Rubisco wrote:What happened? We never used to think that calling people names defeated their arguments. We used to argue points properly, no matter how "deplorable" our opposition, and we used to win because of it.
Perhaps because people don't set out to defeat others' arguments because that's not a very interesting or important thing to do. Calling them names and making jokes about them is more fun and although it's no great intellectual exercise, it really doesn't need to be because it's not expected to achieve anything.
I mean, anyone who doesn't see what's wrong with Trump at this stage isn't going to be turned around by ... well, pretty much anything, because it's all been laid out pretty clearly for them to see if they ever wanted to.
Last edited by gumboot on Tue Nov 15, 2016 11:06 pm 0, edited 1 time in total.
In the meantime Defence Ministers of the Euro Zone met with NATO Commander Chief and agreed that the Euro Zone countries need to contribute more to Nato's budget. I don't know about the other countries but Portugal would raise its contribution by 1 Billion € over the nxt decade.
(I don't think that's going to go well with people in the middle of all this cuts)
The Foreign Ministers also met on Sunday to discuss the "New America" as it's being called by some but i don't know what or if anything special came out of the meeting.
Note: What happened to Pogo? His last post was on Election Night.
That is, Trump got less votes to victory than the loser Romney had last time against Obama. Clinton even won the popular vote - if the American system was a simple majority win, she'd actually have won - but she lost the electoral college, as a few significant-to-the-maths usually solid "blue states" turned red on her.
Democrats abandoned her more strongly than Republicans abandoned Trump. Because both candidates managed to lose their base support - Romney was the unpopular loser last time around and Trump did worse than he did - but Clinton lost them in a much bigger way.
As I previously mentioned during the election count, Florida - which is a crucial state for all the electoral college votes it dumps on its winner's tally (not quite a California (55) or a Texas (38), but level-pegging with New York (29) as the joint third most important state for electoral college votes) - was won for Trump by a mere 130,000 votes.
The third-party candidates of Johnson and Stein collectively gained 260,000 votes. Double Trump's victory margin.
Obviously, we can't say how much of that is protest vote or genuine third-party support, how much of it might have gone to Clinton or Trump (or just resulted in those voters staying at home and not voting for anyone) if there weren't any third-party candidates. But it gives the overall gist of the arithmetic that both Trump and Clinton lost base support, but Republican support stayed stronger for Trump than Democratic support stuck by Clinton.
The "alt right" didn't so much rise as liberalism collapsed. The election arithmetic shows us that, overall, Trump didn't really gain any new recruits to the Republican cause. Indeed, he lost some of their base support. But where he lost a little, Clinton haemorrhaged a lot. In all the wrong places, regards how the electoral college's "winner takes all" FPTP system distorts from the raw popular vote.
And, yes, we can even see this reflected in the loss of the House and Senate for the Democrats too. Historically, America has a tendency to auto-balance its voting and brought in a politically-opposite Congress to the Presidential winner, so that they "check and balance" one another.
But this was a Republican take-over and that's significant. That confirms the abandonment of the Democrats, rather than the victory of Trump.
And did Brexit succeed? Or was it more a failure of Remain to make an attractive case, in the face of charismatic bullshitters like Boris and Farage?
Corbyn was, at best, horribly lukewarm about Remain, as it's clear he was more anti-Leave than actually pro-Remain. Every time Cameron mentioned the EU, he said that we should remain part of a "reformed EU". That's also horribly lukewarm to effectively keep saying "let's remain part of a broken system, which we might be able to fix later, maybe" every time you mention the thing you're supposed to be advocating for.
I mean, it's honest.
I was anti-Brexit too. But that's the point. I'm describing it as "anti-Brexit" rather than as "pro-EU". I could mince my words and say "pro Europe" - which is subtly different from saying "pro-EU", of course - or, indeed, start utilising the "reformed EU" language that Cameron was using.
But while that's honest to not pretend that I'm all 100% happy and joyful about everything the EU's ever done or what we would have been signing back up to, had the vote gone the other way, it's not much of a convincing campaign message, is it? It's difficult to convince others, when you don't sound entirely convinced yourself.
I know that this isn't the orthodox narrative of what happened, but it's what the actual numbers tell us.
But I feel that's the real problem these days. Everything has an agenda. No-one looks at the numbers and the facts anymore. They rather decide on their pet narrative that all white people are intrinsically racist or that it's the patriarchy or that if you don't 100% agree with everything the Israeli government does then you're "antisemitic", and so on and so forth, and the facts are twisted to support the pre-determined conclusion that pushes their agenda, not that anyone is ever forming their opinion from the facts themselves.
Truth is, that also entirely describes Trump and Farage too. They're the biggest "whatever bullshit works to get what I want" merchants out there, in fact. But that's perhaps the point. If we're now play a game of "push the agenda" rather than looking at the facts, then the best bullshitters will carry the day.
If we're all now subscribed to this new non-violent ideological "might is right" game, then the most verbally violent will inevitably win.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
It's really very simple. The status quo was almost certainly more popular in both cases, but didn't inspire enough enthusiasm to counter those who wanted change. The prospect of change is exciting to those who want it. Excitement is motivating.
Trump was voted "second worst", and second worst is good enough for America.
On the plus side, it sounds like it's all turning to shit already (if the corrupt liberal media is to be believed), so I'm wondering if things could actually get so bad that Trumpers will start to realize what they've done.
KlaxonCow wrote:And did Brexit succeed? Or was it more a failure of Remain to make an attractive case, in the face of charismatic bullshitters like Boris and Farage?
I think this is an important question. You certainly can't accuse the left of being charismatic IMO, with the levels of sanctimoniousness that tend to come with it, especially as one drifts too far towards "SJW" extremes. (In other words, it's that same "no one likes being called a racist" thing, but I think your comment about charisma expands upon that)
No matter whether you like it or think it's sensible or not, human nature is such that people do fall for what amounts to sales tactics, which also makes me wonder if the 'left' type causes are too humble and honest. On the US election side of things they had an actual salesman (with all the exaggeration and bullshit that comes with salespeople, which it seems his supporters accounted for) vs... well, someone who it appears even a lot of the left hated.
I mean... to be fair, to us, Boris and Farage (and Trump) are hardly shining examples of charisma! But to the people they're campaigning to they are, and to everyone else at the very least they're good comedy. Who even was the face of the Remain campaign?
"massive retard™", "full of shit™", "tiny bitch™", "retarted™", "a bit of a one trick pony™", "petty™", "simple minded idealistic twat™", "miserable humourless fucker™"