there were certainly people who he thought could have done that sort of thing around then. But as an outsider now it's very hard for me to tell how much of the Momentum stuff is being over-inflated by the media and Corbyn's political opponents.
I'm not sure how much of it is just an artifact of the sheer size of the dissenting blob, so it appears that tolerance has narrowed when in fact it's just that opinion has shifted.
Maybe the more worrying evidence for a narrowing of scope is Momentum and the various claims of intimidation. My dad was a Labour district chair back in the Militant days: Preston was definitely out on the fringes of all of that so while he never really saw any of it himself there were certainly people who he thought could have done that sort of thing around then. But as an outsider now it's very hard for me to tell how much of the Momentum stuff is being over-inflated by the media and Corbyn's political opponents.
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: Politics Thread!
The thing that’s stuck in my mind was this:
I think it was after the Brexit vote, when people were calling for him to resign, and there was a very rapidly organised rally in the heart of London. Who organised it? Judging from the banners carried by many of the attendees the Socialist Worker Party, normally well outside Labour’s broad tent as far too extremist. Yet here they are supporting the Labour leader.
I think it was after the Brexit vote, when people were calling for him to resign, and there was a very rapidly organised rally in the heart of London. Who organised it? Judging from the banners carried by many of the attendees the Socialist Worker Party, normally well outside Labour’s broad tent as far too extremist. Yet here they are supporting the Labour leader.
Re: Politics Thread!
That's because he has no 'woeful' performance.pogo wrote:He is not saying how he will change to improve his woeful performance
It's all perpetuated bullshit that twats like you cling to as if it's tangible.
Fact is, the members want him and that's as good a performance as it needs. Unless you too are one of these twats that think they are above the common democratic voice.
Woeful my right testicle!
This is the new democracy!
Just because some self entitled elitist twats say they know what is best does not make is so.
Blairites and right weighted MP's should know that their day is up, the people don't buy it no more!
Fuck you May and your roll over of favouring the rich, the people are making noise, the people are fucking pissed off!
I'M SOOOO FUCKING ANGRYYYYY
Lork oh lordy, my bottom's on fire!
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: Politics Thread!
No it’s not. He was only supported by 300,000 members. That‘s about 1/4 the vote of the Green Party at the last election. You can’t win General Elections with 300,000 enthusiastic supporters.k345y wrote: That's because he has no 'woeful' performance.
It's all perpetuated bullshit that twats like you cling to as if it's tangible.
Fact is, the members want him and that's as good a performance as it needs.
How is he doing with voters? Very badly.
Jeremy Corbyn is 'out of touch' and an 'election loser' among working class voters, poll finds
Or look at the election results since he became leader, in Scotland or England. The worst performance by an opposition party since the 1980s in England, and Labour are now in third behind the SNP and Tories in Scotland. And that was before Labour spent the summer fighting over the leadership.Worryingly for Labour, just 22 per cent of working-class people thought Mr Corbyn “in touch with voters”, while 42 per cent said he is “out of touch” and 36 per cent did not know.
Asked if people thought him “competent” or “incompetent”, working-class voters again gave an unsettling response. More than a third, 36 per cent, went for incompetent, only 26 per cent went for competent and 38 per cent did not know. That compared with 32 per cent of ABC1 middle-class voters who were prepared to say the Labour leader was “competent”.
Re: Politics Thread!
You just don't get it do you?
He has fuck all to do with the polls in Scotland.
Scottish Labour are fucked because of Scottish Labour and their incredibly detached leader Kezia Dugdale, it's got nothing to do with Corbyn.
You actually demonstrate why the SNP are so popular, a complete and utter lack of understanding of the fundamentals of Scottish politics.
He has fuck all to do with the polls in Scotland.
Scottish Labour are fucked because of Scottish Labour and their incredibly detached leader Kezia Dugdale, it's got nothing to do with Corbyn.
You actually demonstrate why the SNP are so popular, a complete and utter lack of understanding of the fundamentals of Scottish politics.
Lork oh lordy, my bottom's on fire!
Re: Politics Thread!
Scottish Labour is a brilliant example of New Labour centrism obliterating a political party.


