KlaxonCow wrote:Also, the whole point with Buffy was that the entire premise was ironic. It was meant to be all rather silly.
The vampire slayer - the chosen one in a long and ancient lineage - called "Buffy", of all things.
It was not so much "lazy typecasting" as it was a deliberate use of genre clichès and tropes, in order to subvert and reinterpret them. The characters were knowing of how fundamentally silly all the vampires and werewolves and the many weird situations they found themselves in actually were. The purposeful juxtaposition of having to juggle boyfriends and going to the Prom and mundane things like that with her destined fate to take on the forces of evil.
It was ironic. So the clichès and typecasting and such were supposed to be there, as they played / mocked / subverted / reinterpreted all the horror genre tropes.
It's really a completely different thing entirely and, thus, not an apple-for-apple comparison here.
Doctor Who is also quite frequently self- and genre-aware in exactly the same way. Indeed, RTD took
BtVS as his model for the revived series (and it seems, perhaps less directly and successfully,
Angel as inspiration for
Torchwood). It would seem that
Class aims to balance normal concerns with fantasy conflicts in much the same way, with similar trope deconstruction and use of fanciful weirdness as allegory for common problems.
Emoticon and contraction free since... quite a while ago.