Trump
- zbandito
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 2916
- Joined: Sat May 18, 2002 10:00 pm 0
- Location: Portland, Oregon
- Contact:
Re: Trump
Neither party plays with a full deck; it was a choice between two liars who represent wall street. A very poor showing. What's next?
Failure of the commons on information authenticity on the internet is really something of a problem that's hard to solve short of a state sponsored education network, fraught with it's own problematic issue of control and contention. But it's kinda like, what kinda next-generation educational system can we build for our future generations. I don't mean feel good iPad apps; technology has been shown to be very invasive to mixed - sometimes detrimental - effect. But think back to encyclopedias, some of which may have had errors, but in theory were full of vetted factual information. But the cost, size, and the nature of updating the information within the set is a monumental task that nations build entire libraries to try and manage. The glory of the networked information age is the (nearly) free exchange of information. If that can't be retained, while somehow allowing people to vet the information themselves, it represents a real risk of degenerating the availability of information and the resulting effect upon populations intellect and values will be negatively effected. There is hubris because of this election. Who will get up and actually involve them selves in the system? It's challenging to compete part time against full time players representing vested interests. So in this way Trump is an interesting candidate in that for many Americans he represented someone outside of the ongoing hegemony of Bush and Clinton political families. How true that remains to be seen, considering his failed personal and business relationships I don't expect his plan-less rhetoric to amount to much. But it might actually be a stronger face to an international scene where, frankly, women in positions of power are uncommon shall we say. It is unfortunate for feminist values to have been represented by a candidate who's reputation for fraud runs high. But it is those who persist and try and make politics their life interest, instead of an armchair interest, who inevitably end up in power in electorate democracies. I didn't even vote in the Presidential election; I already knew what both the popular and electorate college would vote and the decision was made fairly decisively. People reasonably want accurate information but who's going to do something about it? There is obviously an aristocracy, and yet this is an apparently inevitable outcome of everything that's already happened now. So the best thing to do is figure out how to change the system, how to maintain free flow of information, and how to vet information. We, the US, already just gave away ICANN, which was a huge mistake for any true patriot and was in fact something Trump opposed. Relinquishing ICANN to the UN will inevitably lead to state monitored interstate networks. Mesh networking FTW. And, that free flow of information and ability to vet information needs to be able to transpire asynchronously. But where does this really lead? A giant block chain of who said what first? Better funding for libraries and librarians at schools so that schools and societies can educate people how to do their own homework is probably the only real answer, and obviously faces some stiff competition for interest from media industries in capitalistic societies.
Failure of the commons on information authenticity on the internet is really something of a problem that's hard to solve short of a state sponsored education network, fraught with it's own problematic issue of control and contention. But it's kinda like, what kinda next-generation educational system can we build for our future generations. I don't mean feel good iPad apps; technology has been shown to be very invasive to mixed - sometimes detrimental - effect. But think back to encyclopedias, some of which may have had errors, but in theory were full of vetted factual information. But the cost, size, and the nature of updating the information within the set is a monumental task that nations build entire libraries to try and manage. The glory of the networked information age is the (nearly) free exchange of information. If that can't be retained, while somehow allowing people to vet the information themselves, it represents a real risk of degenerating the availability of information and the resulting effect upon populations intellect and values will be negatively effected. There is hubris because of this election. Who will get up and actually involve them selves in the system? It's challenging to compete part time against full time players representing vested interests. So in this way Trump is an interesting candidate in that for many Americans he represented someone outside of the ongoing hegemony of Bush and Clinton political families. How true that remains to be seen, considering his failed personal and business relationships I don't expect his plan-less rhetoric to amount to much. But it might actually be a stronger face to an international scene where, frankly, women in positions of power are uncommon shall we say. It is unfortunate for feminist values to have been represented by a candidate who's reputation for fraud runs high. But it is those who persist and try and make politics their life interest, instead of an armchair interest, who inevitably end up in power in electorate democracies. I didn't even vote in the Presidential election; I already knew what both the popular and electorate college would vote and the decision was made fairly decisively. People reasonably want accurate information but who's going to do something about it? There is obviously an aristocracy, and yet this is an apparently inevitable outcome of everything that's already happened now. So the best thing to do is figure out how to change the system, how to maintain free flow of information, and how to vet information. We, the US, already just gave away ICANN, which was a huge mistake for any true patriot and was in fact something Trump opposed. Relinquishing ICANN to the UN will inevitably lead to state monitored interstate networks. Mesh networking FTW. And, that free flow of information and ability to vet information needs to be able to transpire asynchronously. But where does this really lead? A giant block chain of who said what first? Better funding for libraries and librarians at schools so that schools and societies can educate people how to do their own homework is probably the only real answer, and obviously faces some stiff competition for interest from media industries in capitalistic societies.
Re: Trump
So you're nearing the end of your patrol and everything has been quite normal so you haven't been rationing. What do you do if it all kicks off on the last day and you can't go home?F-ZeroOne wrote:Er, six months might be pushing it a little, the normal patrol duration is three months but I guess you could ration things. And hope nothing important breaks.
I'm sure they're equipped to run six months at the very least. If they can't manage that then they've already lost sight of why they're out there.
Re: Trump
And on information vetting, it used to be that you could filter things by what makes sense to avoid a lot of the chaff. You shouldn't need access to significant resources for that. But "what makes sense" flew right out the window when Trump came along. So many ridiculous stories that should fail the what-makes-sense test being repeated by what used to be reputable sources.
It's little wonder people lost sight of what to believe.
It's little wonder people lost sight of what to believe.
- Little stoned kiwi
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 4597
- Joined: Mon Oct 27, 2003 6:05 am 0
- Location: Christchurch
Re: Trump
That's the problem though; confirmation bias. The solution is for individuals to challenge their beliefs and entertain contrary positions.gumboot wrote:And on information vetting, it used to be that you could filter things by what makes sense to avoid a lot of the chaff. You shouldn't need access to significant resources for that.
If they think you're crude, go technical; if they think you're technical, go crude. I'm a very technical boy.
Re: Trump
A lot of the wrong information being discussed was meant to be so wrong that it was obviously wrong. That was the joke. Confirmation bias should have been no excuse in any normal election... but Trump managed to make true things so ridiculous that it became impossible to tell. See, for example, post number 1 of this thread.
Re: Trump
Nope, not enough commas for it to be me.gumboot wrote:KlaxonCow hacked your account, eh?
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
- John Maynard Keynes
-
offyoutoddle
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 2644
- Joined: Sat Mar 19, 2005 2:16 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: awvc1@yahoo.co.uk
- Location: London
- Contact:
Re: Trump
So the sub commander can stand behind his orders if there is no chain of command left - otherwise the ultimate decision was in his/her hands, because they could at that point decide 'enough is enough'. He/she will in all probability be one of the few who have to live with that decisionKlaxonCow wrote:Then why do the letters of last resort even exist in the first place?zip accident wrote:You don't bluff about stuff like that.
one joy scatters a thousand griefs
Re: Trump
If there is no chain of command above them, then they are the chain of command. It's a chain. That's the whole point.
And if there's any doubt of the sub commander's competence to fulfil their standing orders, then a hand-written letter in a double safe ain't going to change anything, is it? They could look at the letter and simply state "enough is enough" anyway. It's all in secret. Who's to know otherwise? Who's left to court martial them for belaying an order?
The Prime Minster could - openly, in public - simply state that the standing orders are to launch. It'd be just as good and would absolutely confirm that it's not a bluff. Indeed, as everyone knows what those orders are, as they're not in any secrecy, then you could better guarantee their fulfilment - if the sub commander refuses, the rest of the crew know what's required of them and insist that it's carried out.
Why the secrecy? The only possible explanation is that it permits the Prime Minster leeway to actually deviate from their publicly stated position. To allow them to say "no" with their private face, even if their public face has always maintained "yes" for the sake of its deterrent effect.
The very existence of the letters logically allows it to be a bluff. Whether it is or not, depends on its contents, which could change from Prime Minster to Prime Minster. But, as I say, think about it. The fact that the letters even exist means that there's the possibility it's just a bluff.
And if there's any doubt of the sub commander's competence to fulfil their standing orders, then a hand-written letter in a double safe ain't going to change anything, is it? They could look at the letter and simply state "enough is enough" anyway. It's all in secret. Who's to know otherwise? Who's left to court martial them for belaying an order?
The Prime Minster could - openly, in public - simply state that the standing orders are to launch. It'd be just as good and would absolutely confirm that it's not a bluff. Indeed, as everyone knows what those orders are, as they're not in any secrecy, then you could better guarantee their fulfilment - if the sub commander refuses, the rest of the crew know what's required of them and insist that it's carried out.
Why the secrecy? The only possible explanation is that it permits the Prime Minster leeway to actually deviate from their publicly stated position. To allow them to say "no" with their private face, even if their public face has always maintained "yes" for the sake of its deterrent effect.
The very existence of the letters logically allows it to be a bluff. Whether it is or not, depends on its contents, which could change from Prime Minster to Prime Minster. But, as I say, think about it. The fact that the letters even exist means that there's the possibility it's just a bluff.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
- John Maynard Keynes
-
offyoutoddle
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 2644
- Joined: Sat Mar 19, 2005 2:16 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: awvc1@yahoo.co.uk
- Location: London
- Contact:
Re: Trump
You may be over thinking it. Its just my opinion, but to a military mind, 'I have my orders' is for the most part where it starts and finishes. As for the 'who knows' question - they know. The ones with an ingrained sense of duty etc through all their training, who unlike those who will die as a consequence of their actions will be nice and safe in their mobile radiation shelter, and will probably have to live with that and whatever comes after.
Or maybe I'm overthinking it
As for the possibility of it being a bluff , yes I agree it exists of course. But it is not the only possibility by any stretch of the imagination. I suspect there is more detail in it than the words launch or don't launch - that's probably the real reason for the letters. Possibly it also would contain some thank you to the one who would bear the weight of the decision.
Or maybe I'm overthinking it
As for the possibility of it being a bluff , yes I agree it exists of course. But it is not the only possibility by any stretch of the imagination. I suspect there is more detail in it than the words launch or don't launch - that's probably the real reason for the letters. Possibly it also would contain some thank you to the one who would bear the weight of the decision.
one joy scatters a thousand griefs
Re: Trump
It's just game theory. Holding your 'opponent' in a Nash equilibrium whilst keeping your options open.
The 'letters' removes any vulnerabilities which weaken your position. The safe could contain anything but I'm sure it exists.
A more obvious "bluff" is Theresa May saying she would launch nukes. She totally gives the game away by following up with "our enemies need to know we would be prepared to launch nukes". So yeah, she's going to say she would regardless of what she would really do (and as we all know now, she lies like lying is fashionable - which it is under Tory rule).
The 'letters' removes any vulnerabilities which weaken your position. The safe could contain anything but I'm sure it exists.
A more obvious "bluff" is Theresa May saying she would launch nukes. She totally gives the game away by following up with "our enemies need to know we would be prepared to launch nukes". So yeah, she's going to say she would regardless of what she would really do (and as we all know now, she lies like lying is fashionable - which it is under Tory rule).
Trippy vibes...
http://soundcloud.com/two-gapper
http://soundcloud.com/two-gapper
Re: Trump
If it all kicks off on the last day, you fire your missiles and then try and find somewhere that isn't a radioactive wasteland before the rest of your food runs out. The average patrol duration is typically 80 or so days and every spare available space on the submarine is often packed with food before setting out. They don't ration food on-board as a matter of course. If you know the End of the World is coming then perhaps you would be a bit more prepared beforehand and ration from the outset.gumboot wrote:So you're nearing the end of your patrol and everything has been quite normal so you haven't been rationing. What do you do if it all kicks off on the last day and you can't go home?F-ZeroOne wrote:Er, six months might be pushing it a little, the normal patrol duration is three months but I guess you could ration things. And hope nothing important breaks.
I'm sure they're equipped to run six months at the very least. If they can't manage that then they've already lost sight of why they're out there.
Some submarines are larger than others and might be able to store more food beforehand.
And still hope nothing breaks.
Its worth bearing in mind, they used to plan for US fighters to make one-way nuclear bombing missions a few decades ago. The pilots were supposed to bail out and make their way back to what was left of civilisation afterwards, which was a plan that probably everyone involved from the pilots up realised was a bit of a fig-leaf.
Edit: Thinking over it, yes, I think I've missed your point a little. It is possible that submarines carry more food than they actually need on a "typical" patrol, but given how space is at a premium on any submarine (to the extent that until a few years ago sharing crew bunks was the norm even on state-of-the-art nuclear attack submarines) I have some difficulty believing a significant excess of supplies may be carried without some preparation beforehand.
"Stars don't twinkle in space." - Char Aznable.
Re: Trump
My 11 yr old made me laugh today by asking me if Lord Vader has started ruling America yet. When I asked him who do you mean he replied with 'Darth Trump' which I thought had a good ring to it.
Lork oh lordy, my bottom's on fire!
Re: Trump
Did you read Steve Bannon compared himself to Darth Vader and Satan ?k345y wrote:My 11 yr old made me laugh today by asking me if Lord Vader has started ruling America yet. When I asked him who do you mean he replied with 'Darth Trump' which I thought had a good ring to it.
Trippy vibes...
http://soundcloud.com/two-gapper
http://soundcloud.com/two-gapper


